Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD homeless abroad

432 replies

EmilioSoup · 08/12/2022 18:44

Okay, I’m prepared to be told my daughter needs to toughen up and I’m getting too involved but I’ve had her on the phone in absolute bits.

My 18 year old DD moved to Canada 8 weeks ago, on a temporary travel visa. Got a job in a hotel with staff accommodation, just near the hotel. We were so, so proud of her and thought it was a brilliant opportunity. They really liked her during interview.

She hasn’t had the best luck of it, and got struck down with influenza a week in, requiring an A&E visit (she’s insured, thank god). She was first taken ill at work, having fainted, they allowed her to leave to seek medical attention but nobody offered her a lift. Not saying anybody owes her a lift, but I think it’s common decency. She had a week off, was pressured into returning whilst still ill. Unfortunately the virus has caused some long-term side effects for her, such as thyroid problems, and she’s been struggling.

Yesterday, she had a performance review. She has had no feedback previously, had no inclination that anything was wrong. The review was terrible. I have seen a screenshot of the written review she was presented with, these are direct quoted:

“X seems to lack basic social skills, struggling in interactions with guests. She is robotic. We suggest X seeks support for this and an assessment.” (This seems to be implying that my daughter has ASD or something? She certainly doesn’t! Has always had many friends and been fine in school and other customer facing jobs! ASD has never, ever been on anybody’s radar. How can they think it’s okay to say this in a work review?)

“X causes other staff members stress due to her incapabilities. Newer staff members are a lot more capable than X. X is a hindrance on every shift she is on.”

“X is always claiming to be ill, and has no concept of basic punctuality.”

Among other stuff. She was the told she was dismissed, and had to be out of the staff accommodation that night with nowhere else to go. She called me in absolute bits. Luckily she has savings and has gone to a hotel, but it’s in a very expensive area and hotel is £350 a night. She has about £2000 left. She is trying to find another job with staff accommodation last minute but if nothing comes up, she will have to book a flight home. I have told her that once her savings get down to below £1000, she needs to come home as we don’t have the means to send her money for an emergency flight back on once she can no longer afford the hotel. So likely she will be home in the next few days.

DD is devastated about the work review and feels it went too far, and that it was a character assassination. Maybe it isn’t the job for her, fair enough, but I think the comments are incredibly cruel and they should’ve given her more notice to sort out alternative accommodation. She spent so much money on this visa, and was so excited to go, and she is heartbroken. They don’t owe her a job and home, of course they don’t, but had they handled it differently she probably could have sorted out a new job with staff housing, as there is plenty of it in the town. I don’t know why I’m posting on AIBU as I expect to be told she’s an adult, isn’t owed anything etc etc but I am heartbroken. She has had mental health issues before and this was supposed to be the making of her, and her confidence has been destroyed.

OP posts:
Flippingnora100 · 09/12/2022 19:33

Now that she’s coming home, the meaning she makes of the experience will be important for her confidence and her future approach to life. I would suggest trying to encourage her that it was just bad luck and has no bearing on her actual capabilities or ability to succeed in life. Maybe once she has recovered she can work a bit to save up and go traveling for a few weeks instead. I’m sure she’ll feel so much better to be home for a few weeks. How lucky that she has this support in her life.

I don’t think it was unrealistic at all to go at 18. So many parents coddle this generation of kids when we would have been perfectly capable at the same age.

She just got unlucky with getting ill, not recovering quickly, not being fully able to work and not having a very sympathetic employer.

Onwards and upwards!

MadameMackenzie · 09/12/2022 19:32

I know of a hotel in the most beautiful part of the Lake District that has staff accommodation as my 22yr old nephew lives & works there - he LOVES it! 7 months in and he's choosing to stay there over Christmas as he enjoys it so much. This is a lad that wouldn't even keep appointments let alone jobs, so it must be good!

Happy to pass on the details to your DD if you PM me, OP. For once she's recovered. Not quite Canada but a beautiful place none the less!

Heyhoitsme · 09/12/2022 19:31

If it was my daughter I'd want her home. My son ended up in a bad way in Australia. I was so relieved when he got home.

rookiemere · 09/12/2022 19:27

@Burgoo , but OP says that "previous jobs loved her, her last one has said they’ll have her back in a flash when back from Canada."

