Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that people should be allowed to strike

191 replies

Kissmybaubles · 08/12/2022 19:40

I get it causes inconvenience, and there has been lots of strikes lately Royal Mail, railway, nurses and now paramedics.

I caught on the news this morning that the government are looking to put a stop to strikes. I just don’t think it’s right to take aways peoples right to strike… These people work hard and deserve a decent wage.

AIBU?

OP posts:
drpet49 · 10/12/2022 19:14

Quveas · 08/12/2022 19:43

If people want to strike, nothing in law will stop them. And good on them if they fight back. I'll be on their side, whatever the government throws at them.

I agree with this

Crispynoodle · 10/12/2022 18:58

Fragmentsof2022 · 08/12/2022 20:16

Of course we should be allowed to strike. It’s a bloody fundamental right to be able to withdraw our labour.

Solidarity with the strikers ✊🏻

And absolutely Fuck the Tories 🖕🏻

This

SinnerBoy · 10/12/2022 18:57

LindorDoubleChoc · 08/12/2022 20:34

We are going to have to swallow the price increases on our mortgage and utility bills and we both earn less than a train driver...

I'm not sure that the train drivers are on strike - they may be. The figures quoted for their earnings are usually utter rubbish. The Mail reported that they could earn £100,000.

That would take all possible available overtime, for the highest paid driver.

If you mean Mick Lynch & co, they're ancillary staff, guards, catering crew, ticket sellers etc. Most of them are on between £23,000 and something over £30 odd thousand.

The press then comes out with deliberate conflation between them and the drivers and many people think, "Greedy bastards are all on £65 grand a year, fuck them!"

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 18:49

Unicorn34 · 10/12/2022 17:29

I wasn't demanding how people report, just giving some info on the Fire Brigade strike (which I agreed with). People are free to say what they want.

Oki koki. I thought you were asking people to read up on it first. I don't need to know the full negotiating terms to see that fucking up your own employer is not the best idea for job security. Not if they aren't a monopoly or public sector.

I work in this field, restructuring businesses so know full well its not done for shits and giggles. Its done to make the organisations resource fit the business need.

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 18:44

Many businesses are being hurt by things not arriving and ebay basically enforce refunds. How is that compatible with people supporting the strikes at all costs, what about online retailers.

Many of whom are small independent businesses.

What about their pay which will be affected now.

Why are they less important?

Do people support them choosing to use alternate couriers?

MrsHamlet · 10/12/2022 18:10

Of course union officials get paid on strike days - they're working for the union on those days, not on strike. Union reps - people like me - will not get paid when we strike. We're not paid by the union but by our employers from whom we are withdrawing our labour.

Florenz · 10/12/2022 17:54

RM workers need to accept things as they are, not as they would like them to be. If people can stuff delivered cheaper and more reliably by another company, they'll do that. It isn't the 70s when people used to wait with excitement for the postman to arrive, bringing letters, and the Royal Mail had a monopoly over mail. Things have moved on since then, and for the better.

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 17:50

I've just had to refund another buyer whose parcel was sent in November and hadn't arrived.

Lost about £50 so far from these clowns and you want me to support the strikes??

Many bigger sellers are fucked if they continue to use them.

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 17:37

DrManhattan · 10/12/2022 16:18

Magic money tree? What aload of bollocks - there is loads of money! Look how it is all being pissed away on defective PPE, rubbish like that. Money is being hoarded and not filtering down.

Stop believing the tory lies

You do know RM is privatised now and making losses of 500m a year?

How does that relate to PPE???

Unicorn34 · 10/12/2022 17:29

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 13:50

I don't think you can make demands on how people post on an open forum like MN

By all means if you think talk guidelines have been breached , report.

I wasn't demanding how people report, just giving some info on the Fire Brigade strike (which I agreed with). People are free to say what they want.

DrManhattan · 10/12/2022 16:18

Magic money tree? What aload of bollocks - there is loads of money! Look how it is all being pissed away on defective PPE, rubbish like that. Money is being hoarded and not filtering down.

