Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told I was 'phobic' for not using pronouns!

684 replies

NewStartIn50s · 08/12/2022 17:48

Asked for my preferred pronouns and I said ' I don't use them', pushed on what I use to refer to myself and I said I don't use on emails or when I introduce myself or at all. Apparently, if I use them I am showing inclusivity to others and being accepting. I'm not quite a dinosaur yet but why are these things forced on us. I don't have a beard (yet) and I think you can tell what I am/but does it really matter if you can't.

So AIBU

YANBU - don't have to use pronouns if you don't want to

YABU - you should state what your preferred pronouns are

OP posts:
Emotionalsupportviper · 08/12/2022 20:01

BlackForestCake · 08/12/2022 18:11

Oh, I am so glad you asked. I am she/her on Mondays. On Tuesdays I am mostly she/it unless I have a client meeting when I am ze/zir. On Wednesdays I am she/they in the morning and he/they in the afternoon. Thursdays and Fridays I am they/them most of the time. At the weekend I am usually she/her except on the fourth Sunday of the month when I am ze/zir again.

If you get any of this wrong I’ll report you to HR.

I would insist on them using the medium of interpretive dance, too.

Just to get the nuances . . .

TheMarzipanDildo · 08/12/2022 19:59

silverclock222 · 08/12/2022 19:45

WTF is a gender apostate?

I don’t believe in gender. I believe that gender ideology is a bit like a religion, in that it expects faith but provides very little in the way of concrete evidence to prove its claims.

Gender is the performance of stereotypes. I don’t think it has much of a place in the 21st century. I do believe in biology.

arethereanyleftatall · 08/12/2022 19:59

Shoxfordian · 08/12/2022 17:53

How hard would it be to just say she/her? 🙄

Because going along with all this shit is damaging to women. Notably vulnerable ones. And, if you're privileged enough or not in ti sports so that it doesn't affect you, have some empathy for those it does.

Dreamwhisper · 08/12/2022 19:57

Ytterbium · 08/12/2022 19:56

I wondered how long it would take before white people were blamed. 🤔

omg 🙄🙄🙄🙄

Ytterbium · 08/12/2022 19:56

MoirasSaggyBundles · 08/12/2022 19:50

Well here's the problem with the whole movement. White centric, Western centric luxury beliefs based on capitalist consumption values (the purchase of body parts/cosmetics/clothing, none of which is essential to survival) dressed up as a matter of life and death. Using others for legitimacy - the deaths of brown and black trans women in South America (poverty stricken sex workers), the experiences of black people (particularly black women) under segregation, and the very real struggles of the LGB community who have a SEXUALITY not an IDENTITY.

Add to this the changes of terminology and pronoun demands that do nothing other than catch out everyone not white and western and aware of social justice discourse, be that poor immigrant women with English as a second language who are trying to negotiate health care under the NHS and having to deal with terms like "mentruator" or autistic children being called bigots for correctly sexing someone who has an "identity" fantasy that they are demanding everyone else participate in.

Being your "authentic" female self isn't that attractive when you are living under the Taliban.

I wondered how long it would take before white people were blamed. 🤔

electricdreaming · 08/12/2022 19:56

I can’t believe there’s some people on here saying they never use pronouns. You’ve never referred to someone as she/her/he/him/they? Irregardless of the trans debate, surely pronouns are helpful. If someone sends me an email and i don’t recognise their name as male or female - i.e. a unisex name, or a name I’ve never heard before, including their pronouns is helpful. In my job role, I will have email conversations with external contacts and then deliver that message to the rest of my team. So instead of saying Alex the whole way through that conversation, it would be helpful to say she/he. Saying someone’s name rather than pronouns throughout a conversation is unnatural. If you’re face to face and obviously look like a man or a woman, it’s probably not necessary. One of my close friends growing up had very long hair and was very short and slim - they were a boy, but often got misgendered.

Notanotherusername4321 · 08/12/2022 19:55

I just don't get why there is such a war about it all. Why can't people accept that trans people are trans and that sex also matters

most people do.

it’s the idea that transwomen are women and we must absolutely accept that, and also alter our behaviour and speech so transwomen believe that we believe it. And not doing so is literal violence. That’s what is not accepted.

Starlitexpress · 08/12/2022 19:55

I am literally just watching an old episode of QI and they are talking about how women who are consciously reminded that they are women do less well at tasks as they have been so conditioned to feel inferior, they will do less well. Eg if there is a maths test and they are told they are in the women's group vs a men's group, they will do less well than if it was group A vs group B.

Scientific evidence not to play this game.

Just use your eyes and if someone wants to be called by different pronouns they can let me know and I will endeavour to use them correctly for them.

MarshaBradyo · 08/12/2022 19:55

MoirasSaggyBundles · 08/12/2022 19:54

I just don't get why there is such a war about it all. Why can't people accept that trans people are trans and that sex also matters. I really can't get my head around the amount of fall out this issue has caused in recent years.

The TRAs created the war. Rather than fight for and campaign for services and spaces the way women did, they just told women to fuck off out of our own spaces. And misogynists dressed up as liberals allowed them to do this.

Yep and also would like our words so they get woman and we don’t.

No chance.

Dreamwhisper · 08/12/2022 19:54

MoirasSaggyBundles · 08/12/2022 19:50

Well here's the problem with the whole movement. White centric, Western centric luxury beliefs based on capitalist consumption values (the purchase of body parts/cosmetics/clothing, none of which is essential to survival) dressed up as a matter of life and death. Using others for legitimacy - the deaths of brown and black trans women in South America (poverty stricken sex workers), the experiences of black people (particularly black women) under segregation, and the very real struggles of the LGB community who have a SEXUALITY not an IDENTITY.

Add to this the changes of terminology and pronoun demands that do nothing other than catch out everyone not white and western and aware of social justice discourse, be that poor immigrant women with English as a second language who are trying to negotiate health care under the NHS and having to deal with terms like "mentruator" or autistic children being called bigots for correctly sexing someone who has an "identity" fantasy that they are demanding everyone else participate in.

Being your "authentic" female self isn't that attractive when you are living under the Taliban.

I do take note of this.

While I think that there is more depth and transness is not just a privileged concept, I think this is an important point.

MoirasSaggyBundles · 08/12/2022 19:54

I just don't get why there is such a war about it all. Why can't people accept that trans people are trans and that sex also matters. I really can't get my head around the amount of fall out this issue has caused in recent years.

The TRAs created the war. Rather than fight for and campaign for services and spaces the way women did, they just told women to fuck off out of our own spaces. And misogynists dressed up as liberals allowed them to do this.

HatThatWearsYou · 08/12/2022 19:53

LizzieSiddal · 08/12/2022 18:06

My response would be-

Some people may not be sure of their pronouns and it may be triggering for them to have to “declare” them.
Then I’d ask how the department will be ensuring they do not victimise or trigger anyone who does not wish to declare pronouns.

And this too, brilliant response!

StaunchMomma · 08/12/2022 19:53

'Refer to me as whatever you like. I don't mind whatever you choose. I do, however, mind pressure being put on others to have to have remember what they should refer to me as and being fearful of saying the wrong thing.'

ZooMount · 08/12/2022 19:52

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 08/12/2022 18:41

Impossible.

As a woman, 'gender' has caused me nothing but trouble. Like most women I've faced a good deal of sex-based discrimination in my workplace. I've also been stalked and sexually-harassed in my workplace. Owing to a changed, 'inclusive' policy, my stalker could now follow me into female facilities and there would be nothing I could do to stop him.

Having fostered that environment of bullying and sexism, my workplace now have no right to demand that I draw attention to the (protected characteristic) that led to these situations in the first place. Hell will freeze over before I willingly - or unwillingly for that matter - gleefully announce the basis of my own oppression every time I enter a meeting or send an email.

They can fuck right off. I will never comply. This is the hill I'm willing to die on.

Sitting on that hill with you!

Emotionalsupportviper · 08/12/2022 19:51

CourtneeLuv · 08/12/2022 19:39

Add the pronouns.

But change your mind every day and send an all staff email each morning tellling everyone what that days pronouns are.

GENIUS!

😃😃😃

Dreamwhisper · 08/12/2022 19:51

FWIW, I'm left wing and gender critical. I don't think it's automatically a right wing idea. My point is I believe right wing conservative bigots use the reasonable line of "men can't become women" to lead into much more sinister messages about trans people.

I just don't get why there is such a war about it all. Why can't people accept that trans people are trans and that sex also matters. I really can't get my head around the amount of fall out this issue has caused in recent years.

TheMarzipanDildo · 08/12/2022 19:50

Dreamwhisper · 08/12/2022 19:09

NOBODY THINKS THAT!

The irony of this 😂

They bloody pretend to.

