Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nativity disappointment why do teachers do it

417 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 18:42

Want to key stage 2 nativity today. It was 1 hour long! Approx 40 kids in it. Some children had multiple lines throughout the hour, on the stage for the bulk of the time, solo songs the works. Others had just one line and spent the rest of the time sitting to the side apart from group songs where they all stood up. I understand all parts cant be equal and it must be a nightmare to try and be fair but this was shockingly poorly distrubuted. Why would you do this as a teacher? So disappointing for the children and parents unless you happen to be one of the "stars" of the show.

OP posts:
LamaRama · 07/12/2022 19:40

When we did this across the two Y2 classes every single child had a line- yes, some had main parts, but all children had a line. I personally think that’s important to give everyone a little go at speaking in front of an audience, learn a line, however short, and perform. At my DC’s former school it was different, there the teacher’s kid got the main part. And some didn’t get any lines at all. I think in KS1 as a minimum everyone should ‘have a go’.

Tinseltosser · 07/12/2022 19:39

RosaGallica · 07/12/2022 19:35

I have to say I think this is something my kids’ school does quite well. I don’t see eye to eye with them about other things, but literally every child had something to do in ours. They always had plays or just nativity where they could say ‘stars came out’ or ‘camels rode to someplace’ or ‘toy robots and dolls for the baby’ and therdd Ed would be a couple or few children dressed as everything who would get their chance to do a a spin or special dance across the floor. Not all speaking, but that’s not s as good thing for everyone. Doesn’t everyone do something like that?

That sounds lovely and definitely would be preferable to the borefest we had to sit through today with just under a third getting to actually dress up/talk/sing/move around the stage.

Fantastic for the children/parents who got to participate, but a misery for the rest of us sat there for nearly an hour.

Not sure why saying this is being taken as an attack on teachers though?

twelly · 07/12/2022 19:39

I think it is interesting in terms of school plays. At one of my children's school the year 6 play just before covid involved every child - fine but the lead parts were not given to the children who were the best. The teacher even said this. My view is that the same then needs to be applied for sports teams - don't always select the best.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 07/12/2022 19:38

We ask the kids who wants a speaking part. Just because the parent wants them to be the star of the show doesn’t mean the child wants to. Also not all children have the support at home to learn lines, songs, etc. Some are too frightened to speak in front of an audience. Some have additional support needs that you can’t see from the audience.

JudgeJ · 07/12/2022 19:37

Tinseltosser · 07/12/2022 19:28

Argh, as someone from a ethnic background, this is why we laugh at white peoples kids

Wow.

That is incredibly unpleasant and racist. Laughing at children of a certain colour because you are stereotyping?

Had someone said they laughed at black kids this post would have been reported but white people are fair game apparently.
I cannot believe that the poster has never encountered over-ambitious parents from her own back-ground. In my first teaching job in a school with a very multi-racial population we were advised to be careful when writing reports of anything that could be construed that a child wasn't trying hard enough, there had been serious consequences for some children.

itsgettingweird · 07/12/2022 19:37

My ds was always in the music cupboard starting and stopping the music.

He wanted that part.

He hated it even when his role was to sit at the side because there was an audience.

I went every year to cheer on the play. Cheer on every child. Celebrate every child's successes and part.

I always found the children who enjoyed it the most seemed to be those in the chorus who got to wear various hats they'd made for various group songs!

clopper · 07/12/2022 19:36

Years ago my DD got picked to say a few lines as Angel Gabriel because she was a good reader. She was so stressed at 5/6 that she couldn’t sleep at night for worrying about it. In the end, her friend also got dressed up and stood next to her whilst she said the words. I’m in two minds about it, maybe they should get a different group or class to be on stage for each song? This tends to happen in my school where 80 kids might be involved, so each class has its own special song and actions on the stage.

RosaGallica · 07/12/2022 19:36

Sorry for typos!

RosaGallica · 07/12/2022 19:35

I have to say I think this is something my kids’ school does quite well. I don’t see eye to eye with them about other things, but literally every child had something to do in ours. They always had plays or just nativity where they could say ‘stars came out’ or ‘camels rode to someplace’ or ‘toy robots and dolls for the baby’ and therdd Ed would be a couple or few children dressed as everything who would get their chance to do a a spin or special dance across the floor. Not all speaking, but that’s not s as good thing for everyone. Doesn’t everyone do something like that?

Tinseltosser · 07/12/2022 19:35

MargotChateau · 07/12/2022 19:32

think I touched a nerve 🤣 Also don’t worry I’d never teach in a million years, reading mumsnet and the ridiculous things posters complain about the poor teachers, why would you in this country, a thankless task with so many entitled parents

It tends to touch a nerve when someone is being viciously unpleasant and racist about young children yes.

