Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that people should be allowed to strike

191 replies

Kissmybaubles · 08/12/2022 19:40

I get it causes inconvenience, and there has been lots of strikes lately Royal Mail, railway, nurses and now paramedics.

I caught on the news this morning that the government are looking to put a stop to strikes. I just don’t think it’s right to take aways peoples right to strike… These people work hard and deserve a decent wage.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Florenz · 10/12/2022 10:35

Royal Mail workers striking at this point is like McDonalds workers striking. People will just go to KFC.

Untitledsquatboulder · 10/12/2022 10:33

As most mumsnetters think the police are the biggest threat to women's safety ever I'm sure they'd be delighted if they went on strike - right up til the moment it happened.

MushMonster · 10/12/2022 10:28

@DdraigGoch around here, earlier this year, the news did mention that the railway unions wanted the government to intervene in the conversations, this according to the newspaper. Now it is the government the one to blame for them walking off the table, yet again.
In the meantime, is the everyday taxpayer, commuter, who is paying for all this. Next week, they are striking for the whole week!
This one is well out of hand. Why can't they sit on the table and flipping negotiate?
I am done with it, to be honest. I do not think they are being reasonable, at all. I am against holding a country citizens, its economy and everyday turningvof the wheel ransom, week after week after week...

Brefugee · 09/12/2022 22:18

I'm also intrigued by the argument that some jobs shouldn't be allowed to strike (my dad was in the army, i remember when his regiment were driving green goddesses around trying to cover for the striking firefighters - the soldiers didn't begrudge the firefighters trying to get a better deal, even though the army can't strike) but don't connect the dots and make the follow-through logical argument that those important jobs should have decent pay and conditions and be well enough funded for very high staffing levels.

Instead it's years of believing that unions are evil (even while enjoying the fruits of past union fights) and moaning that they don't have a union. Anyone can, and should, join a union. Especially now that workers are being screwed over left right and centre.

DdraigGoch · 09/12/2022 22:15

Brefugee · 09/12/2022 21:47

Most of us don't actually have the right to strike in all honesty and we have to leave and move on if we don't like things

If i understand you correctly, if we follow this train of thought, since the majority of HCP (is it just nurses?) voted to strike, what they should actually do is all jack in their jobs and work elsewhere?

Yeah. That's going to work

It's a crackpot argument. Just like the people going "sack them all". The very reason that collective action was effective, even in the days when there was no legal protections for strikers, was that you can replace the odd handful of sacked men, but you can't replace your entire workforce at once. Sack them all and you can expect disrupted services for years because of course you've sacked your instructors too.

Brefugee · 09/12/2022 21:47

Most of us don't actually have the right to strike in all honesty and we have to leave and move on if we don't like things

If i understand you correctly, if we follow this train of thought, since the majority of HCP (is it just nurses?) voted to strike, what they should actually do is all jack in their jobs and work elsewhere?

Yeah. That's going to work

DdraigGoch · 09/12/2022 21:36

Oysterbabe · 09/12/2022 07:01

Striking Royal Mail and rail workers are just signing their own redundancy cheques. Would I balls use Royal Mail now when there are so many more reliable options. Passenger numbers have gone through the floor since WFH and it wouldn't even cross my mind to use a train when planning a trip now, it would have been default option before.

Rail passenger numbers have not gone "through the floor". The latest confirmed figures from the DfT (so the third week of November) put usage at 97% of the equivalent point in 2019 - which considering that 2019 was a record-breaking year is very impressive.
assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1094056/COVID-19-transport-use-statistics.ods (accessed 09/12,file gets revised regularly)

The government however is hell-bent on wrecking the service by underfunding it. Lower wages, threats to pensions, and poorer working conditions have left many operators with huge retention problems. A driver could hand 3 months notice in tomorrow and you won't have a productive replacement for 15 months. That's why TPE and Avanti are cancelling services left, right and centre. The way that maintenance is being cut, they are risking another Hatfield accident and all of the disruption that will result when they go "oh shit" and slap speed restrictions everywhere.

