Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nativity disappointment why do teachers do it

417 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 18:42

Want to key stage 2 nativity today. It was 1 hour long! Approx 40 kids in it. Some children had multiple lines throughout the hour, on the stage for the bulk of the time, solo songs the works. Others had just one line and spent the rest of the time sitting to the side apart from group songs where they all stood up. I understand all parts cant be equal and it must be a nightmare to try and be fair but this was shockingly poorly distrubuted. Why would you do this as a teacher? So disappointing for the children and parents unless you happen to be one of the "stars" of the show.

OP posts:
steppemum · 08/12/2022 12:55

Just to be controversial, I am going to look at this from another point of view.

Every bloody year dd2 was the narrator.
Why? because

  1. she can learn or read stacks of lines easily
  2. she says those lines in a loud clear voice that can be heard at the back of the room (probably one of only 3 children in her year group could do this at that age)
  3. they knew she would be there to every rehearsal and every evening performance.
dd2 hated it. She wanted a proper part, to be on the stage not at the side doing narrator bits, and more than anything, she wnated a 'proper costume'

In reception when she was the narrator, I asked her teacher if there was a costume for the narrator, and (amazing lady that she was) she saw the problem very quickly and said - I think the narrator should be in a sparkling party dress, do you think you have one of those dd2?
problem solved.

I wouldn't be the casting director for anything.

Goldenbear · 08/12/2022 12:51

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot I've literally just said I don't work for the schools I work with them and so I am not 'staff' so I doubt you've ever worked i a school with staff who are onsite consultants- how does that work then with their abundant budgets! I do advise admin team members in schools sometimes, all of whom seem very busy, who again you obviously feel superior to- im not entirely sure why you would think the Head's PA should be working as hard as a Head of curricular teacher for about 2/3rds of their pay, renumeration doesn't work like that. I work with children and their parents quite a bit actually often the disgruntled ones as they want a Subject Access Request response when their initial request to the school has not been answered. If only my workload was manageable, I have noted how school's are not very good at planning, always fire fighting so as a consultant that makes things very tricky making the workload of everyone 10 times what it needs to be of only a bit of planning was carried out!

Anyway, I was answering in my capacity as a parent, I think it is unfortunate that the weary cynicism dominates thee educational workplace as it enslaves people and they are not receptive to change or ideas just see it as criticism.

Well I have never heard of the parent/client reference, it sounds like BS as has no value in the meaningful sense of the word, proven by posts on this thread that schools really don't want to hear anything from parents!

twoshedsjackson · 08/12/2022 12:41

My sympathies to all the disappointed ones.
When I was teaching, my job was note-bashing the songs; other people dealt with casting etc., and I heard a remark I still remember from this.
As I launched onto singing practice, Year 2 excitedly told me of their given roles, until one glum little soul, when asked by me, replied, "Nothing; I'm just A People"

stargirl1701 · 08/12/2022 12:29

The teacher has to choose children who are capable of behaving appropriately, learning lines and speaking loudly and confidently on stage in front of an audience.

Some children are confident but very silly. Some children can learn lines but have quiet voices that cannot be heard. Some children are loud but cannot learn lines.

ilovesooty · 08/12/2022 12:24

Goldenbear · 08/12/2022 12:04

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot

'Made up', so data protection law doesn't exist and my advice and work hasn't stopped te schools being fined huge amounts from potentially serious data breaches. Ok then, I mean, you do realise that 'data' and it's protection/security in a school are quite key to the school running or even opening no don't you? Don't answer that I know the answer already. I am paid appallingly for the work I do but luckily for me I don't 'rely' on it ancan jump ship quite easily. When you thought I worked in school you assumed it was in a support staff capacity like a TA and referred to my 'unqualified arse', really exuding 'respect' there for your old fellow colleagues so anyone unqualified does not deserve your respect?

Again, you clearly have no clue about other jobs, as an Architect doing public consultations you can definitely get 'lots' of abuse from members of the public that don't like what you do, my DH has been physically threatened. If money is at stake people can get very arsey indeed. Way more than parents asking why for the 4th year running their child is overlooked. Of course teachers deal with lots of annoying people but the grass is not always greener and the parents aren't clients expecting certain deadlines and profit.

Of course the parents are encouraged to think of themselves as clients in state schools.

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot · 08/12/2022 12:17

No I didn't think you were a ta. I thought you were admin or consultants who have far too much to say and complain about working hard all the time whilst doing a very manageable workload.

I referred to your unqualified arse because you are not qualified to teach yet think you know it all.

