I honestly never chose a child on whether they were pretty or not.
Loud yes, as many schools don't have the budget for decent microphones.
Generally you ask, but get the answers you expected anyway. Shy kids don't want main parts etc.
When I was an nqt I do remember trying to get a child to do one line because I didn't want him to feel left out. No matter how much encouragement he was given he hated it and I had to accept that it wasn't in his interest to be forced to do it. He kept a mimed part in rehearsals that we could do without if he got stage fright and refused to go on. Which he did.
What I have seen sadly is kids with arsehole complainy parents, who demand their child has a starring role, despite no drive, interest etc being given a role they don't bother learning the lines for and taking away from a child more keen but with nicer parents.
Every time I did a play some parent always tried to use it as an excuse to bully me or suggest I lose my job. Along with every other single thing I did in teaching that benefited their children. Clubs, parents evening, reports, concerts.
It's not the number one reason I left teaching but all these things add up and I will never go back and that's the loss of yet another trained teacher.
I'm sure the dregs they replace us with will pander to your whims though. Bravo.