Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry it's a harry one

232 replies

SuperSuperCold · 07/12/2022 20:05

Just getting a bit pissed off with hypocritical people lately and turn on twitter to find it full of harry and Megan, which got me directing my annoyance at hypocrites to Harry.

I did used to love the guy, and no hate from me here, but what I can't understand is:

  1. The boy (man?) hates the press apparently, yet is in the media every second of his own choosing
  1. He didn't want the press to use Diana for media gains and money making. Now his new netflix documentary appears to be going to do just that, judging by the trailor (which has already exploited Diana for clicks without the documentary even being out yet)
  1. The man professes the royal family are all racist, but HE is the one who wore a nazi uniform, black faced himself, and has used racial slurs to many. (I don't think any of the other royals have gone so far as to dress up as a Nazi have they?)

Sorry for doing another Harry and megs thread, but the hypocrisy has really got to me today for some reason! (maybe PMT!)

If you r fed up with Harry threads, feel to coment on what other people you know have done hypocritical things that drive your nuts!! No need to mention Harry or Megan!

OP posts:
beAsensible1 · 08/12/2022 01:18

HotChoxs · 08/12/2022 01:11

I agree with you that it was only when H&M starting experiencing things that they realised the extent of the problem.

I agree with you that Meghan was naive at best, but as someone with a white sibling I take a very different view on it.

I also think that neither have realised that they're still essentially one of the most highly privileged white couples in the world and all the messaging around it just doesn't come across as sincere on their part.

That's not to say there aren't some positives that haven't come out of it there are, but for me they are overshadowed by the negative side.

I think its both of their first times having to seriously understand and navigate race politics in a white space.

everyone remember when their white ally friend first starts getting into racism and doing the reading and basic activism and how "loud" they are and wanting to share with the world.

they're doing the same thing but on an international scale with one of the oldest whitest institutions in the world. I am choosing to give grace because ultimately i don't think its a BAD thing.

The royal family has never had to interact with race or multiculturalism ever, their first time is in the 2020s! its uncomfortable to watch especially in britain where we like to pretend it doesn't happen.

They'll be quiet eventually, plus we all have bills!

Dictionaryencyclopedia · 08/12/2022 01:13

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 07/12/2022 20:49

My sentiments precisely. It was predictable that as soon as their matriarch died, that family would splinter. The Yorks will likely rarely be seen in public again and will fade into the background as they were always going to do, the Wessex's daughter wisely keeps a low profile, meanwhile Anne's son-in-law goes on a ridiculous reality show and makes every bit as much a numpty of himself as Harry's so frequently accused of doing. Then it takes all of three months for Susan Hussey - the Queen's close companion and William's godmother - to let her mask slip and show exactly who she really is. Elizabeth's veneer was already coming off: she'd stood by her revolting son Andrew and married a notorious racist. Now that her friend of 6 decades has displayed similar racist credentials, it stretches plausibility way too far to imagine the Queen didn't know exactly what she was, and likely shared similar views herself.

Meanwhile, Meghan's pulled a People's Choice award for her podcast series and they've both scooped one for standing up to the Windsors' (well-documented) institutional racism.

Harry and Meghan must be hooting. I can't really say I blame them. And if they succeeded in taking the Windsors down, I'd even send them a thank-you note.

Brilliant comment. I couldn't agree more. Thank you!

HotChoxs · 08/12/2022 01:11

beAsensible1 · 08/12/2022 01:00

I do think she was massively naive, which she has admitted i think.

But also she has spoken about how she navigated the world and specifically north america as a light skinned mixed woman.
I honestly don't think she expected it and was not expecting to be treated as black and all the insanity that comes with 'misogynoir'

The racism and also the tabloids here are a complete different kettle of fish and once they've decided to get onto you they will spend everyday obsessing its quite terrifying.

Look at all the stuff with sistah space, they've dug up her marriage license her kids, her name change all that stuff. Thats in a week, I imagine it was bewildering.

Being a visible black woman in this country seems bloody horrible and has honestly put me off getting any further into a field I love. H&M are bound to make some missteps =, but they're finding their feet and i'm sure it will all find its level at some point.

It naive of any of us who exist on this island to pretend that the brf are some bastion of racial tolerance and modernity.
The same institution that banned poc in any front of house positions until recently.

I agree with you that it was only when H&M starting experiencing things that they realised the extent of the problem.

I agree with you that Meghan was naive at best, but as someone with a white sibling I take a very different view on it.

I also think that neither have realised that they're still essentially one of the most highly privileged white couples in the world and all the messaging around it just doesn't come across as sincere on their part.

That's not to say there aren't some positives that haven't come out of it there are, but for me they are overshadowed by the negative side.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 01:04

AliensToTheLeft · 08/12/2022 01:03

The OP said that she thinks maybe it’s her PMT causing Harry to really get to her, so how the fuck is my post sexist for suggesting she gets help with that PMT?

Sorry for doing another Harry and megs thread, but the hypocrisy has really got to me today for some reason! (maybe PMT!)

Oh. How embarrassing. I missed that Blush apologies to that poster. I’ll ask my comment to be deleted.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 01:04

I do think she was massively naive, which she has admitted i think.

Nah, she’s a very smart woman and will have been fully briefed despite what she says (no way did she get no training at all). I reckon she didn’t quite grasp that the RF aren’t like the Kardashians or any Hollywood entity, you can’t use your charm and looks to clamour for the position of top dog, and I suspect she thought she’d shake things up once she got into the fold. And it never happened because the RF doesn’t work like that

AliensToTheLeft · 08/12/2022 01:03

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:57

Read her post again. She told people to get help for their PMT if Harry annoys them. Sexist comment, and a lazy sexist comment at that

The OP said that she thinks maybe it’s her PMT causing Harry to really get to her, so how the fuck is my post sexist for suggesting she gets help with that PMT?

Sorry for doing another Harry and megs thread, but the hypocrisy has really got to me today for some reason! (maybe PMT!)

beAsensible1 · 08/12/2022 01:00

HotChoxs · 08/12/2022 00:08

But not smart enough to marry into a racist family. Which as as dark skinned (important) mixed race person I would have seen the red flags coming a mile off, particularly if the person I was dating was brought up to think calling someone a P**i was acceptable.

I do think she was massively naive, which she has admitted i think.

But also she has spoken about how she navigated the world and specifically north america as a light skinned mixed woman.
I honestly don't think she expected it and was not expecting to be treated as black and all the insanity that comes with 'misogynoir'

The racism and also the tabloids here are a complete different kettle of fish and once they've decided to get onto you they will spend everyday obsessing its quite terrifying.

Look at all the stuff with sistah space, they've dug up her marriage license her kids, her name change all that stuff. Thats in a week, I imagine it was bewildering.

Being a visible black woman in this country seems bloody horrible and has honestly put me off getting any further into a field I love. H&M are bound to make some missteps =, but they're finding their feet and i'm sure it will all find its level at some point.

It naive of any of us who exist on this island to pretend that the brf are some bastion of racial tolerance and modernity.
The same institution that banned poc in any front of house positions until recently.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:57

AliensToTheLeft · 08/12/2022 00:52

Sexism? She said she thinks she feels this way due to her PMT. There are treatments available.

Read her post again. She told people to get help for their PMT if Harry annoys them. Sexist comment, and a lazy sexist comment at that

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:56

beAsensible1 · 08/12/2022 00:50

Thats not what he said though is it? It was he withdrawal of funded security when there were constant and credible risks to them and their children lives?

Wasn't their location leaked in canada and then security pulled at the same time? which is why they went to the US as they were able to get security there and guarded accommodation?

Not sure what you mean about childhood lies? Maybe i missed something

That’s just a long way of saying he moaned about daddy cutting him off. He’s a millionaire in his own right, he can well afford his own security but he wanted the British taxpayer to fork out for it instead.

Why should they get UK funded security in Canada? The taxpayer shouldn’t be funding their choice to move abroad. They quit the RF - you don’t get to do that but take the expensive bits only for Royals with you.

Re his childhood - a sob story about never riding on the back of his dad’s bike. Then several pictures of him riding bikes with his dad showed up. It was a lazy lie and an attempt to make him sound like he had an awful childhood.

AliensToTheLeft · 08/12/2022 00:52

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Sexism? She said she thinks she feels this way due to her PMT. There are treatments available.

HotChoxs · 08/12/2022 00:52

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:48

@Sigma33 i absolutely agree, I’m so sorry your DDs have experienced that. I too only learnt a lot about racism and the way it affects people when meeting my DH and them having my kids. Not that I was racist before of course - but I have a much better understanding of it and yes that does come from marrying into a non-white family. Which isn’t the way people should be learning, but it is what it is and I can only hope for change for my DC. However MN threads of late and comments on social media give me very little confidence that the world is changing its views on racism sadly.

If anything people have become more entrenched in their views, which is what happens when the wrong people are preaching about it.

beAsensible1 · 08/12/2022 00:50

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 07/12/2022 23:39

You think criticising daddy for not giving you more money is ‘nice’? Or lies told about your childhood?

Thats not what he said though is it? It was he withdrawal of funded security when there were constant and credible risks to them and their children lives?

Wasn't their location leaked in canada and then security pulled at the same time? which is why they went to the US as they were able to get security there and guarded accommodation?

Not sure what you mean about childhood lies? Maybe i missed something

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:48

@Sigma33 i absolutely agree, I’m so sorry your DDs have experienced that. I too only learnt a lot about racism and the way it affects people when meeting my DH and them having my kids. Not that I was racist before of course - but I have a much better understanding of it and yes that does come from marrying into a non-white family. Which isn’t the way people should be learning, but it is what it is and I can only hope for change for my DC. However MN threads of late and comments on social media give me very little confidence that the world is changing its views on racism sadly.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

AliensToTheLeft · 08/12/2022 00:42

Seek some help with your PMT if it means Prince Harry ‘really gets to you‘.

I reckon some posters are suffering high blood pressure and heading for a heart attack with the cause being Harry and Meghan and this Netflix programme. 😬

Sigma33 · 08/12/2022 00:41

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:23

I agree with you, I remember reading newspaper articles in a book about the Nazi reign and the positive publicity they received at a certain time.

But nothing I can find points to the Queen Mother specifically being a Nazi sympathiser. Obviously David and Wallis were (The Traitor King is an excellent read that details it all!)

There is footage of the then Princesses Elizabeth and Margaret larking about and doing Nazi salutes in 1933 with their mother and future Edward VIII.

Hitler had just taken power.

There was no indication that this was a gesture of support for the Nazis. And at that point the Nazis had not enacted any legislation that discriminated against any group in society.

MrsFinkelstein · 08/12/2022 00:39

To the PP asking about Harry's "you don't sound black" comment.

www.independent.co.uk/news/people/news/harry-told-me-you-don-t-sound-black-claims-comic-1606648.html

He also said "don't worry, she's not black" to friends about a previous girlfriend.

www.theguardian.com/g2/story/0,,1383309,00.html

Mumtobabyhavoc · 08/12/2022 00:37

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:32

@Mumtobabyhavoc lol

😉

Sigma33 · 08/12/2022 00:34

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:00

@Sigma33 absolutely spot on. It’s such a shame that he missed an excellent opportunity

My DC are mixed race and whilst we have been very lucky to have experienced minimal racist comments (there’s still time they’re only 5 & 9) it genuinely breaks my heart that there are so many fucking arseholes out there who will tie themselves in knots to excuse racist words like P**I and dressing up as Nazis and who don’t think people preaching about racism should even attempt to speak about their own racist actions. It would be such a win for POC such as my children to be able to see privileged white men owning their fuck ups and misunderstandings around race and acknowledging how it makes people feel - not whining that someone may or may not have said something potentially unsavoury to a loved one and that’s only when they started giving a shit themselves

Yep. Mum to black daughters (trans-racial adoption) who have experienced outright racist abuse (being called a ni*r on a bus by an adult male) as well as so many microaggressions.

I was brought up to be 'woke' and an 'SJW' (to use the terms of abuse that I embrace) but only truly began to understand the level of insidious racism once my DDs experienced it and I began to see the world through their experiences.

Just as I only began to understand what it is to live in a context of homophobia when I had close friends who are gay.

I don't beat myself up about my previous lack of understanding, but I do hold my hands up to not understanding how pervasive, exhausting, and undermining it is to have to factor in - day to day - that people may be hostile to you no matter what you do. That by existing you are an enemy of 'decent people' or a 'threat to society'.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:32

@Mumtobabyhavoc lol

Mumtobabyhavoc · 08/12/2022 00:31

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:21

For me the reasons I dislike them, in a nutshell is

  • The hypocrisy. Preaching about the environment and poverty whilst being filthy rich and flying about in private jets. It’s annoying. I can’t stand any celeb doing this TBH who doesn’t practice what they preach
  • The porkie pies. So many in the Oprah interview and neither of them were bright enough to tell lies that couldn’t be contradicted.
  • they stink of wealth and privilege and seem to moan that they don’t have enough. They have about a thousand times more than most people could imagine and yet complain that their lifestyle is expensive. They also tried to cash in on the Sussex name given to them which doesn’t sit right with me
  • The fake news-esque style of them both. The trailer has used footage that has nothing to do with them. Oprah’s interview similarly fabricated headlines. And I’m sure they didn’t personally make either of those things happen but equally it clearly doesn’t bother them one bit
  • The way they drop in and out of the RF. which, if they did as they said they would do and live a dual life overseas then fine. But they want to hold salacious interviews and say hurtful things and still expect to get a front row seat at a royal event
  • The complete surprise from Harry that the RF has a hierarchy. It’s literally built on a hierarchy of birth. Didn’t he notice?
  • the way they only want the ‘good bits’ of the RF - such as their DC to have titles (despite declaring after Archie’s birth that they wanted him to be a private citizen. And for them to keep their titles. They are like children, they want everything their way and no compromise.
  • The total insensitivity of slagging off an old woman whilst her DH was dying. And similarly releasing a Netflix show and book about their ‘pain’ at a time their dad has only just lost his mum.
  • Everything they do is tone deaf. I’m sure they are told they are relatable and duke and Duchess of the people etc but really a man with a dodgy past re racism from a family with history colonising, preaching about how people shouldn’t be racist, is a joke.

Just a few things. I sympathise with them in many ways too - her family are fucking awful and I’d have dropped them like hot potatoes too. And I don’t think I’ll ever quite believe anyone thought it was ok for a 12yo boy to walk behind his mum’s coffin while the world watched. And I don’t blame them for buggering off and leaving it all behind. But they are SO tone deaf and out of touch, it’s hard not to get irritated by it.

Could you elaborate?

Blocked · 08/12/2022 00:30

BiscuitLover3678 · 07/12/2022 20:09

Now I’m disappointed as I wanted it to be about Harry Styles. Sigh.

In his defence, the media hounded his wife and trash talked her like mad. A bit different to wanting to have your say and try and make a good difference to the world. I honestly believe he means well.

Personally I find it all a bit boring!

I think he means well too, he's a good hearted soul who has ended up a toxic mix of being massively privileged and self important to the point where he can't even see it, not brilliantly clever, troubled by mental health and surrounded by people giving him really bad advice to exploit him for their own gains.

MrsFinkelstein · 08/12/2022 00:26

Pandor · 07/12/2022 23:12

Has anyone ever laid out the precise rules as to when you are, and aren’t allowed to dress up as a Nazi without that demonstrating that you are in fact terribly racist?

Ralph Feinnes put in an incredible performance as Amon Goeth in Schindler’s List, but presumably that didn’t make him a racist as it was a very serious film.

The whole Mel Brooks “Springtime for Hitler” routine in the Producers was done for laughs, but presumably isn’t evidence of appalling racism either?

I used to watch a lot of Allo Allo as a child and don’t ever remember Richard Gibson being hounded by accusations of racism for his portrayal of Herr Flick of the gestapo, but perhaps I missed it.

In fact, I suspect there are literally countless examples of people dressing as Nazis over the years that have gone utterly unremarked upon.

it’s almost as if the motivation behind someone dressing up as a Nazi, whether that it is to make a serious point, to make people laugh, or to showcase their love and support of Far Right political views, is actually really important.

You could almost say that whilst a young prince dressing up as a Nazi amongst friends in the context of a fancy dress night is clearly naive, it doesn’t “necessarily” demonstrate an actual love of nazis or reveal any deep seated racism.

But no…much simpler to just call him a racist.

This maybe the worst defense of dressing up as a Nazi I have ever heard.

Kudos to you.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:23

Sigma33 · 08/12/2022 00:16

There were a lot of people who initially thought Hitler (Mussolini as well) were good leaders. They brought their countries out of a period of chaos, and developed infrastructure, jobs, etc

Of course today we know where that led.

But in 1935 it wasn't unreasonable to take the approach that Hitler was doing a lot of good, and that his weird obsession against the Jews was unfortunate and wrong, but would wither away because it was so ridiculous. At least they weren't Bolshevik, which was seen as worse (and had murdered the RF's close relatives) and killed more in the gulags than Hitler did in the concentration camps - to provide a contemporary perspective.

The Queen Mother was committed to the war against Germany by the time the war broke out.

I agree with you, I remember reading newspaper articles in a book about the Nazi reign and the positive publicity they received at a certain time.

But nothing I can find points to the Queen Mother specifically being a Nazi sympathiser. Obviously David and Wallis were (The Traitor King is an excellent read that details it all!)

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/12/2022 00:21

doorheckk · 08/12/2022 00:09

What is it about the H&M constructive criticism ‘bashing’ that gets under your skin??

I'm intrigued by it as I said. Undoubtedly they attract far more criticism than other celebs & royals & I don't see how it's warranted. I don't think they are particularly "good", I just don't see them as "bad". Obviously there are elements of sexism & racism but is it also the doth thy cap reverence that some give to the RF? Are people personally offended because they see the RF as their own family? Im not English & do find it quite strange tbh.

For me the reasons I dislike them, in a nutshell is

  • The hypocrisy. Preaching about the environment and poverty whilst being filthy rich and flying about in private jets. It’s annoying. I can’t stand any celeb doing this TBH who doesn’t practice what they preach
  • The porkie pies. So many in the Oprah interview and neither of them were bright enough to tell lies that couldn’t be contradicted.
  • they stink of wealth and privilege and seem to moan that they don’t have enough. They have about a thousand times more than most people could imagine and yet complain that their lifestyle is expensive. They also tried to cash in on the Sussex name given to them which doesn’t sit right with me
  • The fake news-esque style of them both. The trailer has used footage that has nothing to do with them. Oprah’s interview similarly fabricated headlines. And I’m sure they didn’t personally make either of those things happen but equally it clearly doesn’t bother them one bit
  • The way they drop in and out of the RF. which, if they did as they said they would do and live a dual life overseas then fine. But they want to hold salacious interviews and say hurtful things and still expect to get a front row seat at a royal event
  • The complete surprise from Harry that the RF has a hierarchy. It’s literally built on a hierarchy of birth. Didn’t he notice?
  • the way they only want the ‘good bits’ of the RF - such as their DC to have titles (despite declaring after Archie’s birth that they wanted him to be a private citizen. And for them to keep their titles. They are like children, they want everything their way and no compromise.
  • The total insensitivity of slagging off an old woman whilst her DH was dying. And similarly releasing a Netflix show and book about their ‘pain’ at a time their dad has only just lost his mum.
  • Everything they do is tone deaf. I’m sure they are told they are relatable and duke and Duchess of the people etc but really a man with a dodgy past re racism from a family with history colonising, preaching about how people shouldn’t be racist, is a joke.

Just a few things. I sympathise with them in many ways too - her family are fucking awful and I’d have dropped them like hot potatoes too. And I don’t think I’ll ever quite believe anyone thought it was ok for a 12yo boy to walk behind his mum’s coffin while the world watched. And I don’t blame them for buggering off and leaving it all behind. But they are SO tone deaf and out of touch, it’s hard not to get irritated by it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread