Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Oxford 'climate lockdowns' and '15-minute city' - can anyone local explain their views on this?

897 replies

unsureatthispoint · 07/12/2022 10:48

This news has been published in several media outlets and being talked about ATM.

Road blocks stopping most motorists from driving through Oxford city centre will divide the city into six "15 minute" neighbourhoods, a county council travel chief has said.

And he insisted the controversial plan would go ahead whether people liked it or not.

Duncan Enright, Oxfordshire County Council's cabinet member for travel and development strategy, explained the authority's traffic filter proposals in an interview in The Sunday Times.

He said the filters would turn Oxford into "a 15-minute city" with local services within a small walking radius.

Mr Enright said: "It is about making sure you have the community centre which has all of those essential needs, the bottle of milk, pharmacy, GP, schools which you need to have a 15-minute neighbourhood."

The aim is to reduce traffic in the city centre and make city living more pleasant, but critics say the plans will negatively affect businesses and the city centre's economy.

Here's the link

www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/23073992.traffic-filters-will-divide-city-six-15-minute-neighbourhoods-agrees-highways-councillor/

Are local people aware of this and what's their take on it?

OP posts:
jgw1 · 01/02/2023 19:20

Charles11 · 01/02/2023 14:46

"Did you read my post which said that if 15 minute cities mean people live within 15 minutes of regular amenities they would need to use their cars less?"

Most people would be happy to not need to use their cars but we're not set up like that so then it's just a massive inconvenience.
I'd be happy if my work, kid's schools, shops, restaurants, parks, football pitches, swimming pool, friends, family all lived 15 minutes walk away and we used the car occasionally for days out and holidays.
But as it stands, except for the primary school, none of that is close by and it's not as if everything will be restructured soon so it is.
It then feels like such a restriction and an attack on a way of life that was fitting to our personal circumstances.

Life is so much more enjoyable when you slow down, listen to the birds singing (if you can here them above the traffic noise). It makes everyday like a holiday.

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 19:02

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 17:10

I'm asking if you want the plumber to pay.

can someone else tell me if my questions aren't clear enough?!

What would you like your plumber to pay?

Mine just walks round, but obviously that isn't practical in all situations.

WendyAndCIyde · 01/02/2023 18:27

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 17:10

I'm asking if you want the plumber to pay.

can someone else tell me if my questions aren't clear enough?!

Questions are clear.

TizerorFizz · 01/02/2023 17:55

@EmmaEmerald
You are trying to have a conversation with someone who probably doesn’t have a car and doesn’t need to go anywhere much . A sort of 15 minute hermit. Most of us cannot operate like that. We have elderly parents, jobs, go shopping once or twice a week. We don’t have a Pashley bike with a shopping basket for a daily loaf of bread and some cheese - that’s been brought to the shop by road transport. We don’t have time to walk 3 miles to school and back with sports kit and books for Dc. We actually do live at a faster pace where saving time is key.

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 17:10

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 16:28

I am failing to follow your logic.

Saying people need to use their cars much less, makes life better for the plumber travelling to jobs as there would be less congestion, makes life better for someone who needs to drive to a hospital appointment, for example it is much easier to get to Birmingham Children's hospital now the traffic is reduced as a result of the cities clean air zone.

I'm asking if you want the plumber to pay.

can someone else tell me if my questions aren't clear enough?!

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 16:28

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 15:43

So what do you propose for people needing vehicles for work e.g. plumbers with equipment to carry.

Someone driving a person to hospital if patient can't use public transport.

Someone driving to shops because they can't carry shopping home and can't meet minimum spend for delivery.

do you want to charge people for travelling outside their allocated zone

etc etc

I am failing to follow your logic.

Saying people need to use their cars much less, makes life better for the plumber travelling to jobs as there would be less congestion, makes life better for someone who needs to drive to a hospital appointment, for example it is much easier to get to Birmingham Children's hospital now the traffic is reduced as a result of the cities clean air zone.

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 15:43

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 15:28

The first post you replied in part answered your question and my 2nd gave further examples.

Most people could use their cars far less. 25% of journeys are under 1 mile. In 2021 18% of those were by car. A staggering 67% of journeys between 1 and 5 miles are by car.

