Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nativity disappointment why do teachers do it

417 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 07/12/2022 18:42

Want to key stage 2 nativity today. It was 1 hour long! Approx 40 kids in it. Some children had multiple lines throughout the hour, on the stage for the bulk of the time, solo songs the works. Others had just one line and spent the rest of the time sitting to the side apart from group songs where they all stood up. I understand all parts cant be equal and it must be a nightmare to try and be fair but this was shockingly poorly distrubuted. Why would you do this as a teacher? So disappointing for the children and parents unless you happen to be one of the "stars" of the show.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AnotherLogOnTheFire · 11/12/2022 00:40

jamira · 10/12/2022 20:25

Well said @ancientgran - proof that it can be done in a way that prioritises a happy and inclusive event, rather than focusing on the 'quality' of the performance.

Absolutely - it’s focusing on the quality of the performance that seems to be the source of the issue.

jamira · 10/12/2022 20:25

Well said @ancientgran - proof that it can be done in a way that prioritises a happy and inclusive event, rather than focusing on the 'quality' of the performance.

ancientgran · 10/12/2022 20:21

Dottymug · 10/12/2022 16:37

It isn’t possible to please every parent. It just isn’t. The only thing that would make some parents happy would be if their child was doing a monologue in the spotlight throughout. Just go along, clap enthusiastically and praise your child, whether they were the star or the donkey’s backside. Almost invariably the children will be delighted with themselves if you are.

My GCs nativity the other day was inclusive, parents were all happy, children were all happy. I was there saw the parents crowding round teachers and it was all positive. There weren't any stars, all kids were included. It wasn't perfect in the sense that the performances were worthy of an Oscar, kids fluffed lines, missed cues etc but it was perfect in that everyone enjoyed it.

I think the only reason parents might want a monologue from their child is if they've sat through the monologues from the favourites for years.

It isn't true that children will invariably be delighted with themselves if the parents praise them. I've heard children replying that it was rubbish and they did nothing.

Your school might not go for the epic performance with the tried and trusted few but schools do it and children do get upset. I've seen both types of schools and performances and the difference is stark. It isn't all schools, it isn't all teachers but for the children who constantly feel left out it is painful.

AnotherLogOnTheFire · 10/12/2022 19:06

antelopevalley · 10/12/2022 16:28

@Dottymug I do not think teachers are lazy. But neither do all schools or teachers do as you suggest.

I didn't think my dc's teacher was lazy either - I think she could have done with a chill pill - she behaved like it was a Broadway musical - the stress on the kids was unbearable - they all let her down - frequently and didn't she let them know it!

Dottymug · 10/12/2022 16:37

It isn’t possible to please every parent. It just isn’t. The only thing that would make some parents happy would be if their child was doing a monologue in the spotlight throughout. Just go along, clap enthusiastically and praise your child, whether they were the star or the donkey’s backside. Almost invariably the children will be delighted with themselves if you are.

antelopevalley · 10/12/2022 16:28

@Dottymug I do not think teachers are lazy. But neither do all schools or teachers do as you suggest.

DisneyChops · 10/12/2022 10:52

What ever happened to parents just enjoying seeing their child dressed up?
Get a grip.

Dottymug · 10/12/2022 10:46

Teachers have been horribly maligned on this thread by some posters. If we were lazy we’d be doing another job and we certainly wouldn’t be arsed putting on Christmas plays. And you have no idea what you’re talking about if you think teachers favour the loud confident kids. I taught for many years and my ‘favourites’ were usually the neglected children who were never going to get a big part because of behaviour issues or because weren’t able to remember lines or had really poor attendance. The Nativity play is a massive amount of work for teachers and in these entitled times it seems to please very few parents so why schools continue to bother I don’t know.

Itaintwhatyoudoitsthewaythatyoudoit · 09/12/2022 15:50

ancientgran · 09/12/2022 15:04

And it is fine not to want to join in, it isn't fine to never get the chance if you want it.

This I agree with this. Some kids just need some encouragement but it’s far easier for the organisers of these shows to pick an already confident kid. It’s a shame as it makes the less confident ones believe they aren’t good enough. It’s an incredibly easy and lazy excuse to say they are too quiet etc. My kids to be told they can do it before they start believing in themselves. There was a time their hands would shoot up to he chosen but when repeatedly passed over, tell themselves they are no good.

If the group organisers are unable to give everyone at least one speaking line, then they shouldn’t bother doing them at all. Parents attend to support their own children, not just a few select kids.

ancientgran · 09/12/2022 15:04

Sartre · 09/12/2022 14:27

I watched my DD’s last ever nativity last night (year 6) and she stood at the back with a massive grump on looking like she’d rather be anywhere else. I took videos because it’s really funny and it will be hilarious to look back on when she’s older. There’s a group of children in front of her really getting into it, dancing with huge grins on their faces and she looks like someone just told her Santa died.

