Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To change my whole posture etc when I speak a different language

35 replies

Hoppinggreen · 09/12/2022 10:13

So I speak 2 other European languages and am learning a 3rd and I have noticed that my tone and body language/posture change depending on which one I speak
Spanish - my voice drops lower and I tend to be a bit more feisty , louder and gesticulate more
French - I kind of slump a bit and use my shoulders a lot and also my eyebrows
German - I sit up straighter and am a bit more formal

I had no idea I was doing any of this until DH took the piss but now he has I notice it. Does anyone else do this or something similar? It’s almost like I assume a character.
Also I tend to use Spanish to bollock the DC and German to issue commands to the dog

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hoppinggreen · 09/12/2022 19:41

ILoveeCakes · 09/12/2022 18:28

Hopefully, when you go to France, Spain and Germany, they don't think you are taking the piss out of them. It may well look and sound like it.

No, it’s not that overt.
If you didn’t know me you wouldn’t notice.

OP posts:
Cheesuswithallama · 09/12/2022 18:44

It's normal. I have completely different tone and demeaner in English than in my native language. Apparently it makes me 5 years younger based on higher voice and such😂
In my native i am good half an octave lower

whumpthereitis · 09/12/2022 18:39

Buteverythingsfine · 09/12/2022 14:47

My husband always speaks in a far more animated, even aggressive seeming way in his native (Slavic) language. He doesn't smile as much, which is a cultural difference, his friends take the mickey out of him smiling a lot now which he does as used to UK/US culture in which random smiling is not perceived as insincere.

This is my experience too, as a speaker of two Slavic languages. I ‘soften’ when I speak English, and yes, smile more.

BeringBlue · 09/12/2022 18:34

I'm a native speaker of English. Dutch is my second language and I also speak fluent French (I live in France).

I'm a lovely person in French! I'm smiley and friendly and relaxed. I'm the best version of me.

I can be quite stroppy in English. I sag inwardly when I set foot on UK soil because I know stuff is going to wind me up several times a day and I'm going to rise to the bait and end up dithering: do I say something or do I end up being wet and ineffectual so I don't offend people?

But the flip side is I love the no-nonsense side (bolshie) side of me that comes out when I speak Dutch. Sentences are short and to the point. English waffling be gone - I'll tell it to you straight. I don't think I'm being rude...

Melassa · 09/12/2022 18:34

I’m the same, to me switching between languages is like putting on a different dress and it appeals to the closet actress in me 😂

I also have different Englishes, depending who I’m addressing. Other than my normal English I have European English with different words and tone when addressing European colleagues, and full on Downton Abbey when talking to Americans. I really can’t help it. Maybe it’s to avoid slipping into faux American and possibly offending them, so I go completely the other way.

my DD is bilingual and I’ve noticed recently that when she speaks English she out Britishes her British relatives. Local language she just sounds bored.

ILoveeCakes · 09/12/2022 18:28

Hopefully, when you go to France, Spain and Germany, they don't think you are taking the piss out of them. It may well look and sound like it.

Hoppinggreen · 09/12/2022 18:09

SleekMamma · 09/12/2022 17:57

I'm much more assertive in french, it's bizarre

I go passive aggressive tiger mum in Spanish

OP posts:
Havanananana · 09/12/2022 18:08

"I'm much more assertive in french, it's bizarre"

It's not really bizarre. "Language" is more than just the words spoken and the grammar - there is a cultural aspect as well.

In some languages there is a cultural reluctance to be too assertive, with lots of wandering about trying not to sound too direct or critical. In some other languages, this would be considered "waffle" and the message and impact would be lost because the culture is to be more direct (which, for example, to an English speaker might sound rude or abrupt).

Yddraigoldragon · 09/12/2022 18:01

There is science behind it! Proxemics and kinesics..
There is a superb fantasy novel by Janet Kagan, Hellspark, which really illustrates the concept.

SleekMamma · 09/12/2022 17:57

I'm much more assertive in french, it's bizarre

katscamel · 09/12/2022 17:55

I can't remember the full details now but there has been research carried out on language learning for dementia sufferers and how they become different personalities. It was fascinating and must find it again.