It was ever thus. When I was at Primary School we walked the mile and a half each day. The vast majority of students lived closer and were driven.

So what do you propose for people needing vehicles for work e.g. plumbers with equipment to carry.

Someone driving a person to hospital if patient can't use public transport.

Someone driving to shops because they can't carry shopping home and can't meet minimum spend for delivery.

do you want to charge people for travelling outside their allocated zone

etc etc

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 15:28

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 14:18

Um, yes, I read your post.

You don't want to answer my questions, I guess.

The first post you replied in part answered your question and my 2nd gave further examples.

Most people could use their cars far less. 25% of journeys are under 1 mile. In 2021 18% of those were by car. A staggering 67% of journeys between 1 and 5 miles are by car.

It was ever thus. When I was at Primary School we walked the mile and a half each day. The vast majority of students lived closer and were driven.

Charles11 · 01/02/2023 14:46

"Did you read my post which said that if 15 minute cities mean people live within 15 minutes of regular amenities they would need to use their cars less?"

Most people would be happy to not need to use their cars but we're not set up like that so then it's just a massive inconvenience.
I'd be happy if my work, kid's schools, shops, restaurants, parks, football pitches, swimming pool, friends, family all lived 15 minutes walk away and we used the car occasionally for days out and holidays.
But as it stands, except for the primary school, none of that is close by and it's not as if everything will be restructured soon so it is.
It then feels like such a restriction and an attack on a way of life that was fitting to our personal circumstances.

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 14:18

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 13:32

Did you read my post which said that if 15 minute cities mean people live within 15 minutes of regular amenities they would need to use their cars less?

Anyway as an example 30 years ago my grandmother was doing all her shopping by bike in a town a lot hillier than Oxford.

It is perfectly possible in Oxford to get to the hospitals by bike, foot or public transport, I know this as I have done all 3.

Um, yes, I read your post.

You don't want to answer my questions, I guess.

JazbayGrapes · 01/02/2023 13:57

It is hugely controversial locally, the street furniture that has been put in place has been vandalised several times.

Good. Good!

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 13:32

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 13:06

thanks.

What would you like to see happen for people who need a vehicle for work, shopping, (can't always meet the minimum spend for delivery) medical appointments, visiting friends?

I'm going to imagine that you exempt those with disabilities or mobility issues etc from any extra charges.

Did you read my post which said that if 15 minute cities mean people live within 15 minutes of regular amenities they would need to use their cars less?

Anyway as an example 30 years ago my grandmother was doing all her shopping by bike in a town a lot hillier than Oxford.

It is perfectly possible in Oxford to get to the hospitals by bike, foot or public transport, I know this as I have done all 3.

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 13:06

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 11:38

If 15 minutes cities means that people live within 15 minutes walk of most regular amenities then vehicle use will be dramatically reduced as it needs to be.
It is perfectly possible to go for weeks without getting in a car, if one wants to.

thanks.

What would you like to see happen for people who need a vehicle for work, shopping, (can't always meet the minimum spend for delivery) medical appointments, visiting friends?

I'm going to imagine that you exempt those with disabilities or mobility issues etc from any extra charges.

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 11:38

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 10:58

What would you like to see happening re vehicles please?

If 15 minutes cities means that people live within 15 minutes walk of most regular amenities then vehicle use will be dramatically reduced as it needs to be.
It is perfectly possible to go for weeks without getting in a car, if one wants to.

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 10:58

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 05:26

You would think that was an uncontroversial statement, but it seems it is not.

What would you like to see happening re vehicles please?

TizerorFizz · 01/02/2023 10:03

Electric cars won’t clog anything at the moment. Sales have stalled and there are not that many on the road when compared with petrol/diesel cars. @greenacrylicpaint We cannot run our economy without transport and certain freedoms. If you wish to live in the middle of nowhere and walk everywhere, great. However you need food and all sorts of other services based on others using transport. So I would think about that rather than worrying about tyres!

sashh · 01/02/2023 06:38

I used to live in Oxford, the city centre is tiny.