The operators and the staff want the dispute settled. The operators wanted to offer 4% per year for two years with no strings attached, and the staff would have probably accepted this despite it being well below inflation. The government stuck its oar in at the eleventh hour and insisted on a long list of conditions being added to the offer - conditions the operators didn't even want - that they knew would result in an outright rejection. The government has stirred up this dispute for political reasons of its own.
www.ft.com/content/f181e88b-777e-4285-902c-55f925213fd8

RosaGallica · 09/12/2022 21:22

If we can’t withdraw labour or protest at unfair conditions how exactly can Britain still call itself a democracy? If we can’t make a living from work because wages are so low but we still have to work, are we not closer to being simple slaves? And what the fucking hell is the point?

upfucked · 09/12/2022 21:15

healthadvice123 · 08/12/2022 20:13

Most of us don't actually have the right to strike in all honesty and we have to leave and move on if we don't like things

But that is what is happening - nurses, heath care assistant, paramedics, teachers- have been leaving their jobs in increasing numbers to the point where patients aren’t safe and children aren’t always been taught by qualified staff. If they don’t do something it will get worse and more people will die as a direct result.

DdraigGoch · 09/12/2022 21:09

sneezingpandamum · 09/12/2022 05:58

Fair enough nhs workers

But not Royal Mail or train workers - they do this every year

Don't like your pay and conditions- then leave

Most of the rest of us aren't getting inflation level pay rises oh and our employers are actually profitable businesses unlike Royal Mail and many train companies

People ARE leaving. Employers are getting so short of skilled staff that the non-strike days are almost as chaotic as the strike days. This is because they don't treat their staff well.

Elodie09 · 09/12/2022 20:30

@Masterblasterjammin Thank you for being a nurse, what a terrific person you are.
Thank you to everyone who is working harder and harder for less and less pay .
This country has never been in such a mess but our care for one another is still there.
I hope somehow things can get better for everyone.

DdraigGoch · 09/12/2022 10:35

Clouds3898 · 08/12/2022 21:39

I believe in the right to strike as v important but I think the RMT should've accepted the 8% over 2 years pay deal they were offered earlier in the week. It's a decent deal

Did you see the strings which were attached to that offer? One senior manager has said privately that he would be embarrassed to put that to the workforce, but they were forced by the government to add the conditions in.

DdraigGoch · 09/12/2022 10:29

XenoBitch · 08/12/2022 20:41

It does feel like a lot all at the same time. It makes you wonder if the strikes are all co-ordinated to cause chaos.

On the radio, there have been union reps saying they have heard of nurses using food banks due to low pay. If the pay is that dire, surely all nurses would be using food banks, as well as everyone that earns less that them. That is simply not the case, and I do not understand why that is being mentioned in the press.

Don't be silly. Different nurses have different incomes (different grades, different amounts of overtime), and they have different outgoings. Some will be trying to bring up three children on a single income in London, while others might be living with a high-earning partner in a cheap part of the country.

Masterblasterjammin · 09/12/2022 10:12

I didn’t vote to strike because of my standards of living. I voted to strike because we are haemorrhaging nurses, and because patient care is being risked everyday.

For everyone saying ‘if you don’t like it, just leave. You knew what you were signing up for’, no. I don’t want to leave. I don’t want to not be a nurse. But I want it to be safer to be a nurse. I want it to be like it was 10 years ago, when a patient being in A&E for 12 hours was considered a serious incident, not the norm. I want patients to have enough staff to answer their call bells and give them prompt pain relief. I want to have my (short) lunch breaks, I want to drink more than a small bottle of water a day, and I want to go home when my shift finishes, not stay behind an hour or two because the department is on black and there are no staff, and no one to handover to.

I love looking after patients. I love being a nurse. But I am terrified at what is happening to the health service that I used to be so proud to work for. And it’s just going to get worse and worse and worse. I could easily leave and get another job. I have a good degree, transferable skills, and I’m pretty intelligent. But I don’t want to, because that won’t make it better.

I don’t know anyone who took the decision to strike lightly. But everyone I know who voted yes, did it because we don’t see any other way of making things better for ourselves and our patients.