I would recommend never going on Twitter. Or YouTube. The “sex is a social construct” crowd are very much present (and nuts).

Mahanii · 08/12/2022 19:50

The only place I've ever been asked to declare my pronouns is at a women's sports club which is primarily LGBQ. In that context I don't mind it because I generally like and get on with women and if one of them is struggling with being called she then I don't mind supporting that person by calling them they.

At work...absolutely fucking not.

MoirasSaggyBundles · 08/12/2022 19:50

Well here's the problem with the whole movement. White centric, Western centric luxury beliefs based on capitalist consumption values (the purchase of body parts/cosmetics/clothing, none of which is essential to survival) dressed up as a matter of life and death. Using others for legitimacy - the deaths of brown and black trans women in South America (poverty stricken sex workers), the experiences of black people (particularly black women) under segregation, and the very real struggles of the LGB community who have a SEXUALITY not an IDENTITY.

Add to this the changes of terminology and pronoun demands that do nothing other than catch out everyone not white and western and aware of social justice discourse, be that poor immigrant women with English as a second language who are trying to negotiate health care under the NHS and having to deal with terms like "mentruator" or autistic children being called bigots for correctly sexing someone who has an "identity" fantasy that they are demanding everyone else participate in.

Being your "authentic" female self isn't that attractive when you are living under the Taliban.

HatThatWearsYou · 08/12/2022 19:50

JennyMule · 08/12/2022 17:51

My response when asked in previous (public sector) role - I no longer work there - was to ask what other legally protected characteristics the organisation would like me to declare in meetings/emails etc. Answer, there was none 😎

I love this, brava!

underneaththeash · 08/12/2022 19:49

Shoxfordian · 08/12/2022 17:53

How hard would it be to just say she/her? 🙄

because it's ridiculous. If someone decides to be awkward THEY can put their pronouns. Everyone is non-binary, it really is not an issue. Except I am physically a woman so a she.

OP - I've been asked twice and ignored both, they both asked again and the university one (I'm a clinical demonstrator) I said I was undecided.....and they ticked all options, so my emails are very long.

Emotionalsupportviper · 08/12/2022 19:48

Shoxfordian · 08/12/2022 17:53

How hard would it be to just say she/her? 🙄

How hard would it be just to let someone keep their pronouns to themselves?

howmanybicycles · 08/12/2022 19:47

Dreamwhisper · 08/12/2022 19:37

Not true, this makes no sense. If you don't believe in gender then you are stating your very normal and commonly used pronouns. We have different pronouns for males and females in the English language. How is it an automatic assumption that by saying pronouns which will be used in your professional setting, that you are declaring a belief over a gender identity vs biological sex? It's not. No one can definitively say that it is.

And please, "compelled speech and attempted religious conversion"? Can we tone down the hyperbole 🙄

And again, no one is forcing you to use your own pronouns. People may consider it transphobic, perhaps their reasoning might be accurate, but it's not like they can force you. You not liking the fact that people think your assertion to do so may be transphobic, is still not compelling you to speak.

It's clearly not hyperbole and it's nasty of you to say it is. I don't give a shiny shit which pronouns people use for me. Trying to make me state a preference is aggressive and unpleasant. People are trying to make it a disciplinary issue to not go along with this which clearly is trying to make people comply.

Dreamwhisper · 08/12/2022 19:47

BlackForestCake · 08/12/2022 19:41

It's actually quite a common tactic for bigoted views to be sold to the wider public. Find that common ground that people agree to, but then use it to push their own narrative further.

You mean that people can have differing opinions based on their own perspective of a shared perception of reality?

So left wing people and right wing people can agree that it’s cold in winter, that electricity prices are higher now than this time last year, or that men aren’t women, but still have different views and analyses?

So it’s not in fact the case that people are right wing just because they understand reality?

Absolutely, if you leave it at that. As already said, it's not inherently bigoted to be gender critical, why would it be? As you've said, sometimes with the way the world has moved it's important to be able to assert that in some circumstances.

If you use the pretty universally accepted fact that "men can't become women" to assert your views when called out, but what you've also been doing is denigrating and shaming trans people for existing though, that would be bigoted, no?

This does happen. It also doesn't just happen with the trans issue, like I said it's definitely a thing.

ZooMount · 08/12/2022 19:45

CottonSock · 08/12/2022 18:02

Hell will freeze over before I declare my pronouns on a work email signature. Yanbu.

Same

Swipe left for the next trending thread