Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parent's funeral

112 replies

namechange143 · 09/12/2022 14:23

My mum has recently told me she doesn't want a funeral. Not a cremation, nothing.
She has changed her will to ensure this doesn't happen.
Hopefully this isn't a concern I have anytime soon, but isn't a funeral for the living rather than the dead?

I feel myself and my brother should have at least been spoken to to get our options on this? My dad also won't be having one.

She isn't being horrible, she genuinely thinks that it'll save us money. I understand they're expensive but isn't it all part of the grieving process? Funeral planning/car planning/wake etc? A way for everyone to say bye?

AIBU to think part of life would be to go to your parent's funeral? Or am I being ridiculous?

OP posts:
Tinkerbyebye · 09/12/2022 15:34

It’s want they want. My parents have specified it’s their children only if anyone wants to attend, no grandkids, partners, friends, other family members. If they were to say a direct cremation then we would respect that

you can always hold a wake

ChocolateBauble · 09/12/2022 15:33

It’s a tricky one. I see your point that a funeral is for the people left behind and you are right in many ways and of course she would never know what you decide to do. However, it might seem like a bit of a betrayal of her final wish if you ignore her wish not to have a funeral. You might in the long term afterwards think it’s the right thing to change her final wish, or in the long term you might end up with guilty feelings that you didn’t respect her wishes.

Invizicat · 09/12/2022 15:32

strawberry2017 · 09/12/2022 15:05

I respect my parents wishes in life so I will respect their wishes in death also.
It's not about me, it's about them and what they want.

But what if the parent who died wanted a funeral which goes against the wishes or beliefs of the remaining living parent? Whose wishes matter more - the living mourning parent or the deceased mourned parent?

Footballmyarse · 09/12/2022 15:30

Invizicat · 09/12/2022 15:26

I have a similar problem the other way round. My dad has said he wants a traditional church funeral with hymns, prayers etc etc. He is in his nineties and has no friends or family remaining except for dm, myself, dh and 2 dgc (who are all strongly atheist and/or muslim background.

I just can't imagine how we will be able to fulfill his wishes. It would feel so meaningless, the 5 of us stood there in a totally empty church mumbling our way through rituals we aren't familiar with. Do we agree now for his peace of mind and then go against his request when the time comes? Or do we point out now that a church funeral wouldn't hold any meaning to any of his potential mourners?

We are in a similar predicament then, @Invizicat It’s so hard isn’t it? I am luckier I guess as the money side of things has taken the decision out of my hands. I knew if my dad was still able to understand, there’s no way he would want me getting into thousands of pounds of debt for his funeral.

00deed1988 · 09/12/2022 15:30

Funerals definitely for those left behind. I have told my DH that I want to be cremated but other than that they can do what they like. As big or small as they feel they want. It is them who have to attend and deal with it.

maddiemookins16mum · 09/12/2022 15:26

AuntieMarys · 09/12/2022 14:29

It's nothing to do with you.

Of course it is, she’s the left behind having to (probably) sort out everything.

Invizicat · 09/12/2022 15:26

I have a similar problem the other way round. My dad has said he wants a traditional church funeral with hymns, prayers etc etc. He is in his nineties and has no friends or family remaining except for dm, myself, dh and 2 dgc (who are all strongly atheist and/or muslim background.

I just can't imagine how we will be able to fulfill his wishes. It would feel so meaningless, the 5 of us stood there in a totally empty church mumbling our way through rituals we aren't familiar with. Do we agree now for his peace of mind and then go against his request when the time comes? Or do we point out now that a church funeral wouldn't hold any meaning to any of his potential mourners?

2bazookas · 09/12/2022 15:15

As an adult, we've been to the funerals of parents and loved relatives and religious or humanist, church or crematorium, they were awful/harrowing/farcical in various ways. We won't put our family survivors through that (either the organising or attending). Instead, we're both having direct cremation; our remains will be whisked away by the undertaker and disposed of at the crematorium with no attendance and no service. ( cardboard coffin, "off peak" time because it's cheapest. And as we're paying for it, we get the last word.)

If our children want to have some personal farewell ceremony they are welcome; but there will be no corpses or coffins, no hired venue, no hired "celebrant" or minister, no prayers or hymns . Feel free to hold it on our birthdays, in a garden or on the beach or hills, bring wine, beer, a picnic, children, dogs, deckchairs, frisbees.

SilverSalver · 09/12/2022 15:15

My neighbour's husband died this year. There was a "pure cremation". No service, no wake. She seemed happy with it and says she'll do the same.

My mother's funeral was curtailed because of covid. She wanted a grand send off and had it planned down to the last detail. It would have been fabulous and we did what we could but it wasn't what she planned. She was religeous and these things mattered to her.

In the end it's for the living I think. A will won't enforce it because the funeral takes place long before the will gets sorted. You have to decide how you would feel if you had a funeral knowing it wasn't what she wanted. I'd also say the surviving spouse gets final say if there is one.

Ginmonkeyagain · 09/12/2022 15:11

Ha! the "full works" funeral is very expensive. My partner' dad always wanted that - he was old school Irish Catholic so he wanted the full requiem mass, burial, fancy coffin, full procession of hearses, pub based wake. When he died the he had veyr little in the way of money and we all anxiously totted up the costs of honourign his wishes (we had just brought house and were pretty broke). Turned out he had pre paid for the whole thing on one of those funeral plans to make sure he got exactly what he wanted..

Footballmyarse · 09/12/2022 15:08

I’d say you need to respect her wishes. I want the same.

I’ve the opposite problem with my dad. He wants a huge funeral in a church (he’s not even religious)', has had all the songs picked out for years etc. Only trouble is, he didn’t pay for it. He assumed he would just die one day and then I would have his savings to pay for it all. What happened was, he got dementia and all his money is soon to be gone due to paying care fees. And there is only me and my children anyway, so a funeral would be a waste, I’m not getting into debt for the 4 of us to sit and listen to someone who didn’t know him parrot things back to me that I have told them to say. It’s going to be a direct cremation (and even then, that will get me into debt I can’t afford - if the council do it, they don’t let you have the ashes) and then we will scatter ashes where he’s asked.

I expect to be haunted.

Ginmonkeyagain · 09/12/2022 15:07

My aunt specified "no funeral".

She had a direct cremation and there was a simple Church of Scotland thanksgiving service. It felt a bit odd not having a wake afterward as everyone milled around awkwardly and then just left. But it what she wanted, so we respected it.

strawberry2017 · 09/12/2022 15:05

I respect my parents wishes in life so I will respect their wishes in death also.
It's not about me, it's about them and what they want.

oakleaffy · 09/12/2022 15:05

@xogossipgirlxo Edit...Sorry, I should have said your husbands Grandmother, not Mum.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 09/12/2022 15:04

I find these dictats from beyond the grave very unsettling. You will be dead/gone/unknowing when your relatives have to do something or not do something according to your instructions. It's a form of control - 'you will do what I say even though I'm not there any more'. Thank goodness my parents just let me get on with organising their funerals as I wished, without lots of controlling instructions. My DD can do what she likes when I die, because I won't know a thing about it!

ThickTiuri · 09/12/2022 15:04

They may be her wishes but, bluntly, she'll be dead and won't know if you followed them or not. The important thing is for you and your family to say your goodbye in the way that works best for you in terms of ceremony, cost, memorial etc. Do what you need to do.

oakleaffy · 09/12/2022 15:04

xogossipgirlxo · 09/12/2022 14:33

Tell her she doesn't have a say in wake and it will be done on your terms then😂But seriously, I think I understand you. Funeral is for those who are alive. DH's grandma died of Covid, she was buried in plastic bag in hospital pyjamas. Did it make her any difference? No. Did it affect my husband? Hell yes. He couldn't get over it for ages. He found his closure when he burst into tears one night and just cried it all out. Until then, he was suffering insomnia and felt really low.

That's really sad.
However, I was the only person in out family to view Dad at the Undertakers, and he had specified ''No makeup!'' and he looked ''Honestly dead'' and not at all like him.
Just ''Empty''.
His Spirit had truly flown.
It's strange how people look different once their Spirit leaves.
I remember adoptive mum {when dad died} said she was upset at the thought of him being in a ''fridge'' as he had claustrophobia.

I hope your Husband can think of his Mum's Spirit being free of her body.

Flapjackquack · 09/12/2022 15:03

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 09/12/2022 14:54

Thanks.

Our relationship is a tad strained (understatement) and I wasn't going to feed the ghoul by asking.

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist - no worries, my MIL didn’t collect one of her parents ashes due to their relationship. I didn’t judge her. We all have our own way of dealing with things.

SheWoreYellow · 09/12/2022 15:03

I think funerals are for the ones left behind and they should choose.

But I suppose you just need to work around this and have whatever sort of gathering you want to.

MincepiesforRudolph · 09/12/2022 15:00

I think you should follow her wishes but maybe have a family lunch afterwards for scattering her ashes?
A couple of my close younger friends have died unexpectedly this year which has forced me to think about what I'd want. I'm an organ donor. I have a small family, and friends are scattered far and wide. My preference would be a direct cremation, followed later by a scattering off the beach/pier, and a nice lunch for all at the nearby pub where DH and I first met. I have a short play list for the scattering. Sorted! 😉

AWaferThinMint · 09/12/2022 14:58

Follow her wishes. Then after the dust has worked get you family together for a knees up but without the big funeral bit. That's the big for you that you will appreciate.

Nottodaty · 09/12/2022 14:57

It is her choice - my fil has requested something similar & we would all still get together and do something but he doesn’t want the fuss or cost (he could afford it!)
My Grandad passed away recently and he had a cremation but had pre paid & requested what he wanted songs and readings - we all respected that.
My Mil wants the whole lot mourners cars etc

We just need to respect their wishes.

mumda · 09/12/2022 14:55

The good bits about funerals are
Family - seeing family members you don't normally find time to see.
Friends - hearing about aspects of their life you knew nothing about.

The cost of funerals is obscene.

Bogglebrain · 09/12/2022 14:55

BMW6 · 09/12/2022 14:41

Direct cremation for DH and I, and 4 of my 5 siblings.

I've asked that they get together to scatter my ashes in a particular spot, have a lovely pub lunch and toast my journey while having a lovely time.

I'm going to get a selection of family photos to leave for them to prompt happy reminiscing, mostly funny.

This is what I want for myself - except a nice cream tea for everyone instead of a pub lunch. My mother has questioned my decision though by saying that a funeral would be better for the DC - would it? hopefully they’ll be adults when it happens though!

Womencanlift · 09/12/2022 14:54

Is it down to cost or her beliefs?

If it’s cost then if your and your brother offer to pay would she change her mind? If you expect her to pay when she doesn’t want one then YABU

If it’s beliefs then you should respect them and do something directly with your brother to have closure

Swipe left for the next trending thread