Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nativity disappointment why do teachers do it

417 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 18:42

Want to key stage 2 nativity today. It was 1 hour long! Approx 40 kids in it. Some children had multiple lines throughout the hour, on the stage for the bulk of the time, solo songs the works. Others had just one line and spent the rest of the time sitting to the side apart from group songs where they all stood up. I understand all parts cant be equal and it must be a nightmare to try and be fair but this was shockingly poorly distrubuted. Why would you do this as a teacher? So disappointing for the children and parents unless you happen to be one of the "stars" of the show.

OP posts:
AnotherLogOnTheFire · 07/12/2022 23:00

jamira · 07/12/2022 21:20

I agree - the barely concealed favouritism is a real problem in primary school. And too many teachers are concerned with the quality of the performance vs letting more kids get involved and.... god forbid, have fun

I apologised to the teacher for dd (5) missing a rehearsal due to ill health (she was part of the choir - so not like the star or anything) her reply - they were all awful anyway so it didn't matter - there was no charm, no smile, she was very disappointed with them - if you can't handle it don't do it.

SuperSuperCold · 07/12/2022 22:48

My son was the rear end of donkey number 2 in his year 2 nativity!!! He said nothing and was on stage for mere seconds (not that you could see him!) He LOVED it!! I was v proud!! Not all kids need to be Mary or Joseph! 😉

Dottymug · 07/12/2022 22:48

@NosieRosie Hope he has a brilliant night!

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 22:48

MostTacticalNameChange · 07/12/2022 22:41

I'm still bitter from my primary school experiences - i was always picked to be an (out of site) narrator - i could be relied upon to learn lines but was too fat, tall and un-blond to be onstage.

My dc wanted roles and would really have benefitted from the experience (I never had a chance to do public speaking on stage until i was 21 and turns out i enjoy it and am good at it) but the popular, obnoxious kids are given 2 or 3 roles in the same play while others are just chorus. Not even on stage. Kids internalise that shit.

Yes, there are loads more important things to worry about, but this is just something free and easy to fix - it's not like parents ay based on performance. There should be a lot more fairness, it's not bloody Oscar bait.

I believe I was tricked into feeling I was unpresentable and unworthy of being seen and heard (at the same time) by this and my confidence was affected. I have learned to speak up and engage now but it was a barrier that I should never have had to overcome.

Obvs, I am not blaming all my issues in not being cast in the school play 30 years ago...but I won't pretend it wasn't a factor

Being good at it at 21 doesn’t mean you would have enjoyed it age 9 though. It also doesn’t mean that you weren’t given any opportunity to develop those skills in school.

Wheelz46 · 07/12/2022 22:45

@NosieRosie bet he will be brilliant and do you so proud, my son is non verbal at school and I love going to see him in his school nativity they do each year.

OvaryActions · 07/12/2022 22:45

You should think yourselves lucky you get to see your kids in a play at all 🥺 my son has done one nativity play since starting school. Just one in reception..then Covid came along and put a stop to it and his school never started them up again...same thing with other stuff like the summer fete!

I'd love to see him even just singing in the choir would be nice!!

MostTacticalNameChange · 07/12/2022 22:41

I'm still bitter from my primary school experiences - i was always picked to be an (out of site) narrator - i could be relied upon to learn lines but was too fat, tall and un-blond to be onstage.

My dc wanted roles and would really have benefitted from the experience (I never had a chance to do public speaking on stage until i was 21 and turns out i enjoy it and am good at it) but the popular, obnoxious kids are given 2 or 3 roles in the same play while others are just chorus. Not even on stage. Kids internalise that shit.

Yes, there are loads more important things to worry about, but this is just something free and easy to fix - it's not like parents ay based on performance. There should be a lot more fairness, it's not bloody Oscar bait.

I believe I was tricked into feeling I was unpresentable and unworthy of being seen and heard (at the same time) by this and my confidence was affected. I have learned to speak up and engage now but it was a barrier that I should never have had to overcome.

Obvs, I am not blaming all my issues in not being cast in the school play 30 years ago...but I won't pretend it wasn't a factor

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 07/12/2022 22:41

@NeverDropYourMooncup the school had a stage...

NosieRosie · 07/12/2022 22:41

Dottymug · 07/12/2022 22:21

The only starring role in the Nativity is the Baby Jesus surely?

Baby Jesus has a starting role for sure - even if he doesn’t appreciate it 😂

The best roles are The Innkeeper, The 3 Wise Men, The shepherds, the angels, the city people. All have a line or two. Mary and Joseph are usually given to the quieter (or non verbal) children of the class.

I really don’t get the parent insistence that their child is cast as Mary or Joseph.

My 5 year old GS is Joseph this year. Perfectly cast seeing as he’s non verbal and easily able to sit still for 30 mins.

Id prefer he had a line to say but that’s not possible.‘I’m looking forward to supporting him in his school Christmas concert.

He’s 5.He’ll be amazing 🤩

Confusion101 · 07/12/2022 22:40

@antelopevalley and what if 5 other parents were in telling the teacher how suitable their child was for the part!?

Algor1thm · 07/12/2022 22:40

Every musical has a few main parts, a few medium parts and a chorus. From the West End down to school shows. What were you expecting?

"The same favourites" some people are talking about generally refers to the talented performers. Sorry. There's a reason not every child is chosen to perform a solo.

I'm sure all of the kids got to sing a few songs and have fun. In Y2 my part in the Christmas play was to ring a little bell every time the main character walked on stage. My mum thought it was hilarious and I've made it into adulthood unscarred.

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 22:39

antelopevalley · 07/12/2022 22:37

I am sure some believed me that she did drama. I am not sure they believed me that she is confident on stage as she was so quiet at school. They treated me like a pushy parent.

How could they possibly treat you like a pushy parent if you only ever spoke to them once, then didn’t ever question their poor judgement of your kid? What you’re saying is completely illogical.

Dottymug · 07/12/2022 22:38

That's so sad. Surely parents would want to come and hear their child singing? Are we going to end up with an audience consisting of Mary's Mum and the narrator's?

antelopevalley · 07/12/2022 22:37

I am sure some believed me that she did drama. I am not sure they believed me that she is confident on stage as she was so quiet at school. They treated me like a pushy parent.

catsonahottinroof · 07/12/2022 22:36

I always thought our old primary school did it fairly well, and were catering to individual child's needs, eg those less confident giving non speaking parts. Dd1 with fairly significant special needs yet an excellent speaking voice was often given main parts or narrator, yet other times taken to a classroom to sit out the noisy parts. Dd2, less confident, mostly had minor non speaking parts and I don't think she minded.

Where I think schools could improve is giving parents a heads up on their child's roles. So parents whose child is going to basically have no part but singing along with the chorus can avoid taking a day off work to watch this non event. Also if any child would actually like a bigger part their parents should let the teacher know, as sometimes these quieter children shine when given a chance.

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 22:35

antelopevalley · 07/12/2022 22:34

Different teachers once.

And none of them believed you?

Do you think there’s a common factor here?

antelopevalley · 07/12/2022 22:34

Different teachers once.

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 22:32

antelopevalley · 07/12/2022 22:28

Not sure they believed me. She was quiet at school and always went under the radar.

Why wouldn’t they believe you? It’s hardly something unbelievable. How many times did you tell them?

Smileandtheworldsmileswithyou · 07/12/2022 22:31

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 18:52

Yes I understand that not all children are equal and thr play can't have 45 equal parts but it was the way those who didn't have big parts were basically just sat at the side for an hour while the main characters performed that was so uninclusive.

So how would you have directed the play differently? If the script is as it is, how would you have included the more supporting roles in more scenes if their role wasn’t included in the other scenes? The script will be the script, unless the teacher writes that play what can they do differently? I’m a drama teacher and am about to put on a show this week that is over 2 hours long, this is secondary but we are doing a full length musical and it just is what is it.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 07/12/2022 22:29

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 07/12/2022 22:12

I appreciate that it's not possible for every child to have a speaking part. What I would have appreciated at DDs primary school was that there was a bigger stage so that all the children who were 'the chorus' could actually be seen throughout the performance.

Seven years I went to DDs primary school to watch the same few kids on stage while all the others were down the side somewhere, out of sight... complete waste of time.

Parents don't want an Oscar award winning performance, just a chance to see their children having a bit of fun.

DD didn't particularly want to be in the limelight, but it was really sad when she left primary school and said "7 years I was at that school and not once do they ever pick me for anything..." There wasn't a lot I could say as it was true!

You'd have a fit at the cost of hiring staging. I can't remember the exact amount of the last invoice I signed for (it was about six years ago), but I know it was the best part of a grand for a small thrust and steps to add to the proscenium that already took about 30 all crammed up together.

It's really not a priority for spending, particularly at the moment.

antelopevalley · 07/12/2022 22:28

Not sure they believed me. She was quiet at school and always went under the radar.

Pumperthepumper · 07/12/2022 22:27

antelopevalley · 07/12/2022 22:25

They said she was too quiet and would not cope. They were wrong. She did drama afterschool and was confident on stage but they just ignored me when I said that.
It was always the same kids picked.

They told you your kid was too quiet for the stage, even though they knew she did external drama classes?

Wheelz46 · 07/12/2022 22:26

Many children don't want a large part or a speaking part and some would much prefer to sit there quietly, it's about being part of the production, not how many lines you have or how many times you appear on stage.

Of course, if there are multiple children who wish to have a leading role, they need to be allocated fairly. Kids also need to learn we don't always get what we want. Like sports days, you are always going to get the sporty ones, who win most events and that's fine, again it's the taking part or being apart of the production or event that matters.

My eldest child has always loved being up there, performing in front of people, he has done both leading roles and non verbal roles and he was absolutely fine with that.

My youngest is extremely anxious in such settings and would never stand up on stage and talk or sing or whatever. He always gets the role of sitting at the side, back or wherever and that's what he would prefer.

I tell both my boys, how proud I am of them after their productions and I am always proud of them equally however big or small their roles are.

antelopevalley · 07/12/2022 22:26

Just realised I answered a question not aimed at me, sorry.

antelopevalley · 07/12/2022 22:25

SweetSakura · 07/12/2022 22:20

But it's clear from this thread that if she had tried to raise it then teachers would have sneered at her as a pushy parent

They said she was too quiet and would not cope. They were wrong. She did drama afterschool and was confident on stage but they just ignored me when I said that.
It was always the same kids picked.