Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD homeless abroad

432 replies

EmilioSoup · 08/12/2022 18:44

Okay, I’m prepared to be told my daughter needs to toughen up and I’m getting too involved but I’ve had her on the phone in absolute bits.

My 18 year old DD moved to Canada 8 weeks ago, on a temporary travel visa. Got a job in a hotel with staff accommodation, just near the hotel. We were so, so proud of her and thought it was a brilliant opportunity. They really liked her during interview.

She hasn’t had the best luck of it, and got struck down with influenza a week in, requiring an A&E visit (she’s insured, thank god). She was first taken ill at work, having fainted, they allowed her to leave to seek medical attention but nobody offered her a lift. Not saying anybody owes her a lift, but I think it’s common decency. She had a week off, was pressured into returning whilst still ill. Unfortunately the virus has caused some long-term side effects for her, such as thyroid problems, and she’s been struggling.

Yesterday, she had a performance review. She has had no feedback previously, had no inclination that anything was wrong. The review was terrible. I have seen a screenshot of the written review she was presented with, these are direct quoted:

“X seems to lack basic social skills, struggling in interactions with guests. She is robotic. We suggest X seeks support for this and an assessment.” (This seems to be implying that my daughter has ASD or something? She certainly doesn’t! Has always had many friends and been fine in school and other customer facing jobs! ASD has never, ever been on anybody’s radar. How can they think it’s okay to say this in a work review?)

“X causes other staff members stress due to her incapabilities. Newer staff members are a lot more capable than X. X is a hindrance on every shift she is on.”

“X is always claiming to be ill, and has no concept of basic punctuality.”

Among other stuff. She was the told she was dismissed, and had to be out of the staff accommodation that night with nowhere else to go. She called me in absolute bits. Luckily she has savings and has gone to a hotel, but it’s in a very expensive area and hotel is £350 a night. She has about £2000 left. She is trying to find another job with staff accommodation last minute but if nothing comes up, she will have to book a flight home. I have told her that once her savings get down to below £1000, she needs to come home as we don’t have the means to send her money for an emergency flight back on once she can no longer afford the hotel. So likely she will be home in the next few days.

DD is devastated about the work review and feels it went too far, and that it was a character assassination. Maybe it isn’t the job for her, fair enough, but I think the comments are incredibly cruel and they should’ve given her more notice to sort out alternative accommodation. She spent so much money on this visa, and was so excited to go, and she is heartbroken. They don’t owe her a job and home, of course they don’t, but had they handled it differently she probably could have sorted out a new job with staff housing, as there is plenty of it in the town. I don’t know why I’m posting on AIBU as I expect to be told she’s an adult, isn’t owed anything etc etc but I am heartbroken. She has had mental health issues before and this was supposed to be the making of her, and her confidence has been destroyed.

OP posts:
EmilioSoup · 09/12/2022 16:50

She found a decent flight, for £700 with a flight change in the USA though (where she is now), she’s boarding to Heathrow in a few hours. She had to apply for a ESTA to enter the USA and there was some concern it wouldn’t come through in time, but it came through before she booked the flight so she was okay. She got harassed by some bloke in the airport before boarding her first flight, who’d noticed she was alone and kept bothering her and got nasty when she didn’t entertain him, so she had to get security! The joys of being a woman. She seems in better spirits anyway, and already has New Years plans with her friends.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 09/12/2022 16:48

I think my issue is that they have just been SO harsh.

As a teen I worked in a lot of hotels and commercial accommodation; they were ALL very high pressure harsh workplaces. The turnover of hospitality staff is huge because the demanding environment; long unsocial hours; non stop work to a fixed standard, relentless managers who are invariably as tough as nails. Plus putting on a smile even to rude and demanding customers when you're exhausted and your feet are killing you.

Look at it from the hotels POV. It's clearly a wintersports area; this is the run up to Christmas, a very hectic period in hospitality; and your DD works front desk reception. A role required to be on the ball, on their feet, lit up smile, welcoming, efficient etc. because they are the front line of a fun holiday venue.. North American hospitality staff perform an act ,super-friendly- happy-polite and she would surely know that before taking the job.

What they got was a dizzy girl feeling faint, wanting to do her job from a chair, keep rushing out to the back office. I suspect "no clue about punctuality" was a recurring issue she;'d been warned about, and her idea of "I wasnt late" was the boss's expectation of " arrive early on shift for a seamless handover so you hit the ground running. Do not wander in on the dot carrying your coffee".

  Regardless of the reason,  she clearly  can't do the job so somebody else must replace her ASAP, and that somebody has to be accommodated.

There's no way a manager could let a failed receptionist carry on doing a bad job; and no way they could let her stay in the accommodation needed by her replacement.

I

Ritascornershop · 09/12/2022 16:46

Do let us know when she gets home safe and sound!

I’ve got to say, this doesn’t surprise me. Work reviews and attitudes to sick leave are brutal in Canada. I’ve worked in England and Canada (mostly Canada) & the differences are night and day. The working culture is shit here (Canada). That performance review was very personal, rude, and harsh. I’d be upset and I’m decades older. I’ve been bullied at work here and the protections for workers are there as window dressing: there is - in reality - next to no worker protection. Even in union jobs, it’s only as good as your union is strong (I had a weak union in my role where I was bullied). Whatever each province says about worker protection is not worth the paper it’s written on. Most jobs would rather you came in sick (unless it’s Covid or stomach flu, in which case they’re petrified).

I hope she can have a cosy Christmas at home and go on to have a lovely rest of her gap year.

Goodgrief82 · 09/12/2022 16:44

Psychgrad · 09/12/2022 16:16

What you actually mean is you searched my posts, busy day at work today is it?

Very quiet thankfully

Canuck48 · 09/12/2022 16:44

I can guess where she is now with the mention of Calgary. Has she tried some of the bigger hotels like Lake Louise or similar? She may need to fax them over. There is also similar ski towns near by that have similar set ups. She could also apply to the ski mountains and see about joint accommodations with others at the ski mountains. I know of someone who does this from Australia. I am in BC so have limited ideas from there.

lieselotte · 09/12/2022 16:43

What a sad story and what a nasty employer. But it's not just a North American thing, there are plenty of employers in the UK who would be that cruel as well. I agree that if you are providing accommodation you have a duty of care to those people even if there was gross misconduct (which being ill and therefore not really on the ball is not).

I hope she gets home safely and recovers and can then find something else interesting to occupy her time and earn some more money.

ChilliMum · 09/12/2022 16:36

Just seen your update and so happy for you and your daughter that she has made the brave decision to come home.

We don't build resilience by sticking out a bad situation but by learning when to call it a day, that it's OK to feel sad and disappointed but to know we tried our best and it wasn't to be. She can rest, then pick herself up and new adventures will come along when she is ready.

ArabellaScott · 09/12/2022 16:32

I'm glad she's coming home, OP. Sounds like the most sensible decision.

Sometimes 'resilience' means making that kind of decision. She needs to rest and recover, look after herself, be kind to herself, and confront the shitty behaviour of her employers - perhaps learn not to place her self worth in the hands of people who don't care about her?

Sometimes we learn a different lesson than the one we think we needed!

notanothertakeaway · 09/12/2022 16:24

2bazookas · 09/12/2022 15:51

An 18 yr old with MH and thyroid problems, no experience of hotel work, in a different winter climate and a strange country . Same language as UK, but different social manners expected in the hospitality trade.

Given her vulnerability, why didn't she try it out in Harrogate or Birmingham?

@2bazookas

Yes, probably would have been easier to work in the UK, but it's a bit late to suggest that now...............

Tangled123 · 09/12/2022 16:16

I’m so sad for you daughter OP. Coming home early due to sickness at this time of year is really disappointing, especially since you can only get those working visas once and the hotel were so horrible to her. It’s absolutely the right decision in the circumstances though. Hopefully she’s able to pick herself up quickly.

Psychgrad · 09/12/2022 16:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What you actually mean is you searched my posts, busy day at work today is it?

notanothertakeaway · 09/12/2022 16:08

I found cheap accommodation in Banff
www.hostelworld.com/s?q=Banff,Canada&country=Canada&city=Banff&type=city&id=4674&from=2022-12-10&to=2022-12-17&guests=1&page=1

And this
www.workaway.info/en/host/613659434345

But, 18 is young. If her big adventure hasn't worked out, she might be better coming home for some TLC

MeridaBrave · 09/12/2022 16:07

She could look on au pair world. At least with being an au pair don’t need to pay for accommodation. Although given the circs probably best to cut losses and come home. Being ill was unfortunate, being late was a stupid mistake. The world of work is different to being at school and sounds like she lacked maturity.

