Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About DD staying over at a boy's house

209 replies

lilacclementine · 08/12/2022 22:06

DD is 17. She's just out of an 18 month relationship and enjoying spending more time with friends and working for her A levels.

She's just announced that on Sat she was going to watch a sporting thing with a lad she's known for ages (they've been a bit flirty for a while) then they're going to go round to his and watch Christmas films and get a takeaway.
The kicker is she's planning on staying over as it's quite a long journey back and I can't get her.

I said no.

She said that I can't say that.

She also says that :

  1. she's not planning on sleeping with him
  2. she's pretty sensible and sober
  3. she's 17 and doesn't think I have much of a say in this.

It's point 3 that bothers me. She's not planning a night of drunken foolishness (neither of them really drink because they both play sport quite seriously) but instead a takeaway and movies. She's very clear that she's not planning on doing anything but I've told her that plans change. Then she told me that if plans did change that would also be ok as she's 17, knows her own mind, and is safe.

It just feels so strange. Technically in a year she'll be at university doing whatever she likes but this feels strangely permissive.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Trottersltd · 10/12/2022 16:00

lilacclementine · 09/12/2022 12:06

So.... apart from a couple of notable exceptions (!) most people fell on the side of telling me I was being unreasonable. Frankly the exceptions didn't sound like we parented the same way at all which made me think. I'm very low contact with my
Mum who parented the same way as the exceptions: do as I say, threats of being thrown out, her way or the highway, obsession with me being a "good girl". I lied and lied as a teenager and a young woman and our relationship has never recovered. I've never shared anything of my life with her and she wonders why me and my sister avoid her.

Anyway, I'm a grown up. I can take it. This was why I posted- DD and I are usually on the sane page about most things now so this caught me unawares. I got up early in the cold and offered her a lift to 7.30am conditioning training. We have our best conversations in the car!

I stressed the safety aspect- she might have one plan about the evening but he might have a different one. She's 5foot 3 and 7 .5 stone. He's 6 foot 2 and plays rugby. Initially she was quite offended on his behalf but eventually I think she understood my anxiety. We now have a code word, plus she's now been added to the family Uber account so if she needs/ wants to come home we will find the £40+ for the trip. She did stress though that he's nice, has been respectful so far as to her boundaries and she's known him and his whole group of friends for years.

So- she's going and I'm getting used to my new, very-nearly-a-proper-adult daughter. On her way out of the car she magnanimously said she's forgotten to eat her advent calendar chocolate today so I could have it.
Proper adult!

I'm with you on this really.

Boys for damn sure aren't at 17, its the saftey aspect and while I agree with most saying no she'll just rebel, you've done what I would do, say yes but with a heavy caution about protection and a get out plan, like you've done.

I'm sorry, but those who just see this as a freedom issue for a young adult are missing the point, young boys vary widly in maturity and many a 'nice boy' has ended up being a monster.

I had a strict upbringing and did rebel at university, but was always mindful of my parents , so never went off the rails.

EconomyClassRockstar · 10/12/2022 15:38

saltinesandcoffeecups · 08/12/2022 22:18

A little credit where credits is due…you are asking and taking differing opinions on board. You didn’t come across like you were threatening her with a convent 😁

This!

amiold · 10/12/2022 15:34

Hopefully she will have a lovely time. Because you've had a chat and sort of given your consent for her to stay over and give her an option to get home should she need it, she won't have to lie if anything goes wrong and she needs help. You've left the door open for more communication on the matter should she need it and she'll respect the trust between you both.
Hope you both have a lovely evening

menopausalbloat · 10/12/2022 15:32

You're so lucky to have an open and honest daughter. You've obviously got a great relationship.
I have an adult child and know just how difficult it can be to cut those ties but it sounds like that's exactly what you need to do.
Good luck.

pilates · 10/12/2022 15:30

Glad you have acknowledged you are a little unreasonable. You sound a great mum btw and just carry on with what you’re doing - talking!

Cakeorchocolate · 10/12/2022 15:28

Sounds like you've raised a sensible daughter.

Glad you managed to support her.

Plumnora · 10/12/2022 15:25

Sorry but yes YABU. She sounds a lot more clued up than I was at 17. She’s been honest with you and as you say, she’s not much of a drinker. She’s known this boy a long time do it’s not like he’s a stranger. And whether or not it’s platonic she’s old enough to know her own mind. My parents WERE very Victorian in their values but my mother would always say she didn’t want to hear the details about what I was doing but she did always want to know where I was and if I badly needed a lift I could call any time if I had to. She was very wise in that respect because she knew a teenager would do whatever the hell they wanted to regardless do it was better to have her on side. And it worked for us. She’s not a little girl any more and you need to trust her.

Haribosweets · 10/12/2022 15:24

When I was 17, I just discovered new friends through work and some 10 years older than me. My parents tried to forbid be from seeing them, I wasn't allowed out anywhere. It made me run away once and resent them and lieing where I was saying I was with school friends when I was with new friends. The day I turned out 18 was amazing and told them to get stuffed and went off the rails big time. Something to think on. Good luck x

saveitsally · 10/12/2022 15:19

Hate to break it to you, but it doesn’t have to be night time to have sex 😬 YABU but I know my husband will feel the same when my daughters are 17. Glad she’s sensible though—that’s 9/10th of the battle.

Msbrodr · 10/12/2022 15:17

I can see how it's a dilemma for you, but you've raised her well. She has been open and honest with you and if you don't handle this correctly you might find that she shuts down on you in future. It's your job to counsel her and make sure that she understands how to stay safe and re-iterating what consent means to her/you. The compromise here is that you explain that you're worried about her being safe and you arrange to check in with each other. You have to consider whether it's time to give her that trust. She trusted you to speak to you about this and as OP have said, she could have lied.

ToadyPoady · 10/12/2022 15:16

My children are only 5 and 7 but you sound like the kind of parent I hope to be in a decade OP. It’s not easy to admit when you don’t get something right but it is such a positive example to set.
Love this heartwarming thread!

StarlightLady · 10/12/2022 08:44

You are not being unreasonable, you are being extremely unreasonable. She’s 17 for goodness sake. And what’s more you even say he’s nice and seems polite.

Perhaps this is something you should be encouraging!

It sounds as if you have a reasonable relationship with her, why drive her away?

When l was 17 l was doing the same thing. I’m in my 40s now and didn’t grow horns out my forehead.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 10/12/2022 08:23

I'm really glad you've done what you've done- you sound like a really supportive parent, OP.

FWIW, when I was a bit older (early 20s), I went to stay with a male school friend after a nasty break up- I thought he just wanted to be a supportive friend, he had other ideas, and really tried to pressure me into sex. I was able to leave, as I had my own money, and I knew the area well, so knew where would be busy and I could get a taxi on a Saturday night.

It sounds awful, but a lot of rape/sexual assault does come from someone known to the victim, not a stranger.

I'm sure he's a really nice lad, but it's good she has an exit plan- and even if she doesn't need it now, it's still there for the future.

I have also seen some similar situations with sixth formers at the school where I work, so it does make me wary.

I do also think it's worth talking about the dynamics of sex in this sort of situation- what happens if one of them wants more and the other doesn't? What's going to be the impact on their friendship group?

Ahsoka2001 · 10/12/2022 01:24

BabyOnBoard90 · 08/12/2022 22:26

YANBU.

My daughter certainly would not be permitted to do such a thing at 17. And if she ever said I can't tell her what to do, then I'd tell her good luck finding her own place.

So.....would your daughter be allowed to do this at 18?

Pelo2022 · 10/12/2022 00:01

Code word is a great idea, I used it a couple of times as a teenager
Once was at a nightclub and there was a shooting, rang my dad and managed to sob the code word at him and he was already on his way (had heard about it)
If I rang him now and said it, he would be keys in hand and ready to go

HelllBaby · 09/12/2022 23:54

I liked your update. The part where you said this:

I lied and lied as a teenager and a young woman

stuck out a lot, that's basically the path you were writing with your daughter by not letting her do stuff. The most well behaved children in the world still rebel when being told no when they are old enough to make sensible decisions themselves. Glad you let her go, you sound like you have a great relationship with her x

iamjustwinginglife · 09/12/2022 22:18

@lilacclementine

I'm glad the car chat went well. Well done-bring a mum to teenagers is a tough gig!!!

Helpplease888 · 09/12/2022 19:15

BabyOnBoard90 · 08/12/2022 22:26

YANBU.

My daughter certainly would not be permitted to do such a thing at 17. And if she ever said I can't tell her what to do, then I'd tell her good luck finding her own place.

This is a shame. Having grown up with very similar- not being able to discuss anything with my mum at age 16/17/18, being expected to never have any physical relationship until marriage etc, being told at 15 that I could get cancer if I had sex or ruin my body by putting chemicals in it if I took contraception. When I needed contraception at 18 after being in a relationship since 17 (and lasted until 21), it all had to be done in secret. I was told that if I got pregnant I would be made to leave. When I had to have a colposcopy at 22, I felt ashamed and again kept it a secret (back then you were called from 21 for a smear). I now have a lot of issues as a 40 something adult around sex and relationships and feel a lot stem from this.

It sounds like OP has a fantastic relationship with her daughter. I hope to have the same with my girls.

DigbyLongcock · 09/12/2022 18:58

OP, I am a bit late to the party but just want to say that you sound like a lovely mum and your daughter sounds as if she's inherited it too.

My youngest child (also a DD) has just turned 18 and I've had my share of kneejerk reactions to things (most of which I've managed to keep to myself), so I know how you feel.

(BTW I was not allowed to share a bed at my parents' house with my parter of 8 years when we were 30...)

altmember · 09/12/2022 18:52

CrownTheTurkey · 09/12/2022 11:11

She's 17.
Legally she can sleep with a hundred different blokes a night and there's Bob all you can do about it.
You don't get to say no to another adult, which is what she is for her choices outside the home.
Stop being so controlling.

I agree with you, except she is isn't legally an adult until 18. However, in reality you can't tell a 16/17 year old what to do or not do, only guide them in making their own decisions (sometimes bribery can work though!)

Zanatdy · 09/12/2022 18:51

YABU, she’s 17. You’re right in another year she could be at Uni doing whatever she likes.

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 09/12/2022 18:51

@lilacclementine both you and your daughter sound lovely and indeed you can have my advent chocolate is the highest accolade.

I hope he lives up to her expectations and she has a lovely time. But I think your concerns do you credit. Well done for articulating them and making a plan.

CalamityClam · 09/12/2022 18:44

iknowimcoming · 09/12/2022 12:38

Well done @lilacclementine! And in teen language 'you can have my advent calendar chocolate' translates into 'thanks Mum, you're the greatest, love you' (in case you didn't know)!

It really does!
@lilacclementine what a mature DD you have.

Flowersinspringgrowwild · 09/12/2022 18:40

@lilacclementine your update really made me smile. Lovely, well done!

whattodo2019 · 09/12/2022 13:05

What are her boyfriends parents like? Can you have a chat with them?
I have a 17 yr old and don't want her sleeping with her boyfriend yet.... I don't care if she's over 16....

Swipe left for the next trending thread