L1ttledrummergirl · 09/12/2022 10:04

For those saying the railway workers shouldn't strike over Christmas:

twitter.com/GWRHelp/status/1601154873919168512?t=OmvmsrjEQCcb_jvib3Qv9Q&s=19

They weren't planning to run any trains here anyway and I suspect this isn't the only set of planned works.

Brefugee · 09/12/2022 09:39

So this is a political protest?

it's hard not for it to be a political protest when it is in the goverment's hand to solve it.

But in case you missed it, it is a personal issue to the strikers. And the personal is the political.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 09/12/2022 09:37

Fragmentsof2022 · 08/12/2022 20:16

Of course we should be allowed to strike. It’s a bloody fundamental right to be able to withdraw our labour.

Solidarity with the strikers ✊🏻

And absolutely Fuck the Tories 🖕🏻

So this is a political protest?

Dotjones · 09/12/2022 09:31

Under the proposals people will still be able to withdraw their labour. People can't be compelled to work. All the changes will do will raise the stakes, if people decide to withdraw their labour they have to face the risk that they will not have a job to go back to.

If someone is unhappy enough to strike, they should be looking at alternative employment.

MiniFig · 09/12/2022 09:28

I believe in the right to strike, but if someone I love dies through lack of medical treatment then I will hate the strikers who caused it.

The government. The government have caused it.

A couple of years ago the government drew up a list of who are key workers. They were listed and named. And they kept the country running. So it would be great if the government would refer to that list and - oh i dn't know - improve the terms and conditions of those valuable people instead of giving grifters like Michelle Mone and Dido Harding piles of money for nothing.

CousinKrispy · 09/12/2022 09:17

Taking away the right to withhold labour seems like a terrible idea to me. It is fundamental.

And I say that as someone who could have been joining strikes recently but hasn't.

The government is fundamentally wrong on this.

MiniFig · 09/12/2022 09:13

If a job is so vital that it not happening causes "meltdown", then that job should be one that is worth doing both in terms of pay and conditions. I am a striking worker. If others would like to come and do my job for the day please do. You are more than welcome. Perhaps it would garner more support!

Good luck!!

Reading the comments here makes me want to weep. You've all grown up on a diet of the govermnent telling you unions are evil.
Well now the government are rolling pack workers' rights, you can see how evil unions are, can't you.

Join. A. Union.

If you think they'Re inefficiant, stand as a rep and improve it. If you think you don't need one - give back all the rights unions have won for you over the years and try to win them back as an individual. Do feel free to let us know how you get on.

Dragonskin · 09/12/2022 09:07

*Most letter post is junk mail. Documents can be scanned sent and even signed electronically these days, more and more will be now.

The vast majority of people have access to email.*

And the one place that seems to be incapable of embracing new technology? The NHS, that still insists on letters through the post being the only way to notify you of the appointment which has been booked on a random date. It'll be interesting to see how many no shows there are for appointments

GetThatHelmetOn · 09/12/2022 08:50

TooBigForMyBoots · 08/12/2022 20:08

It is up to society to understand the importance of certain jobs, pay them well and make them an attractive career prospect.

^ This, if their jobs are so essential they should have kept them in a reasonable salary over the years. If it comes to that point is because they have not given the priority they deserve.

And what else can they do? With a government who can dismiss petitions, which have been signed by thousands and thousands of people, with no more than a deflective sentence, it is no surprise we are were we are.

What are we seeing these days is the result of a self serving government who ignores the basic needs of society. Honestly, just an example of this is that Liz Truss may have apologised for her stupid economic experiment, but an apology doesn’t remove the fact that we all will pay for it by the thousand, that people would lose homes, and that their families are cold and hungry.

Sapphire387 · 09/12/2022 08:49

Don't *get

Sapphire387 · 09/12/2022 08:49

Of course people should be allowed to strike. We have most of our employment laws due to the actions of trade unions. Rights don't have handed out for free - if they cannot be negotiated, they are fought for and won.

Swipe left for the next trending thread