I think it's far more likely that the poor review is caused by DD not being fully well and perhaps struggling to get to work on time if not well, and not as smily and jolly as Canadian employees seem to be as it's a bit alien to her culture.

Buteverythingsfine · 09/12/2022 19:22

I went away when I was 17 on a gap year and it wasn't a great success, I got out of my depth quickly and ended up coming home and struggling with panic attacks. I was so glad my mum just took me in unquestioningly and I was able to restart and reset things. I then went to uni the following year and did great, and I didn't have another panic attack for decades. It's ok to be young and have false starts, it's about what you do afterwards that matters. Hugs to you and your daughter, you sound like a great mum who will support your dd in this misstep and help her get back up again.

Missingpop · 09/12/2022 19:22

It’s very sad but shes 18; she’s been poorly & she’s a long way from home; could there be some truth in what been written?
Before everyone jumps down my throat; an 18 year old feeling crappy; basically being forced back to work isn’t going to be working anywhere near 100%.
I know as a parent that I can say if it were my child they one thing they’d want is to be at home with mum; sleeping in their own warm bed; eating wholesome meals made by mum; knowing everything is going to be ok & that they are safe.
It doesn’t sound like this young lady has had much understanding in the past few weeks I’d be telling her to get herself on the next flight home; no one needs to know about this bump in the road; if anyone asks; she became unwell & wasn’t improving so she decided to come home for Christmas & will se how it goes in tge new year xx
I hope she comes home safely & is able to put this nasty experience behind her these people don’t appear to be very pleasant x

Delphinium20 · 09/12/2022 19:21

Also, customer service employees in N. America are expected to be upbeat, friendly, extroverted and engaging. That's why we get grief when we travel to other parts of the world because we're so loud. It could be a cultural difference in behavior.

Delphinium20 · 09/12/2022 19:19

EmilioSoup · 08/12/2022 19:22

In a way I understand it’ll be a really good character building experience if she stays and sticks it out. But also, I don’t know if it’s worth it for a sake of what was supposed to be a 6 month gap year opportunity living in the mountains and having fun. If she goes to Calgary, can only afford a seedy flatshare, and gets a horrible job and has no friends or support system it will be crap for her.

I have a DD 18 who is doing something very similar for her gap year and has had some roadblocks thrown her way, so I'm more than empathetic to what your DD is going through - it sucks for your DD and it's quite the disappointment. My DD had to readjust and find a new opportunity and it was a lot of work and a lot of disappointment. The new situation has since worked out and she's quite happy, but for several months, she was miserable. However, I'm of a mind that sticking it out and having a kind of shit experience might be just the thing to teach her the value of a university degree or other education towards a profession. Learning that a shit job with shit pay and shit employers is the reality for most of the world's low-wage employees is a great motivator to study once in college or other professional training.

Burgoo · 09/12/2022 19:17

@EmilioSoup It sounds terrible for your daughter and my thoughts are with you all in such a tough situation.

What strikes me is how you seem to have a strong urge to defend her and the attitude toward a suggestion that she may have ASD is rather interesting. People can have many friends, do well at school etc and still have autism. In fact, ASD in girls is FAR more masked because they look like they are fully functioning.

Is there any way in which this feedback may actually be accurate? Most employers don't give that type of feedback unless there is at least a kernel of truth in it and I am always really reluctant to jump to being defensive when getting any feedback.

Just some thoughts on the feedback:

"“X seems to lack basic social skills, struggling in interactions with guests. She is robotic. We suggest X seeks support for this and an assessment.” (This seems to be implying that my daughter has ASD or something? She certainly doesn’t! Has always had many friends and been fine in school and other customer facing jobs! ASD has never, ever been on anybody’s radar. How can they think it’s okay to say this in a work review?)

I would like some clarification on the first point re: social skills. She may well not "fit" in that culture in terms of what is expected. The UK is full of fairly aloof people and I wonder whether she has gotten away with customer facing jobs in the past because in the UK we don't value it all that much? For example, I don't want you to talk to me when booking me into a hotel! I want you to get my key, tell me what time to get out and occasionally carry the bags if that is included. In Canada it may well be that you have to do the niceties and if you don't then you really stand out. Is she robotic? You are probably not the best judge, because you will always see her behaviour as normal. My sibling has autism but my family never once even thought it to be the case. Why? Because she was "just being her". In terms of the suggestion, yes it is not polite in the UK and it may well be that the suggestion is coming from a place of wanting her to get the right support. Who knows?

