Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Posting that you're donating to charity instead of sending Christmas cards

134 replies

Animallover87 · 09/12/2022 17:24

I've noticed this over the last few years.

Just saw the first one this year pop up on my Facebook. To be fair, she included a screen shot of the charity donation. People were commenting 'well done' etc.

AIBU to be irritated by these posts and think folk are just doing it because they CBA with Christmas cards? And why the need to announce it year after year?

OP posts:
cardibach · 09/12/2022 18:53

Tinkerbyebye · 09/12/2022 17:36

To me it’s being lazy. You can’t even be bothered to write a card to someone,
I buy from a charity, I write a small note in each and send

lots of elderly family members out there who are lonely, lots of friends who know you can be bothered to spend time sending a card because they mean something to you

cards can be recycled so it’s not wasteful

Not lazy. Why should they be done? It’s a relatively recent ‘tradition’. I put my energy into actually connecting with my friends by phone, text and physical meeting. A bit of card seems a bit of a lazy way of doing it.

cardibach · 09/12/2022 18:51

ChrisPriss · 09/12/2022 17:34

I love sending Christmas cards and receiving them from friends who I only touch base with at Christmas. Anyone who says that they aren't sending them doesn't get mine.
Which reminds me, one friend announced on Facebook that she was not sending cards but making a sizeable donation to charity, although she hoped her friends would still send cards to her!
I didn't.

friends tou only touch base with at Christmas? So the only connection is a card they may not even want (I really find them annoying - the card itself, not the motive)? You aren’t friends.
If you are friends you actually talk/meet at some point in the year.

phoenixrosehere · 09/12/2022 18:50

I couldn’t get worked up about this. Why is it such an issue? People get so petty over a piece of card that most only say the barest and generic of messages that could easily have been texted without the extra cost and even more bonkers when you’re actually going to see the person over the Christmas season anyway and/or see and speak to them several times a week.

If people want to spend their money on cards, fine but being annoyed that someone has decided to not participate in it anymore and choosing to inform people in a way that reaches the most so others know they won’t be receiving one from them is ridiculous.

Sounds like some would be annoyed regardless if the person said it on social media or told them personally.

ohioriver · 09/12/2022 18:47

I donate to charity as well.

I put up on Facebook mostly just in memory of my mum. I miss her so much, especially at Christmas and it feels like I'm including her by telling people I've donated in her memory.

FeltCarrot · 09/12/2022 18:44

I think sending Christmas cards is dying out. Neither of my dc (both 20’s) send any, and with the chaos the postal service is in, lots of cards are unlikely to be delivered before Xmas anyway, soooo, I’ve donated the cost of stamps (nearly £30 ) to a food bank and whatsapped groups of friends/ family Merry Christmas instead.

Pidgeonslipshit · 09/12/2022 18:42

Have been irritated by this for years . Just say I can’t be arsed with Christmas cards .
Would like to think that anyone who can afford it should be donating to charity anyway !
I personally still send cards to elderly relatives backed up with a phone call because I think it means a lot to them .

notanothertakeaway · 09/12/2022 18:38

Most of the people I know could easily afford to donate to charity AND pay for Christmas cards if they wanted to do both

So, the virtual signalling / "look at me" does irritates me

I never hear them say "No need to give me a gift this year. Please donate to charity"

Cuddlywuddlies · 09/12/2022 18:36

I never send xmas cards and I tell people not to send them to me either. A text will do just fine!! Waste of paper, time, money and space….sorry

Decisionfatiguequeen · 09/12/2022 18:34

I've donated to the foodbank the past few years instead of the £20-30 I'd have spend buying and posting christmas cards and posted it on FB so people know not to expect a card from me or send me one. Shock horror I also have a monthly charity direct debit and donate to the food bank when shopping and I don't post about it. If anyone thinks thats rude I couldn't give a monkeys - saves me several evenings of pointless wifework, my preferred charity benefits, it might prompt someone else to donate and I'll make sure I visit any elderly relatives in person rather than just sending a card. Win/win/win. You make you own choice and I'll make mine. YABU.

DepIndoChridmadWidMe · 09/12/2022 18:33

Oh God, some nutter posted about this last year. They were really frothing at the mouth about it. Why do people get so enraged about it?

Justtoshare · 09/12/2022 18:33

The reality is that writing out a lot of Christmas cards:
'To X, Merry Christmas and Happy New Year Love from Y x',
posting it and then waiting to receive a reply with a similar lack of actual contact/news/information.....is a bit pointless.

Years ago I was an early adopter of computer cards when I used to design my own, print them and post them; but even now I still send some normal hand-written cards (especially to close family/elderly relatives).

I don't know what the solution is but my adult children do not send Christmas cards at all and rarely send Birthday cards, so I think cards in general are dying out but it is likely that people will still choose to communicate greetings electronically or by email.
So I am on the fence.
YANBU it is possible to donate to charity and send cards.
YABU it is such a faff and you get a better response from a personalised e-mail anyway.

AliensToTheLeft · 09/12/2022 18:31

I suppose it’s to try to stop some people whinging that they haven’t got a card off you. I don’t send cards, I don’t announce it on social media either, but we do get the same people every year commenting that they haven’t received a card from us.

mutleyschuckle · 09/12/2022 18:30

I've done it for the first time ever this year. Donated to the local air ambulance, they played a massive part in saving my mums life about 8 weeks ago & without them she wouldn't be here recovering now. It came with the option to share on fb, which I did explaining that I wasn't sending or expecting to receive cards this year & to let wider family know before they buy them (I dislike them anyway) & wanted to use the money to increase my donation to charity. if you think that's crass - fine. I'm just pleased to have my mum back. You do you, maybe think why they may have chosen to do that.

JusteanBiscuits · 09/12/2022 18:28

I'm shit at sending christmas cards, so have done this for about 15 years and always donate to Shelter. But I have never posted about it. I've seen a few over past few years that are so fucking smug - and always from the same type of people!

BigCheeseSandwich · 09/12/2022 18:28

i don’t like Christmas cards, they’re just needless clutter- they get opened and put straight into the recycling bin! Couldn’t get worked up about someone donating to charity in the least.

Consufed · 09/12/2022 18:28

Christmas cards are a tangible, not virtual, way to send something to friends and family. I like them.

If you forego something which is a treat for yourself (wine, entertainment, dinner at a restaurant, takeaway coffee in a paper/plastic cup) and donate the money to charity instead, you've made the sacrifice yourself.

Cancelling someone else's Christmas present or card, and replacing it with a goat, self-congratulatory message, or nothing at all, does not involve any extra sacrifice or effort, so why should it get a 'well done'? It's just virtue signalling.

Christmas cards are only once a year and are about good wishes. They are usually plastic-free and recyclable. There are so many other things, year round, which are wasteful, or spread negativity not good cheer. yet this is often downplayed or ignored by many who are loudly on the anti Christmas card bandwagon.

Americano75 · 09/12/2022 18:25

@KitchiHuritAngeni I'm so sorry for your losses. This time of year must be especially hard.

I've done the Facebook thing as well. As pp have said, it raises awareness of my chosen charity and lets anyone expecting a card from me know not to. If it makes any whiners feel better, I also make sure to add that I fucking hate Christmas cards full stop.

StillWeRise · 09/12/2022 18:25

yes, we always get this thread don't we
I do enjoy getting cards and also sending them although it's sometimes a chore- for some people this is the only contact I have with them and it seems a nice thing to do. I really roll my eyes at people claiming they don't do it 'because of the environment' - the impact of christmas cards compared to almost any other aspect of the annual consumer-fest must be absolutely minimal. If you can't be arsed at least be honest about it.
But this week we had a new one- our milkman (who normally sends us a christmas card) emailed us (which is how he sends the bill) wishing us happy christmas and saying he was making a (generous) donation to the food bank instead this year which I though was great.

DisplayPurposesOnly · 09/12/2022 18:23

AIBU to be irritated by these posts and think folk are just doing it because they CBA with Christmas cards? And why the need to announce it year after year?

You're probably right that they CBA but if they do actually donate to charity, then it comes good.

I think it's reasonable for them to let people know via SM that they aren't sending cards. It saves people being hurt or offended.

There are other things worth being irritated by. Let this one float past you.

Lampshadered · 09/12/2022 18:23

I have monthly direct debits to two charities.

I don't send Christmas cards.

I don't announce either of those things to people.

As a PP said, it's rude to just stick it on facebook and expect that to be your Christmas greeting. Why not just send a Happy Christmas text to friends and family.

ohioriver · 09/12/2022 18:23

And I definitely do give (£50 to the charity) and I don't care if no one sends a card to me.

I text the people I'd be likely to send a card to on a regular basis.

ohioriver · 09/12/2022 18:20

I do it. And I post it on Facebook. I give to a charity in memory of my mum and since she's not here at Christmas it's a way to remember her - not just for me but for her and the people who knew her.

MajorCarolDanvers · 09/12/2022 18:20

I CBA doing cards and post that I'm donating to charity so that my family and friends don't think I've just forgotten to send a card to them.

MarigoldPetals · 09/12/2022 18:18

someonecookmydinnerplease · 09/12/2022 18:16

YANBU

Giving to charity and choosing not to send cards are nothing to do with each other. If you don't want to send cards, fine, don't justify it by telling everyone about your (usually imaginary) charity donation.

Own it like @AuntieMarys and at least admit the money has been spent on gin! 😆😆 I respect that honesty!

Absolutely!

MarigoldPetals · 09/12/2022 18:17

It winds me up. I think it’s sad.