Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told I was 'phobic' for not using pronouns!

684 replies

NewStartIn50s · 08/12/2022 17:48

Asked for my preferred pronouns and I said ' I don't use them', pushed on what I use to refer to myself and I said I don't use on emails or when I introduce myself or at all. Apparently, if I use them I am showing inclusivity to others and being accepting. I'm not quite a dinosaur yet but why are these things forced on us. I don't have a beard (yet) and I think you can tell what I am/but does it really matter if you can't.

So AIBU

YANBU - don't have to use pronouns if you don't want to

YABU - you should state what your preferred pronouns are

OP posts:
LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 09/12/2022 21:39

‘Thankfully it is not most women who are this difficult’

There is much to be said in favour of ‘difficult’ women…

KarenOLantern · 09/12/2022 20:39

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/12/2022 11:06

Can I just mention - gender identity is NOT a protected characteristic.

Many people think it is.

Many would like it to be.

Many are determined to behave as though it is.

Many are determined to loudly proclaim that it is.

But it isn't.

SEX is, though.

Of course, good point!

Delphinium20 · 09/12/2022 20:35

I'm a difficult woman as a PP noted. When asked about pronouns, I say, "No thank you," and move on. I expect a witch burning one day.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 09/12/2022 18:52

samyeagar · 09/12/2022 18:03

Oh how regressive wanting to go back to a time where people were literally not allowed to exist. This is such a violent thread.

I'm genuinely not sure if you are being ironic or not, but either way I find this worth saying...

We are in a time when there is a concerted effort to say some people - the ones the word woman used to mean - are not allowed to exist.

We are told it's fine to be just defined as "cis" women but that is not at all the same thing:

  1. It is a statement that our bodies are irrelevant to the experience and social consequences of being a woman, what is important is a womanyness of the mind which all women, trans and cis, have in common.

  2. It excludes female-bodied people if they are non-binary or trans men, and therefore excludes their experiences and voices from the story of sexism and the understanding of its consequences.

Yet we do exist and we know our bodies have consequences even if it is only because a few thousand years of patriarchy shaping our laws and culture has made them matter.

The idea that denying trans people the right to appropriate a name and history that was not theirs, and rather ask that they use a new name that reflects their own, different journey, is somehow denying they exist is laughable. The reality that what they demand is exactly the undefining of the female-bodied, the group of humans who have been most consistently disempowered across human cultures, as a coherent social group is terrifying.

samyeagar · 09/12/2022 18:38

@babyjellyfish and p.s. yes I was being sarcastic. Very telling though isn't it? That by using the exact same words in the exact same way that there is functionally no difference between sarcasm and genuine belief.

samyeagar · 09/12/2022 18:35

babyjellyfish · 09/12/2022 18:15

Pretty sure @samyeagar was being sarcastic!

I have fond memories of an ex colleague who I barely knew. She came out to me in the best way. We were standing by the kettle making small talk and I asked her if she had anything nice planned for the weekend and she said, "Going out for a nice dinner with my partner, it's her birthday."

We'd been working together for about two years by that point.

Zero drama.

Hmmm....am I though?

I think this is all a perfect example of one of the most detrimental, yet rarely considered impacts of the internet and communication without any barriers such as audience size, time and distance.

Language has always changed and evolved throughout history, but what we have today is so unprecedented, I'm not sure if it should even count as language evolution. The internet allows for language and meaning to literally change over night for huge populations, where words can change meanings several time in just a matter of a few years. It was inevitable to activist players would take advantage of the confusion caused by rapidly changing language, especially when they use the tools to be the ones changing it.

Pinetreechristmas · 09/12/2022 18:34

BadSkiingMum · 09/12/2022 17:42

There's a petition open at the moment to update the Equality Act to clarify that sex means biological sex:

https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/623243

Thank you, didn't know about the petition, just signed.

user1496146479 · 09/12/2022 18:33

Shoxfordian · 08/12/2022 17:53

How hard would it be to just say she/her? 🙄

Biscuit
FOJN · 09/12/2022 18:20

It's hilarious because the people using pronouns hurt is those with gender dysphoria who are struggling with their identity, what an own goal.

Absolutely. Someone told the virtue signalling tossers that universal pronoun declarations were progressive and inclusive and a whole bunch of people who always like to think of themselves as being on the side of the angels responded like nodding dogs. It's quite depressing that people are so willing to embrace something which harms the group it purports to help because it's easy and they don't need to think.

peaceandove · 09/12/2022 18:17

Roughly 50K transwomen genuinely believe they are women. Fortunately, roughly 6 billion other people, don't.

CountZacular · 09/12/2022 18:17

samyeagar · 09/12/2022 18:03

Oh how regressive wanting to go back to a time where people were literally not allowed to exist. This is such a violent thread.

Also when did the meaning of the word ‘violent’ change to ‘words that I don’t like’.

babyjellyfish · 09/12/2022 18:15

Wiccan · 09/12/2022 18:08

Not violent at all ! What a stupid comment . I didn't say people couldn't exist. I don't wish to use pronouns . Not stopping any one else so crack on !

Pretty sure @samyeagar was being sarcastic!

I have fond memories of an ex colleague who I barely knew. She came out to me in the best way. We were standing by the kettle making small talk and I asked her if she had anything nice planned for the weekend and she said, "Going out for a nice dinner with my partner, it's her birthday."

We'd been working together for about two years by that point.

Zero drama.

Boomboom22 · 09/12/2022 18:14

It's hilarious because the people using pronouns hurt is those with gender dysphoria who are struggling with their identity, what an own goal.
It's also dangerous as saying you are female will affect work, many studies show this, so it continues the sexist treatment of women.

