Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that people should be allowed to strike

191 replies

Kissmybaubles · 08/12/2022 19:40

I get it causes inconvenience, and there has been lots of strikes lately Royal Mail, railway, nurses and now paramedics.

I caught on the news this morning that the government are looking to put a stop to strikes. I just don’t think it’s right to take aways peoples right to strike… These people work hard and deserve a decent wage.

AIBU?

OP posts:
DrManhattan · 09/12/2022 08:42

100% support the strikers
100% support the right to strike
If there is one near you go and show your support, if you can

TheGoogleMum · 09/12/2022 08:40

Workers need to be allowed to strike or we will all have terrible pay and conditions! When healthier strikes they do still have some staff working to try to minimise loss of life, staff don't want patients to suffer. Nurses aren't paid enough for the expectations of the job and are working in unsafe conditions as the job is so shit nobody wants to do it. Let's pay them fairly and make the job a bit more desirable! At the moment they can work in a supermarket for a relatively small pay drop and massively less stressful job

Newmama29 · 09/12/2022 08:38

@CrapOnASchtick yes I believe everyone should have the right to strike, including military & police. If the government cared enough for public safety, they wouldn’t let it come to a strike & would negotiate an appropriate solution to working conditions & pay. Not all health workers are allowed to strike, I work in emergency receiving & I don’t think we will be allowed to strike & ED/ICU aren’t allowed either. Emergency services will be covered for EMERGENCIES, not the shite that comes through the door on a regular basis.

CrapOnASchtick · 09/12/2022 08:34

Aren't very well loved**

CrapOnASchtick · 09/12/2022 08:34

I know they are very well loved here but the thought of police being on strike makes me a bit terrified personally!

CrapOnASchtick · 09/12/2022 08:31

I also love the view that people have that only certain jobs should be allowed to strike because it doesn’t affect them

This is already the case though isn't it? For example police officer's cannot strike. Neither can the military or prison workers (for reasons I'm assuming are obvious to everyone) the explanation given is 'a matter of public safety', I would assume healthcare workers also fall into the category of public safety.

So I'm assuming you agree that those examples above should also be allowed to strike too? I'm not saying I do or do not, I'm curious whether people really mean this 'everyone should be allowed to strike' stuff.

Newmama29 · 09/12/2022 08:07

amylou8 · 09/12/2022 06:02

As much as it go against my libertarian views, no I don't think they should. Work to rule, yes..hold the country to ransom by striking from critical roles no. If you don't like your job there's plenty more out there.

This is a ridiculous view to have. That’s the reason we’re choosing to strike in the first place, because thousands of nurses & health care workers are choosing to leave the profession with no one to replace them. Who’s going to care for you or your family when everyone is so sick of the working conditions & pay that they all leave?

I also love the view that people have that only certain jobs should be allowed to strike because it doesn’t affect them. That’s the whole point of a strike, to cause disruption & make a case. People are so self involved these days that as long as it doesn’t affect them they don’t care.

Noodledoodledoo · 09/12/2022 08:00

I'm a teacher, I agree with the right to strike, however what we are allowed to strike for is not always what we are really unhappy about.

We are currently being balloted to strike, it's for our pay rise for 22/23 (5% for the majority, 8% for those with less service) to be fully funded to schools. It was announced after budgets planned and no further funding into the schools budget - so schools have to find it from already squeezed resources. On top of increased bills like the rest of the country.

Yes I would like a higher % however our complaint isn't that, it's the fact it is unfunded, the fact this will mean in some schools redundancies, poorer teaching as support staff won't be replaced if they leave, less teaching assistants in classes, this makes teaching harder, less support fir SEN. This is the reasons but the press will just say we want more money.

I try to not just take the press at face value over strikes as I know how badly teaching strikes are reported.

I guess a lot in the current industries striking would struggle to 'go and get another job' as if I want to still be a teacher there aren't many options of alternatives (private schools are often worse off in terms of working conditions), in the private sector there is the potential for lots of people to look else where, I worked in private sector before I retrained.

CrapOnASchtick · 09/12/2022 07:43

Sadly I agree with PPs about royal mail strikes being a bit of an own goal.

As a small business owner who used royal mail to send multiple parcels every day, I'll be using other couriers now and won't be going back after the strike action ends either.

Myrevengewillbesweet · 09/12/2022 07:31

Absolutely and fuck the Tories!!!

Metabigot · 09/12/2022 07:24

Catspyjamas17 · 09/12/2022 06:44

Is he not worried that the business is losing custom to other couriers now and they won't necessarily return to Royal Mail

That problem is for the business owners, not the workforce. At least in a situation where there is also a labour shortage.

Absolutely agree with the right to strike and am fundamentally opposed to any reduction in these rights.

It's certainly a problem for the workforce when the business contracts and they Nedd to make redundancies.

Less trade = less money and less demand for staff.

Metabigot · 09/12/2022 07:21

noideabutstilltrying · 09/12/2022 06:41

@Metabigot he is worried about job security. Part of why he's striking

Owner drivers mean that people would be given ever increasing amounts of drops to complete

There are other delivery companies out there. They are struggling and have backlog of parcels which is being widely reported

Thats the most kafka esque thing i ever heard.

He's worried about job security so striking, which will damage the business and lose custom long term, leading to further job insecurity will make it better how?

You can't strike your way to better market conditions. No company should ever be held to a demand of no compulsory redundancies.

