Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A Christmas Family one, of course!

154 replies

60degreecycle · 09/12/2022 14:39

DH has invited his sister to stay over Christmas, we don't really get on, she's usually a bit absent, lives away and only sporadically in touch when she wants something, often money, has been very cold/rude with me at times which I've tried to let roll off my back to keep the peace, drinky, has been known to nip down the end of the garden to smoke a joint, but would otherwise be alone over Christmas and DH doesn't feel he can say no to her. Selfishly, a proper festive dampener on what was planned to be a first cosy quiet family one just the four of us with all other family having made other plans.

I in turn decided to take my DDs (not DP's daughters) down South to my brothers so they can have some fun with two sets of cousins, and my mum and elderly aunt who will be there. A big jolly old fashioned Christmas. DDs happy with this arrangement, which I organised as they weren't filled with joy about hanging out at home with DH strange sister.

DH is upset with me for bailing on him and leaving him with his sister, as he thinks they will have a shit time. I am inclined to agree, as it will basically involve watching her wordlessly motor through the drinks cabine. I'm a bit upset with him for agreeing to her sort of gatecrash our christmas and completely change the vibe for the DDs especially. I am upset not to be able to spend Christmas with DH but felt if I could save things for the kids I should do that? And now it's kind of done.

Is either of us being unreasonable? Have I been selfish to bail? Or was he unreasonable to change our plans and invite his sister? Is this just how it goes with weird family that you don't really want to hang out with?!

OP posts:
44PumpLane · 09/12/2022 17:10

Honestly OP you've done the right thing!

Muddywaters1 · 09/12/2022 17:05

OP - you've prioritised your children which is the right and only thing to do in this situation. Your partner has created a situation which only he can fix - what happens now is up to him. Why should your children suffer because of his weakness and horrid sister? They shouldn't.

amonsteronthehill · 09/12/2022 16:58

You need to prioritise your children.

He's your partner, not your husband, and he invited his difficult, drinks-too-much sister who's not even nice to you to your home for Christmas without a second's thought for how that would affect your and your DCs' Christmas.

Tell him you understand why he chose to prioritise his sister, but you have to prioritise your own children here, and staying at home would be a misery for them and you, so you're not going to. He can ask his sister to change her plans and come another time so he can travel with you, or he can stay home with her. But you're out.

60degreecycle · 09/12/2022 16:53

@MillyMollyManky we have discussed it, we have had some calm open chats about how he feels upset and he feels somewhat that I've turned my back on him. I've been honest and said that it didn't feel right to put the kids through it, had it just been me and him it would have been no problem, and I'm feeling a bit upset that we had a chance at a cosy time as a "family" in our own right and it's now not happening.

He doesn't feel it's possible for him to reverse the invite leaving her on her own, and I'm not willing to tell the kids that we are now staying home with her, when they're looking forward to a good time with the family.

If you can think of a solution I'm all ears, any suggestions welcome!

OP posts:
Peashoots · 09/12/2022 16:49

I voted YANBU, as that’s what I’m leaning toward with the info provided. However, it depends. Was there any discussion with him about you going to your parents? Or about how unhappy you’d be to spend it with her?
ultimately your kids are your priority, he isn’t their dad so you’re not depriving a father of a christmas with his kids. So I think you’ve done the right thing. Although it’s a shitty position to be in and I feel for both you and your partner.

MillyMollyManky · 09/12/2022 16:43

60degreecycle · 09/12/2022 16:29

@MillyMollyManky I did heavy hint that maybe she might be uninvited as we had plans, but that was not an option apparently. They are expecting us at my brothers but would be totally fine if we decided to stay put, they're very low drama.

Stop hinting, start talking. Why not just say everything to him as clearly as you have said it here and try to work out a solution between you? Yes, he was in the wrong to invite her without checking, maybe he can uninvite her. Or perhaps there’s some other solution. Without discussing it openly, you won’t know.

diddl · 09/12/2022 16:41

If he thinks that he'll have a shit time with her-why did he think that it would be better with you there?

