Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Oxford 'climate lockdowns' and '15-minute city' - can anyone local explain their views on this?

897 replies

unsureatthispoint · 07/12/2022 10:48

This news has been published in several media outlets and being talked about ATM.

Road blocks stopping most motorists from driving through Oxford city centre will divide the city into six "15 minute" neighbourhoods, a county council travel chief has said.

And he insisted the controversial plan would go ahead whether people liked it or not.

Duncan Enright, Oxfordshire County Council's cabinet member for travel and development strategy, explained the authority's traffic filter proposals in an interview in The Sunday Times.

He said the filters would turn Oxford into "a 15-minute city" with local services within a small walking radius.

Mr Enright said: "It is about making sure you have the community centre which has all of those essential needs, the bottle of milk, pharmacy, GP, schools which you need to have a 15-minute neighbourhood."

The aim is to reduce traffic in the city centre and make city living more pleasant, but critics say the plans will negatively affect businesses and the city centre's economy.

Here's the link

www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/23073992.traffic-filters-will-divide-city-six-15-minute-neighbourhoods-agrees-highways-councillor/

Are local people aware of this and what's their take on it?

OP posts:
TizerorFizz · 12/01/2023 10:41

@AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii
I have a hybrid car but even they are frozen out of congestion charging areas in London. They are available secondhand so more affordable. There will be limits regarding who can afford electric cars and it’s a big issue looming up very soon.
I don’t have the answers for Oxford. We parked for a day and it was £20. They don’t want visitors.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 12/01/2023 09:29

@TizerorFizz i read an article yesterday saying that electric car production is being scaled back this year due to the drop in demand and the price of them for the average person 🤷‍♀️

OhFFS! · 12/01/2023 09:00

The other thing is the 25 passes for the rest of Oxfordshire. I live right on the border with Buckinghamshire. It goes through my village yet I am on the wrong side of it. My children go to school in Oxfordshire, we do all our shopping in Oxon, I work in Oxon, I am 15 mins from the ring road yet, I won't even be able to get those. My colleague who lives 5 miles further out but just the other side of the same border will.

PermanentTemporary · 12/01/2023 08:32

Well, the Boswells building turned out to have walls made of packed straw, so there was no way to make it safe I think without rebuilding.

RoseAndGeranium · 12/01/2023 06:11

Rummykitten · 12/01/2023 00:06

@TizerorFizz , good point about the price of electric cars. I keep hoping they’ll come down (especially as we get closer to 2030) but you’re right that they are currently unaffordable for most.

The Clarendon Centre is a shadow of its former self. I walked through it just before Christmas (should have been the busiest time of the year) but most of the units were empty!

Isn’t that partly because of the plans to redevelop the site? Plans I thought were supposed to kick off in 2022. It’s crazy, really. Yes, the more open arrangement proposed looks like it will be more modern and attractive, but aside from the fact that it’s out of fashion there’s nothing wrong with the building. Lots of talk on this thread about reducing car use to combat climate change but what about the carbon disaster of knocking down and rebuilding retail units that are perfectly structurally sound every few decades?
You’re right though that Oxford centre is quiet. I don’t know what the average turnover is in a development like the Westgate but there are several units in there that are already on at least their third tenants, and others that they seem to be struggling to fill at all. And yes, the Debenhams building is empty, lovely old Boswells is now a hotel.

Rummykitten · 12/01/2023 00:06

@TizerorFizz , good point about the price of electric cars. I keep hoping they’ll come down (especially as we get closer to 2030) but you’re right that they are currently unaffordable for most.

The Clarendon Centre is a shadow of its former self. I walked through it just before Christmas (should have been the busiest time of the year) but most of the units were empty!

TizerorFizz · 11/01/2023 23:21

@Rummykitten
Theres a big issue with saying there should be special concessions for electric cars. Have you seen the price of them? Will the average office or shop worker or cleaner afford one? Obviously the highly paid university staff will sail on through whilst the cooks and cleaners are stuck with snails pace public transport.

I think Oxford is far quieter than it used to be. There are quite large shopping areas that are dead. The Clarendon centre for one. The old Debenhams store is another. I remember it being Elliston and Cavell. Also my DF got rainwear from Zacs for Macs! Happy days.

Devoutspoken · 11/01/2023 22:27

*simply

Devoutspoken · 11/01/2023 22:26

Another oxon, it's aimply not true to say it won't make things better for anyone, because it will

jgw1 · 11/01/2023 20:37

AnotherOxonResident · 11/01/2023 20:25

LTNs are entirely irrelevant to the Botley Road because there is only the one road into Oxford from the west.