Arewethebadguys · 09/12/2022 07:17

Fragrantandfoolish · 08/12/2022 19:48

I think there should be limits. You should only accept certain jobs if you understand the importance to society, so for example paramedics or nurses. So as such only a certain percentage can strike, a certain amount need to stay.

im not overly supportive no,but that doesn’t mean I don’t think they have a case. I just think it’s incredibly difficult, as there is only so much money to go round and when taxes go up everyone kicks off. But where does the money come from to pay people more. It has to be taxes. But in a cost of living crisis, taxing people more is not accepted.

so many people say I support the strikes, but are also the first to kick off of the government says ok then your taxes are going up to pay for it.

Maybe there would be more money if government ministers didn't line their pockets during covid with massive contracts for friends and family.

I hate this bullshit. What that quote? 'The rich have convinced the middle class yo blame the working class' or words to that effect.

How many people lost their homes in 2008? I know loads. How many bankers prosecuted? 0
Utter bullshit

There's money when they think it's important. Nurses, teachers, workers just aren't that important to the govt

thinkponk48 · 09/12/2022 07:13

I work in central London. The train strikes haven't effected me too much as I can simply work from home, same with many colleagues and friends. Most people o work work have simply said "they won't go into London between now and Christmas". This has no effect on their jobs.

It does however have a huge effect on all the bars/ restaurants/ shops. Most aren't bothering with Christmas parties as travel is such a pain. A lot of hospitality business will have been relying on the income from the pre Christmas crowd, it's just not going to happen this year.

CourtneeLuv · 09/12/2022 07:10

Fragrantandfoolish · 08/12/2022 19:48

I think there should be limits. You should only accept certain jobs if you understand the importance to society, so for example paramedics or nurses. So as such only a certain percentage can strike, a certain amount need to stay.

im not overly supportive no,but that doesn’t mean I don’t think they have a case. I just think it’s incredibly difficult, as there is only so much money to go round and when taxes go up everyone kicks off. But where does the money come from to pay people more. It has to be taxes. But in a cost of living crisis, taxing people more is not accepted.

so many people say I support the strikes, but are also the first to kick off of the government says ok then your taxes are going up to pay for it.

Make big Starbucks, google, boots etc pay their full taxes. Tax the energy companies and banks. Don't allow profiteering.

Catspyjamas17 · 09/12/2022 07:08

If rail workers don't strike there will be mass redundancies, as rail companies want unmanned stations and no guards on trains. Which is not what rail passengers want.

There is also a massive staff shortage to serve the current high passenger demand for train services. So train companies have to listen to what staff and passengers want.

olivehater · 09/12/2022 07:05

I feel like there should be a limit. For instance the train strikes have been endless for years. As a result they have bloated pay packets in comparison to their skills. NHs strikes are few and far between. One of the reasons we are payed so badly for our level of skills x , How else are we supposed improve our pay conditions. If we aren’t allowed to strike then there needs to be other ways to improve things but there doesn’t seem to be. I am not even striking by the way. I am NHS on the same pay and conditions but not a nurse. I have been on strike once in my entire 20 year career.

Oysterbabe · 09/12/2022 07:01

Striking Royal Mail and rail workers are just signing their own redundancy cheques. Would I balls use Royal Mail now when there are so many more reliable options. Passenger numbers have gone through the floor since WFH and it wouldn't even cross my mind to use a train when planning a trip now, it would have been default option before.

RunningAlong · 09/12/2022 07:00

I support the right to strike and that public sector workers deserve a decent payrise. However I think the percentages seem incredibly high, would there still be the support for them if the government offered 19% across the board but the whole country had to pay 10% more income tax to pay for it? I wonder if there would be the same support if private sector workers went on strike if mechanics went on strike or all supermarkets shut for a week.

Catspyjamas17 · 09/12/2022 06:54

If anything, I just wish people had been this angry ten years ago, but alas, most people seemed to agree with austerity and the ideological dismantling of public services, and went along with freezing salaries or derisory increases, and nodded along to the super rich getting exponentially richer while living standards fell for everyone else.

mids2019 · 09/12/2022 06:50

There hasn't a strike of core life and death emergency health care workers in hospital. It's the elective stuff that may get.postponed.

mids2019 · 09/12/2022 06:48

How should nurses for instance lobby for better pay and conditions of the right to strike is removed? The government have rejected their pay demand and striking is a lad t resort as they have literally tried everything else. I really do hate the way the right wing press are trying (and faoling) to present nurses as some sort of militant job wanting to bring misery to millions when a couple of years ago we were all clapping for carers including those advocating for pay restraint now.

Ylvamoon · 09/12/2022 06:47

I agree to the right to strike as a principle.

BUT if it endagers life (doctors, paramedics, ....) or security (police & prison services) I am on the fence.

I think if anything preventive would happen to a loved one during strike action I'd resent the strikers.

On the flip side, the government should pay a decent wage to people who are supplying these services, then there wouldn't be any need to strike.

Bestcatmum · 09/12/2022 06:47

In my local NHS nobody even bothered to vote to strike or not. We didn't even get the required 50%.

Catspyjamas17 · 09/12/2022 06:44

Is he not worried that the business is losing custom to other couriers now and they won't necessarily return to Royal Mail

That problem is for the business owners, not the workforce. At least in a situation where there is also a labour shortage.

Absolutely agree with the right to strike and am fundamentally opposed to any reduction in these rights.