Some kids really don’t want to be star of the show or even in the show at all, my DD hated it.

And it is fine not to want to join in, it isn't fine to never get the chance if you want it.

Sartre · 09/12/2022 14:27

I watched my DD’s last ever nativity last night (year 6) and she stood at the back with a massive grump on looking like she’d rather be anywhere else. I took videos because it’s really funny and it will be hilarious to look back on when she’s older. There’s a group of children in front of her really getting into it, dancing with huge grins on their faces and she looks like someone just told her Santa died.

Some kids really don’t want to be star of the show or even in the show at all, my DD hated it.

FancyFanny · 09/12/2022 14:23

I'm the parent of a professional dancer, probably the most successful performer to ever come out of her primary and secondary school, and yet she was overlooked every year in favour of the super-confident show-offs

But how does being a professional dancer make her right for the lead in a school play- that's where you need a confident show off!

pinneddownbytabbies · 09/12/2022 14:17

saraclara · 08/12/2022 15:53

So many excellent teachers clearly going to waste on this thread. If only some of them would train, get qualified and fill the gaps left by those who've been ground down by those parents who do nothing but criticise them.

I'm the parent of a professional dancer, probably the most successful performer to ever come out of her primary and secondary school, and yet she was overlooked every year in favour of the super-confident show-offs.

I've also been a chaperone for child performers in both amateur and professional theatre performances, and once went on a training course for directors at the ROH. I've also done theatrical make-up, and numerous amateur performances myself. Not only that, I have watched numerous junior auditions for professional productions, and have got to know what is required.

I also once judged a talent contest.

I don't want to be a school teacher. If someone asked me to help them with casting, them I would happily oblige. What I would like is for (certain) teachers to stop having favourites, stop overlooking what is under their nose, and give those kids a chance to prove themselves. If teachers can't bring themselves to do that, then they are in the wrong job.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 09/12/2022 13:40

ancientgran · 09/12/2022 09:54

If a girl was Mary in year 1, she wouldn’t be given that part in year 2 etc.

That is exactly the sort of thing that is easy to do and would make a difference. I have wondered if a teacher in say year 3 realises that James and Kate have had the lead parts in reception, year 1 and year 2 so it would be appropriate to let someone else do it this year.

100%

OP posts:
ancientgran · 09/12/2022 09:54

If a girl was Mary in year 1, she wouldn’t be given that part in year 2 etc.

That is exactly the sort of thing that is easy to do and would make a difference. I have wondered if a teacher in say year 3 realises that James and Kate have had the lead parts in reception, year 1 and year 2 so it would be appropriate to let someone else do it this year.

7eleven · 08/12/2022 22:19

After over 20 years of teaching, I’ve been involved in a lot of plays! Children have always been asked what sort of role they want and quiet ones encouraged to give it a go. Everyone got on the stage at one point, either to dance or say a line. I do think that’s nice for the children and the family.

If a girl was Mary in year 1, she wouldn’t be given that part in year 2 etc.

Auditions always took place in Year 6 for the main parts. One memorable year, a parent came in and demanded to see the the notes and scores from the auditions, as he couldn’t believe his child hadn’t got a main part. Eyes we’re rolling aplenty about that prat 🙄

FancyFanny · 08/12/2022 22:04

We've been practising our Christmas show today- no acting but all classes singing a song each, reading poems, playing instruments etc. etc. Front row today was five year 6 boys- none of them singing or joining in, smirking at each other, hands in pockets... you get the picture. We'll be hiding them at the back for sure for the actual performance where nobody can see them- I wonder if their parents will be on here complaining their child never gets a main part and is always sitting where they can't see them???

MargaretThursday · 08/12/2022 21:53

Pumperthepumper · 08/12/2022 21:27

Next time say your kid doesn’t want a big part then, and let one of the other kids have a go. Job done!

With dd1 she'd had a number of big parts (3/4 of the junior Christmas shows, not the main, but a good part each time, and the majority of her year hadn't even had a part, just were choir each time) and so when it came to the year 6 play, we talked about it, and went in together and requested she didn't have a big part because she'd more than had her turn.

They gave her the main part and said if she wouldn't do it, she wouldn't be in the play. She was good, she was reliable, but I'm sure there were several others who would have done as well. I didn't really get their reasoning.

I proposed to the school (juniors) that they should make sure that each Christmas play had enough parts for 1/4 of the year (150 children total, so around 40 parts) to have some sort of part with at least one line. Then there should be a list and each child ticked off as they have a part, so every child should have had a part for one show. Then the year 6 play done by audition. I thought that was fair.
They didn't take my suggestion.
I thought it was both sensible and practical. It wouldn't have taken too much to have a list they ticked off every year. And it would have encouraged them to change from having one shepherd with 20 lines to having 10 with 2, for example which, when you have 150 kids for parts, is far better.