The bonkers thing about this whole traffic filter idea is that it's supposed to encourage people to take the bus rather than the car. Well the buses on the Botley Road cannot avoid getting snarled up in the appalling traffic as there isn't room for bus lanes, so no one will be able to get a bus into Oxford from anywhere west (the S1 from Witney/Eynsham, S9 from Wantage, S6 from Swindon/Faringdon, as well as the Seacourt Park & Ride). By making it the only approach to the Westgate they're never going to decrease the number of cars going there, so what is the plan for the buses? Answer: there isn't one. Everyone is supposed to just magically not mind that the journeys take hours and they'd be quicker to walk from Botley (which not everyone is able to do).

Less traffic in Oxford would be great but the alternatives have to be there and have to be attractive and work. All this is going to do is ruin lives and journeys and make nothing better for anyone.

I've heard that they've had the same queue on Botley road for the last 60 years.

AnotherOxonResident · 11/01/2023 20:25

LTNs are entirely irrelevant to the Botley Road because there is only the one road into Oxford from the west.

The bonkers thing about this whole traffic filter idea is that it's supposed to encourage people to take the bus rather than the car. Well the buses on the Botley Road cannot avoid getting snarled up in the appalling traffic as there isn't room for bus lanes, so no one will be able to get a bus into Oxford from anywhere west (the S1 from Witney/Eynsham, S9 from Wantage, S6 from Swindon/Faringdon, as well as the Seacourt Park & Ride). By making it the only approach to the Westgate they're never going to decrease the number of cars going there, so what is the plan for the buses? Answer: there isn't one. Everyone is supposed to just magically not mind that the journeys take hours and they'd be quicker to walk from Botley (which not everyone is able to do).

Less traffic in Oxford would be great but the alternatives have to be there and have to be attractive and work. All this is going to do is ruin lives and journeys and make nothing better for anyone.

RoseAndGeranium · 11/01/2023 20:09

Rummykitten · 11/01/2023 19:31

@RoseAndGeranium , I couldn’t agree with you more. It would make far more sense if electric cars were permitted to travel into the city centre through the bus gates. As it stands, this plan doesn’t stop petrol/diesel cars entering the city, it simply concentrates them all onto Botley Road. As I’ve tried to explain before, this will make life so much worse for those of us living on that road and we already suffer from the pollution caused by idling engines in the mile-long queue outside our front doors.

This plan neither reduces overall vehicle use nor encourages people to switch to electric cars (which could easily have been done by allowing them through the bus gates). Nobody is going to get on a bus when you have to pay twice (to park and then also to ride) and especially when any buses heading down Botley Road will be even more delayed than they currently are due to the increased number of cars using that route into the city.

I completely sympathise with your concerns regarding the huge increase in your commuting time. I doubt this has been considered at all by the council. They urgently need to review this plan.

To all the people telling me that emissions won’t increase on Botley Road, this can at least be properly evidenced if the scheme is put in place as we already have air quality monitoring (and it already shows illegal levels of NOx).

I feel for you living on the Botley Road. The traffic there is always horrendous and it stinks of pollution. It is absolute madness to funnel yet more traffic through there. The same is true to a lesser extent for the northerly roads. I can’t imagine the congestion on the Banbury Road is going to be helped. I know someone on here keeps going on about LTNs lowering traffic on neighbouring roads but I’m really sceptical. I thought LTNs were what they’d already put in on the Cowley side streets. This is much more radical, so I’m not sure how studies measuring traffic around LTNs of the Cowley variety would have any relevance to this scheme. And where have these studies taken place? Did those places have realistic alternative transport options (as opposed to dysfunctional park and rides) to offer those who previously drove?

Rummykitten · 11/01/2023 19:39

If this is truly what the voters of Oxford want, why won’t @DuncanEnright and co publish the results of the consultation? And why did they press ahead with LTNs in East Oxford against the majority’s wishes?

We vote them in. We can boot them out.

Rummykitten · 11/01/2023 19:36

@TizerorFizz that is exactly what will happen. The shops are already dying in the city centre and this will finish them off. The council are making Oxford impossible to do business in (I’m sure Didcot and Witney will be the beneficiaries).

They are very short-sighted if they can’t see how working people will struggle to reach the city centre. If you’re in a low wage service industry job, why would you put up with an even longer commute at either end of your working day? Especially when there are similar vacancies in much more accessible towns eg Abingdon, Didcot.

Rummykitten · 11/01/2023 19:31

@RoseAndGeranium , I couldn’t agree with you more. It would make far more sense if electric cars were permitted to travel into the city centre through the bus gates. As it stands, this plan doesn’t stop petrol/diesel cars entering the city, it simply concentrates them all onto Botley Road. As I’ve tried to explain before, this will make life so much worse for those of us living on that road and we already suffer from the pollution caused by idling engines in the mile-long queue outside our front doors.

This plan neither reduces overall vehicle use nor encourages people to switch to electric cars (which could easily have been done by allowing them through the bus gates). Nobody is going to get on a bus when you have to pay twice (to park and then also to ride) and especially when any buses heading down Botley Road will be even more delayed than they currently are due to the increased number of cars using that route into the city.

I completely sympathise with your concerns regarding the huge increase in your commuting time. I doubt this has been considered at all by the council. They urgently need to review this plan.

To all the people telling me that emissions won’t increase on Botley Road, this can at least be properly evidenced if the scheme is put in place as we already have air quality monitoring (and it already shows illegal levels of NOx).

TizerorFizz · 11/01/2023 19:28

Well restricting movement within the city is the councils solution but people still live and work in Oxford. Maybe it should just be declared a museum with entry fees? Book your visit!

Bella989 · 11/01/2023 19:21

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

jgw1 · 11/01/2023 19:18

TizerorFizz · 11/01/2023 18:53

Many people in the more central zones will be inconvenienced too. Oxford has always had long queues of traffic. In my 60 years of visiting it was ever thus!!

Sounds like a strong argument for doing something radical to change the traffic system then.

RoseAndGeranium · 11/01/2023 19:15

It’s the fact that it’s so draconian and so lacking in any mitigations for many of those adversely affected that makes this such a bad scheme. As lots of people on the thread have said, if this came with real improvements in local public transport, or guarantees that employers would be leant on to provide more home working options, or if it were a congestion charge scheme with lower prices for car sharing or electric vehicles — well, I’d be all for it. I can fully see that there is a pollution problem in Oxford, and it would be great to fix it. Just not like this.

TizerorFizz · 11/01/2023 19:09

I do understand that. I was responding to people who think the benefits to the city centre outweigh all the other inconvenience. I don’t think they do.

RoseAndGeranium · 11/01/2023 19:04

TizerorFizz · 11/01/2023 18:53

Many people in the more central zones will be inconvenienced too. Oxford has always had long queues of traffic. In my 60 years of visiting it was ever thus!!

Inconvenienced is not the same as losing one’s job because it’s impossible to be there for the required number of hours because one’s commute has ballooned from 25 minutes each way to 1hr 15, but the kids still need dropping off and picking up at the same time as they always did. Because that’s what some of the mums I know are facing, and what I will struggle with if/when I go back to work in Oxford.

TizerorFizz · 11/01/2023 18:53

Many people in the more central zones will be inconvenienced too. Oxford has always had long queues of traffic. In my 60 years of visiting it was ever thus!!

OhFFS! · 11/01/2023 14:37

They ask for feedback and then ignore it though. The LTNs had a high negative response......from recall it was high 60s but still went ahead regardless.

These new plans will cause chaos on the ring road, on all the approaches to the ring road causing all sorts of issues and delays. The A34 is bad enough already, just wait until you get the standing traffic at Peartree or Islip. It can be like that now.

I had to queue for 15 minutes to get to the ring road near Headington so queuing just part Wheatley all the way down past the park and ride the other day . If I go the other way and come in from Islip, through Kidlington and past the Water Eaton park and ride, there have been numerous occasions where I've had to queue from the Islip turn.

So long queues just to get to the Park and Rides, let alone anywhere else.

So whilst the centre of Oxford may benefit from some of these restrictions, what about your deliveries, commuters, day to day trade, hospital staff etc it will still have an impact. The Marston exit is always solid from early in the morning.

And as for all the resulting queues caused by the LTNs now, unless you can travel by bike, which is then dangerous, most people will e impacted.

jgw1 · 11/01/2023 14:28

Takeittotheboss · 11/01/2023 14:26

@AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii
They are not just making changes whether people like it or not!
Oxford city residents have voted the councillors in and they are proposing potential changes to car use/road usage in the city centre to benefit city residents. That's working democracy.
Even if, as a resident of an outside very rural village with no public transport options it will could be very tricky for myself and my family to continue to travel into town. As I said earlier, without joined up thinking across city, county and country levels, it's very difficult to make workable solutions for all affected parties.

I think the issue may be so used to the current government standing on a manifesto which is utterly meaningless and they have no intention of implementing that they have forgotten that many people do stand for election on a manifesto they intend to implement.

Takeittotheboss · 11/01/2023 14:26

@AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii
They are not just making changes whether people like it or not!
Oxford city residents have voted the councillors in and they are proposing potential changes to car use/road usage in the city centre to benefit city residents. That's working democracy.
Even if, as a resident of an outside very rural village with no public transport options it will could be very tricky for myself and my family to continue to travel into town. As I said earlier, without joined up thinking across city, county and country levels, it's very difficult to make workable solutions for all affected parties.

Swipe left for the next trending thread