Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask Public or Private Sector - which to choose?

40 replies

needabreak5 · 08/12/2022 08:53

DH and I have always worked in the Private Sector (for a number of organisations).

Generally the roles we have had have been long hours, limited holiday, unpaid overtime, minimum pension, risk or redundancy, being available out of hours. But individual pay increases based on performance, good ‘perks’ - gifts, parties, for example my organisation this year is giving everyone £1500 Xmas bonus, plus a hamper and a party. DH not as generous but does still get nice things ‘on the company’.

DH has applied and been offered a public sector role in the same industry he is in at the moment. his industry is quite volatile and he feels the civil service role may be more secure in a recession. It’s less pay, better pension, more holiday - we have 2 young DC and I’m thinking this might suit us better.

If you have worked a similar role in both private and public sectors which do you prefer. Do you think job security is the main advantage of public sector?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Asdf12345 · 08/12/2022 21:43

The gap in remuneration is quite sector dependent. I have a few colleagues who left public sector jobs to triple their overall package in the private sector but from niche areas, others who have gone the other way in much more common roles and overall reckon they are a good bit better off in the public sector.

In short I suspect it’s quite case dependent.

GetOffTheRoof · 08/12/2022 21:37

@MyTreeIsFake Not one person has brought out the "gold plated pension" trope until now. I simply stated, and accurately, that its a damn good pension. Not many employers will be paying in anything like that % for a pension scheme. How it's paid back out matters of course, but nevertheless my pension is worth about £9k a year more than I receive as a salary, so it's a decent part of the job when you are paid less and don't get any monetary perks that you might in the private sector like health insurance, gyms etc.

MyTreeIsFake · 08/12/2022 15:38

GetOffTheRoof · 08/12/2022 12:41

@ComtesseDeSpair my employer's contribution to my pension is paid at 27.1%. I pay in 5.45%.

That's a damn good pension by any standards, even if its now career average rather than final salary.

The 27.1% doesn't represent a gold plated pension pot at all.

It is based on the employer's liabilities under the scheme - so paying for the aged gold plated pensions that the CS used to provide as well as the defined benefit scheme that they now provide. % usually re-stated triennially based on the scheme valuation and forecast at that time.

needabreak5 · 08/12/2022 14:25

Thanks for all the replies, sorry I'm not able to mention the department/agency.

I do think it will give us more flexibility which would be a huge advantage and an easier life, its a struggle at the moment with us both working full time in demanding roles. And the job security.

Our concerns are more based on job satisfaction etc too, e.g. comments from a few posters and we do get this impression talking to people across the board IRL who are civil servants / public sector:

"Personally I've found that much more is expected of you in the private sector, longer hours etc. However I HATED working in the public sector. I found it very disorganised and nowhere near as "driven" as the private sector!"

"I did one brief stint in the public sector and found the culture completely alien and incredibly depressing. Any excuse to get out of work by doing fringe HR type shit was seized and made the most of, but they were still all joyless fuckers. Nobody cared whether or not a job was done well, or even at all. I’d never do it again, and I know others who say the same."

OP posts:
AdelineLou · 08/12/2022 14:08

Depends on the sector.

My public sector role...
Third ‘restructure’ ( redundancy process) in 5 years.
Poor redundancy package (5 years ago, £12,500 for capped 20 years service some part-time but my service was 26 years)

Stretched - each time central government bring in an initiative the existing staff have this added to their existing full time role so we end up with ‘existing fulltime role 2 days per week, new ‘initiative’ role 3 days per week.
Key team's have gone, key gaps in services, poor performance and many complaints. .
No administrative support.
No set office base - a hot desk as offices have had to be closed down permanently and additionally temporarily due to energy costs.
Low travel expenses, no rise to reflect fuel increases, travel only paid from the allocated office meaning paying much of the work miles ourselves.
No financial support to work at home.
Stretched line management, meaning poor communication, lack of advice, support, CPD and performance management.
Hierarchy means slow decision making.
Team days without even a hot drink.

Demoralised and exhausted staff.

🙁

LoobyDop · 08/12/2022 13:59

I did one brief stint in the public sector and found the culture completely alien and incredibly depressing. Any excuse to get out of work by doing fringe HR type shit was seized and made the most of, but they were still all joyless fuckers. Nobody cared whether or not a job was done well, or even at all. I’d never do it again, and I know others who say the same.

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/12/2022 13:58

MiddleParking · 08/12/2022 13:53

Plus public sector workplace cultures are utterly toxic

That’s also just a subjective generalisation. The workplace culture in the bit of the CS I work in is really wonderful.

I did think I’d written that some are, apologies. The bullying in my department was off the scale, backed up by the annual survey. I didn’t experience it particularly badly, but it was uncomfortable to witness colleagues whispering about other colleagues behind their backs and colleagues being shut out of projects when they weren’t in favour with their lead. I’m sure some departments are much better, but I can’t recommend mine.

MiddleParking · 08/12/2022 13:53

Plus public sector workplace cultures are utterly toxic

That’s also just a subjective generalisation. The workplace culture in the bit of the CS I work in is really wonderful.

MiddleParking · 08/12/2022 13:48

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/12/2022 12:46

Or if it should have been, I need to call their pension administrator! I just got a statement showing my balance at around £10k, which is in no way 30% of my salary over two years!

Are you sure you understand how defined benefit pensions work? It’s very unlikely you’d have been on a different scheme to the one pp mentioned but equally you probably wouldn’t have anything you’d describe as a ‘balance’. The employer/employee contributions are more or less irrelevant to a DB pension, they can’t meaningfully be compared in that way to the pension arrangements it sounds like you now have.

GetOffTheRoof · 08/12/2022 13:46

Have another look at your pension statement @ComtesseDeSpair - I've just checked mine and it's deliberately opaque. In 2021-2022 it's added £942/year to the max annual pension I'll be paid on retirement. I've used 11% of my max allowance (the one that's about £1million) apparently. It doesn't state what has been paid in for this period, I'll have to get that from my P60.

restisall · 08/12/2022 13:21

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/12/2022 12:46

Or if it should have been, I need to call their pension administrator! I just got a statement showing my balance at around £10k, which is in no way 30% of my salary over two years!

10k per year once you retire presumably?

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/12/2022 12:46

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/12/2022 12:43

Fair enough. My Civil Service pension in 2020 wasn’t anything like as generous as that, so I’d assumed they were more level with many private pensions.

Or if it should have been, I need to call their pension administrator! I just got a statement showing my balance at around £10k, which is in no way 30% of my salary over two years!

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/12/2022 12:43

GetOffTheRoof · 08/12/2022 12:41

@ComtesseDeSpair my employer's contribution to my pension is paid at 27.1%. I pay in 5.45%.

That's a damn good pension by any standards, even if its now career average rather than final salary.

Fair enough. My Civil Service pension in 2020 wasn’t anything like as generous as that, so I’d assumed they were more level with many private pensions.

PeppermintChoc · 08/12/2022 12:43

I trained in the private sector, currently public sector and returning to private sector.

Its a lack of finances an a fixed term that’s forcing my return. I’d have preferred to stay in the public sector whilst my children are young because the flexibility I have cannot be matched privately. Even though the private firm I’m joining could not be more accommodating. Not having targets etc means my job really isn’t stressful and as long as I’m getting on and I’m left to my own devices.

That does have draw backs, no progression, no personal development. But that might be unique to my team because my boss just doesn’t seem engaged with her team at all. My salary is well below market rate but because I use less childcare it doesn’t bother me. Although once the kids are both hatched Im sure I’ll feel differently. My organisation will start redundancies soon so I wouldn’t be so sure it’s more secure. The work is still there but because we’re reliant on funding they can’t sustain the staff/service levels.

GetOffTheRoof · 08/12/2022 12:41

@ComtesseDeSpair my employer's contribution to my pension is paid at 27.1%. I pay in 5.45%.

That's a damn good pension by any standards, even if its now career average rather than final salary.