Spread the misery?🙄

60degreecycle · 09/12/2022 16:41

I think neither of our motivations were selfish. He wanted to make sure she wouldn't be alone, I wanted to make sure that the girls have a drama free time without an atmosphere driven by an adult they don't really know being out of step with the rest of us, which wouldn't be possible if we had just stayed put. I ran it past the kids and gave them the two options and they were definite they wanted to go to their uncles.

OP posts:
forrestgreen · 09/12/2022 16:36

I'd say he was U as he said yes knowing it would completely change Xmas for the worse. Then annoyed you're leaving him to it.
If he thought she'd be ok, he wouldn't be peeved he'll be shouldering the burden alone, he thought you'd soften the edges for him.

Nah, your priority is your children. His is his sister.

60degreecycle · 09/12/2022 16:35

@CarefreeMe I do see your point, and I'm feeling really regretful that we have got ourselves into this position. However, if he had kids and my mother was a wayward bordeline alcoholic loner, although I'd be pretty devastated we wouldnt' be spending the day as we had planned, I'd be fully accepting of him taking them elsewhere for a family Christmas rather than expect them to deal with her.

OP posts:
ImAvingOops · 09/12/2022 16:35

This is a mess entirely of his own making.
No one has a right to unilaterally invite people to stay over Christmas without even having a discussion with their partner whose house and Christmas it is too. The exception being their own children (assuming they are actual children)!

You have shown him the same level of consideration that he has shown you.

But your relationship is going to run into difficulties if both of you keep making choices without any consideration of the other - you are meant to be a unit, sharing a home and a life.

MichelleScarn · 09/12/2022 16:33

When did MN become the doormatty, #bekind, doesn't matter if you/your kids have a shitty time, you need to do what other people want and put them first or you are just DREADFUL! ?
@60degreecycle you've done the right thing, if the dsis is as unpleasant and self centred as she's sounds it's on her that she's on her own at Christmas!

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/12/2022 16:31

Good for you! People on here are usually all for Christmas being about children. I think Christmas is for everyone but you’re definitely doing the right thing by your DDs and he’s only worried about having a shit Christmas with his sister now you and DDs won’t be there to absorb some of her behaviour for him.

If he’s going to make selfish unilateral decisions about Christmas you get to do the same. Ignore his moaning and have a fabulous time! Maybe he’ll be more considerate and collaborative next time. If not at least you know how to motivate his selfishness.

60degreecycle · 09/12/2022 16:29

@MillyMollyManky I did heavy hint that maybe she might be uninvited as we had plans, but that was not an option apparently. They are expecting us at my brothers but would be totally fine if we decided to stay put, they're very low drama.

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 09/12/2022 16:27

Good for you! Interesting how people

Natty13 · 09/12/2022 16:27

MillyMollyManky · 09/12/2022 16:19

Going against the majority here- he has been fairly unreasonable but you've been massively unreasonable. The plan was the four of you spending Christmas together. He spoiled that a bit by inviting a fifth person without consulting you but you and he were still going to be together. In response you've blown the whole thing up.

MN tends to be very black and white- he did something wrong and so all bets are off, do whatever you like with no consultation or consideration of his feelings. I'm not sure that's a very healthy approach to relationships and I'm not surprised he's upset. This person is after all your partner whom you presumably love? A better approach might have been to explain how you feel and work out a way to still have a good Christmas together, even if that meant un-inviting the sister at least for part of it.

Not sure what to suggest as presumably everyone is now expecting you at your brother's. Bit of a shit show all round.

I do have this approach in my relationships: if you railroad me/don't treat me like a team mate/do things deliberately you know will have negative consequences for me then yes, all bets are off. I dont do it to people i love and don't tolerate it being done to me. Guess what? I'm neither a miserable martyr nor a lonely, friendless spinster. People in my life don't do things that take the piss out of me and I don't take the piss out of them, and we are a happy. Hopefully my daughter is growing up to be the same.

60degreecycle · 09/12/2022 16:25

Thanks all. Just to clear up a couple of questions, DP is not the girls dad, but have a great relationship with him and he's a partner of several years. We were all looking forward to a quiet one together. Past years she's done her own thing, threatened to come a couple of times but not arrived, and when she did turned up empty handed with a sleep deficit and a very different body clock to the rest of the house.

He didn't check with me first, just said that she had asked and he had responded with a yes as he couldnt enoy himself knowing she was on her own if he had said no, knew that it wouldn't be a popular move and we should maybe head down to my Brothers as that would be the best time for me and the kids. I'm not sure he thought I'd actually do it though, as there are some hurt feelings going on, which I completely understand. His motive was good, he didn't want her to be alone.

I don't want to invite her to my brothers, it would be as welcome as a fart in a lift. I would be on edge all day waiting for her to offend someone, and hoping for her not to swear/get too pissed/tell inappropriate stories in front of the kids/keep disappearing down the end of the garden for a joint or whatever else.

OP posts:
Highlyflavouredgravy · 09/12/2022 16:25

If my husband did this to me, i woildcfind it pretty hard to forgive tbh

Crumpleton · 09/12/2022 16:24

It all depends. If he had discussed it with you before asking her then yes YABU but if he asked her before telling you then absolutely not unreasonable!

He may well have discussed it and OP poster expressed a preference in not wanting her to join them....but he still invited her.

StopFeckingFaffing · 09/12/2022 16:24

Since he is your DP rather than DH and not the father of your DC then I can understand why you have prioritised what you believe is best for your DC

It does send him a fairly clear message about your priorities but I don't think that is necessarily a bad thing

magicalorange · 09/12/2022 16:22

Blueberrywitch · 09/12/2022 15:48

I think you’re being unreasonable I’m afraid. Christmas is about giving back and including people, your DP is being kind to a lonely family member and you’ve left him in the lurch.

Inviting a badly behaved drinker at the expense of young children?

That's the kind of giving back you mean?

Highlyflavouredgravy · 09/12/2022 16:21

MillyMollyManky · 09/12/2022 16:19

Going against the majority here- he has been fairly unreasonable but you've been massively unreasonable. The plan was the four of you spending Christmas together. He spoiled that a bit by inviting a fifth person without consulting you but you and he were still going to be together. In response you've blown the whole thing up.

MN tends to be very black and white- he did something wrong and so all bets are off, do whatever you like with no consultation or consideration of his feelings. I'm not sure that's a very healthy approach to relationships and I'm not surprised he's upset. This person is after all your partner whom you presumably love? A better approach might have been to explain how you feel and work out a way to still have a good Christmas together, even if that meant un-inviting the sister at least for part of it.

Not sure what to suggest as presumably everyone is now expecting you at your brother's. Bit of a shit show all round.

This

CarefreeMe · 09/12/2022 16:21

YABU

It’s one thing to invite someone over to join in with your Christmas.

But to go to a complete different house than your DH is way worse.

I wonder if you had invited your mum round and so your DH decided to go to someone else’s house instead, if he too would be getting as much support as you.

MillyMollyManky · 09/12/2022 16:19

Going against the majority here- he has been fairly unreasonable but you've been massively unreasonable. The plan was the four of you spending Christmas together. He spoiled that a bit by inviting a fifth person without consulting you but you and he were still going to be together. In response you've blown the whole thing up.

MN tends to be very black and white- he did something wrong and so all bets are off, do whatever you like with no consultation or consideration of his feelings. I'm not sure that's a very healthy approach to relationships and I'm not surprised he's upset. This person is after all your partner whom you presumably love? A better approach might have been to explain how you feel and work out a way to still have a good Christmas together, even if that meant un-inviting the sister at least for part of it.

Not sure what to suggest as presumably everyone is now expecting you at your brother's. Bit of a shit show all round.

StickyCricket · 09/12/2022 16:18

pigonalipstick · 09/12/2022 16:01

I think you've been awful. He has done a kind thing by inviting someone who was on their own, and you've used it to punish him. Yes of course he should have told you, but he wasn't doing anything mean or malicious, just trying to make sure his sister had someone to spend Christmas with by adding one person to your existing plans. In turn you've completely changed the plans by leaving him alone and taking your kids somewhere else. That's an awful way to treat a 'D'P no matter if they've upset you.

OP wasn’t doing anything mean or malicious, just trying to ensure her children have a lovely Christmas, rather than allowing them to be used as human support devices by her DP to dilute his own miserable Christmas.

That’s an awful way to treat your partner and their children, especially since he issued the invitation without even having the decency to consult with them first.