Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told I was 'phobic' for not using pronouns!

684 replies

NewStartIn50s · 08/12/2022 17:48

Asked for my preferred pronouns and I said ' I don't use them', pushed on what I use to refer to myself and I said I don't use on emails or when I introduce myself or at all. Apparently, if I use them I am showing inclusivity to others and being accepting. I'm not quite a dinosaur yet but why are these things forced on us. I don't have a beard (yet) and I think you can tell what I am/but does it really matter if you can't.

So AIBU

YANBU - don't have to use pronouns if you don't want to

YABU - you should state what your preferred pronouns are

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 09/12/2022 13:18

That is (or perhaps was, in this brave new world) considered rude.

Exactly. Calling someone she in earshot is not polite.

JackTorrance · 09/12/2022 13:15

It is perfectly common to use 3rd person pronouns about someone in their earshot

That is (or perhaps was, in this brave new world) considered rude.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/12/2022 12:55

waterlego · 08/12/2022 21:19

Fairly obvious what people mean though, isn’t it?

On the contrary. It is rarely obvious what "wokespeak" means.

It sometimes seems that words change meaning halfway through a sentence.

tabbysarerude · 09/12/2022 12:52

I'm dyslexic so I use eh?/cher

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot · 09/12/2022 12:50

KatharinaRosalie · 09/12/2022 12:38

Works in theory, except we base quite a few decisions on sex with mind to safeguarding and dignity.

I get what you're saying, but in my native language, there are no gendered pronouns and honestly I have never encountered this type of issues in real life. If the sex is important but unclear, you can specify, but that would be in very rare cases.

But in England we have a culture that assumes female name+she = woman and so people are not versed in clarifying. Obviously if your culture has neutral pronouns there will be language nuance that helps you navigate the lack.

When I request a female nurse for a smear for example, and they say Sally will do it she will be along in a minute, I'd like that to reflect reality or otherwise it will put me in a situation where I have to refuse someone and deny their 'gender identity' because they were trying to obscure their sex from me.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/12/2022 12:50

Dreamwhisper · 08/12/2022 20:56

You've completely missed the point of my post, please read it again.

Then I missed it as well.

Perhaps it wasn't very clear?

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/12/2022 12:46

nolongersurprised · 08/12/2022 20:48

If you use the pretty universally accepted fact that "men can't become women" to assert your views when called out, but what you've also been doing is denigrating and shaming trans people for existing though, that would be bigoted, no?

It’s true that men can’t become women, it’s not shaming or denigrating transwomen to acknowledge this. Be Kind is one thing, but having to reject reality discomfits me.

Acknowledging biological reality isn’t a segue into denigrating and shaming transpeople. Not parroting TWAW isn’t political, it’s ok not to believe something that isn’t true.

I find it very immature when the “bigot” and “far right” insults come out when people refuse to capitulate to gender woo. Adults are allowed to have a range of beliefs, we’re not 10 and having to pick some sort of side in the playground. Transwomen are not women, they are transwomen. This isn’t political, it’s not literal violence not to believe it and it’s not kind to pretend that people can change sex.

Hear, hear.

It is no more bigoted to say "transwomen" aren't women than it is to say "men aren't women", or "dogs aren't cats".

audeloquipalam · 09/12/2022 12:40

orzoisorange · 08/12/2022 18:11

Sheesh, Girl, it could be a MALE vagina, of course 🙄

To misquote Gervais: “….HER penis, you f*ing bigot…”

KatharinaRosalie · 09/12/2022 12:38

Works in theory, except we base quite a few decisions on sex with mind to safeguarding and dignity.

I get what you're saying, but in my native language, there are no gendered pronouns and honestly I have never encountered this type of issues in real life. If the sex is important but unclear, you can specify, but that would be in very rare cases.

IcakethereforeIam · 09/12/2022 12:38

Yup, too often hard on the heels of using pronouns just to 'be kind', or 'be an ally', there's the 'or else'.

I've used 'they' when I didn't know a person's sex or to help preserve anonymity, but using it otherwise has rarely been a feature of English.

I think the German language has tied itself in knots trying to accommodate this.

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot · 09/12/2022 12:28

*I would much prefer that, rather than an obligation to use a person's specified pronouns regardless of how that may clash with our own identity and values, we had an option of polite gender neutral pronouns that can be used for anyone regardless of gender/sex.

