Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Strep A in school

145 replies

EUwannabe · 08/12/2022 15:30

So- I’m not on either side of the fence on this at all but would love to know what others would do. AIBU to keep my primary child off school now a Step A case has been confirmed in the school? X

OP posts:
nothingleftttt · 08/12/2022 19:39

It's a worry.

Sadbeigechildren · 08/12/2022 19:35

Favouritefruits · 08/12/2022 19:23

Send your child to school for goodness sake, Step A is in most schools during winter but it’s had more publicity this year with children sadly dying.

This makes literally no sense. The media is publicizing higher death rates because they are taking place.

If there's an antibiotic shortage that makes a difference too. Scarlet fever is no joke, never mind sepsis.

Sadbeigechildren · 08/12/2022 19:33

It's sad and ridiculous that we don't quarantine for scarlet fever anymore. It's not as if our health service can cope and the best way for children to grow up is to avoid, within reason, getting these illnesses. There is no benefit to them whatsoever. It's a dangerous myth that it's good for children to get these diseases. Their immune systems do not need that kind of exposure to be fully functioning.

It's a personal risk decision based on your attitude to risk.

I don't understand the 2-3 children will die in your school argument at all though as the number would be much smaller if you're thinking about one school!

Favouritefruits · 08/12/2022 19:23

Send your child to school for goodness sake, Step A is in most schools during winter but it’s had more publicity this year with children sadly dying.

RagzRebooted · 08/12/2022 19:23

ILoveeCakes · 08/12/2022 19:17

Are you saying that Strep A is passed (even from people who have the harmful "form") and, only in some people, it becomes the harmful "form"? ie it's all about the person not the bacteria? It's about how that person deals with/responds to the bacteria.

Not challenging btw - I'm genuinely asking - and as the setup premise to my question, which is:

If that's the case (ie the same thing is being passed as in every other year) why are more people becoming seriously ill or dying than in other years?

If the bacteria being passed hasn't changed, then what has?

Anyone who is informed on this, please explain if you can.

Yes that's right. A bit like people with HIV can get AIDS but they don't pass on AIDS, they pass on HIV.

IGAS is what happens if the bacteria get into the blood stream, rather than just hang around on the tonsils/skin (impetigo can be strep as well) whatever. More fatalities this year because more cases and also less exposure in previous years due to covid measures makes children have a lower immunity (their bodies' haven't got the antibodies, or as many of them as they haven't been exposed to it for a few years).

ILoveeCakes · 08/12/2022 19:17

saraclara · 08/12/2022 17:54

No. Your school has a case if Strep A. Not of iGAS.

Uncomplicated Strep A itself isn't the problem. It's the allied invasive type that is. You cannot avoid strep A. It's always around and is mostly mild. It's only those tiny few cases that turn into iGAS.

I haven't checked yet, but I don't think iGAS transmits iGAS itself to contacts. It's more that on these very few occasions, strep A becomes iGAS in those very few people for some reason.

This is from memory though, so in very happy to be corrected by someone with professional knowledge

Are you saying that Strep A is passed (even from people who have the harmful "form") and, only in some people, it becomes the harmful "form"? ie it's all about the person not the bacteria? It's about how that person deals with/responds to the bacteria.

Not challenging btw - I'm genuinely asking - and as the setup premise to my question, which is:

If that's the case (ie the same thing is being passed as in every other year) why are more people becoming seriously ill or dying than in other years?

If the bacteria being passed hasn't changed, then what has?

Anyone who is informed on this, please explain if you can.

CaveMum · 08/12/2022 19:10

As has been said, iGAS cannot be passed on - it is an individual reaction to a Strep A infection.

All of the fatalities are utter tragedy’s but as far as I’m aware they are all isolated cases in their areas.

Tulipvase · 08/12/2022 18:59

Our reception classes had approx 8/10 cases of scarlet fever last year. Once the first couple of cases were finally diagnosed, they were all given AB’s (have to have for at least 24 hours before returning to school) the children were all fine. The previous year also had a spate of cases too.

I certainly wouldn’t worry yet.

Crazykatie · 08/12/2022 18:52

In 30 yrs nursing I never saw Scarlet Fever so I had to look it up, for children it’s more of a threat than Covid so you do need look out for the specific symptoms.
There is a good description on Wikipedia and no doubt other sites, the symptoms are quite distinctive.

Smearywindowsagain · 08/12/2022 18:51

@Bluekerfuffle that article still seems to be saying that penicillin works. It’s other types of antibiotics that don’t. I could be reading it wrong though.

Bluekerfuffle · 08/12/2022 18:43

There is a telegraph article about a newly discovered undetected superbug of strep A which is immune to some antibiotics. I can’t read the full article as you have to pay or start a free trial. Haven’t seen it reported elsewhere but if this the case, that’s really worrying.

WimbyAce · 08/12/2022 18:02

What would you have done before though when scarlet fever was in school? We have 4 cases at our primary.

saraclara · 08/12/2022 17:56

alasangne · 08/12/2022 17:05

Oh you're right. Worried again now

Don't be. As per my post above, those children will have normal Strep A. Which we know to normally be very mild.

twocatsandtwokids · 08/12/2022 17:56

But if you keep them off now, will you every time the school let you know of a confirmed case? That could happen again multiple times over the next few months, and how long would you keep them off for each time? What about the cases floating around which aren’t officially identified?

saraclara · 08/12/2022 17:54

ILoveeCakes · 08/12/2022 16:31

In this case, those 2-3 people are not in a crowd of 100,000 - they are in the same school as your child. This changes the odds significantly. See my other post.

No. Your school has a case if Strep A. Not of iGAS.

Uncomplicated Strep A itself isn't the problem. It's the allied invasive type that is. You cannot avoid strep A. It's always around and is mostly mild. It's only those tiny few cases that turn into iGAS.

I haven't checked yet, but I don't think iGAS transmits iGAS itself to contacts. It's more that on these very few occasions, strep A becomes iGAS in those very few people for some reason.

This is from memory though, so in very happy to be corrected by someone with professional knowledge

Dittosaw · 08/12/2022 17:37

I was at the GP’s today GP said he had had about 30 kids in with sore throats that day…better safe than sorry

Blocked · 08/12/2022 17:36

There's a case in my 5 year olds class. I'm not keeping him off but I'm keeping a close eye for symptoms and will blatter the doctors door down for antibiotics if I see anything starting on his throat if I need to.

Ansumpasty · 08/12/2022 17:32

I understand the worry, though. I’m struggling a lot and my anxiety is through the roof about it, so I do understand

ILoveeCakes · 08/12/2022 17:06

Ansumpasty · 08/12/2022 17:04

Is this 2-3 people with invasive strep in the class or 2-3 with strep?

I’m worried sick, but remember that if it’s 2-3 with strep then it’s not the same as hospitalised with invasive strep. 1/4 all children have strep in their throats all the time. My little boy had tonsillitis every month for a long time. It was bacterial, so strep. He never passed it on to anyone else except my toddler (who got a mild case of scarlet fever, although this could have been from nursery).

There will be children with strep continually in your child’s school.

If it’s invasive strep then yes, I’d 100% be keeping them home

I don't know the medical answers to your questions. I was just making a point about statistics and averages.

alasangne · 08/12/2022 17:05

ILoveeCakes · 08/12/2022 16:31

In this case, those 2-3 people are not in a crowd of 100,000 - they are in the same school as your child. This changes the odds significantly. See my other post.

Oh you're right. Worried again now

Ansumpasty · 08/12/2022 17:04

ILoveeCakes · 08/12/2022 16:31

In this case, those 2-3 people are not in a crowd of 100,000 - they are in the same school as your child. This changes the odds significantly. See my other post.

Is this 2-3 people with invasive strep in the class or 2-3 with strep?

I’m worried sick, but remember that if it’s 2-3 with strep then it’s not the same as hospitalised with invasive strep. 1/4 all children have strep in their throats all the time. My little boy had tonsillitis every month for a long time. It was bacterial, so strep. He never passed it on to anyone else except my toddler (who got a mild case of scarlet fever, although this could have been from nursery).

There will be children with strep continually in your child’s school.

If it’s invasive strep then yes, I’d 100% be keeping them home

Smearywindowsagain · 08/12/2022 17:03

i probably wouldn’t send but I am very anxious. I think this is going to keep happening with the media the way it is.

Teder · 08/12/2022 16:45

ofwarren · 08/12/2022 16:31

Do you think I don't know?
He gets vaccinated for flu and a week off school if anyone is diagnosed and has 2 weeks off school if noro is around.
Yes, there is strep. The whole school is coughing and ill. It's an utter germ pit right now.
He's off with a chest infection for something else and will be off till the cases in the school settle.
He's on high dose steroids so even more immunosuppressed than normal.

I was curious, that’s all. I’ve had an immunodeficiency since childhood.
Personally, I’ve not come across anyone isolating with outbreaks of noro or similar. I wonder if it’s new since covid…? I’m not saying it’s a bad thing, just being nosy. I wouldn’t go to a play date (as a child!) if someone had noro but I’d attend school.

cherriegarcia · 08/12/2022 16:34

(Wouldn't send them in, I mean!)

cherriegarcia · 08/12/2022 16:33

ILoveeCakes · 08/12/2022 16:31

In this case, those 2-3 people are not in a crowd of 100,000 - they are in the same school as your child. This changes the odds significantly. See my other post.

Good point and I think we are even more in agreement in that case!

I wouldn't.

Swipe left for the next trending thread