I think every child should be able to go home and say "my part is XXX". What they had was normally about 10 children with big parts and 15 with little, and 120 who were "choir" wearing, on a good year, a Christmas hat with school uniform.

Pumperthepumper · 08/12/2022 21:27

Bucketheadbucketbum · 08/12/2022 20:58

This sounds absolutely lovely and was what I had expected. It was just really eye opening to see they had decided to do a show that had parts which were either stars or very obviously rejected fillers

Makes Mr nervous about the whole ethos of the place

Next time say your kid doesn’t want a big part then, and let one of the other kids have a go. Job done!

Bucketheadbucketbum · 08/12/2022 20:58

ancientgran · 08/12/2022 20:20

Absolutely. It was so lovely to see them all. The whole atmosphere was brilliant and I just felt it showed what a supportive and caring environment that school is. That's why I made a point of finding some of the staff to say how good it was and what a brilliant job they'd done.

Contrast with my older GCs school when he was in primary. He had a leading if not the leading role in every play for 7 years, one at Christmas and one in the summer. Class assembly he was always a reader and then some kids never got a look in there were two girls in his class who were the same. I was proud of him but to be honest in the end I felt embarrassed.

This sounds absolutely lovely and was what I had expected. It was just really eye opening to see they had decided to do a show that had parts which were either stars or very obviously rejected fillers

Makes Mr nervous about the whole ethos of the place

OP posts:
hookiewookie29 · 08/12/2022 20:41

OnlyFannys · 07/12/2022 18:49

My ds desperately wanted a good part and he got one bloody line 🙄 the usual favourites got the big part its ridiculous

Same at our school. It became a running joke. " Ooh let's guess who will get the main parts thus year.....". Always the same one's. My daughter auditioned every year. She was lucky if she got one line. She desperately wanted a good part in her year 6 leavers play. She had to audition in front of the whole class,which was a big thing for her...and she got one line. I understand that many kids are happy with that, but when there are others who desperately want to be given a chance and don't get it, then it's annoying

JubileeTrifle · 08/12/2022 20:31

Wait until year 6 and you realise it’s the same 3/4 children being given the parts every fucking year.
DD would have liked a part, is very well behaved, had 100% attendance, spoke very nicely and clearly. So she was in the ‘choir’ for 5 years.
Year 5/6 the show is actually at night. Year 6 I didn’t send her. I was sick of going, seeing the same kids, never even seeing her face.

We had alternative plans and i chose them over it. Teacher had a go at DD and I left a message that I would be happy to explain why she wasn’t going and if he wanted to complain to do it to me not to a child.

Nursery teacher was great and arranged it so at least you saw your child, everyone was on stage for at least a minute. There’s a point if you want parents to support things you have to give them what they want, which is to see their child at least when you’ve begged work to be there.

ancientgran · 08/12/2022 20:20

SweetSakura · 08/12/2022 18:47

That's how it should be done. No superstars. No sidelined children.

Absolutely. It was so lovely to see them all. The whole atmosphere was brilliant and I just felt it showed what a supportive and caring environment that school is. That's why I made a point of finding some of the staff to say how good it was and what a brilliant job they'd done.

Contrast with my older GCs school when he was in primary. He had a leading if not the leading role in every play for 7 years, one at Christmas and one in the summer. Class assembly he was always a reader and then some kids never got a look in there were two girls in his class who were the same. I was proud of him but to be honest in the end I felt embarrassed.

Pumperthepumper · 08/12/2022 20:13

antelopevalley · 08/12/2022 16:00

No need for the snark. This is not about being a teacher. It is about understanding how important this is to a child and allocating roles fairly. Some schools do this, some do not.

Or do you think all the PE teachers who used to get kids to choose team members leaving the same kids to the end every time were also right because they were trained teachers?

Things that some teachers see as minor can really impact on children. Like the teacher on this thread who said all young kids are thrilled to get a part and don't notice who has a bigger part. They are wrong. I know. I did not care what parts my DD got, she noticed and cared a lot and got upset about it from a young age.

If she was really that upset that’s when you (her parent) should have stepped in.

SweetSakura · 08/12/2022 18:47

ancientgran · 08/12/2022 16:47

Just been to a bloody brilliant school Christmas play, reception and year 1. Every child had their moment at front of stage, some in twos or threes, some in a group of five, maybe one line each, maybe singing a verse with the rest of the children joining in the chorus. Not one child had more than a couple of lines, not one child left sitting at the side all through it. One or two fluffed a line, some seemed to be confused about going right or left, a couple missed their cue and it would never have won an Oscar but the kids and parents were so happy, everyone congratulating each other's kids at the end.

It was absolutely lovely. I made a point of congratulating the class teachers and the head of KS1 on what a fantastic job they had done.

That's how it should be done. No superstars. No sidelined children.