“X causes other staff members stress due to her incapabilities. Newer staff members are a lot more capable than X. X is a hindrance on every shift she is on.”

I want to know more about what this incapability is. If she doesn't do stuff, takes a long time to do fairly standard tasks or needs a fair amount of guidance then it makes sense they would get stressed. Given that this isn't a high end, intellectually taxing profession that requires a great deal of skill and technical expertise. Nobody wants to drag another person through a shift.

“X is always claiming to be ill, and has no concept of basic punctuality.”"

Is she claiming to be ill? We all CLAIM that we are ill, even when we are ill. It is a very abrasive term that comes off like they don't believe her. Though again we can't attribute motives. It sounds like she turned up late a lot. That is a problem and will be in any job.

I would really advise against making the assumption that 1) it was put to her in bad faith and 2) that it is all nonsense. But I do also get that she is your daughter and you will, instinctively, want to defend her.

CPL593H · 09/12/2022 19:13

Daffi · 09/12/2022 18:55

Brits aren't suited to hotel work, they are far too lazy

Substitute "lazy" for "unprepared to work long unsociable hours for wages that cannot support a home and family in the UK"

gourmetperle · 09/12/2022 19:12

I have met plenty of good British hotel staff. Way to write off a whole nationality as being capable of certain jobs 🤦‍♀️

Daffi · 09/12/2022 19:06

EmilioSoup · 09/12/2022 19:03

@Daffi

It’s a good job there’s no hotels in the UK then, isn’t it?

Have you seen many British staff in them? There is a crisis in the industry since Brexit, do you watch the news?

ganachee · 09/12/2022 19:04

Daffi · 09/12/2022 18:55

Brits aren't suited to hotel work, they are far too lazy

What an ignorant load of nonsense. The girl is recovering from post viral symptoms. She needs to rest, recuperate and get her health back.

EmilioSoup · 09/12/2022 19:03

@Daffi

It’s a good job there’s no hotels in the UK then, isn’t it?

OP posts:
pattihews · 09/12/2022 19:03

Just googled Canmore hostels and if your daughter can get there (there must be buses) tomorrow she can have a bed in a dorm for less than $50 a night.

canmoredowntownhostel.ca

That's a whole week for the price of a night in her swanky hotel. I've checked it and there's choice available.

In a hostel she'll have companionship, advice from staff and other guests and the opportunity to job hunt. Even if she's there for a fortnight she should be able to afford it if she's careful with food and drink costs. She ought to be able to get there on a bus. Tell her to take ordinary local buses. You'll always pay a premium for the airport shuttle but she'll almost certainly be able to get to the airport using slower but cheaper services.

When you're 18 and panicking and inexperienced it's difficult to make good decisions. Your role, OP, is not to panic but to provide advice and a plan to enable her to turn this into a success.

gourmetperle · 09/12/2022 19:01

Daffi · 09/12/2022 18:55

Brits aren't suited to hotel work, they are far too lazy

I beg your pardon?

Daffi · 09/12/2022 18:55

Brits aren't suited to hotel work, they are far too lazy

ganachee · 09/12/2022 18:55

EmilioSoup · 09/12/2022 17:41

She always has been ‘with it’, genuinely. I had no concerns at all about her going! Didn’t need any help at all going through the visa process. She usually is very practical and organised. The staff accommodation is/was basic (like uni dorms) but she didn’t mind that at all. She liked the sound if it for the social aspect.

I think the illness has messed with her head. She got terribly unlucky being ill so soon, and once she’s realised she hasn’t fully recovered and still isn’t well she’s become depressed. It also birthed bad feelings from her employers, and if that’s happened within the first week I can imagine it’s hard to come back from. I think she’s having a mental health episode, I don’t mean a psychotic episode or anything, but she’s angry at what’s happened and is self-sabotaging maybe (spending money unnecessarily). That’s why I don’t think staying and trying to tough it out is necessarily a good idea. She was mentally coping with her illness (still down, but managing) up until the job fired her, and I think it’s just set something off. She needs to come home and recuperate. It’s all well and good saying “the real world is harsh” bla bla bla, but at the end of the day it’s just a gap year trip, she’s not got a mortgage and kids to feed has she? So if she needs to recuperate, why shouldn’t she utilise coming home to family support and a comfortable bedroom to sleep in whilst she gets well? Most parents would offer that to their DC, surely?

