Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that people should be allowed to strike

191 replies

Kissmybaubles · 08/12/2022 19:40

I get it causes inconvenience, and there has been lots of strikes lately Royal Mail, railway, nurses and now paramedics.

I caught on the news this morning that the government are looking to put a stop to strikes. I just don’t think it’s right to take aways peoples right to strike… These people work hard and deserve a decent wage.

AIBU?

OP posts:
malificent7 · 09/12/2022 06:43

I'm an AHP working fir the NHS. I only recently graduated therefore my bursary only got reinstated in my final year. This is one issue...to be a AHP or a nurse you have 3+ years of gruelling, expensive training which puts people off.I put in my all and got a 1st.

On graduation as a band 5 you start on 25, 000 pa which is just about acceptable BUT there are consequences to your decisions that can affect patient outcomes, we have 30 mins lunch, if we definately do not want to work a weekend we have to take it as annual leave. People are leaving to earn more as locum so we are short staff...recruiting internationally as there aren't enough in this country. Also AHP are leaving to get jobs in other sectors where there isn't the same level of responsibility and better pay/ conditions. This is the 1st hospital where I havn't been bullied.

So yes. I do support the strikes but I will not be striking as like many of my colleagues, we don't want to risk patient care so we cannot bring ourselves to do it. The government have relied on our bleeding hearts for too long.

Interesting how as nursing is mostly seen as a female, nurturing, role, they have been overlooked for so long.

Good job I adore my current role but sadly i can't work for buttons forever.

noideabutstilltrying · 09/12/2022 06:41

@Metabigot he is worried about job security. Part of why he's striking

Owner drivers mean that people would be given ever increasing amounts of drops to complete

There are other delivery companies out there. They are struggling and have backlog of parcels which is being widely reported

Metabigot · 09/12/2022 06:36

noideabutstilltrying · 09/12/2022 06:27

My husband is a postie and we were talking about the Christmas Eve strikes.

He is feeling very conflicted about that day.

Royal Mail staff don't want to be on strike as I am sure is the case with other union backed professionals

It's a case of trying to stop the race to the bottom and to ensure that companies pay their staff a fair wage.

People in work shouldn't be reliant on UC etc. to protect company and shareholder profits

Genuine question, is your hubby not worried that Royal Mail will be absolutely decimated by these strikes leading to job insecurity? Is he not worried that the business is losing custom to other couriers now and they won't necessarily return to Royal Mail.

I'm only one person, but I'm a small business seller on ebay and will definitely stay with yodel after all this, cheaper ams more reliable.

noideabutstilltrying · 09/12/2022 06:27

listsandbudgets · 08/12/2022 20:57

I'm really unhappy about impact of.strikes on me personally and I do think the rail and postal workers are being quite vindictive in the way they seem to be trying to ruin everyone's Christmas.

However they should have the right to withdraw labour. Its caused a lot of tears and financial loss in our family and numerous others though.. I used to support the strikes now I just bitterly resent them

My husband is a postie and we were talking about the Christmas Eve strikes.

He is feeling very conflicted about that day.

Royal Mail staff don't want to be on strike as I am sure is the case with other union backed professionals

It's a case of trying to stop the race to the bottom and to ensure that companies pay their staff a fair wage.

People in work shouldn't be reliant on UC etc. to protect company and shareholder profits

Pjsandhotchoc · 09/12/2022 06:24

amylou8 · 09/12/2022 06:02

As much as it go against my libertarian views, no I don't think they should. Work to rule, yes..hold the country to ransom by striking from critical roles no. If you don't like your job there's plenty more out there.

If everyone thought like this there’s be no nurses left. I’m glad we’re striking and not all just packing it in and leaving.

Metabigot · 09/12/2022 06:04

Ratched · 08/12/2022 20:38

Anyone, no matter what their job, MUST have the right to withdraw their Labour.

To have that right denied, legally, could potentially lead to slave labour.

Yes, dramatic, but ultimately, withdrawing the individuals right to say ' no, I'm not working for crap wages/ working conditions/working conditions', ultimately results in the same thing.

My son won't be able to travel home for Christmas, my MRI scan has been postponed twice now, my dad was on a trolley waiting for admission to hospital for 18 hrs ( His care once admitted was excellent and he is recovering at home now after a 9 day stay).

I fully expect to be inconvenienced by future strikes, but fully and totally support them.

In most jobs you have the ability to withdraw your labour by going to work elsewhere if you are unhappy. That's what I usually do anyway.

I understand for certain professions especially public sector this is not always an option though.

amylou8 · 09/12/2022 06:02

As much as it go against my libertarian views, no I don't think they should. Work to rule, yes..hold the country to ransom by striking from critical roles no. If you don't like your job there's plenty more out there.

Metabigot · 09/12/2022 06:00

Q2C4 · 08/12/2022 21:59

For parcels yes, but for letters? Genuine question as I'm worried about the lengthy delays to letter deliveries which Royal Mail seem to have deprioritised.

Most letter post is junk mail. Documents can be scanned sent and even signed electronically these days, more and more will be now.

The vast majority of people have access to email.

sneezingpandamum · 09/12/2022 05:58

Fair enough nhs workers

But not Royal Mail or train workers - they do this every year

Don't like your pay and conditions- then leave

Most of the rest of us aren't getting inflation level pay rises oh and our employers are actually profitable businesses unlike Royal Mail and many train companies

IncompleteSenten · 09/12/2022 05:57

"You should only accept certain jobs if you understand the importance to society, "

If a job is important to society then perhaps the people doing it should be paid and treated well.