CountZacular · 09/12/2022 18:14

I’m so glad a TRA popped up on this thread. I think it’s a really helpful demonstration of the utmost intolerance and bigotry they have towards any view that doesn’t align to their own.

I can’t talk for anyone else, but I’ve never wished someone with different views be excluded from society yet it’s a common theme with TRAs. Facism at is finest.

What would be more compelling (if TRAs actually wanted to reason people to their side rather than scare and intimidate them) would be to explain a bit more about what gender is and what ‘being a woman’ means if not sex based so we could all properly understand and agree.

Instead we just get the usual insults (normally misogynist and ageist), the ‘it’s transphobic’ without explaining why and refusal to engage in counterpoints.

It’s a shame it’s that way, but helpful for those on the fence to see what’s actually happening.

Wiccan · 09/12/2022 18:08

samyeagar · 09/12/2022 18:03

Oh how regressive wanting to go back to a time where people were literally not allowed to exist. This is such a violent thread.

Not violent at all ! What a stupid comment . I didn't say people couldn't exist. I don't wish to use pronouns . Not stopping any one else so crack on !

samyeagar · 09/12/2022 18:05

ooops...quoted wrong comment. Should have been like this...

@babyjellyfish

Looool.
Of course, then Claire wouldn't be a lesbian, because Mrs would be in an opposite sex relationship...
Can we not go back to when pronouns were supposed to make language easier, rather than a way for people to announce their individual identities?
Wouldn't that be nice?
I don't want to assume anything about anyone's gender identity or their sexuality tbh. I don't want to think about either of those things because I'm not actually interested.

Oh how regressive wanting to go back to a time where people were literally not allowed to exist. This is such a violent thread.

samyeagar · 09/12/2022 18:03

Wiccan · 09/12/2022 18:01

I agree I'm simply not interested in people's pronouns or there sexuality and my own is my business Just want to get through my day and live my life and to not be forced to take part in others beliefs!

Oh how regressive wanting to go back to a time where people were literally not allowed to exist. This is such a violent thread.

Wiccan · 09/12/2022 18:01

I agree I'm simply not interested in people's pronouns or there sexuality and my own is my business Just want to get through my day and live my life and to not be forced to take part in others beliefs!

babyjellyfish · 09/12/2022 17:53

samyeagar · 09/12/2022 17:11

Yep... Unless Claire was married to a trans woman, in which case, you just misgendered the Mrs, so again...you with the literal violence.

Looool.

Of course, then Claire wouldn't be a lesbian, because Mrs would be in an opposite sex relationship...

Can we not go back to when pronouns were supposed to make language easier, rather than a way for people to announce their individual identities?

Wouldn't that be nice?

I don't want to assume anything about anyone's gender identity or their sexuality tbh. I don't want to think about either of those things because I'm not actually interested.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/12/2022 17:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wiccan · 09/12/2022 17:49

BadSkiingMum · 09/12/2022 17:42

There's a petition open at the moment to update the Equality Act to clarify that sex means biological sex:

https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/623243

Thanks 🙂 just signed and passed it on .

BadSkiingMum · 09/12/2022 17:42

There's a petition open at the moment to update the Equality Act to clarify that sex means biological sex:

https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/623243

Wiccan · 09/12/2022 17:24

FlirtsWithRhinos · 09/12/2022 17:01

Yes I agree . I think at some point employers are going to see pronoun use as a distraction in the work place leading to serious disputes

I hope not. I think it's misguided but generally it's coming from a place wanting to be less sexist and more accepting of different ways to be a man or a woman. It's just gone a bit wrong (got a bit hijacked) into thinking the best way to do that is to decide that Man and Woman are purely gender roles so progress is to and let people of any sex identify into them, instead of realising Man and Woman is just a type of body and that doesn't have to determine anything about your mind and personality, so we don't need gender roles at all.

I don't want to see people villified for doing what they thought was the right thing, and I don't want a backlash that means we just go back to gendered roles based on sex. I want to see the pronoun people grow up a bit more, recognise that sexist and predatory beliefs about the female body haven’t gone away just because we pretended we didn't know who had one, and end up somewhere that combines female only protection and support when it's needed with an openness to social roles, personalities and presentations that are currently gendered becoming just part of the general pallette of being human.

I hope in 10 years we look back and see this as a well meaning but naive step on a path that lead to a genuinely less sexist and more tolerant society.

Well I agree on some points , and I am aware of problems with sexism I've been a women a long time. I do not want the hassle of having complaints because I misgender people that could lead to disciplinary action and as I have said up thread if it ever happens I will fight it with utmost vigour !Sexism will never be dealt with as long as there are men that can identify as women !

daisychain01 · 09/12/2022 17:22

samyeagar · 09/12/2022 17:11

Yep... Unless Claire was married to a trans woman, in which case, you just misgendered the Mrs, so again...you with the literal violence.

All the Whatifery in this conversation reminds me why the whole thing has reached a whole new level of ridiculous and absurd

How can a human being with average comprehension ever be expected to understand this gobledigook.

MichaelFabricantWig · 09/12/2022 17:17

PickyTea · 09/12/2022 14:50

Of course it is, as it tends to align with other hateful views.

Just one look at this comment thread will show lots of use of the term ‘woke’ and other right wing aligned crap

No it really isn’t “hate filled” to issue a polite “no thanks” or explain why not to a request to use pronouns. Grow up and stop labelling everyone who doesn’t agree with you haters, bigots, transphobes or right wingers. You just sound petulant.