She is doing the right thing as are you supporting her to come home. As some of us have said on here, she is physically unwell and the best thing for her is to come home, rest and recuperate. This will give her the best chance of recovery and then she can make future plans. It is also not surprising if she is feeling mentally down as well, it will be v disappointing to have organised what she hoped would have been a fun trip living in Canada for six months with other young people to then get ill and struggle to do the job. I wish her all the best.

Lizzylum · 09/12/2022 18:50

I’d say to her. Come home. Take stock. And try again when she’s ready. She’s very young. Plenty of time. Just because others have done it doesn’t matter. She will fly when she’s ready again

whatayear22 · 09/12/2022 18:49

I'm sure her security/ room / system passes or whatever they are called would all tied in together, so they wouldn't be able to extend it. Once someone is out, they are out. It's not their fault she didn't have much contingency. And they wouldn't want someone in the company dorm badmouthing the company.

DeliberatelyObtuse · 09/12/2022 18:44

So glad to hear she's on her way home

She can rest and recover and rethink her plans

Perhaps some down time until after Christmas and then back to her old job

She gave it a go and she should be super proud of herself

FerryYaBerryLa · 09/12/2022 18:37

Layersoftaytoes · 09/12/2022 18:07

Could she do a bit more saving back in the UKand then head off to Australia? She’s clearly capable of travel and sounds like she has a strong head on her shoulders so 6 more months of savings, get her finances topped up and head to Oz? I went there on my own after my friend dropped out (without telling me!), I arrived in Sydney airport in tears as it was obvious my friend wasn’t coming and I was suddenly terrified. Told myself to stick it out 2 weeks or go back home. I had saved £2000 and had absolutely no plans or any idea what I was going to do, I was just sort of hoping to Bob along with my friend. Anyway… 2 weeks in.. I absolutely loved it. I travelled the East Coast on my own, made so many friends, got a bar job on an island, ended up staying until the very last day of my year visa! I’m still close with a lot of friends I made there. Turned out to be the best thing, doing it alone. It forced me to socialise and I wasn’t “held back” by anyone. I hope your daughter gives travelling another go and doesn’t let Canada be her last travel chapter! ❤️

That is awesome, what a great experience, thanks for sharing!

Hooverphobe · 09/12/2022 18:15

Unless she’s a ski-bunny, Banff was an unusual choice to have made (in November!). Can she gather her thoughts and give it another whirl in the new year in perhaps a more forgiving climate?

I’ve got tons of family in Alberta - but we’re all ski nuts and have done “hospitality” for the proximity to the slopes alone.

Layersoftaytoes · 09/12/2022 18:07

Could she do a bit more saving back in the UKand then head off to Australia? She’s clearly capable of travel and sounds like she has a strong head on her shoulders so 6 more months of savings, get her finances topped up and head to Oz? I went there on my own after my friend dropped out (without telling me!), I arrived in Sydney airport in tears as it was obvious my friend wasn’t coming and I was suddenly terrified. Told myself to stick it out 2 weeks or go back home. I had saved £2000 and had absolutely no plans or any idea what I was going to do, I was just sort of hoping to Bob along with my friend. Anyway… 2 weeks in.. I absolutely loved it. I travelled the East Coast on my own, made so many friends, got a bar job on an island, ended up staying until the very last day of my year visa! I’m still close with a lot of friends I made there. Turned out to be the best thing, doing it alone. It forced me to socialise and I wasn’t “held back” by anyone. I hope your daughter gives travelling another go and doesn’t let Canada be her last travel chapter! ❤️

TakingTime2 · 09/12/2022 17:57

EmilioSoup · 09/12/2022 17:46

The world is harsh, and I’ll always encourage DD to do things, work hard and provide for herself, but as a parent my home will always be open to her as a safe haven if shit ever hits the fan for her and she needs somewhere to go. So I don’t feel I’m giving her unrealistic expectations by welcoming her back home rather than telling her to stay and sort it out. Does that make sense?

Makes complete sense op and the exact ethos I plan to have with my dc.

I remember going home a few times myself as an adult, sometimes when shit hits the fan you just get this overwhelming urge to be at home no matter how old you are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread