Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nativity disappointment why do teachers do it

417 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 18:42

Want to key stage 2 nativity today. It was 1 hour long! Approx 40 kids in it. Some children had multiple lines throughout the hour, on the stage for the bulk of the time, solo songs the works. Others had just one line and spent the rest of the time sitting to the side apart from group songs where they all stood up. I understand all parts cant be equal and it must be a nightmare to try and be fair but this was shockingly poorly distrubuted. Why would you do this as a teacher? So disappointing for the children and parents unless you happen to be one of the "stars" of the show.

OP posts:
Itaintwhatyoudoitsthewaythatyoudoit · 07/12/2022 21:22

Untitledsquatboulder · 07/12/2022 21:16

They spread the lines out at dc's school one year and it was a fucking nightmare. Imagine trying to get 30 children to each remember a) their line and b) their cue, and then someone says their line in the wrong place and chaos. Lots of confusion, lots of tears as kids missed their turn or had it gazumped. Never did find out what the story was supposed to be.

Did you really care what the 'story' was though?

They do this at my kid's school ie they all get one line (and some of them get a few more). Plenty of kids fluff their line. I don't think I've ever spoken to a parent afterwards who cared. Certainly some kids were better at speaking loudly and clearly than others but the kids were treated equally and the shy ones (one being my own DC) was so proud of their part in it.

Ijustdontknowanything · 07/12/2022 21:21

crochetmonkey74 · 07/12/2022 20:56

There's a certain type of person who believes they are the centre of all teachers attention, it's really wearing. I've worked at the same school for years and regularly see ex students when they bring their kids to open evenings and things. The number of times we have heard "I was terrible at school and all the teachers hated me"
This will be from totally normal, nice kids who were nothing of the sort. It's a strange phenomenon that we can't quite work out.

Well that's not me. I just got on with it. I still had a bit of tinsel to wear.

jamira · 07/12/2022 21:20

I agree - the barely concealed favouritism is a real problem in primary school. And too many teachers are concerned with the quality of the performance vs letting more kids get involved and.... god forbid, have fun

GuyFawkesDay · 07/12/2022 21:18

WombatChocolate · 07/12/2022 21:17

I wonder if those who say ‘their face didn’t fit’ make this comment about everything to do with school?

Some parents have decided the school is the enemy and wants to keep their kid down, before they’ve even visited the school or met the teacher. It can be a mindset thing.

And often those parents will badmouth the school and teacher to their child and a few friends, but would never have a constructive conversation about their issues with the school ....wouldn’t dream if it, because actually often it would be ridiculous and there would be nothing to say. Because how can a comment like ‘they should all have equal parts’ make any sense, or how could ‘they wanted a big part’ be sensibly responses to when the teacher tells them they were asked and said they wanted a small non-speaking role....those parents will still be determined to believe that’s a lie and the child has been denied.

On one level, it won’t be entirely fair. Not every child will get their favourite role. Certainly it seems not every parent will have their child in the role they would choose for them. Funnily, more parents want their kid in a bigger role than the kids do themselves. As parents and children, accepting natural constraints on things like this, is a part of life and growing up. Most kids and parents accept and understand. Some kids and even some adults can’t get beyond their personal desires or see the bigger picture. They can’t grasp that with 60 kids, some will be chorus or that the nativity isn’t the key focus of the teacher’s year and there are other things than writing a bespoke script that will please every parent, all of whom want something different. Some parents are just always disappointed about everything because essentially they want individual attention for their child and not for them to be just one of 60 or 90 or whatever. They might be their little prince or princess, but the play has to meet multiple constraints of time, cost, effort, performance quality etc etc and in the end it’s about a group effort, community event and building a memory....and most plays do that for the kids. Some parents want a lifelong deep and meaningful memory, a quality video that can be used to brag to multiple friends and Aunts and a boost to their own ego. The school nativity isn’t the right place to get a fix of those things. But some people seem to demand that.

Expect something quite cute, a bit funny and the little kids as they are, performing as befits their age and inexperience. Enjoy it for their pride at being involved and singing the songs at home in the week before. Praise them for their lovely singing or speaking the odd word they might have. Thank the teacher and other staff for their efforts. Congratulate other families and tell all the kids how great they were. And forget it by a day or two later. Don’t be too over-invested. It really isn’t a big deal.

Hear hear

WombatChocolate · 07/12/2022 21:17

I wonder if those who say ‘their face didn’t fit’ make this comment about everything to do with school?

Some parents have decided the school is the enemy and wants to keep their kid down, before they’ve even visited the school or met the teacher. It can be a mindset thing.

And often those parents will badmouth the school and teacher to their child and a few friends, but would never have a constructive conversation about their issues with the school ....wouldn’t dream if it, because actually often it would be ridiculous and there would be nothing to say. Because how can a comment like ‘they should all have equal parts’ make any sense, or how could ‘they wanted a big part’ be sensibly responses to when the teacher tells them they were asked and said they wanted a small non-speaking role....those parents will still be determined to believe that’s a lie and the child has been denied.

On one level, it won’t be entirely fair. Not every child will get their favourite role. Certainly it seems not every parent will have their child in the role they would choose for them. Funnily, more parents want their kid in a bigger role than the kids do themselves. As parents and children, accepting natural constraints on things like this, is a part of life and growing up. Most kids and parents accept and understand. Some kids and even some adults can’t get beyond their personal desires or see the bigger picture. They can’t grasp that with 60 kids, some will be chorus or that the nativity isn’t the key focus of the teacher’s year and there are other things than writing a bespoke script that will please every parent, all of whom want something different. Some parents are just always disappointed about everything because essentially they want individual attention for their child and not for them to be just one of 60 or 90 or whatever. They might be their little prince or princess, but the play has to meet multiple constraints of time, cost, effort, performance quality etc etc and in the end it’s about a group effort, community event and building a memory....and most plays do that for the kids. Some parents want a lifelong deep and meaningful memory, a quality video that can be used to brag to multiple friends and Aunts and a boost to their own ego. The school nativity isn’t the right place to get a fix of those things. But some people seem to demand that.

Expect something quite cute, a bit funny and the little kids as they are, performing as befits their age and inexperience. Enjoy it for their pride at being involved and singing the songs at home in the week before. Praise them for their lovely singing or speaking the odd word they might have. Thank the teacher and other staff for their efforts. Congratulate other families and tell all the kids how great they were. And forget it by a day or two later. Don’t be too over-invested. It really isn’t a big deal.

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 21:17

Goldenbear · 07/12/2022 21:15

Pumperthepumper, I didn't say that you should 'centre' the parents over the children but they certainly need to engage them as they're a valuable contribution in the education of a child. Schools that are successful know that. I'm not sure why cheeriness and happiness are in a young child's life who are at that age keen to show their parents their abilities and school life, are so repellent to you- seems a bit miserable, surely you are working towards the ideal at that age as they are pretty sweet and innocent.

No, you’re saying schools should push kids on to make the parents happy. I’m not sure why quiet kids are so repellant to you, they’re just as important as the confident ones - regardless of how desperate their parents are for them to be Mary.

Untitledsquatboulder · 07/12/2022 21:16

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 18:58

My son had a big part but his best friend didn't and was in tears about it more than once. Just don't understand it. No one cares if the child fluffs a line or two, spread the lines out.

They spread the lines out at dc's school one year and it was a fucking nightmare. Imagine trying to get 30 children to each remember a) their line and b) their cue, and then someone says their line in the wrong place and chaos. Lots of confusion, lots of tears as kids missed their turn or had it gazumped. Never did find out what the story was supposed to be.

Goldenbear · 07/12/2022 21:15

Pumperthepumper, I didn't say that you should 'centre' the parents over the children but they certainly need to engage them as they're a valuable contribution in the education of a child. Schools that are successful know that. I'm not sure why cheeriness and happiness are in a young child's life who are at that age keen to show their parents their abilities and school life, are so repellent to you- seems a bit miserable, surely you are working towards the ideal at that age as they are pretty sweet and innocent.

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 21:14

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 21:11

100% this!

ITs the easy option to pick just a few/ the same kids

But the reason that doesn’t work is the shy kids don’t go straight to being the confident lead in the school play. They need loads and loads of time to practise - by talking in groups, then in front of the class, then to people they don’t know well, then assemblies, or any other millions of ways to make them feel happier in front of a group.

It would actually be shit, lazy teaching to bash them on stage with a couple of weeks of rehearsals to say you’d attempted to make them more confident. And it wouldn’t work.

echt · 07/12/2022 21:14

There was never any fairness with awards at primary - same kids every time - I just don’t understand teachers, I think my expectations were too high - I thought they’d think about stuff like this but turns out they didn’t think it mattered. I stopped respecting the profession - too many let downs - lockdown sealed it

Awards are given to those who are best at whatever, so likely to go to the same ones.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 21:11

Italiandreams · 07/12/2022 19:16

Actually as a primary teacher I think they are a great opportunity to help develop the less confident children. I love nothing more than giving some of those a chance to shine, a bit of coaching and a chance to shine can do wonders for their self esteem. I think it’s important all children are given a chance, nothing worse than seeing the same ultra confident children shine year after year, no wonder these others lack confidence if they are not given the chance. No one should be forced but I have definitely seen children overlooked before. A well planned production should give opportunities for all.

100% this!

ITs the easy option to pick just a few/ the same kids

OP posts:
StephanieSuperpowers · 07/12/2022 21:10

I'm on the PTA. I'd be astonished if any of the teachers are aware of it or connected me with my child. I'd imagine they have more to think about.

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 21:10

AnotherLogOnTheFire · 07/12/2022 21:09

There was never any fairness with awards at primary - same kids every time - I just don’t understand teachers, I think my expectations were too high - I thought they’d think about stuff like this but turns out they didn’t think it mattered. I stopped respecting the profession - too many let downs - lockdown sealed it.

So do you homeschool your kids now?

AnotherLogOnTheFire · 07/12/2022 21:09

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 18:42

Want to key stage 2 nativity today. It was 1 hour long! Approx 40 kids in it. Some children had multiple lines throughout the hour, on the stage for the bulk of the time, solo songs the works. Others had just one line and spent the rest of the time sitting to the side apart from group songs where they all stood up. I understand all parts cant be equal and it must be a nightmare to try and be fair but this was shockingly poorly distrubuted. Why would you do this as a teacher? So disappointing for the children and parents unless you happen to be one of the "stars" of the show.

There was never any fairness with awards at primary - same kids every time - I just don’t understand teachers, I think my expectations were too high - I thought they’d think about stuff like this but turns out they didn’t think it mattered. I stopped respecting the profession - too many let downs - lockdown sealed it.

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 21:07

Ijustdontknowanything · 07/12/2022 21:06

Chubby kid with glasses.

In a school of what? Abercrombie models?

Itaintwhatyoudoitsthewaythatyoudoit · 07/12/2022 21:07

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 18:49

Oh no! How sad. This isn't teaching the quieter ones anything. I understand for older ages when they are more self conscious but the young ones love to feel involved even if they're not eg be on stage for the songs etc

I agree with you OP. How are the shy kids supposed to gain confidence without being encouraged and supported to overcome their nerves by giving them a speaking part.

The schools give the bigger parts to the kids who are naturally good at it (and don't need it as much) because its easier for them.

My kids don't do nativity plays but I had them in a drama group for a couple of years where the same thing happened despite ALL the kids being there because they wanted to perform. Instead of building their confidence, it destroyed the confidence they initially went in with. The organisers gave the speaking parts to the same kids over and over. They insisted they did 'auditions' in their weekly classes but omitted to say that the auditions were not open for all the kids, and were instead hand selected by the organisers. For a 'community' group to behave like this, was very disappointing. It backfired because as soon as the average kids reached a certain age, they all left apart from the selected few, meaning the drama group's average member is approx five years of age!

Ijustdontknowanything · 07/12/2022 21:06

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 20:51

Wtf does that mean though? Face didn’t fit what?

Chubby kid with glasses.

antelopevalley · 07/12/2022 21:06

OnlyFannys · 07/12/2022 18:49

My ds desperately wanted a good part and he got one bloody line 🙄 the usual favourites got the big part its ridiculous

This has been my experience as well.

saraclara · 07/12/2022 21:06

for the nativity the tallest dark haired boy and girl were Mary and Joseph, the tallest blonde boy and girl were the Star of Bethlehem and Angel Gabriel etc.

And you think that's more fair than the alternatives, @ancientgran ? Seriously?

I was the shortest child in every class I was in, from aged 5-18. So I'd certainly not be happy with being ruled out due to something I had absolutely no control over.

stayingaliveisawayoflife · 07/12/2022 21:06

Anyone else play the chime bars in the school play? I had A and D and was very proud! Altogether now

It was on a starry night, when the hills were bright.....

viques · 07/12/2022 20:59

Cherrysherbet · 07/12/2022 20:05

The teachers only want the confident kids in the best parts. The ones that would love to have a go, don’t get the opportunity. They have to sit on the sidelines bored shitless. I’ve seen it time and time again.

Last year (yr6) My dd was off sick for one day when the parts were given out and the teacher forgot her completely. She ended up just sitting at the back of the choir, not on the stage at all. She told me the part she would have liked, but the teacher never even bothered to ask her.

Bad teaching. Lazy teaching.

I’m so glad she has left primary now.

Thank fuck I don’t have to sit through anymore boring bloody plays. The same kids dominating them for 7 yrs running. It’s like they push their favourite kids in your face and you have to sit and admire them. Its so cringeworthy.

So damn the eyes of the child who was offered and took the part your child wanted. Selfish little critter should have immediately apologised and given the part back.

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 20:57

Goldenbear · 07/12/2022 20:53

Pumperthepumper, well I think particularly at infant school age, it is important to engage the parents and not be so serious about it all, they are little kids and mostly cute and what is wrong with wanting the parents to be happy to see their child performing in something only put on once a year! I think we have been incredibly fortunate as my DC had a very good music teacher that was great, happy and was seemingly pleased to engage the parents. I went to prep school and that's what it was like for me in our school performances.

Because education shouldn’t - at any point - centre the parent over the child. Making parents happy is completely irrelevant.

crochetmonkey74 · 07/12/2022 20:56

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 20:51

Wtf does that mean though? Face didn’t fit what?

There's a certain type of person who believes they are the centre of all teachers attention, it's really wearing. I've worked at the same school for years and regularly see ex students when they bring their kids to open evenings and things. The number of times we have heard "I was terrible at school and all the teachers hated me"
This will be from totally normal, nice kids who were nothing of the sort. It's a strange phenomenon that we can't quite work out.

TheaBrandt · 07/12/2022 20:54

Great post Nosie. My mother was a primary teacher - her issue was always Joseph no boy ever wanted to do it - having to stand with a girl rather than be a shepherd or a king with your mates is a hard sell… 😁

ancientgran · 07/12/2022 20:53

Inyournightgarden · 07/12/2022 20:51

At my sons primary school the head has 3 of his own kids across 3 different year groups.

amazingly they are selected for EVERYTHING. They are the best speakers, singers, athletes, mathematicians etc.

btu they aren’t, they just share his last name. Everyone can see it, it’s discussed openly by parents but none will challenge the school because although he comes across as mr nicey the teachers are all terrified of him

Yes we used to have a saying when parts were handed out, "you only get a big part if your surname is X" Sad for the teachers if they are being bullied into it.