Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to cancel Christmas at MIL to keep toddler routine

435 replies

HallieM93 · 07/12/2022 23:43

I’m stressed about Christmas Day.

My 20 month old little boy stayed with my parents on Saturday for the night and was an absolute nightmare, he has learned to climb out his travel cot as he’s very tall for his age and only slept for 3 hours. He’s always struggled with new environments and routine changes, and never has been a good sleeper (we’re currently waiting for an autism assessment due to a number of factors with his development)

I felt so guilty on Sunday knowing he kept my mum up all night and that he couldn’t sleep, he was so tired when we picked him up he went to sleep at 9AM and slept until 12:30PM. I went back to work when he was very young at 5 months due to a fantastic opportunity but made the decision to return to being a SAHM in September due to the ongoing autism speculation and just wanting to spend more time with him. I made the decision on Sunday that I don’t want to change his routine or stay out overnight anymore because of this.

our plans were to go to the in-laws on Christmas Day and stay overnight but due to him being able to climb out the travel cot and far too young and excitable to sleep in the bed, I want to change our plans to just an afternoon visit (maybe for dinner?) between his afternoon nap and bedtime so as not to cause any more disruptions to his routine.

Aibu? I feel like my in-laws will be disappointed and my partner will likely sulk, but my main excitement for Christmas is to see my little boy happy and excited and I just think that overtiredness and overstimulation could ruin that for him. Also on a selfish level it would be me that would have to battle with him for hours to nap and sleep at bedtime whilst everyone else drinks!

OP posts:
FraserFox · 15/12/2022 15:11

I'm kind of shocked by all of the comments here of people saying you are being unreasonable. You're suggesting a very reasonable compromise that would enable everyone to enjoy the day. The 1.5 year timeframe is one of the hardest in parenting and it's absolutely reasonable to do what you need to do to take care of your child. It's only 40 minutes away! You could even go back the next morning!

Children are also humans and their needs matter, too. I don't think it's acceptable to drag young children around, making them forgo naps, etc., so that parents can be selfish and do whatever they want. When we have children, we're making a commitment to put their needs first, when they're too little to do so for themselves. I feel that your letter was very thoughtful and it sounds like you're going through a very challenging time. Everyone who is dismissing your concerns has either never had a child that age, never had a neuro-atypical one, or thinks that women should set aside their own needs and those of their children in order to make everyone else in the family happy. You're not being a diva. You're not being selfish. You're being caring. Your concerns are very valid. And your proposed solution is very good.

My heart nearly broke when you wrote how the thing you value most around Christmas is seeing the excitement and joy of your little boy getting to experience it. Of course it is! And you should get to prioritize that for yourself, for him, and for your family. And your husband and in-laws should be supportive of that, as well! As parents, we spend so much time trying to make the holiday special for our kids. You do not have to put your own needs and those of your child second to everyone else's. When a child that age can't sleep, they are miserable and the parents are miserable. Your husband and in-laws should be helping support you. You're part of the family! Your son is part of the family!

Making small adjustments to the routine to support the smallest among us is the right thing to do, it's the Christmas spirit thing to do. I hope your husband's family steps up to make you feel like you don't have to choose between yourself/your child and them.

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 15/12/2022 13:21

I think if you tell your in-laws about the experience your Mum has just had, that they will be relieved that you are changing your plans. No one wants unbroken sleep!

Jaenelle · 15/12/2022 11:32

YANBU

I drive to and from my mums house every year and they stay an hour away, we also do year about but I’m firm on the sleeping in our own bed routine because my DD won’t sleep solo in someone else’s house. And it doesn’t matter the age, overtired is overtired and a bitch to deal with for a neurotypical child let alone a neurodivergent child, and I hate having to readjust the next few days after to get the sleep routine back in check.

And for those saying they need to form
coping skills he’s bloody 20 months old, no child should be forming coping skills solo at that age! I’d understand if the child was older but a toddler shouldn’t be made to adjust to suit adults whims for one day a year, when home is less than an hour away.

Do what’s best for you and your son, OP, if that’s spending the day and heading home then do that. This is your Christmas too and you shouldn’t be the one to suffer to suit everyone else’s whims.

sux2bu0806 · 15/12/2022 10:22

You are not unreasonable, although some information could be useful like how far is your in-laws from your house? If it's close enough for you and the child to go home for bed then leave your partner there for the night and go back in the morning, you could always try melatonin for the boy it's natural and safe for autistic children and they make a gummy of it or liquid so you can put it in his drink if he's difficult about those things. You can get it and start at 1mg at home to see if it helps at night, just Google melatonin for autistic children and read on it. I hope this helps. Take care of YOUR child to best of your abilities and screw everyone else HE COMES FIRST.....

blondie7317823 · 15/12/2022 09:08

Ugh! I meant to write neurodivergent, not neurotypical!

blondie7317823 · 15/12/2022 09:04

Going to be sexist here, but traditionally, mothers take on MOST of the childcare responsibilities, regardless of the situation. There was a great article written by a female primary caregiver that explained why she hated going out to restaurants because she was the only one with kids, so the whole time out, she was hustling and bustling left and right while everyone, including her partner, relaxed and enjoyed their meal.

So, let's be honest, all of it is going to fall on you, and it is well within your right to do what's best for you and him. It's not up to you to make everyone happy.

As a teacher and former Special Ed aide, I've worked with dozens of neurotypical kids (and am one myself, although not an autism diagnosis), so I very much get everything you are feeling.

Unfortunately, many, many, many people, both in your family and this thread are not going to come with the unique challenges of caring for a neurotypical child. It isn't just "let them stay out and have fun. They'll crash later."

It just doesn't work that way for every child and the fall out can last DAYS!

You have every right to go and enjoy the day, too. You shouldn't have to sacrifice your happiness and throw your son's body into a tale spin just to make everyone else happy and comfortable.

You do you, mama! And don't let anyone make you feel anything negative for doing what is best for you and your little!

Jimzle · 15/12/2022 08:58

YABU

I'm autistic and u can firmly tell you denying him difficult experiences makes it easier on you but denies him the opportunity yo develop coping skills which he will need. Denying autistic people experiences because things can be harder with/for us is most definitely not about helping the autistic person.

If you're worried it's going yo be all on you THAT is your real problem. You need support when he's struggling, not yo avoid the struggles.

GR4H4M · 15/12/2022 06:33

Absolutely not unreasonable. These commenters are nutters. The kid is 20 months old and might be autistic. Let him have his routines.
These comments are indicative of what's wrong with Brits.

SpoonMOM · 14/12/2022 22:17

I get the feeling that a lot of people saying that you're being unreasonable don't understand just HOW important it is for some kids to 1. have a schedule that they adhere to and 2. not be overwhelmed. You're doing what's best for your kid to go and visit during the day. Getting some kids back on their schedules takes a VERY long time, and everyone suffers. Except for your in laws.

Your kid won't remember the day, and if he could, he'd remember it as stressful and upsetting. Don't let this be the foundation for all other Christmases.

Femke01 · 14/12/2022 19:26

YANBU!
My son is 3 and I still feel bad thinking about our first christmasses together. I remember last year: day one: my parents, day 2 MIL and her family, day 3 FIL and his family. Day 2 and 3 were spend almost entirely with me being in a seperate room trying to comfort our overstimulated son, while the rest was enjoying themselves and sometimes popping in to ask why we didn't join in (because the boy started crying every time we came in to the crowded room obviously?!)
I was very strict on his naptimes and evening routine after that, because he needed it. After a weekend of less sleep and overstimulation, he was was very difficult and unhappy the next days. If there was 1 night with changes in his evening routine, almost the whole next week was ffed up. I was strict for a reason, and it was his wellbeing and my sanity. I had ppa and during holiday season it was the worst, because the days were filled with family not respecting my boundaries.
NTA, you are a good mother!
AND if this arrangement is not entirely needed for your child, but also for your mental health, that is completly valid too!

If your husband agrees to share the duties fair, you could try for the afternoon+evening and maybe night. BUT go home is you feel its needed and tell them this in advance. Better: have your husband tell them in advance

good luck and happy holidays
happy mommy = happy baby

calliemarch · 14/12/2022 16:29

I'm having trouble understanding why it matters so much to the extended family where the child sleeps (or doesn't.) Lots of toddlers, including neurotypical, don't sleep well away from home. Loads of adults don't sleep well away from home, too. Plus all the trouble of packing and toting everything you need to sleep away. Why would anyone want to insist on having a cranky, crying, miserable child, and his equally miserable mum, in the house while everyone is sleeping- when they could have a happier, well rested child and mum most of the day instead?

YANBU
40 minutes is close. My daily commute to work is longer than that, in either direction.
Many parents I know get up very early in the morning, load the kids in the car (sometimes still in their pajamas) and are at the grandparents home by the time the household is just waking up. It's difficult, and may have some cranky kids or tantrums- but so much easier than trying to sleep over and all that entails.

OP, could your mother speak with your MIL, to explain how miserable your child was at her home? Coming from another person may help.

When he's older, and has an understanding of what's happening, will be soon enough to find ways to help him adapt.

Moonglow789 · 13/12/2022 22:33

Not Unreasonable at all, it is only one day, the family can deal with you not being there first thing in the morning. It is a small price to pay for a peaceful afternoon for everyone involved.

Pamelaonthefarm · 13/12/2022 20:41

YANBU - many years ago, I told my hubby that I was taking over Christmas. It's one holiday a year. Only one. None of my kids were diagnosed with any special needs, I just got tired of saying "look what Santa brought you, but you can't touch it because if we don't visit your grandparents, their heads will explode". (not literally, but they got the idea)

My husband literally told me I was killing his mom and that dinner had to be at 1 or they would all starve. They never ate a big noon meal, so I don't see what the problem was. We ate at 3.

So, with some very loud discussion, I took over Christmas for the 15 years or so until I had grandkids. Then I told my kids to take it over. Why? I just never felt like it was the younger generations responsibility to run to Grandmas. If anything, they should show up at your place. My son invites me to his home. My daughter comes to my home. It's their choice. The older son shows up sometime between Christmas and New Years.

Now, my husband's parents lived two houses away and my mum lived 15 minutes away. Traveling could be a big factor in all your plans. But IMO, no child should be asked to leave their home during a time that is already stressful. Let them stay in a place they are comfortable and enjoy their day. And grandma and grandpa should suck it up. I know they want to see those early morning faces, so go to the kids' home. It's much easier for one or two people to travel than a family.

amysquie · 13/12/2022 18:10

This is really a question of who deserves to have a nice Christmas. You AND your family or just your in laws and husband the expense of yourself. Do what is best for you, and I highly recommend reading Michelle Elman's book on boundaries. If, as you predict, no-one is going to help with your son, you deserve a nice Christmas too. Why people still expect women to be martyrs in 2022 is beyond me. Go for the afternoon and don't even invite discussion from the husband and in laws. Merry Christmas xx

LovingTheAbbreviations · 13/12/2022 10:17

I can’t believe all the nasty comments on here, you’re not cancelling you’re just changing plans after sleeping elsewhere went terribly, I can totally understand this. You must do what is best for you and your toddler, everyone saying he won’t remember but everyone else will is being ridiculous, they are grown adults who can surely cope! I hope your DH supports you enough that you can make this plan together as it sounds like you are taking sole responsibility for the sleep and general welfare of this kid. Diagnosis or not, many toddlers struggle with a day/night out of their routine and overstimulation so at only 40mins away it seems a very good plan (not to mention safer if he can climb out of his cot in a strange house that isn’t toddler proof!) to do the day only and come back for the night. They won’t see him at night anyway. And you could even go back the next day if you want to. Put your needs over theirs for once, sleep deprivation is torture so you need to think of yourself and your kid. Hope that helps. I have a toddler and have experienced sleep dep so I hear you!!! Xxx

Blueeyedgirl21 · 12/12/2022 12:34

@raspberrytinsel I’m sure OP would probs prefer to stay at home where her child will actually be comfortable and go to sleep and she can tuck into some choc and wine and actually relax

In the past I’ve offered to do the same so my dp can spend time with his (very needy) family - it’s eat with horrified gasps that I wouldn’t be there to facilitate them all getting their ‘best auntie/uncle/whatever’ pics with the kids for the one day a year they bloody bother with them!! I think the Christmas of 2019 when I suggested coming home around 8pm and leaving them all to get one with it is still talked about in horrified whispers

Yousee · 12/12/2022 08:27

It's worrying that even so called journalists seem unable to read what the OP actually said.

HallieM93 · 11/12/2022 19:31

raspberrytinsel · 11/12/2022 09:12

my little boy this, my little boy that, this is one painful post - it is one night of the entire year, the absolute drama of it; you'd be better off just staying at home with him and leave your husband enjoy himself with his family as you had yours last year.

😂 I don’t know why you’re on mumsnet as you clearly don’t have children

OP posts:
harrassedmumto3 · 11/12/2022 19:22

Haven't read the full thread, but is this referring to the same post?
It's the first time I've seen anything taken from Mumsnet in the media.

AIBU to cancel Christmas at MIL to keep toddler routine
Dahliasandtea · 11/12/2022 14:04

I don’t know what it’s like to have a possible autistic child and all children deal with stress differently.

what I would say is that they obviously want the family altogether and if they are a supportive family that understands the possible diagnosis then this may be an opportunity to explain and let them see it so that next time they can help join in and organise the day around your child. If you start stepping a way for their comfort now you’ll be doing it forever and personally i think your child shouldn’t need to be hidden.. explain beforehand and let them decide…. If they are hosting, give them the option but make it clear what you have to.

get DP onside first.

FallingsHowIFeel · 11/12/2022 10:10

raspberrytinsel · 11/12/2022 09:12

my little boy this, my little boy that, this is one painful post - it is one night of the entire year, the absolute drama of it; you'd be better off just staying at home with him and leave your husband enjoy himself with his family as you had yours last year.

What an idiot.

PinkiOcelot · 11/12/2022 09:21

raspberrytinsel · 11/12/2022 09:12

my little boy this, my little boy that, this is one painful post - it is one night of the entire year, the absolute drama of it; you'd be better off just staying at home with him and leave your husband enjoy himself with his family as you had yours last year.

who pissed on your cornflakes this morning?

PinkiOcelot · 11/12/2022 09:20

I would just come home if they only live 40 minutes away.

raspberrytinsel · 11/12/2022 09:12

my little boy this, my little boy that, this is one painful post - it is one night of the entire year, the absolute drama of it; you'd be better off just staying at home with him and leave your husband enjoy himself with his family as you had yours last year.