Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parent's funeral

112 replies

namechange143 · 09/12/2022 14:23

My mum has recently told me she doesn't want a funeral. Not a cremation, nothing.
She has changed her will to ensure this doesn't happen.
Hopefully this isn't a concern I have anytime soon, but isn't a funeral for the living rather than the dead?

I feel myself and my brother should have at least been spoken to to get our options on this? My dad also won't be having one.

She isn't being horrible, she genuinely thinks that it'll save us money. I understand they're expensive but isn't it all part of the grieving process? Funeral planning/car planning/wake etc? A way for everyone to say bye?

AIBU to think part of life would be to go to your parent's funeral? Or am I being ridiculous?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UsingChangeofName · 10/12/2022 11:47

I think there are some people seemingly arguing for both sides but actually agreeing with one another, and it is to do with the language used.
For me, a 'funeral' is an all encompassing word for getting together to celebrate that person's life. So those having a memorial service or a thanksgiving service or a ceremony to scatter the ashes, and so forth all are meeting that need for those left behind to get together and celebrate the person's life.

SallyWD · 10/12/2022 09:55

My mum suggested this too and I simply said it's up to me and my brothers how we choose to mark her passing.

Londonnight · 10/12/2022 09:34

My elderly parents have signed up and paid for Direct cremation. They want no funeral. This is their wishes which we as a family respect. Once they have both gone we will get together and arrange to scatter the ashes where they wish them to go.
My parents decided this during the pandemic when travel just wasn't available. We are a family who are far flung around the world and they saw just how difficult it would be even during normal times to get everyone together for a funeral.

I think it is a very sensible decision and I will be putting the same plans in place for myself.

bobisbored · 10/12/2022 09:34

My mum said the same to me recently. I think she thought she would be making it easier for me not having to organise abc go through a funeral but I feel like it's part of the grieving process and a kind of closure. It needs further discussion I think.

Pinkblanket · 10/12/2022 09:30

I have done it both ways. My dad passed away a few years ago, he didn't want a funeral, his only close family were me and my mum and my mum hates funerals. He was very clear about his wishes. So we decided not to have one. When my mum passed away last year I did have a very small, low key funeral for her, not for me, but her brother and her partner/boyfriend. I can't say I personally gained anything from it. I don't feel I have grieved any differently than I did for my dad. I wondered if I might, having seen so many posts like this, but I don't. There's no amazing sense of comfort or closure. It didn't even save any money, the funeral was cheaper!
It's such a personal choice. What I would say is that it would be nice if people could be a bit more respectful about people who choose to grieve differently from the 'norm' and accept that not everyone feels the same way. There are a multitude of ways to remember a loved one and they don't have to involve standing around a coffin if you don't want to.

LostAtTheCrossRoad · 10/12/2022 09:24

I should add that having organised both my parents' funerals when I was still a teenage only child has coloured my views on allowing the family left behind to do what they need to cope..

LostAtTheCrossRoad · 10/12/2022 09:21

I'm an atheist and don't believe in anything after death so I won't give a rats ass what my family do after I'm gone. What I want is for them to do whatever they need to do at the time to get through things. That's it. Whatever they need.

If pushed to state a preference, I'd personally love it if they went for a direct cremation or a minimal service, followed by spending a metric fcuk tonne of money on getting some great champagne in at our favourite local, put a similarly enormous sum behind the bar, getting their most favourite couple of street food vans in town in their courtyard, and having the best afternoon possible in the circumstances on it.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/12/2022 09:11

I don’t see how she can get away with ‘not a cremation’, nothing. Are you supposed to put her out for the bin men to recycle?

To me, funerals are largely for those left behind, and I wouldn’t worry too much about not doing precisely what they wanted.

My DF had a bit of a Thing about money wasted on flowers for funerals, and more than once joked that he’d come back and haunt anyone who wasted money on them for his. So my DM - who really wanted him to - put a little bunch on his coffin anyway.
Alas she was disappointed.

Zukki · 10/12/2022 09:03

Direct cremations are increasingly popular, the way round giving your dm her wishes is have a direct cremation then have an internment of ashes which is similar to a funeral but the cremation is already done, it is putting the ashes to their final resting place.

NerrSnerr · 10/12/2022 09:02

I think it's really unfair to not to respect their last wishes. I know people are saying funerals are for the living but what are you going to say in the Eulogy? She didn't want this, she put in her will she didn't want this but we ignored the last thing that she wanted as we wanted to do this.

I'd have a separate gathering.

Hobbesmanc · 10/12/2022 08:59

My lovely father in law died in November and had a direct cremation. No service, no fuss. We picked up his ashes a few days after his death and we are having a small family memorial event in the new year.

He wasn't religious and had outlived most friends and family. His choice and one we needed to respect.

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 10/12/2022 08:48

When my Dad died in May, he wanted a direct cremation. He was collected from his care home, then cremated about 2 weeks later. He was ready to collected about 3 days after the cremation.

They were his wishes, it was not for us to ignore them. It was what he wanted.

The only final wish we haven’t carried out is he wanted a teaspoon of himself to be sprinkled on Mum’s (his ex wife’s) carpet every time we went round, so she’d have to vacuum him up (there was no love lost at the end)!

The only reason we haven’t done this is a week after Dad died I had to start caring for Mum, including doing her cleaning, so it’d be me both sprinkling & then vacuuming. Sod that lol.

We may have a scattering with a party, but since he said, “My family didn’t give me the pickings from their arses when I was alive, I’m not feeding the buggers now when I’m dead.” we’re not rushing to do anything with them!

WuTangGran · 10/12/2022 08:35

Funerals are for the left behind and your mum doesn’t want one. She’s told you that.
Why not hold a celebration of her life instead?
Will you be ok in later years knowing that you didn’t do what she wanted?

Fluffycloudland77 · 10/12/2022 08:29

If you’re not a regular at church etc it’s a officiant who never met you poncing on about what a great person you were while your loved ones sit there using up a day of annual leave.

At my granny’s funeral they said much loved grandmother of cousins names, my bloody cousins didn’t even turn up & my mums cousin tried to chat me up.

OoooohMatron · 10/12/2022 01:13

Geppili · 09/12/2022 15:36

David Bowie did it.

So? Is OP David Bowie's DD.

Choconut · 09/12/2022 19:07

Could you not have a direct cremation and then sprinkle her ashes somewhere special and have some sort of small social thing around that?
I hate going to funerals, to me they are just depressing and so pointless and I'd be so happy if my parents wanted a direct cremation and scattering somewhere special. Unfortunately they don't.

jackstini · 09/12/2022 19:00

My mum has already booked a direct cremation

She has said she would like it if we then got together at whatever point we want to celebrate her life - pub meal, picnic sort of thing

She doesn't want anything involving her body being there

I will go with her wishes as she's left it completely up to us what to do as the celebration part

namechange143 · 09/12/2022 18:31

I am also so sorry to the posters that have been through these really sad events too. It does sound like funerals aren't closure for everyone too.

OP posts:
namechange143 · 09/12/2022 18:30

*.think!

OP posts:
namechange143 · 09/12/2022 18:30

Thank you so much for all of the replies.

It has definitely made me see things from both sides too. Yes, I think it must be the direct cremation she wants. I was a big baffled at the time.

I have often wondered if funerals do give closure.

Also to the poster that said "I'll do what I want", I wasn't saying I'd go against her wishes. Was just thinking she could have discussed it beforehand, before a final decision whilst she is alive.

A get together does sound really lovely.

Thanks again everyone. It's made really interesting reading and made me have a good thing!

OP posts:
iklboo · 09/12/2022 18:28

Both my parents died within nine weeks of each other. Dad on December 23rd last year, mum on 28 February this year. In between that my cousin took his own life.

I sat with dad's body for over four hours. I sat at my mum's hospital bedside for 37 hours, made the decision to withdraw oxygen & watched her die.

I wouldn't have been able to handle three 'full' funerals. Not a chance. Neither of my parents were religious, both stipulated cremation. So I had direct cremations for both of them. I held wakes for them both to honour their memory.

losingit31 · 09/12/2022 18:07

FIL refused to have anything more than a few words from the priest at the graveside for MIL. DH and his brothers were very disappointed but couldn't do anything. They had family travel from overseas for this 5 minute extravaganza as well.

mondaytosunday · 09/12/2022 18:06

You can still do something - a lunch with her dearest friends to honour her.

curiousbanana · 09/12/2022 18:03

Hmm, I'm in 2 minds about this.

A close family member of mine died this year. Their funeral was arranged by another family member.

I know that the deceased person would have hated it. They'd have hated the readings, stories told and the photos shown. I tried to steer the organiser in a more low key direction to no avail.

I hated the funeral. It didn't represent the deceased person at all. It was what the person organising wanted, which was much more showy and bigger than others in the family thought it should be. I found it very uncomfortable, and some parts of it I had to step away from.

I loved my relative very much, but many of us were very uncomfortable and unhappy with their funeral. It's not what they would have wanted.

OhPeggySue · 09/12/2022 17:48

I'd be really upset if there was a traditional funeral for me. I won't know of course but I'd much prefer a woodland burial with no one there. I think respecting their wishes is a nice last thing you can do for someone you care for.