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/12/2022 12:35

mummymeister · 08/12/2022 12:29

For the past couple of years, I have thanked God every day that I chose to stay and work in Local govt . I did 20 years before running my own business and have now retired early with a wonderful LG pension that I can happily live on for the rest of my days. I got more holidays, more training on the job, more flexibility, more opportunities and now a lovely pension

Do people joining now have the same pension eligibility, though? Public sector and CS pension schemes are a lot less generous for new entrants today than they were twenty or thirty years ago, so OP’s OH basing a decision on a “wonderful” pension is more than likely incorrect.

mummymeister · 08/12/2022 12:29

For the past couple of years, I have thanked God every day that I chose to stay and work in Local govt . I did 20 years before running my own business and have now retired early with a wonderful LG pension that I can happily live on for the rest of my days. I got more holidays, more training on the job, more flexibility, more opportunities and now a lovely pension

MyTreeIsFake · 08/12/2022 12:26

I went from senior private sector to senior public sector about six years ago and am seriously considering returning to the private sector.

There's no money in the public sector to recruit, so when the workload increases the expectation is that the staff step up. I work ridiculous hours, no bonus, not much of a pay rise and no budget to recruit. Public sector has huge staff retention issues at the minute due to this.

Depends where the job is I suppose as not everywhere is the same.

The pension isn't what it was a decade ago either, in fact my public sector pension isn't as beneficial as the one I left behind.

I left for a work/life balance and was prepared to take the hit on salary etc., for that but it isn't at all what I expected.

Greyskyblue · 08/12/2022 12:18

I left the private sector for the public sector 20 years ago and wish I had done it sooner. Yes there is job security though but it depends where you work as my dept pulled out of some locations altogether. Unless you mess up badly by breaching security etc, you can normally expect a job for life.

I am a civil servant and remember on joining I expected to be surrounded by jobsworths, but was impressed by the commitment and skills of colleagues even in badly paid junior clerical roles.

The pension is not as good as it used to be and the pay is not great, but annual leave and flexi plus the option for special leave in some circumstances is invaluable. I couldn’t have managed 2 small children and working full time otherwise.

I progressed through the grades from AO to grade 7 and I doubt I would’ve had that opportunity in the private sector.

I have had one experience with a bullying manager but on the whole I have had kind, supportive and committed colleagues and managers.

JustCakeInDrag · 08/12/2022 12:15

Can you give us an idea of the sector, OP?

PinkPrettyAndPointed · 08/12/2022 12:05

I found public sector so boring. So many rules and bloody policies 😖

I went back to private and was amazed in a 30 minute meeting with my director, we nutted out a fairly decent policy for a whole (new region). The director had authority to approve and so she did and said at the end of the meeting, that's how you get stuff done here, and it's great!

But my experience of private (10+ years all up) is in tech which is different from financial services etc.

We have above statutory annual leave benefit which helps too 🙂

Dacadactyl · 08/12/2022 12:00

Much better quality of life in public sector. Your husband would be MAD to turn down the job imo.

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/12/2022 11:57

It really depends on the organisation. Small private companies, public sector would probably always win out in overall packages. Once you get into larger companies there can be a lot of good benefits. I’m now private sector and have a pension my employer contributes 19% of salary towards with me not obligated to contribute anything at all if I didn’t want to, which is pretty good and not uncommon in my industry. Leave can often be only a couple of days lower - my current entitlement is only four days less than when I worked for the Civil Service. I’m happy to swap that for higher salary, a 20% annual bonus, average annual 8% pay rise, private healthcare, lavish social events paid for by the company and so on. Plus public sector workplace cultures are utterly toxic - my reason for leaving the Civil Service after 18 months, and few of my friends who work in the NHS have anything good to say about the culture. That’s a huge one, you can’t put a price on happiness at work.

Lurpackintheback · 08/12/2022 11:39

In your particular situation I’d go public

For me personally, always private, but then again I’ve never had to work long hours, be overly stressed and am paid very well with a 20% non contributory pension - a good private organisation will always win against public imo, but if you’re not able to get those roles then that’s decision made surely

NotMyDayJob · 08/12/2022 11:12

Just remember not all the public sector is equal. People on Mumsnet are always assuming public sector means civil service and working in local government for eg is a different experience. I work in a local government aligned agency that is very specifically not civil service. If I want to apply for a CS job I'm on the outside applying with everyone else.

I've worked in both, on balance public sector is better for family life, but that's also because I've been here 10 years and am on a union. I never worked as hard as I ever did during the pandemic (I'm not in healthcare either) though, I had no work life balance at all then.