If you read the actual plan it is certain jusnctions that will be blocked at peak times.

You can always use the ring road it's just routes threou the city centre.

I lived there in the early 90s, there were already electric busses from the station.

There was also a large park and ride.

greenacrylicpaint · 01/02/2023 06:27

TizerorFizz · 31/01/2023 22:36

Electric cars pollute less! It’s just that many ordinary folk cannot afford them. We are not going to get anywhere by being overly judgemental on drivers or car makers. Maybe you would like to provide the batteries and charging infrastructure needed for electric cars? Seems no one else can. We need business in this country by the way. They employ people!

electric cars still produce fine dust from the tyres.
they still are (potentially) dangerous for other road users.
they still clog the roads.

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 05:26

Devoutspoken · 31/01/2023 20:52

I consider it a human right to breathe clean air

You would think that was an uncontroversial statement, but it seems it is not.

TizerorFizz · 31/01/2023 22:36

Electric cars pollute less! It’s just that many ordinary folk cannot afford them. We are not going to get anywhere by being overly judgemental on drivers or car makers. Maybe you would like to provide the batteries and charging infrastructure needed for electric cars? Seems no one else can. We need business in this country by the way. They employ people!

EmmaEmerald · 31/01/2023 22:25

Siobhan interesting to hear re Cambridge, thanks.

Devoutspoken · 31/01/2023 20:52

I consider it a human right to breathe clean air

jgw1 · 31/01/2023 20:50

unsureatthispoint · 31/01/2023 12:24

it's just "unfortunate that bus users as collateral damage"

It's weird how it is apparently acceptable these days for humans to be 'collateral damage' of all sorts of decisions made higher up (by governments and large - mostly global- corporations)

What happened to human rights? Do people not matter any more? It's quite dark if you think about it really

Quite agree, just look at how much humans are collateral damage when it comes to the pollution from cars, manufactured by big business, that could make them much less polluting.

SiobhanSharpe · 31/01/2023 20:48

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 15/12/2022 15:47

Cambridge is trying to adopt a congestion charge to fund better public transport. Except better public transport in the villages (6-7 miles out)means one bus an hour under their "new improved" public transport. That renders a school drop off and commute into Cambridge impossible.

Once you get 3-4 miles out, the roads are generally country lanes with no provision for footpaths or cycle paths, so active travel is at best unpleasant and at worst dangerous.

Yes, this proposed £5 daily congestion charge for entering, leaving or driving within the entire city of Cambridge inside the ring road (or sustainable travel zone as the council likes to call it) is already massively unpopular. It would be from 7am to 7 pm, all day .
There was nary a hint of this proposal in the last election manifestos from Labour/ Greens whose scheme it is. So residents have had no chance to vote on it ... yet.
Cambridge depends on people who live in surrounding villages to come into the city for work. (The city centre, like Oxford, is extremely expensive for housing.) Addenbrookes/Papworth Hospitals, world class medical establishments on a huge 'bio-medical' campus are within the congestion charge (CC) zone and employ thousands of people who travel to it from outside the city.

It will cost around £1,200 a year to drive to work. Cambridge residents will not get a local discount unlike London CC residents. And it will cost much more for tradespeople, plumbers, electricians, hairdressers etc who drive small vans. It applies to electric cars, motorbikes and motor scooters.
There is also much concern it will eventually kill off the city centre with many shops and businesses considering moving away as custom and footfall is predicted to fall sharply. Every resident who moves their car away from their property, even if they live only a few yards into the congestion zone and are driving directly out of the city will be charged.
The local authorities say this will be wonderful as it will operate in tandem with an all-singing, all-dancing expanded bus service which will operate from before dawn to very late at night. Ignoring the fact that the bus operator is canceling services and routes due to a chronic lack of drivers and the system is a shambles.
The final straw for most is that traffic congestion in the city is not considered a major problem at all outside peak hours, 7-9 am and 5-7 pm. (Or unless the council has closed off roads which it seems to be doing with increasing frequency.)

Devoutspoken · 31/01/2023 20:41

Dystopian? Surely roads packed with big metal polluting vehicles, bumper to bumper, is dystopian