I think having a language that requires us to label people as male and female to talk about them(1) at all, even just to say they(1)'ve put the bin out, is the thing that should have been tackled rather than keep the daft, outmoded sex-based language but let people choose which set they want to be referred to.*

Works in theory, except we base quite a few decisions on sex with mind to safeguarding and dignity.

I've. It's late at night. A friend says their friend Robin will give me a lift home as it's on their way home.

Personally, my decision would change depending on whether a she or a he was used.

Which shows the importance of sex based pronouns because risk doesn't change when gender identity does.

Fairislefandango · 09/12/2022 12:27

Why would someone be using a pronoun to my face and if they’re using it outside my earshot why would I care?

It is perfectly common to use 3rd person pronouns about someone in their earshot.

Fairislefandango · 09/12/2022 12:25

It's becoming a grammatical nightmare. If someone has appropriated 'they' as their pro noun, then WTF do we now use as a plural? Would it be 'theys' 'thems' and 'thoses'???

It really isn't becoming a grammatical nightmare. It's always been perfectly normal to refer to a person using 'they' if gender isn't specified - e.g. in a school letter 'If a student wishes to audition for a part, they should x, y or z*. You don't need to pluralise 'they', because it is already mostly used as a plural so you'd still use 'they', not 'theys'!

It's either daft or disingenous to object to these things on grammatical grounds, and I say that as a language teacher. There is rarely ambiguity of meaning, because context makes things clear. We all seem to cope ok with having no distinction between plural and singular 'you' in English, after all!

There's plenty to object to about enforced stating of pronouns, but alleged grammatical confusion isn't one of them imo.

CecilyP · 09/12/2022 12:24

Why would someone be using a pronoun to my face and if they’re using it outside my earshot why would I care?

They might say it in a meeting, something like, 'well done, Cecily, she always comes up with brilliant ideas!' Though these days they might be worried that they've said the wrong thing!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 09/12/2022 12:24

TodayIsFridayHooray · 09/12/2022 12:08

I had an apprentice that took issue with me not putting my pronouns in my email signature. I thanked her for raising this concern with me. I explained I could see her perspective, thinks it's good she sees herself as a trans ally, and wants to demonstrate a welcoming attitude to trans people by showing this allyship through her pronouns. I explained my position, that I don't feel people should have to put their pronouns on their email signature as not everyone wants to tell the world their gender, some people may be questioning their gender and not feel ready to make a statement about it etc..

I thought we'd had a good discussion. I could see her perspective. I explained mine

2 weeks later she made a formal complaint against me for not being transgender aware or promoting equality.

Personally I couldn't care less if someone identify as male, female, blue, pink, an elephant or a table. As long as they are kind, do their job properly and respect others that's all I'm bothered about. If someone is confused or distressed about their identity, of course I care and will want to support. But making a complaint against your boss, even though they respect your view, just because they have a different opinion on pronoun use is, imo, wokery gone mad! (Thankfully the complaint went nowhere as my own boss is sensible)

This is the issue I've seen time and time again. You were sensitive and took her concerns seriously. But IME any form of conciliatory gesture is simply viewed as 'weakness'. (So glad her complaint went nowhere).

This is exactly where #BeKind has got women. It's in no small part of the reason that I no longer for one moment entertain it. I use few words, and am as terse and to the point as possible. The less you say the less they can twist. Three words: 'pronouns are optional' is all she'd have got out of me.

Even my employers, who are up to their nuts in allies and sport rainbow flags and lanyards everywhere, don't make pronouns mandatory, albeit it's strongly encouraged. I, on the other hand, am well aware how dangerous it can be to 'out' a trans person, am well-versed in protecting young trans people (some of whom are very vulnerable), and will pull out all the stops to offer them support. For my views about not announcing pronouns, or involuntary trauma responses as a twice rape-victim when in vulnerable situations with natal males, I'm brushed off as a 'transphobe'. Would they rather I continued to protect gender questioning people as above, or signaled my compliance with rainbows and pronouns?

There's so much navel-gazing bound up with this whole self-involved movement - part of a much broader picture of identity politics - it's beyond tiresome. In reality, your identity is of zero interest to anyone other than you. For my part, I couldn't give a bison's bum how anyone else perceives me.

As for 'guessing' pronouns, people have been doing this with mine for 40+ years with pretty much a 100% success rate. Other people's comfort and wellbeing does not come at the expense of my own. If I'm asked for mine again, rather than responding with a coy 'that's not a practice I follow', I might be tempted to say 'surprise me!'

PickyTea · 09/12/2022 12:24

peaceandove · 09/12/2022 12:22

Not the person per se. But what if you're referring to something as plural (within their hearing) and they think you are actually referring to them? Oh the confusion and chaos...........

Do you often seen issues at work when someone is describing someone else and random people think they’re being spoken about?

The same would apply if I was talking about Mary to John and said ‘she is being annoying’ do you think it’s likely that every woman in the area would think they were the ‘she’ being discussed?

no

because that’s not how life works. So no confusion

PickyTea · 09/12/2022 12:22

G5000 · 09/12/2022 12:12

Do most people not discuss this at work already?

Most people can also take a reasonable guess what pronouns OP would use. But no, she has to add them to all her emails. So why not also
Best regards, NewStart,
she/her, Hindu, single mother, vegan, pansexual, ADHD, postmenopausal, plus sized, believes in fairies etc etc

We aren’t talking about guessing though, someone could guess an Indian co worker was Hindu, but that’s just as silly as guessing someone’s gender identity, let alone also has the potential to be offensive.

Unlike religion though gender identity isn’t often discussed generally at work, so the example of ‘what will we have to share next, our religion’ isn’t accurate and shows a very odd way of thinking.

peaceandove · 09/12/2022 12:22

PickyTea · 09/12/2022 12:02

Unless they have a clone why would you ever refer to someone as a plural anything?

Not the person per se. But what if you're referring to something as plural (within their hearing) and they think you are actually referring to them? Oh the confusion and chaos...........

YetAnotherSpartacus · 09/12/2022 12:18

That would be a fun thread actually ...

she/her, atheist, cynic, postmenopausal (in case you can't tell), cat-lover, overthinker, curry-eater, likes a good tipple.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2022 12:16

LakieLady

Interesting question. It would appear so, based on my sample of one MTF trans person.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Owl_Fisher

TodayIsFridayHooray · 09/12/2022 12:15

G5000 · 09/12/2022 12:12

Do most people not discuss this at work already?

Most people can also take a reasonable guess what pronouns OP would use. But no, she has to add them to all her emails. So why not also
Best regards, NewStart,
she/her, Hindu, single mother, vegan, pansexual, ADHD, postmenopausal, plus sized, believes in fairies etc etc

😁😁

G5000 · 09/12/2022 12:12

Do most people not discuss this at work already?

Most people can also take a reasonable guess what pronouns OP would use. But no, she has to add them to all her emails. So why not also
Best regards, NewStart,
she/her, Hindu, single mother, vegan, pansexual, ADHD, postmenopausal, plus sized, believes in fairies etc etc

LakieLady · 09/12/2022 12:11

Another liguistic difficulty has occurred to me.

In Iceland, girl's take the name of their mother as part of their surname, eg LakieLadysdottir, and boys the father's name, with the suffix "son". Would an Icelandic transperson have to change their surname, too?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2022 12:11

So many of these people just want to get attention and cause trouble. It's a power trip.

TodayIsFridayHooray · 09/12/2022 12:08

I had an apprentice that took issue with me not putting my pronouns in my email signature. I thanked her for raising this concern with me. I explained I could see her perspective, thinks it's good she sees herself as a trans ally, and wants to demonstrate a welcoming attitude to trans people by showing this allyship through her pronouns. I explained my position, that I don't feel people should have to put their pronouns on their email signature as not everyone wants to tell the world their gender, some people may be questioning their gender and not feel ready to make a statement about it etc..

I thought we'd had a good discussion. I could see her perspective. I explained mine

2 weeks later she made a formal complaint against me for not being transgender aware or promoting equality.

Personally I couldn't care less if someone identify as male, female, blue, pink, an elephant or a table. As long as they are kind, do their job properly and respect others that's all I'm bothered about. If someone is confused or distressed about their identity, of course I care and will want to support. But making a complaint against your boss, even though they respect your view, just because they have a different opinion on pronoun use is, imo, wokery gone mad! (Thankfully the complaint went nowhere as my own boss is sensible)

Swipe left for the next trending thread