It's certainly a pattern I've observed in staff of your type. Minimal contact with kids and parents and think you have all the solutions.

tunthebloodyalarmoff · 08/12/2022 12:16

Yep and it's always the same kids that get the star parts. Really unfair and annoying to

chocolatemademefat · 08/12/2022 12:08

When my sons were at school the only way to get a decent part in anything was to have a parent who was in the teaching profession. The amount of sucking up that went on among them was stomach churning.

Goldenbear · 08/12/2022 12:04

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot

'Made up', so data protection law doesn't exist and my advice and work hasn't stopped te schools being fined huge amounts from potentially serious data breaches. Ok then, I mean, you do realise that 'data' and it's protection/security in a school are quite key to the school running or even opening no don't you? Don't answer that I know the answer already. I am paid appallingly for the work I do but luckily for me I don't 'rely' on it ancan jump ship quite easily. When you thought I worked in school you assumed it was in a support staff capacity like a TA and referred to my 'unqualified arse', really exuding 'respect' there for your old fellow colleagues so anyone unqualified does not deserve your respect?

Again, you clearly have no clue about other jobs, as an Architect doing public consultations you can definitely get 'lots' of abuse from members of the public that don't like what you do, my DH has been physically threatened. If money is at stake people can get very arsey indeed. Way more than parents asking why for the 4th year running their child is overlooked. Of course teachers deal with lots of annoying people but the grass is not always greener and the parents aren't clients expecting certain deadlines and profit.

lieselotte · 08/12/2022 12:00

And to be perfectly honest, teachers choose the children who they know
will learn the lines with help from home
will turn up to every rehearsal
will actually turn up to evening performances
it is stressful enough putting on these shows without clock watching and worrying that your main characters will turn up on time, if at all

And the ones they like. Lets not pretend that some teachers don't like some children and won't use them for main parts even if they are the best. It doesn't happen with sporting events so much, if a kid is good at a certain sport they'll get picked, but with things like plays it does.

I doubt very much that things have changed that much from when I was at school - human nature certainly hasn't.

Dixiechickonhols · 08/12/2022 12:00

My mum had this in a play school she ran - they were 2. It was a summer event and she chose who was being which part. One girls mum was so cross and said well she better have a decent part in the nativity.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 08/12/2022 11:58

Cos if they did it equally it would be like when you tell a class to each read 5 lines of Hamlet.

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot · 08/12/2022 11:53

State schools lag behind private schools because of cohort intake and fiddling results.

Volume, willingness to learn lines, parental involvement, child preference are all perfectly acceptable ways to cast a play.

Goldenbear · 08/12/2022 11:48

The OP doesn't sound pushy sounds involved. No wonder state schools lag behind private schools when it comes to developing children's potential, they just seem to take easy root. Most children by year 5/6 are bothered but if they are not being obnoxious are just left with the lesser parts as it is not as easy to placate the obnoxious kids. Or usually, it is the obnoxious kids that are loud and they are trying to channel this in to something productive as in the classroom they are a bloody nightmare! Since when was loudness the only requirement for good acting!

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot · 08/12/2022 11:43

@Goldenbear sounds like your made up, no doubt highly overpaid job requires some poor mugs to be teachers.
Carry on contributing to the disrespect and dismissal of conditions leading to teacher retention, I am sure the education sector you rely on will run smoothly without them.

And in no way does an architect get the kind of abuse and venom teachers do. What planet are you on?

shasha21 · 08/12/2022 11:39

You sound like a bit of a pushy parent TBH. To a small child, any role is a bit deal and these performances are exciting for them. They build confidence and feel proud of themselves. It’s not meant to be about the parents 🙄 It’s for the children! Nobody cares how big your child’s role is so just let the child enjoy the experience!

Goldenbear · 08/12/2022 11:38

Manner not 'Manor'

Goldenbear · 08/12/2022 11:37

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot

'Unqualified arse', what are you on about I very much doubt I'll be asked to cover lessons in a school considering I don't work for the school, I think my 'actual' employer may have something to say about that! I'm a consultant in data protection and cyber security, I work 'with' schools in the Education sector and believe me when I say with a Masters degree and professional qualifications that you need to work in this area I'm far from 'unqualified'- however I am told on a daily basis how to do my job by the highly knowledgeable school staff, that 'are' unqualified in my field of work and have a worryingly bad grasp of concepts and the law. In all honesty, with my knowledge and experience, I really don't need to take the shit either but I do for now as I appreciate they are often under pressure and are time poor - there you go that's how you do 'flexibility'!

From friends/family that work an array of jobs, everyone has challenges and suggestions given to them. My DH works as an Architect and has to do public consultations where all manor of feedback is launched at him, deals with very unhappy clients sometimes, this is the world of work it isn't just teaching!

DailyMailReporterTellMeAllYourSecrets · 08/12/2022 11:36

Absolutely agree with PPs who say that
not everyone wants to be star of the show. I loved playing the Angel Gabriel, and even had a solo, but DS only ever wanted to be in the chorus. He was an elephant once weirdly

ChristmasNoodles · 08/12/2022 11:19

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 18:42

Want to key stage 2 nativity today. It was 1 hour long! Approx 40 kids in it. Some children had multiple lines throughout the hour, on the stage for the bulk of the time, solo songs the works. Others had just one line and spent the rest of the time sitting to the side apart from group songs where they all stood up. I understand all parts cant be equal and it must be a nightmare to try and be fair but this was shockingly poorly distrubuted. Why would you do this as a teacher? So disappointing for the children and parents unless you happen to be one of the "stars" of the show.

Op. I agree with you. I think they should try to pick a play that has a few lines for most kids even if there are bigger and smaller roles. They do exist.

In DD's class they do ask for preferences but also take the kids' ability into account. Apparently they also take.into account who has played what in previous years.

What I like is that apart from the main roles (which is about 4-5 kids) most other kids have roughly the same number of lines, ie everyone has at least two lines except for two kids but dd said they explicitly asked for non speaking roles. In fact in the play I saw that one of them did have a line after all (which was added just for her. It wasn't in the script). I'm not sure if the parents intervened or the teacher insisted. More importantly, I could see from the script that the teacher had actually reassigned some of the lines to make it a bit fairer and also.some individual lines were spoken by several people to ensure that everyone speaks at least two lines.

I disagree with people that most kids wouldn't want a speaking or significant role. I suspect even the shy ones might like one but are too shy to ask for it. And even if they don't I think trying to overcome your fears is a great learning experience and almost more.important than anything else they learn. A school play is a great opportunity to teach kids public speaking skills.

And yes, it's good for kids to learn about disappointment and how to deal with it but I don't necessarily agree that it's good to treat children unfairly or to favour some kids just so the others learn how to deal with nepotism. Do you want to teach them that nepotism is how the world works? Or that those who shout the loudest only get what they want and everyone else has to suck it up?

I also think it's vital that kids who aren't that confident get a chance to learn how to speak in front of others. Being able to speak in front of others is a skill that will help them immensely in all walks of life and at all ages. Who cares if some of the kids don't speak that clearly, can't sing or fluff their lines? It's a school play not a west end production. The parents will be happy just seeing their kids perform.

If you have two or more classes I think.itw fine to give the older class more screen time as the you get class will get their chance in the next year but within a class it's a terrible idea to give the larger roles always to the older ones. What kind of.message does that send? (DD is born end of August so by that logic she'd always end up being a brick or tree or something.for the rest of her school.career).

I understand it's hard for teachers and lot of work goes into this but I think if the end result is a very unfair ajd divisive production it might be better to not do.anything at all as an overtly unfair play does more harm than good and teaches the kids only bad things.

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot · 08/12/2022 10:59

Well firstly feedback is always wrong. Parents saying I'm nearing for not teaching Eyfs children column addition. That their child can read or comprehend better than is evidenced. That their child didn't do xyz because they are 'good' and for a bizarre reason I must have planted evidence to catch them red handed. Parents that called the police because their child lost their pencil case was a good one.

I left quite frankly because I was basically abused and bullied and no amount trying to be flexible makes that ok.

Teachers are leaving in droves, it can't be because they're all not as fabulously flexible as you.

But good luck when your unqualified arse is asked to find cover or fill the gaps. Hope it's not too challenging.

Goldenbear · 08/12/2022 10:53

To not 'too'.

Goldenbear · 08/12/2022 10:52

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot

I'm not sure why a bit of feedback is such an afront to teachers, most jobs have people telling you how you can change things, try a different approach, ask you too be flexible. I work in education but I'm not a teacher and I'm always being told by teachers how to do my job, they don't havve the first clue but I still take on board what they are saying to see if I can make life easier for them.

Goldenbear · 08/12/2022 10:37

Pumperthepumper, my goodness, again, why are you misusing quotation marks when I didn't say any such thing. Neither did I say the Nativity was the only time to step out of the comfort zone, you are a great writer of fiction- the stuff you are coming out with, perhaps you are, after all very skilled at writing the school Nativity! So defensive when there really is no need.

Orangebadger · 08/12/2022 10:08

faffadoodledo · 08/12/2022 07:53

Don't worry OP. I had a reticent one. Always shrunk into the background or was elbowed aside. She now lectures post grads at a prestigious institution and gives presentations to big cheeses. She's only 24.
When I think of her at infant school I'm frankly amazed at what she does now!

I love to read this! My DD is many wonderful things but performing is not one of them! So I always like to read about others who were similar who have gone on to be confident well adjusted women and shine in their own way.