Dottymug · 07/12/2022 19:35

I'm really not sure why teachers bother. Every year, some parents will find something to complain about. Too much pressure on the children/not enough lines for MY child, poorly rehearsed performance/too much time out of lessons, it's on too late at night/I can't come in the afternoon, etc etc etc.

Mred22 · 07/12/2022 19:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I find the last para of your message somewhat offensive.

What racism is this: "...this is why we laugh at white peoples kids"?

I can assure you my parents taught me the value of hard work and I in turn have instilled in my children an ethos of "you get what you work for".

It is wrong to make sweeping generalisations especially on ethnic grounds (imagine if those comments were made with the word white changed to black).

Please edit or ask MN to delete your post.

arethereanyleftatall · 07/12/2022 19:34

Jesus Christ on a cracker.

Give up now teachers! Well, I know you are, and mostly, it's nothing to do with the pay, it's this shit.

They cannot win!! Already on mumsnet this year, we've had someone complaining about every possible thing the teachers could have done for the nativity...too many lines. Not enough lines. Too early. Too late. Siblings making noise. No siblings. Not enough like the nativity. Too like the nativity. Can't get the costume. Pfb has to wear scuzzy costume from last year.

Stop. Complaining. About. Everything. Before. There's. No. Teachers. Left.

saraclara · 07/12/2022 19:34

Exactly. It's not that hard!

@Bucketheadbucketbum I suggest that you become a teacher. Because clearly you know MUCH better than they do.

And MNers wonders why teachers get so defensive on this site. Seriously, people like you, OP, don't have the first clue how stressful it is getting a Christmas performance to parents in place and looking decent. On top of, you know, actually teaching.

bloodyplanes · 07/12/2022 19:34

MargotChateau · 07/12/2022 19:32

think I touched a nerve 🤣 Also don’t worry I’d never teach in a million years, reading mumsnet and the ridiculous things posters complain about the poor teachers, why would you in this country, a thankless task with so many entitled parents

Yeah well being racist will touch a nerve with most people

Exhausteddog · 07/12/2022 19:32

I could have predicted throughout all of DDs and DS primary school who would get key parts same kids year in year out. Same as it was at my own primary.
The only time it changed was when one of the predicted main characters left!

MargotChateau · 07/12/2022 19:32

think I touched a nerve 🤣 Also don’t worry I’d never teach in a million years, reading mumsnet and the ridiculous things posters complain about the poor teachers, why would you in this country, a thankless task with so many entitled parents

Goldenbear · 07/12/2022 19:31

My DD's junior school incorporated musical instrument performances so that it was inclusive, one boy last year played a piece on tjje trumpet that seemed to only be one note- that was interesting, his own Mum was sniggering but I don't think he saw.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/12/2022 19:31

Trouble is talking in front of a crowd is a good life skill even if the kids hate it.

There is something in this. I’m not saying the kids who really hate it, but there is a “middle” group of children who could probably find something they hadn’t realised that was in them if encouraged. I realise a nativity is a nightmare, but the teachers must get to know the kids quite well and have an idea who could do with a little push.

I think as long as all kids have the chance to shine at something during the course of the year, it’s fine for a nativity to be a bit “uneven”. They do all need to learn to deal with disappointment but if some kids are forever disappointed, they’ll learn the opposite lesson, which is not to try.

Maybe pick the ones who aren’t going to get into the play or the sports team for something else, given them the friendship award, anything so they feel they’ve got something.

Also some kids may not be great readers but are good memorisers of lines.

GuyFawkesDay · 07/12/2022 19:31

The end of a monster 15 week term, teachers are on their knees and this is the thanks they get.

And then we wonder why no bugger will train to do the job 🙄

SweetSakura · 07/12/2022 19:31

The best shows I have seen have been pretty much a line a child. No superstars, and pushes the shy ones out of their comfort zone without giving them such big parts it's excruciating to watch them.

My daughter's teacher has gone down the social engineering route this year and given the shy children the big parts and it sounds like the rehearsals are a nightmare as noone can hear them at all

DrMarciaFieldstone · 07/12/2022 19:29

@MargotChateau what?!!

There are many precious parents, ethnicity has F all to do with it.

saraclara · 07/12/2022 19:29

No one cares if the child fluffs a line or two,

The child does, though.

CatSeany · 07/12/2022 19:29

I don't have any personal experience of this because my kids aren't old enough, but I saw a little girl whilst collecting my son from nursery who was devastated at only having one line in the nativity. I actually felt really sad for her, she was sobbing her heart out. I know it can't be completely equal, but it feels sad that someone who wants more than one line can't at least have a few lines.

Goldenbear · 07/12/2022 19:28

MargotChateau, bit of sweeping generalisation there!🙄