Metabigot · 09/12/2022 05:55

I believe in the right to strike but it only really works with monopolies or public sector organisations where there's no alternative routes to trade.

Which is why I'm looking forward to posties / cwu realising they've scored a massive own goal destroying the very company that employs them. I'm sure there'll be lots of jobs for redundant posties with evri, yodel etc where trade has moved, so I won't cry too hard for them. They won't have their cushy union negotiated terms there though.

Fairyliz · 09/12/2022 05:53

Difficult one; I believe in the right to strike, but if someone I love dies through lack of medical treatment then I will hate the strikers who caused it.

SantasFlaws · 09/12/2022 05:48

Yes I support the strikers.

Average wages have stagnated for decades while top job wages have grown massively. CEOs paid several times what they were even two decades ago whilst the average wages has not risen by anywhere near as much. It's obscene.

Whataretheodds · 09/12/2022 05:35

XenoBitch · 08/12/2022 20:16

Inconvenience and a threat to life are worlds apart though.

I don't think people in jobs that people rely on for safety/health should be allowed to strike. That is not to say I do not think they deserve better pay/conditions.

How will thry achieve the pay and working conditions without striking? Lobbying and demonstrating hasn't worked. So what would you have them do?

PuttingDownRoots · 09/12/2022 05:35

Do people think the Police, Priston Service and Armed Forces should also have the right to strike? Or is the reason for their ban rightful?

Kissmybaubles · 09/12/2022 05:31

I’m surprised more trades aren’t striking to be honest. I work in the care industry and staff morale has been down since covid, staff turn around is high and we are constantly short staffed (dangerously so most of the time) There were talks in the media of how carers should be paid more during the pandemic but nothing ever came of it. The care home loses staff to places like Asda who pay more for a job with less stress and responsibility (it’s a no brainier). So the care industry is on its arse…

I have friends that work for the NHS and while they get paid more than care homes conditions still aren’t great.

And yeah fuck the tories!

OP posts:
Woopdaboo · 09/12/2022 01:09

depends on the industry? Nurses working hard, saving lives…yes they should be heard. TFL staff stood around doing f all? They can go f themselves.

EIfie · 09/12/2022 01:06

Absolutely. 100% support from me.

ilovesooty · 09/12/2022 01:03

MushMonster · 08/12/2022 22:37

They had said, earlier this year, that the redundancies were off the table, not to happen.
Then, more strikes. Some for better pay, some for no redundancies...
It is a mess. Between misinformation and playing up, from both sides.
They keep sitting down and walking off the table.
It is about high time that they sit to negotiate for good.
To be honest, I think they should be penalised for missing services, instead of compensated (as Arriva did recently!)

If the government wanted negotiation to happen it would be happening.

BMW6 · 09/12/2022 00:44

Of course they have a right to strike. Support them by all means, but don't wail when you can't travel, your Xmas mail isn't delivered and your loved one can't be admitted to hospital.

Wonder if it'll be like The winter of Discontent when binmen and funeral workers went on strike as well. If so we better hope the really cold spell continues.

TooBigForMyBoots · 08/12/2022 23:46

LindorDoubleChoc · 08/12/2022 21:17

So let's see everyone apart from the highest paid 5% go on strike. What do you think will happen?

Employers and government will have to listen?

MushMonster · 08/12/2022 22:37

Believeitornot · 08/12/2022 22:08

No it is not. They also want to close all ticket offices hence massive job cuts. And get rid of guards on trains = more job cuts.

I don’t want train stations without any ticket offices and I certainly don’t want trains with no guards. It’s fucking ridiculous. Why aren’t the media highlighting this issue, I do not know.

They had said, earlier this year, that the redundancies were off the table, not to happen.
Then, more strikes. Some for better pay, some for no redundancies...
It is a mess. Between misinformation and playing up, from both sides.
They keep sitting down and walking off the table.
It is about high time that they sit to negotiate for good.
To be honest, I think they should be penalised for missing services, instead of compensated (as Arriva did recently!)

WhatLikeItsHard · 08/12/2022 22:22

@LindorDoubleChoc

"I earn less than the average nurse, or teacher - and goes without saying have nothing like their pension provision."

...I think you'd feel differently if you understood how the NHS pension scheme works for newer members. It's not the "golden handcuffs" of a full pension at 60 anymore. It's linked to state pension age, so 68, and will undoubtedly go up. I also have to contribute 9.8% of my salary to it each month. It's better than a lot of other pensions, but not good enough to make people willing to stick it out for 40 odd years.

MushMonster · 08/12/2022 22:21

pompei8309 · 08/12/2022 20:13

The one’s able to hold a country at ransom shouldn’t be allowed, and that should be clearly specified in their work contracts

100% agree with this.
Fundamental jobs should provide a minimum of services, save for the population, at all times.
Other models of strike that do not involve large absences from the workplace should be regulated for this workers. There is such a thing.

LlynTegid · 08/12/2022 22:20

The government say they are planning to. Does not mean it will happen this year or even next. This is a government that talks but often fails to act.

Swipe left for the next trending thread