Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Posting that you're donating to charity instead of sending Christmas cards

134 replies

Animallover87 · 09/12/2022 17:24

I've noticed this over the last few years.

Just saw the first one this year pop up on my Facebook. To be fair, she included a screen shot of the charity donation. People were commenting 'well done' etc.

AIBU to be irritated by these posts and think folk are just doing it because they CBA with Christmas cards? And why the need to announce it year after year?

OP posts:
ohioriver · 09/12/2022 22:16

@cherriegarcia I send personalised texts / WhatsApp / Facebook messages

I wouldn't be able to sit and write that in 50 plus cards so I'd have to type each one and print it out and put it in a card

It's easier to text - yes. For me. It is and I want to honour my mum
So 🤷🏼‍♀️

ohioriver · 09/12/2022 22:14

I have calculated what I'd spend on mid range cards and stamps to be about £50. Instead of doing that (because the biggest cost isn't the charity cards it's the stamps and last I looked Royal Mail isn't a charity) I ring, FaceTime or text people instead

All those I'd send a card to I have contact with by one of the other means.

cherriegarcia · 09/12/2022 22:14

The thing about a card is the individual nature of wishing someone a Merry Christmas.

If I got a personalised message saying something like...

'Hi cherriegarcia, hope you and MrCherriegarcia and BabyCherrie have a wonderful Christmas and New year.
We must catch up sometime at X cafe that has just opened, and you can update me on how the new job is going!
I'll be spending Christmas with the family.... etc etc'

... It wouldn't matter if that message was digital or written in a card. The point is, it's a personalised Christmas wish. That's what matters. I want to hear from my family and friends in whatever format.

If you feel cards are a waste of money, then do a charity donation and send people messages.

But they're not the same thing. The christmas card is about connection, and you're not getting that from your charity donation. It's not a substitute.

I really think it's mostly about laziness and that people don't want to reach out and connect individually.

Brefugee · 09/12/2022 22:14

what on earth kinds of friends do you all have that you literally are accusing them of lying? blimey.

Changingmynameyetagain · 09/12/2022 22:13

I don’t send Christmas cards, haven’t for about 10 years, I hate them. I don’t enjoy birthday cards either, total waste of money and trees.
I do donate to charity every Christmas though, I used to post on FB that I wasn’t sending them but friends and family know now I don’t send them so I don’t bother anymore.

HeckyPeck · 09/12/2022 22:12

if you want to give to charity just give to charity. There’s more honour in doing it privately.

As a Trustee of a small charity, I completely disagree with this.

When people post online about donations, it does inspire other people to donate. Win:win for the donor and the charities.

ohioriver · 09/12/2022 22:10

cant be arsed sending Christmas cards to show people they know and love that they are thinking of them which is pretty twattish.

I don't send Christmas cards to show people I know and love I'm thinking of them. I ring them, FaceTime them or actually go and see them. I don't think I'm twattish to want to honour my mum.

BotterMon · 09/12/2022 22:08

I buy charity cards and send to family and friends, most of whom aren't on Faceache. I just ignore the FB virtue signallers - they don't get a card from me and I don't acknowledge their posts.

MrsFinkelstein · 09/12/2022 22:06

Americano75 · 09/12/2022 21:55

I'm pretty sure I'm not alone here when I say my charity donation exceeds the cost of a pack of cards by the way. I mean, ffs.

Absolutely!

The people posting about a pack of cards costing £2 obviously haven't bought stamps for years.

I estimate the cost of cards/postage and add at least £15 to that.

cherriegarcia · 09/12/2022 22:05

Christmas cards are a nice gesture to send a Christmas message to someone you care about.

A donation to a charity, whilst a lovely thing to do, isn't really a substitute for this.

If you put a generic post on social media to say you've donated to a charity instead of sending Christmas cards, that makes the whole thing very materialistic and takes any warmth out of it.

The thing I like about a Christmas card is that you've written a personal message to me, wishing me a Merry Christmas. Not that you've spend 20p on it. I couldn't care less about that!

It's just not the same thing and it doesn't make sense.

MrsFinkelstein · 09/12/2022 22:04

someonecookmydinnerplease · 09/12/2022 21:51

But you haven't bothered sending them a card! Which is fine, but the charity donation is a separate choice. The two aren't linked!

Yes, I made a conscious choice not to send a card that will just get binned after Christmas and gather dust until then.
I give monthly to charity, but at Christmas I give extra and spread awareness.

The post is so no one gets offended they won't receive one.

However it seems some people get offended regardless. IDGAF.

Americano75 · 09/12/2022 21:55

I'm pretty sure I'm not alone here when I say my charity donation exceeds the cost of a pack of cards by the way. I mean, ffs.

someonecookmydinnerplease · 09/12/2022 21:51

MrsFinkelstein · 09/12/2022 21:45

YABU.

I do this and share it so people don't think I've not bothered sending a card to them.

I donate to a local Cancer charity that gave amazing support to my father and to BHF as my mum had an MI and my dad had open heart surgery. I feel it raises awareness and gives thanks to them.

IDGAF if it pisses you off.

Plus paper cards are environmentally unfriendly nowadays.

But you haven't bothered sending them a card! Which is fine, but the charity donation is a separate choice. The two aren't linked!

MrsFinkelstein · 09/12/2022 21:45

YABU.

I do this and share it so people don't think I've not bothered sending a card to them.

I donate to a local Cancer charity that gave amazing support to my father and to BHF as my mum had an MI and my dad had open heart surgery. I feel it raises awareness and gives thanks to them.

IDGAF if it pisses you off.

Plus paper cards are environmentally unfriendly nowadays.

Ponderingwindow · 09/12/2022 21:45

Send cards, don’t send cards. Entirely a personal choice.

donate to charity or not. Again, a personal choice.

there is no reason to link the two or make any announcements about your choices.

Itsabitnotcold · 09/12/2022 21:44

YANBU SIL always does this.

  1. They can bloody well afford to donate to charity regardless.
  2. They never sent us cards in the first place!
Mojoj · 09/12/2022 21:42

Wow, you're easily annoyed. Christmas cards are a load of nonsense. I like hearing which charities people have donated to - way more interesting than getting a card.

Decisionfatiguequeen · 09/12/2022 21:37

Skyellaskerry · 09/12/2022 19:19

I wish I hadn’t opened this thread. @KitchiHuritAngeni and @ohioriver I am sorry for your losses (and anyone else I’ve missed). I’ve had more than one significant loss this last year or so, I was going to do this in their memories but I can’t bear the thought of eye rolls and such mocking as in this thread, when really all I’m doing is sharing that I won’t have forgotten people via the cards I usually send, and genuinely finding some good in a donation and yes sharing that I miss them.

Please don't be put off by this thread - anyone mocking and eye rolling about a charity donation in memory of a loved on (or any other good cause) are not worth bothering about and you do not have to justify yourself to them. Not wanting to send or being able to face sending Christmas cards is very common after a beareavement - do what feels right for you and the memory of your loved ones.

blubberyboo · 09/12/2022 20:57

I agree people who do this :

are virtue signalling

cant be arsed sending Christmas cards to show people they know and love that they are thinking of them which is pretty twattish.

so full of bah humbug that they disguise as being charitable to make themselves feel better.

a pack of cards costs a pound or 2 so why broadcast that you are donating a pound to charity. Nobody posts in July that they put £2 in the Alzheimer’s bucket instead of buying candyfloss at the fairground

cards can be hand delivered or sent as e-card so no reason why you can’t do both

if you want to give to charity just give to charity. There’s more honour in doing it privately.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 09/12/2022 20:47

I donate in the memory of my husband and parents. I want to remember them publicly. I don't want cards. I don't want to send cards but I do want to raise the profile of various charities that made a difference to our lives at a time when it mattered so much.
If sending that link just encourages one person to donate to a similar charity then you can roll your eyes all you like. I couldn't give a toss what you think. One of my relatives died of a cancer I'd never heard of and another died of a cancer that gets very little funding. Pre covid I did a fair amount in other ways to help fund raise, street collections, organised events but all that stopped and therefore so did the income for the charity. Friends and family used to attend my events or start off my collection tin.
Call it what you like. You write your cards to all at number 15 from all at number 12. And I will post my link. I will also visit my elderly relatives and spend time with them. If I think writing a card as well would be something they'd like then I'll do that.

phoenixrosehere · 09/12/2022 20:36

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 09/12/2022 20:18

I disagree. There are so many threads on AIBU about fall outs after someone getting really offended they've not received a card, and think the other person has forgotten about them or snubbed them etc. I've seen one today with someone upset they never received a 'congrats on your new baby' card from a relative.

Its an easy way of communicating en masse that you've not left someone out and it's not personal, you're just opting out of the tradition, and avoids this weird card expectation that British people seem to have.

Exactly. Do people really expect others to call and inform people individually that they’re not doing Christmas cards and explaining the reason. Some would still come on here and moan about it and call them lazy, grinches, etc..

I would internally side-eye someone if they vented to me that they fell out with someone because the person chose to donate their own money to charity instead of sending said person a Christmas card.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 09/12/2022 20:18

I disagree. There are so many threads on AIBU about fall outs after someone getting really offended they've not received a card, and think the other person has forgotten about them or snubbed them etc. I've seen one today with someone upset they never received a 'congrats on your new baby' card from a relative.

Its an easy way of communicating en masse that you've not left someone out and it's not personal, you're just opting out of the tradition, and avoids this weird card expectation that British people seem to have.

saraclara · 09/12/2022 20:16

napody · 09/12/2022 17:39

To me, it's the wrong way round.
You should say 'don't worry about sending me a card, put the cost of the stamp to charity'.
Same with those 'I've sponsored you a donkey instead of getting you a present'- so the giver has the satisfaction of giving to charity. It should be 'don't buy for ME, give it to charity' if you actually want to be generous.

I've made this point for years, about charity donation gifts. Yet hardly anyone seems to recognise that the giver has sacrificed absolutely nothing on the charity's behalf. In fact they've made their life considerably easier while not spending a penny extra.
The person who's sacrificed their gift is the recipient, who's had no choice in it whatever.

I'd love to be brave enough to say "Oh, so I've got no present this year? You've given it to someone else? Well cheers for that 😕"

Witchofthedales · 09/12/2022 20:13

napody · 09/12/2022 17:39

To me, it's the wrong way round.
You should say 'don't worry about sending me a card, put the cost of the stamp to charity'.
Same with those 'I've sponsored you a donkey instead of getting you a present'- so the giver has the satisfaction of giving to charity. It should be 'don't buy for ME, give it to charity' if you actually want to be generous.

This 👆

Abraxan · 09/12/2022 20:09

I don't bother sending Christmas cards any more, I've gradually reduced how many we send and now all our more elderly grandparents and great aunts have died we don't really send any now.

This year so far we've had 4 - so very few compared to the past. Again how many we receive has also reduced massively.

Most people I know don't send physical cards anymore. Christmas messages are sent via text or social media, or given verbally.

We do also donate to charities at this time of year particularly, but we don't post on social media about any of it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread