Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parent's funeral

112 replies

namechange143 · 09/12/2022 14:23

My mum has recently told me she doesn't want a funeral. Not a cremation, nothing.
She has changed her will to ensure this doesn't happen.
Hopefully this isn't a concern I have anytime soon, but isn't a funeral for the living rather than the dead?

I feel myself and my brother should have at least been spoken to to get our options on this? My dad also won't be having one.

She isn't being horrible, she genuinely thinks that it'll save us money. I understand they're expensive but isn't it all part of the grieving process? Funeral planning/car planning/wake etc? A way for everyone to say bye?

AIBU to think part of life would be to go to your parent's funeral? Or am I being ridiculous?

OP posts:
SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 09/12/2022 14:54

Flapjackquack · 09/12/2022 14:46

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist - you will get the ashes unless you decline them and they will scatter them in a cemetery.

Thanks.

Our relationship is a tad strained (understatement) and I wasn't going to feed the ghoul by asking.

GreenManalishi · 09/12/2022 14:53

I would comply with her wishes, there will have to be either a cremation or a burial of some kind, but let's face it once she's gone she won't know how you choose to mark it for yourselves. I don't think it would be disrespectful for you to organise something that you feel would be fitting after she's passed.

Ceremony around death is hard wired into every culture, in parts of the the animal kingdom as well as for humans since time began, it would be reasonable of you to want to mark it in some way for yourselves without expressly denying her end of life wishes to her while still alive.

startingline · 09/12/2022 14:49

We have direct cremations in our family. Cost of the last one was £1600. We celebrate with a big meal and champagne and the ashes scattered

PinkArt · 09/12/2022 14:49

I tihnk I'd have to honour her wishes, but find another way to mark her passing. Circumstances meant that the majority of my mum's friends couldn't be at her funeral, so we had a separate 'do' about a month later to get everyone together. Our approach was very much about celebrating her life so it was like a garden party, with a lot of cakes etc, but I'm sure the tone could have been changed if that had felt more suitable. It wasn't her funeral as such but it was a way for everyone to get together, to think about her, to support each other and to grieve without the traditional elements of a funeral. You might be able to think of your own version of a different way to mark her passing, when it comes.

Flapjackquack · 09/12/2022 14:46

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist - you will get the ashes unless you decline them and they will scatter them in a cemetery.

Adultchildofelderlyparents · 09/12/2022 14:46

There's nothing to stop you and your brother holding a memorial occasion at a later date after your mum has gone, doing something that's meaningful to you.
But I would respect her wishes around the disposal of her body.
I have also told my family that I don't want a funeral. I've requested to be sent for cremation alone, with no fuss. I cannot bear the thought of everyone standing around singing dreary songs, eating sandwiches. Nor would I expect them to throw an upbeat party. I don't have any religious beliefs. I believe we come from nothing and return to being nothing. I have also requested no stone or plaque or anything permanent to commemorate me.

Flapjackquack · 09/12/2022 14:45

Lots of people in my family have opted for a direct cremation, me and DH included. We’ve had two family members die with this wish and we’ve had two fantastic celebrations for them in keeping with their personalities. One we went to a very fancy restaurant and drank copious amounts of champagne and laughed until we cried and then cried and then laughed. The other we had a lovely calm picnic for. Little speeches were said at both. I find this much more freeing than paying thousands for a funeral and a wake and we had more time to plan. My mother has requested we take her ashes and scatter them at a seaside resort she visited as a child and make a weekend of it.

I would frame it as a positive OP. No funeral doesn’t mean no send off.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 09/12/2022 14:45

My parents have done the same. Direct cremation? They are cheap, paid up beforehand and give them some control, a feeling of not being a burden. They have paid for many funerals in their lives, many older relatives had paid into schemes that didn't cover costs. So they want to be sure.

I have no idea if we'll get the ashes but we can organise a wake!

OoooohMatron · 09/12/2022 14:44

AuntieMarys · 09/12/2022 14:29

It's nothing to do with you.

Of course in concerns her, she'll be the one left behind.

Comedycook · 09/12/2022 14:44

I totally agree with you op. I also think it doesn't have to be a traditional funeral but you definitely deserve a gathering with friends and family to say goodbye and remember her life, when that time comes.

PauliesWalnuts · 09/12/2022 14:44

I went for a burial and no service or wake in my will. And then my brother died suddenly, and because we were on lockdown we had to have a very small service, and then I realised just how much funerals are needed to give those who are left some closure. I need to change my will, but have already told my executor to ignore that bit.

I'd try to have another conversation with her to be honest.

alongtimeagoandfaraway · 09/12/2022 14:43

A friend had a direct cremation but her closest friends organised an afternoon tea in her home afterwards where all her friends from different parts of her life gathered to remember her and share stories about her life. It was a truly lovely event.

IToldYouAmillionTimesAlready · 09/12/2022 14:42

My dad donated his body to medical science, so there was no funeral - no coffin, flowers, hearse, when he died 22 years ago. The hospital asked if we'd like a service for my dad, so that we and his friends could remember him. The hospital arranged it, and it cost us nothing but we left a good donation.

I'm 63 now and I signed up, about 15 years ago, to donate my body to medical science. My husband has, too.

Lemons1571 · 09/12/2022 14:42

Rhondaa · 09/12/2022 14:35

This sounds lovely.

Why pair a fortune for a procession of expensive cars and all the paraphernalia.

I'd much rather do the same as the op's dm, let the kids have a bit of a get together but use the 5k of whatever for something nice.

Direct cremation costs around £1k doesn’t it? Plus costs of storage at the funeral directors which is another £1k. I found the basic unavoidable costs were the highest, much more significant than the £70 on flowers or £200 for the car.

Crunchingleaf · 09/12/2022 14:42

I also think funerals are for those left behind so I can definitely see your point of view.
I am Irish so my opinion is skewed by how seriously we take wakes and funerals. It’s something to focus on when your loved one dies, it’s a time for tears and there can also even be laughter as you remember the person, it’s a time to be with your family. Something about hearing stories about your loved one can really help the grieving process.
Hopefully it isn’t a situation you will have to face for a long time, but you can still do something with your immediate family.

ladywithnomanors · 09/12/2022 14:41

You have to respect her wishes. Although you may ask to have a proper discussion with her about it. Let her know how upsetting it would be for you.
For what it's worth I would have been in favour of a direct cremation when my Mum died. I told my sister at the time that if i could have got away with not going to her funeral I wouldnt have gone. I found it incredibly traumatic. I was beside myself with grief.

AuntieMarys · 09/12/2022 14:41

PickyTea · 09/12/2022 14:31

It’s everything to do with the OP and any immediate family

It really doesn't. I'm having a direct cremation. My family can have a do after if they want. But I'm not paying for it.
They know my wishes and accept them. Funerals are awful in my opinion.

BMW6 · 09/12/2022 14:41

Direct cremation for DH and I, and 4 of my 5 siblings.

I've asked that they get together to scatter my ashes in a particular spot, have a lovely pub lunch and toast my journey while having a lovely time.

I'm going to get a selection of family photos to leave for them to prompt happy reminiscing, mostly funny.

2pinkginsplease · 09/12/2022 14:39

you need to respect her wishes, my mum has certain wishes after her death, I’ve told her to write it all down and sign it so that when I carry out her wishes, no one else can argue with me or go against what she wants as it’s her wishes.

to go against it would be disrespectful.

you could always have an afternoon later on to celebrate your mum with your nearest and dearest, maybe a fundraising event to donate money to your mums favourite charity in her memory.

givemushypeasachance · 09/12/2022 14:38

Funerals are for friends and family, predominantly. But a lot of people have strong opinions on what they want from a funeral, and most families wouldn't go against a loved one's expressed wishes and e.g. have a humanist ceremony if they wanted a traditional catholic service. So I don't see why it isn't equally valid to respect someone's wishes to not have a traditional funeral. You can still arrange a family and friends get together to remember them.

Organ donation has first dibs for me, and if they don't want them then I'm signed up to the local medical school for 'donation to science'. In those circumstances the medical school has your body for a year or two, it only gets released for any further disposal when they're done with it. Medical students often attend services of thanks at the end.

Classinglass · 09/12/2022 14:37

My mum literally said the same thing the other day, all she wants is a no fuss cremation she doesn’t even want her ashes scattered so I know exactly how you are feeling. Funerals can be a huge part of the grieving process but I suppose decisions made have to be respected.

PiggyPlumPie · 09/12/2022 14:36

My Dad had a direct cremation earlier this year as it was what he wanted.

It was odd but right for him. My mum however has said that we should choose what we want for her so that is a conversation to be had with my sisters.

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 09/12/2022 14:36

My mum has said the same and has prepaid for a direct cremation. However she would everyone to have a big party.

Rhondaa · 09/12/2022 14:35

Bobbybobbins · 09/12/2022 14:30

My friend's mum said the same so they did a celebration afternoon in a lovely garden with food and readings but quite different from a typical funeral. Might be an option. You are right that it is for living IMO

This sounds lovely.

Why pair a fortune for a procession of expensive cars and all the paraphernalia.

I'd much rather do the same as the op's dm, let the kids have a bit of a get together but use the 5k of whatever for something nice.

xogossipgirlxo · 09/12/2022 14:33

Tell her she doesn't have a say in wake and it will be done on your terms then😂But seriously, I think I understand you. Funeral is for those who are alive. DH's grandma died of Covid, she was buried in plastic bag in hospital pyjamas. Did it make her any difference? No. Did it affect my husband? Hell yes. He couldn't get over it for ages. He found his closure when he burst into tears one night and just cried it all out. Until then, he was suffering insomnia and felt really low.

Swipe left for the next trending thread