MadameMackenzie · 09/12/2022 16:04

HerRoyalNotness · 08/12/2022 18:50

Can she move to a ski town, there should be plenty of work for her to try and pick up? Definitely needs to love out of hotel per PP!

Not much of Canada is constantly covered in snow you know! 🙄 The west coast & mid-west only gets it about as much as us, if not less!

antelopevalley · 09/12/2022 16:01

I agree it was very harsh to tell an employee from abroad they were sacked and to love out the next day. But sadly it does not surprise me. People advise the exact same response all the time on here when people have a foreign nanny they are not happy with. Its always just chuck her out, she has a family who can look after her. So sadly this attitude is not uncommon.
I hope she is home with you soon and you all have a brilliant Christmas.

2bazookas · 09/12/2022 15:51

An 18 yr old with MH and thyroid problems, no experience of hotel work, in a different winter climate and a strange country . Same language as UK, but different social manners expected in the hospitality trade.

Given her vulnerability, why didn't she try it out in Harrogate or Birmingham?

Goodgrief82 · 09/12/2022 15:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Goodgrief82 · 09/12/2022 15:46

Psychgrad · 09/12/2022 15:34

No I wasn’t a teen but not far from it really, I didn’t have a great relationship with my parents, slightly better now that I’m older- if you must know! Anyway looks like the daughter is going back home so problem is resolved, you can go back to your life now @Goodgrief82.

What an odd post.

but it would be interesting to see how you parent teens if you do go on to have children, if you have the same “resilience, toughen up, stand up strong” to all your children, whoever their personality and whatever the situation.

for their sake, I hope not

Psychgrad · 09/12/2022 15:34

No I wasn’t a teen but not far from it really, I didn’t have a great relationship with my parents, slightly better now that I’m older- if you must know! Anyway looks like the daughter is going back home so problem is resolved, you can go back to your life now @Goodgrief82.

Coyoacan · 09/12/2022 15:34

A certain amount of hardship builds resilence, but that poor girl has been through the mill. We also have the saying that he who fights and runs away, lives to fight another day.

Goodgrief82 · 09/12/2022 15:31

And during these hard times when you were a teen @Psychgrad what was your relationship like with your parents and indeed now?

Goodgrief82 · 09/12/2022 15:26

Psychgrad · 09/12/2022 15:26

Well I have been in a similar situation to the OP’s daughter and for me it did build resilience, confidence and has taught me how to be resourceful in many situations as an adult. I’m just giving my personal opinion on a thread where the poster asked for opinions, I’m entitled to mine and you’re entitled to yours. However, as I’ve been in a similar situation, the OP may find mine more useful. Just saying.

Do you have children @Psychgrad ?

Psychgrad · 09/12/2022 15:26

TheSilentPicnic · 09/12/2022 07:37

No, it won't "build her resilience". It is a myth that hardship breeds resilience. Hardship breeds vulnerability. Support breeds resilience.

Well I have been in a similar situation to the OP’s daughter and for me it did build resilience, confidence and has taught me how to be resourceful in many situations as an adult. I’m just giving my personal opinion on a thread where the poster asked for opinions, I’m entitled to mine and you’re entitled to yours. However, as I’ve been in a similar situation, the OP may find mine more useful. Just saying.

Winter789Mermaid · 09/12/2022 13:45

Bless her I hope with some rest and recharge time at home and she will look back at the positives from her adventure knowing it wasn’t her fault she got sick and coping alone in a foreign country is really hard! Hope she can plan some more adventures for the spring & summer

Coyoacan · 09/12/2022 13:38

If she doesn’t fancy Calgary - what about Edmonton? Slower pace of life

You're nuts. You don't move to a place like Edmonton in the middle of winter and it has a winter that lasts for about 8 months a year, with temperatures of minus 50 degrees. It is also an extremely ugly city.

Swipe left for the next trending thread