Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

CSA - they do fuck all

86 replies

dawnfromgavinandstacey · 07/12/2022 20:36

Long story short.

My exh is self employed. Pays the minimum they can get.

I've had a variation applied every year. Every year it comes back he should be paying more. Nothing ever gets done.

Ever. He owes £11k to my daughter.

He was supposed to pay £300 this month as I'd had a variation applied again. They sent £140.

I am so sick of this.

Every month I call them and say he hasn't paid the full amount. Every month they add it to the debt they never do fuck all about.

My aibu is nothing really just what the actual can I do.

I'm sick of this.

I just wanted a rant.

I've been to court, the amount has been applied by the court. He doesn't pay it ever. He didn't even turn up to any of the hearings.

I am sooo sick of it.

I want this fucker to pay because what he owes her would pay for her uni fees or a house deposit or anything really for her.

Why is our system so fucked up that nothing is ever fucking done.

I'm just on my last nerve and I'm sick of them doing fuck all.

If I contact my mp can anyone help me with a letter?

This is shit. I don't "Need" it but ffs she will one day.

I'm just so angry tonight about it all. I will need to spend another two hours on hold to the CMS again tomorrow and they will just mark it down on my case and do fuck all again.

Is there anyone who can help me.

Is there a csa person who can do an ama so I can understand why it's so shit for the resident parent.

OP posts:
Gingerkittykat · 08/12/2022 04:07

I only got CM after many years by contacting my MP. The CMS phoned me the next day, couldn't be more helpful and put a DOE order in place.

He does job hop a bit so I don't always get the payments but I make sure I don't rely on them.

sjxoxo · 08/12/2022 04:06

It’s beyond disgusting that this is how (mostly women) are treated in the UK and the government do absolutely nothing. I have no answer for you but could you approach your MP? I don’t know if any of the political parties in the UK support change in CMS but urging everyone to vote carefully at the next general election. It’s absolutely vile that this is the truth of it. Its still shit to be a woman in 2022. I hope your exH gets some karma in his life. xox

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/12/2022 03:54

I know someone who worked for the equivalent of the CMS in another country. Sh DELIGHTED in catching and squeezing people who didn't pay. She could take away their driving (or any) licence. She could garnish them in many exciting ways. She could even think about prison for them.

We need a proper system that make sit much worse not to pay.

The sexism is clear. No one cares because it is mostly women, poorer women at that.

JustLyra · 08/12/2022 03:42

Most of the time guys have some money in their accounts as they don’t realise CMS don’t need a court order or DEO to take money. Sadly most of CMS don’t realise that either.

Same with putting a charge on a house - I mentioned it on one of my first days and the person training me was completely unaware that was one of the things they can do.

liveforsummer · 08/12/2022 03:35

They can do a lot of things, but they never do. Like to promise it all at first. Doesn't happen in reality. They can also only take money that is there. The avoiding men will have the money coming in in cash or going in to other accounts (in my case the girlfriends)

JustLyra · 08/12/2022 03:10

liveforsummer · 08/12/2022 03:09

This only works if A - they stay in the employment that the deduction is arranged with after it's (finally) sorted. B - they declare any income of self employed. Can't take a percentage of nothing after all!

They can take one off, or repeat, payments from a bank account to go toward debts though.

they never do, but they can.

liveforsummer · 08/12/2022 03:09

MrsPepperpot79 · 07/12/2022 21:38

dawnfromgavinandstacey - I just kept ringing and whinging. Had him on the payment scheme where they collect the money for you as he was unreliable. (Ha!)
Just kept ringing...

This only works if A - they stay in the employment that the deduction is arranged with after it's (finally) sorted. B - they declare any income of self employed. Can't take a percentage of nothing after all!

user764329056 · 08/12/2022 00:53

I hear you OP, it’s disgusting, my ex is black cab driver in London earning £££££, declared bare minimum, I was awarded £10 a month from CSA, it’s beyond belief how anti-mothers the system is while deadbeat dads laugh all the way to the bank and have no conscience for how their child is being clothed and fed, etc

JustLyra · 08/12/2022 00:37

dawnfromgavinandstacey · 07/12/2022 21:54

I agree. The minute they think they are owed anything they are there!!

Imagine if they were the the same for csa.

Imagine it. There has to be a tax reason they are not.

The minute they are owed from women...

The system when RP's on benefits only got to keep £20 a week of maintenance and the rest was owed to the Sec. of State toward the benefits bill was just as shit at getting money out of (predominantly) men.

The debt owed by NRP's to SoS got so big it was decided that something had to be done... so they said that RP's could all maintenance and it wouldn't affect benefits.

There is zero political will generally to do anything.

That said if your MP is good (I know they are few and far between) then it's worth getting them involved. I briefly worked for CMS (it's soul destroying how shit they are - most of the people I worked with were unaware of the majority of CMS's powers) and the only time people got anywhere was with MP's who hassled and hassled on their behalf.

fifteenohfour · 07/12/2022 23:48

@GeorgiaGirl52 women can't do any of that in the UK. It is dealt with by CMS and they don't deal with it. Your helpless because the system is rigged with so many different ways to get the payments halted and payments are left to accrue and never chased or enforced to be paid.

FuckMyLife2022 · 07/12/2022 23:47

GeorgiaGirl52 · 07/12/2022 23:38

American here so it may be different, but I have known women having success by doing the following:

  1. Hiring a repo team and going to his home to seize assets - including automobile, tools, clothing, furniture, etc. He came home to an empty house - not even lightbulbs in the sockets!
  2. Had electric, gas, water, tv, etc. cancelled and the deposits refunded to her.
  3. Gone before judge and asked that husbands driver's license and work permit be pulled until he paid arrears.
  4. This was my favorite. Husband was a transport driver and hard to serve with papers. Wife took the 4 children to his main office and told the general manager that she was unable to support the children and was leaving them there for the father to take full custody of. Showed GM the documents from court about arrears. Angry GM radioed husband to come in, met him in main office, cut a check and gave it to the wife from his wages. Told wife if payment fell behind again to call him personally.

All great ideas Grin But in the UK you get “but if his driving licence is gone, how can he pay what he owes as he can’t work?” Don’t refuse to pay in the first place, perhaps? BuT wHaT aBoUt ThE mEn attitude, in short.

Mine hasn’t even met our much wanted child that he pleaded with me to TTC for, much less does any parenting at all, nor does he pay a penny.

Part of the problem is that some of them job hop. And it takes HMRC months to tell CMS where they’re working for a DofE to be set up, which then takes CMS months to set up AND they send a warning letter stating when the first payment will be removed from their wages, which gives them a heads up.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 07/12/2022 23:38

American here so it may be different, but I have known women having success by doing the following:

  1. Hiring a repo team and going to his home to seize assets - including automobile, tools, clothing, furniture, etc. He came home to an empty house - not even lightbulbs in the sockets!
  2. Had electric, gas, water, tv, etc. cancelled and the deposits refunded to her.
  3. Gone before judge and asked that husbands driver's license and work permit be pulled until he paid arrears.
  4. This was my favorite. Husband was a transport driver and hard to serve with papers. Wife took the 4 children to his main office and told the general manager that she was unable to support the children and was leaving them there for the father to take full custody of. Showed GM the documents from court about arrears. Angry GM radioed husband to come in, met him in main office, cut a check and gave it to the wife from his wages. Told wife if payment fell behind again to call him personally.
Penguinsaregreat · 07/12/2022 23:12

I agree that the (mainly male) politicians don’t care. Just look at Boris Johnson. So many children to multiple different women. Matt Hancock, adulterer but the public seem to love him.
No, most men would not vote for this and lots of women go along with the patriarchy.

FuckMyLife2022 · 07/12/2022 23:09

Because they don’t give a fuck about single mothers. You only have to look at the many posts on here saying “why didn’t you choose a better man” from smug fucking women to understand why the men in power also don’t care.

Mine owes around 15K. Every time it goes to court, he signs on the dole, court action is stopped because “he has no means to pay”. Well, he fucking did when he chose to run up the arrears.

For the last 6 months I’ve been getting regular payments however they range from £75 to £260 - not once has it been the same amount, there’s no explanation from CMS despite it being a DofE, and it does not include arrears because that department is separate and has to set up their own DofE.

dawnfromgavinandstacey · 07/12/2022 23:00

HeyLala · 07/12/2022 22:45

I agree with everything written here.

Would a petition help?
100k signatures and it has to be discussed in Parliament. I'm sure we could get that organised

I tried too do this a few years ago. I didn't have the benefit or knowledge off mumsnet. I got nowhere.

I'd try it again.

Would you be open to helping me word it?

OP posts:
corlan · 07/12/2022 22:54

There is absolutely no political will to enforce or change the system.

This is the bottom line. It's hard not to conclude it's institutional misogyny. Tens of thousands of men pay peanuts to support their children and women pick up the pieces. Nothing has improved in the 14 years I've been trying to get support for my daughter. Her father contributes £12 a week to support her. The CMS is not working for me or my child and it never has worked.

Mydogatemypurse · 07/12/2022 22:53

MrsPepperpot79 · 07/12/2022 21:29

Oh yes. Had one lot of arrears wiped. He's run up a second lot, owes his kids nearly 9k. I've tried garnering wages- he went self employed and company TOLD csa he'd done it to avoid paying. He reported no income - but was renting and going on holidays. Reported to HMRC - fuck all happened. CSA keep discouraging trying a variation. Finally took him to court, CCJ and bailiffs. They went round and said he had nothing worth taking. And now, he's apparently untraceable, no bills etc and they asked me to find him!!! Told them where his fiancee is but apparently can't use that to locate him. And the kicker? He's infertile - made me go through IVF for the kids he was desperate for, who he then walked out on after a year, that he doesn't pay for or speak to.
Waiting for karma to bite him as CSA clearly not going to!

Absolute c@@t

Mydogatemypurse · 07/12/2022 22:51

Or tax evasion. They arent paying what they should and they are harming thier children in the process whilst profiteering from doing so. Boxing themselves off and their lifestyle before the neefs of their children is, in my opinion criminal.

Mydogatemypurse · 07/12/2022 22:49

They should be treated the same way as benefit fraud. Criminal convictions.

Circe7 · 07/12/2022 22:48

I think it probably needs structural reform. The CSA have a lot of powers but seem reluctant to use them and sometimes very passive / naïve when assessing what is owed e.g. believing that someone with a successful business who apparently has a good standard of living has zero income. HMRC doesn't behave like this when it goes after tax avoiders.

Maybe the government should have responsibility for paying child maintenance to the resident parent and it is then for the government to reclaim it from the other parent (if the government can't reclaim it the resident parent still keeps the money). An independent agency could make the assessment of what is owed. I bet the government would manage to recover most of the money if that was the case.

HeyLala · 07/12/2022 22:45

I agree with everything written here.

Would a petition help?
100k signatures and it has to be discussed in Parliament. I'm sure we could get that organised

Mydogatemypurse · 07/12/2022 22:34

Its a mans world and in my experience it always goes thier way. Don't factor the money owed into any plans for yours or your daughters life. I did and i just had to deal with the grief of trying to fight.

magicofthefae · 07/12/2022 22:32

My father avoided CMS like the plague.
Wish a political party could go after this issue, enforce these changes, make it like the USA, but just not broadcast it. As its just a political sour grape as no male voter would vote for it.

magicofthefae · 07/12/2022 22:22

StrawberryWater · 07/12/2022 20:51

CSA sucks and will continue to suck until there ar e proper consequences for non payers.

In parts of the US they actually garner wages, size assets, revoke driving licenses and send people to jail for non payment.

If only this was implemented here. Like a student loan is docked from pay packets, why isn't child maintenance?

Swipe left for the next trending thread