Rainallnight · 09/12/2022 17:51

I’m glad you posted this! I’ve got decent spoken French and my mannerisms also change. Bof!

CowPie · 09/12/2022 17:50

And your face wrinkles differently, depending on the language you habitually speak, because of the different facial movements needed.

Havanananana · 09/12/2022 17:42

Completely understandable. I speak English (native language) plus two European languages. In one language, the entire mouth shape required for some of the sounds is completely different to English, so I have a very different voice. Also the speed of this language is slower than English, so the body language is different and gestures are slower.

My other language is full of very long words and sentences, and can at times be very formal with an emphasis placed on correct grammar and word order. This means that a good lungful of air is often required before starting a sentence, and a posture that allows this to happen.

Buteverythingsfine · 09/12/2022 14:47

My husband always speaks in a far more animated, even aggressive seeming way in his native (Slavic) language. He doesn't smile as much, which is a cultural difference, his friends take the mickey out of him smiling a lot now which he does as used to UK/US culture in which random smiling is not perceived as insincere.

AnnaBegins · 09/12/2022 14:42

Yup I speak in a slightly different pitch in my second language, I think it's fascinating how language shapes us.

FasterthanBolt · 09/12/2022 14:35

Bizarrely my manager and I were talking about this today! I think she sounds the same when she speaks in English and her native tongue but she says I sound totally different when I speak in a second language. I've never really noticed it before but I think she's right!

Clymene · 09/12/2022 14:23

I've just realised I do it too! How funny - never realised Grin

CowPie · 09/12/2022 14:21

Absolutely normal for me. I actually think I’m a (slightly) different person in the different languages I speak well. A friend who’d only ever been around me in an Anglophone environment once overheard me on the phone in French and said my laugh was different!

Virginiaplain · 09/12/2022 14:21

I knew 2 quiet boring people who turned into lively even sparkling, fun attractive people when they spoke in French.

lljkk · 09/12/2022 14:20

Sometimes you can pick people out (streets of London) by language they are probably speak, from body language alone. Certain expressions or gestures are just "so Spanish" or "Very Italian" etc.

Brefugee · 09/12/2022 14:13

with mine it was that they wouldn't speak L2 to me because that was just wrong. But when they were very small they spoke to all adults in English and all children in L2. That soon stopped as we don't live in an English speaking country (although most adults are very profficient in English)

Then came the phase when they didn't want to speak to me in English, especially if anyone they knew was around. So they alswered me in L2 even though i resolutely always spoke to them in English. Then came homework and concepts that they could only talk about in L2 as that is how they learned them. All fun and interesting stuff, actually, over the years with bilingual DCs.

andyindurham · 09/12/2022 11:07

I'm sure I once read something about research among Japanese women living in California. I think it was in the 1960s. They were interviewed in Japanese, and then in English. After studying the answers, the research found that in their Japanese interviews, the women gave fairly traditional, submissive answers to questions about their role in the family or society, which was largely in keeping with traditional Japanese views about how women should behave.

When they answered the same questions in English, they were much more assertive and focused on themselves as individuals. This was felt to be more in keeping with the increased profile of the women's rights movement in California at that time.

So, yes, there is evidence that the language you speak affects what you think and how you express it.

It may also affect your personality in other ways. My daughter is growing up bilingual. I can speak both her languages, but English is very much my mother tongue and the other is obviously a second language for me. She already notices that in English I can tell jokes, make puns, improvise stories and do all sorts of fun wordplay stuff. However, in L2, I'm limited to instructions and transferring basic information. So she won't speak with me in L2 because it's 'boring'.

Brefugee · 09/12/2022 11:04

Oh there are loads of studies on this. I have bilingual DCs and noticed it pretty much from the start. One is more pronounced than the other, deeper voice and everything. Very interesting.

I speak a 2nd language fluently and a couple of others less so, and i do it too. It's just a language thing, i guess.

FettleOfKish · 09/12/2022 11:01

DH is bilingual, so I'm going to look out for this now.

He learnt fluently as a small child though so I don't suppose he was unconsciously attaching any pre-conceptions to his non-native language.

My Italian friends do use their hands more when they're speaking Italian than English.

Swipe left for the next trending thread