Stop believing the tory lies

PrincessConstance · 10/12/2022 14:59

whateverwillhappennext · 10/12/2022 14:39

Why is pay for such professions like nurses, teachers, police, firefighters not linked to inflation, so there's no arguing every year about who gets what pay increase? If inflation is 10%, everyone gets 10%. No-one gets a real terms pay rise or pay cut. Then if they want more on top to improve their conditions of service, that's an argument they can have separately. Why has no striking union asked for a pay formula? Because whatever unions 'win' this year will be back to square on next year when they're striking again for pay at next years inflation.

For 20 yrs wage inflation has been flat and now with this inflation surge pay has dropped. So I agree they need a longer-term plan.
Although I'm nearly sure these monetary demands will come at a cost in worker privileges and rights. Sickness in the public sector is incentivized and comparatively high in relation to other sectors.

whateverwillhappennext · 10/12/2022 14:39

Why is pay for such professions like nurses, teachers, police, firefighters not linked to inflation, so there's no arguing every year about who gets what pay increase? If inflation is 10%, everyone gets 10%. No-one gets a real terms pay rise or pay cut. Then if they want more on top to improve their conditions of service, that's an argument they can have separately. Why has no striking union asked for a pay formula? Because whatever unions 'win' this year will be back to square on next year when they're striking again for pay at next years inflation.

PrincessConstance · 10/12/2022 14:32

pompei8309 · 08/12/2022 20:13

The one’s able to hold a country at ransom shouldn’t be allowed, and that should be clearly specified in their work contracts

I think this is what covid has revealed. Those looking after the infrastructure are really important and have been taken for granted for a long time. 20 yrs of no pay increase has revealed a deep inequality in society.
This applies across all sectors. Certainly, our 3 main service providers, police, health, and fire service are grossly underpaid.

However, the Uk public must understand goods and services must be paid for, not bargained for on the cheap. Look at the furore over cleaners, and hairdressers' pay, and tradesperson costs.

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 13:50

Unicorn34 · 10/12/2022 13:48

When my husband was a firefighter I joined him and the crew on the picket line during the strikes of the early 2000's. Some 9f the things happening in the background really surprised me:

  1. The Union reps were still being paid!
  2. The Army personnel who were covering were driving past jeering and doing w**ker signs at us
  3. The firefighters still went out to fires, albeit unpaid and uninsured, because they just did! This wasn't reported ANYWHERE
  4. There were lovely people bringing tea, coffee, treats etc when you could see they probably couldn't afford it
  5. There was a huge amount of abuse from people driving past

The main Union man spent many hours having discussions in restaurants, all expenses paid, still taking his salary and ended up with a seat in Parliament!

It's fine to have an opinion but if it's derogatory then please do this knowing the actual facts and not what the papers want us to believe.

I don't think you can make demands on how people post on an open forum like MN

By all means if you think talk guidelines have been breached , report.

Unicorn34 · 10/12/2022 13:48

When my husband was a firefighter I joined him and the crew on the picket line during the strikes of the early 2000's. Some 9f the things happening in the background really surprised me:

  1. The Union reps were still being paid!
  2. The Army personnel who were covering were driving past jeering and doing w**ker signs at us
  3. The firefighters still went out to fires, albeit unpaid and uninsured, because they just did! This wasn't reported ANYWHERE
  4. There were lovely people bringing tea, coffee, treats etc when you could see they probably couldn't afford it
  5. There was a huge amount of abuse from people driving past

The main Union man spent many hours having discussions in restaurants, all expenses paid, still taking his salary and ended up with a seat in Parliament!

It's fine to have an opinion but if it's derogatory then please do this knowing the actual facts and not what the papers want us to believe.

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 13:43

DdraigGoch · 09/12/2022 21:09

People ARE leaving. Employers are getting so short of skilled staff that the non-strike days are almost as chaotic as the strike days. This is because they don't treat their staff well.

They will treat the staff as well as they need to to get sufficient staff in.

In the private sector if you can't recruit to need, you look at your offering.

That's why people are leaving jobs like teaching assistant to go work at Tesco or Aldi.

Far more effective than strikes is workers either not choosing to work for an employer or going elsewhere shortly after starting IMHO.

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 13:39

Florenz · 10/12/2022 10:35

Royal Mail workers striking at this point is like McDonalds workers striking. People will just go to KFC.

Indeede. Ebay have negotiated lower prices with alternative couriers and recommended all sellers to use.

As a small business Ebay seller myself I've already had to refund 4 buyers for parcels sent BEFORE the strikes thar have got lost. And I usually have maybe 1% of sales not arrive so this is unusually high.

I'm losing money so have switched to yodel now.

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 13:35

Catspyjamas17 · 09/12/2022 07:08

If rail workers don't strike there will be mass redundancies, as rail companies want unmanned stations and no guards on trains. Which is not what rail passengers want.

There is also a massive staff shortage to serve the current high passenger demand for train services. So train companies have to listen to what staff and passengers want.

Remind me again how striking helps a failing business make enough money to fulfil demands for no compulsory redundancies?

If they increase ticket prices it will cause more people to find alternative means of transport particularly during the current climate.

How exactly will they fund the unions demands?

Magic money tree?

SilverGlitterBaubles · 10/12/2022 13:34

YANBU we absolutely must maintain the right to strike. This is especially important where we have such an uncaring, selfish, corrupt government who are happy to tell us to just suck up austerity while they gave millions of public money to cronies like Michelle Mone for useless PPE. She gets to swan around in a new private jet and new yacht but we can't afford decent wages for workers. Things are very wrong here.

MushMonster · 10/12/2022 13:21

So... when are we going to get a NEW government?
Because in my opinion, what we should be doing is demanding new elections, and this time, chucking this lot out.
And demanding someone with a political ideology, with believes and guts, not just a bank account to put OUR money in, on their name.
Striking one week per month will not bring the changes we need. As you say, it only plays one against the other, with the whole of the taxpayer losing. And the economy, sinking lower. Here, it is each man/ woman for him/ herself. Damn the others.
And to be 100% clear, I agree that many many people have very valid reasons to be discontent with their working conditions, especially the NHS. But I am also 100% that no amount of strikes will get a penny out of the tory government. They will just cut and cut and cut.

Kreuzberg · 10/12/2022 12:27

How many threads on here regarding the NHS are bemoaning the horrendous care and lengthy waits to be seen by a medic, get a hospital bed or an emergency ambulance ? How many complain about elderly relatives not being fed or left in urine soaked beds ?
Well funnily enough it's not because nurses are sat at the nurses station perusing Ebay or scrolling through their SM accounts (although many posters on here would suggest they are). It's because there aren't enough of us as well as due to the
time consuming paperwork we have to plough through (although now it's on a
computer so takes twice as long). Essentially we nurse computers and the poor patient comes second.
The whole nursing profession needs re examining. Career progression is crap. Agenda for change saw to that. Promotion is not automatic. Ward manager jobs, specialist nursing posts, and ANP positions are few and far between hence nurses of 30 odd years experience are stuck at the bottom with no increase to their wage because they've hit the the top of their pay scale.
Colleagues at my trust have voted against striking because they cannot afford to lose their pay. Simple as...

DdraigGoch · 10/12/2022 11:42

MushMonster · 10/12/2022 10:28

@DdraigGoch around here, earlier this year, the news did mention that the railway unions wanted the government to intervene in the conversations, this according to the newspaper. Now it is the government the one to blame for them walking off the table, yet again.
In the meantime, is the everyday taxpayer, commuter, who is paying for all this. Next week, they are striking for the whole week!
This one is well out of hand. Why can't they sit on the table and flipping negotiate?
I am done with it, to be honest. I do not think they are being reasonable, at all. I am against holding a country citizens, its economy and everyday turningvof the wheel ransom, week after week after week...

The government are pulling the strings - and have been for the last couple of years. This would be over tomorrow if it was left up to the Managing Directors of the operating companies. This is a deliberate ideological war being waged by the government, with workers and passengers alike being thrown under a bus.

Twentypast · 10/12/2022 10:51

anniegun · 08/12/2022 20:43

Private sector workers have seen pay rise a lot faster than the public sector. Also University lecturers are one of the groups striking www.incomesdataresearch.co.uk/resources/news/average-weekly-earnings#:~:text=But%20behind%20these%20figures%2C%20there,sector%20(excluding%20financial%20services).

That's a generalisation. Almost no-one in the airline industry will be getting a payrise and I haven't had one since 2019.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 10/12/2022 10:45

@sneezingpandamum we've just had a ballot for strike action at my rail company. The last time we were on strike was 1981, so not exactly every year.

There are many different unions within the railway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread