Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told I was 'phobic' for not using pronouns!

684 replies

NewStartIn50s · 08/12/2022 17:48

Asked for my preferred pronouns and I said ' I don't use them', pushed on what I use to refer to myself and I said I don't use on emails or when I introduce myself or at all. Apparently, if I use them I am showing inclusivity to others and being accepting. I'm not quite a dinosaur yet but why are these things forced on us. I don't have a beard (yet) and I think you can tell what I am/but does it really matter if you can't.

So AIBU

YANBU - don't have to use pronouns if you don't want to

YABU - you should state what your preferred pronouns are

OP posts:
LakieLady · 09/12/2022 12:07

There are people who want to make misgendering a crime.

It can be a disciplinary matter where I work, but only if it's done deliberately and with the intention of upsetting them. An utter arsehole of a manager tried to give a formal warning to someone who'd "misgendered" a colleague when referring to something that had happened prior to their transition, and it was overturned on appeal.

The "victim" of said misgendering de-transitioned a few months later. No-one has a clue now whether or not they have to refer to them historically as the sex they ID'd as at the relevant time or the sex they are now. Thankfully, our paths don't cross professionally.

One former colleague is gender fluid, and they don't give a shit about how they're referred to.

PickyTea · 09/12/2022 12:03

G5000 · 09/12/2022 11:50

Why only pronouns - surely it's just as important to know my religion, nationality, background, family history etc etc, so you wouldn't accidentally offend me when wishing me Merry Christmas if I don't celebrate it, for example.

Do most people not discuss this at work already?

These comments are as crazy as usual

PickyTea · 09/12/2022 12:02

peaceandove · 09/12/2022 11:07

It's becoming a grammatical nightmare. If someone has appropriated 'they' as their pro noun, then WTF do we now use as a plural? Would it be 'theys' 'thems' and 'thoses'???

Although, pronouncing that last one is a real fucker if you have a lisp.

Unless they have a clone why would you ever refer to someone as a plural anything?

MoanySloney · 09/12/2022 12:00

Shoxfordian · 08/12/2022 17:53

How hard would it be to just say she/her? 🙄

That's not the point.

OP may appear to be of a particular gender and be happy to be addressed as such.

OR OP may be struggling with their gender identity and have been forced to out themselves in a forum they were not yet comfortable to do so.

This is what I throw out when people ask for my pronouns/sexuality/gender. I am not ready to out myself yet. I enjoy watching them all squirm afterwards.

LakieLady · 09/12/2022 11:56

Patronus · 09/12/2022 11:23

I have a question for any bi-lingual speakers. How does the pronoun thing work in, say French when nouns inherently have a gender ie. le chat and la table?

I've been wondering that.

What do speakers of other languages do?* Or is this solely an issue in English?

In German, the equivalent of "they" is the same word as "she".

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2022 11:54

Why only pronouns - surely it's just as important to know my religion, nationality, background, family history etc etc, so you wouldn't accidentally offend me when wishing me Merry Christmas if I don't celebrate it, for example.

Good point.

orangegato · 09/12/2022 11:50

W0tnow · 09/12/2022 11:02

I’ve always wanted someone to ask me mine!

I’d give a deadpan stare and say ‘Guess. Go on. I bet you get it right first go.’

I’m excited to be asked for mine too. I work in the public sector so it’s only a matter of time. Go on I dare you

G5000 · 09/12/2022 11:50

Why only pronouns - surely it's just as important to know my religion, nationality, background, family history etc etc, so you wouldn't accidentally offend me when wishing me Merry Christmas if I don't celebrate it, for example.

IcakethereforeIam · 09/12/2022 11:49

There are people who want to make misgendering a crime. A few years ago a woman in her 60s was the victim of an unprovoked attack by a young transwoman (by the name of Tara Wolff, last heard of cage fighting in Thailand and gagging to be able to fight born women). The woman's compensation was reduced by the judge because, while under oath, she kept forgetting to use 'she' when referring to her male attacker.

Rape victim, child abuse victims were meant to refer to their attackers as 'she' when giving evidence. After an outcry these seem to have been shelved.

Oddly, there's a recent phenomenon where men discover their trans identity while in prison or awaiting trial. This can mean they get sent to a women's jail. There, they (usually having undergone no genital surgery) will share intimate facilities, showers and toilets, with the actual woman. Many women in prisons have been traumatised by male, often sexual, violence.

Sometimes, after being released, these men realise they weren't trans after all.

Anyway, we were talking about pronouns. Can I see any harm?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2022 11:47

Try she/her if you want to put an end to the drama.

No thanks.

BellePeppa · 09/12/2022 11:47

namechangeforvibes · 08/12/2022 23:05

I am perhaps jumping into the frying pan here but I genuinely ask this in good faith.

Those who don’t want to disclose their pronouns in their emails etc., fair enough. But what about if someone specifically asks your pronouns so they know how to refer to you? Would you prefer that people just always use your name? Or guess? Using someone’s name over and over seems clumsy to me and an odd way to go when we’ve been using pronouns for years without a second thought.

I do see the point about it being potentially outing and the protected characteristics issues. Just wondering if people’s general issues are with the email, or with ever disclosing them at all.

Why would someone be using a pronoun to my face and if they’re using it outside my earshot why would I care?

Has there ever been a word so widely written and used and discussed as ‘pronoun’ is today that was only ever used inside a classroom teaching English?

Too many self obsessed people around today.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2022 11:46

Those who want to, yes. I bet the vast majority don't do this though.

Quite. Just like the vast majority of people here don't put their pronouns in their signature etc.

LakieLady · 09/12/2022 11:45

JoyfulGirl · 08/12/2022 23:24

It used to be common to put your title in parentheses after your name in correspondence, like “yours sincerely, J Smith (Mrs)”. I kind of see the pronouns thing as similar. Putting trans issues aside, it can be quite handy when someone has a name that’s gender-neutral, or perhaps from a different language or something. I do understand why people are uncomfortable declaring their pronouns though, and definitely don’t think anyone should feel pressured to do it.

I remember those days, too. I was regarded as a dangerous radical for using "Ms" in the late 70s.

I don't have a problem with using my pronouns, and can see that it can be useful (I work in an organisation with a lot of LGBTQI staff, and there are a couple of people I've seen around whose sex I truly could not determine, so it avoids giving offence.) And I'm not gender critical, so it's not a biggie for me.

Fairislefandango · 09/12/2022 11:43

In Latin America I think they use x instead of o. Ie latinxs

Those who want to, yes. I bet the vast majority don't do this though.

Mogwire · 09/12/2022 11:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

PeaceJoySleep · 09/12/2022 11:32

In Latin America I think they use x instead of o. Ie latinxs
In Spanish in Spain it's elles instead of ellos or ellas
Do some people on sm use @?
Like mi amig@ es de gener@ no binari'e'
😯

FlirtsWithRhinos · 09/12/2022 11:30

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 09/12/2022 11:10

Try she/her if you want to put an end to the drama.

Can't use she/her, it means I identify as a person of unspecified sex a womany mind.

Can't use they/them, it means I identify as a person of unspecified sex with a mind that is neither, or moves between, womany and man-y.

Can't use he/him, it means I identify as a person of unspecified sex with a man-y mind.

I am a person with a definite sex of female and a mind that is neither woman-y or man-y beyond the differences that were imposed on me through society's treatment and expectations of my sex (and which, incidentally, I experience as an external influence not an internal self).

What pronouns can I use please?

JazbayGrapes · 09/12/2022 11:23

My pronouns are "I/me", somebody else would refer to me as "you"

Patronus · 09/12/2022 11:23

I have a question for any bi-lingual speakers. How does the pronoun thing work in, say French when nouns inherently have a gender ie. le chat and la table?

Patronus · 09/12/2022 11:21

"Well, I'm Ted Cruz, and my pronoun is 'kiss my ass,'"

About sums up my views.

SoupDragon · 09/12/2022 11:20

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 09/12/2022 11:10

Try she/her if you want to put an end to the drama.

Try to read the whole thread to avoid looking like a numpty.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 09/12/2022 11:16

Bother, formatting messed up. I'll try that again

I would much prefer that, rather than an obligation to use a person's specified pronouns regardless of how that may clash with our own identity and values, we had an option of polite gender neutral pronouns that can be used for anyone regardless of gender/sex.

I think having a language that requires us to label people as male and female to talk about them(1) at all, even just to say they(1)'ve put the bin out, is the thing that should have been tackled rather than keep the daft, outmoded sex-based language but let people choose which set they want to be referred to.

However even that isn't great because the historical suppression of female people in public life means gender neutral tends to read as male and therefore perpetuates the "default male" cultural fallacy instead of making sure female people are visible as well.

(1) As my natural use of it above shows, "they" historically fulfilled this role for people of unknown sex (not meaning specifically DSD but in situations where you speak of a hypothetical/general person like I have above) and could have been a good option for a polite "I don't need to flag a specific sex/gender in this context" pronoun, but has been hijacked for the specific identity of non-binary and therefore won't work, because someone can now be misgendered by "they". Illustrating yet again that this language is not, in fact, about being reasonable and kind, but about taking away any language that enables expression of concepts outside the ideology )

PeaceJoySleep · 09/12/2022 11:15

AnnieKenney · 08/12/2022 17:53

'I'm not sure' is the best response I've come across yet. Repeat as necessary until they stop questioning you.

Yeh good one. Don't want to be cancelled.

SinnerBoy · 09/12/2022 11:14

SixCharactersinSearchofanAuthor · Yesterday 18:20

^This is one reason why: www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/what-happened-when-a-man-signed-work-emails-using-a-female-name-for-a-week_n_58c2ce53e4b054a0ea6a4066^

I've seen that before and it's pretty shocking. It's well known that when people know that they are dealing with a woman, they are likely to treat them less favourably - even other women!

Apologies if these have already been posted, there were too many posts to read all in one go...

But also - gender identity is a belief system. You're not asked to include your religious beliefs in your email sign off - why is gender identity treated differently?

sex-matters.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Pronouns-at-work-guide.pdf

"Can your employer require you to ‘state your pronouns’? There have been no legal cases about this. But we think not: employees are entitled to decline to take part in this ritual, and to be protected from discrimination, harassment and victimisation."

"If your employer (or your school or university) asks or encourages you to state your pronouns:

The simplest thing is to decline in a low-key manner. You do not need to explain why. Simply refrain from putting pronouns in your biography or your email signature and don’t announce them at meetings. If invited to, say ‘No thank you’ and if asked why, say something bland like ‘It is not a practice I follow’."

www.legalfeminist.org.uk/2020/07/19/pronouns-compulsion-and-controversy/

"In 2019, the Royal Society of Chemistry undertook an analysis of gender bias publishing in the chemical sciences. It recognised that biases were “subtle” and could be “inadvertent.” Women were invited to review less often, their work was more harshly received, their initial submissions more frequently rejected. These “small biases” led to a “significant cumulative effect.” "

"The RSC are not the only organisation to have done such research. Others have found similar results, and of course there are numerous articles spanning the last decade or more which find that CVs with a female name get poorer results than the same CV carrying a male name. CV writing services recommend against including gender on the CV – a practice which used to be common and is now recognised as archaic. Race is also a factor – although for now at least, nobody is suggesting we declare our race at the bottom of email signatures."

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 09/12/2022 11:10

Try she/her if you want to put an end to the drama.