Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to lose hope for my future children?

61 replies

DebatingMumhood · 07/12/2022 06:58

I want to have a baby, but don’t think I can handle it in this day and age. I feel it will be such a struggle to keep them away from screens while their minds are developing. When I was a child, my family had a TV but there would rarely be anything interesting on. So I was forced to make my own fun reading, drawing, and playing outside with friends. Nowadays it seems much more difficult to encourage your children to have healthy hobbies. And it’s more dangerous to leave them alone with other children. Child-on-child sexual abuse has increased exponentially due to access to pornography. And bullies are armed with high-def cameras. I want a baby but honestly think it’s unlikely they’ll be able to lead a happy life in these conditions and don’t know if I can handle the heartbreak. AIBU to feel this way?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GaggleOfSwans · 07/12/2022 15:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 07/12/2022 15:10

My teens are well adjusted and interesting despite access to screens. They are both sporty and went to a school where phones cannot be used during the day.

DS2 (aged 15) and I have long discussions about some of the things he watches - recent discussions have included men’s mental health, equality and critical assessment of claims made on social media eg comparing TikTok claims with academic research or government stats.

Children need to be able to navigate the online world and it is my job to help them evaluate what they are watching critically rather than blindly accepting it. It’s made for some really interesting debates.

There is also some superb content available online including excellent science content. Things like the Khan Academy have been great for helping with maths for example.

As a parent you have to engage with the world as it is. So when my DC were young I did all the days out, picnics, playing in the park etc etc. Now they are older I chat to them about xBox games, go and watch Marvel movies, chat on WhatsApp - I operate on their terms to some extent. I would much prefer to have channels of communication that work for my teens than to try to impose something that doesn’t work for them.

Kennykenkencat · 07/12/2022 14:46

My Dd and Ds make their living online. A lot of my work is online.
i remember as a child having no tv and having to entertain myself and not having answers to stuff or being able to understand homework and not being able to at the click of a button access help
It was Shit.

If I had access to the internet when I was younger my life would have been very different.

Why would you want to keep children from being able to access knowledge.

I learned more through watching tv than I did through school and I have learned more through the phone in my hand than I did through the first 45 years of my life.
Life had moved on.

The rest is called parenting.

XelaM · 07/12/2022 14:38

My daughter spends all her free time on a livery yard with friends looking after and riding her ponies. I think she has a nice childhood despite screens.

MassiveSalad22 · 07/12/2022 14:34

Also you’ll probably homeschool if you really want to be screen free (I’m sure that’s very tricky, screen/internet free homeschool!). They start using screens in reception.
They also do a shit ton of forest school, free play, sensory play, gardening club, our school even has a bloody ecotherapist.

MassiveSalad22 · 07/12/2022 14:31

How old are you? I remember watching loads of telly as a preschooler and spent every evening after school on msn/myspace. Yes I am here on mumsnet now, so it has somewhat continued, but I am a functioning and contributing member of society who is very stable. As a parent you put in the necessary controls and educate your children about safety along the way. I voted YABU but I still think you shouldn’t have kids right now if you’re already this anxious at this point.

DebatingMumhood · 07/12/2022 14:28

Lesserspottedmama · 07/12/2022 11:08

Their childhoods will be what you make it OP. My 3 are home educated, we have no TV (but a DVD player with a collection of beautiful films, ballets, nature documentaries etc), we live in the countryside (in a very shabby small house), they are outside everyday, have lots of friends, they love books, history, nature, art, music. We play lots of classical and Celtic and folk music and they have a big collection of dressing up, instruments and they play and play and play. They are really happy kids and make friends easily and are all starting to really get their own individual passions, hobbies and interests. They have no clue at all about any of the junky pop culture that many kids are exposed to; their lives are filled up with nature, myths and tables, traditions, family and friends, history, books, legends and a lot of imagination. You, the parent, are gatekeeper of what you fill these early years up with. The default is crap, you can build something better!

❤️❤️❤️

OP posts:
GetThatHelmetOn · 07/12/2022 11:12

DebatingMumhood · 07/12/2022 09:25

Yes, that’s another thing to worry about for them. : ( I especially worry about the effects of pollutants on developing baby brains.

If it helps, it was far more polluted in the past. Your kids won’t grow up surrounded by coal smoke, won’t play with toys covered with lead paint and are likely to have a more nutritious diet.

Lesserspottedmama · 07/12/2022 11:08

Their childhoods will be what you make it OP. My 3 are home educated, we have no TV (but a DVD player with a collection of beautiful films, ballets, nature documentaries etc), we live in the countryside (in a very shabby small house), they are outside everyday, have lots of friends, they love books, history, nature, art, music. We play lots of classical and Celtic and folk music and they have a big collection of dressing up, instruments and they play and play and play. They are really happy kids and make friends easily and are all starting to really get their own individual passions, hobbies and interests. They have no clue at all about any of the junky pop culture that many kids are exposed to; their lives are filled up with nature, myths and tables, traditions, family and friends, history, books, legends and a lot of imagination. You, the parent, are gatekeeper of what you fill these early years up with. The default is crap, you can build something better!

liveforsummer · 07/12/2022 11:05

I have hugely happy dc who spend a massive amount of time outdoors. They also watch screens. It's not a huge problem if you monitor and manage. You're catastrophising!

DIYandEatCake · 07/12/2022 11:05

I’m old-fashioned and not a fan of screen time for kids - but I’ve had to be realistic with mine. The internet and screens are part of our lives now, like it or not, and it’s just another parenting challenge to try to get the balance right. Kids are going to have to be adept at using technology to keep up educationally and socially. Both my kids have access to screens, one isn’t bothered and spends hours drawing, playing musical instruments etc; the other loves games and YouTube and has ambitions to be a games designer. They’re both lovely, kind, funny kids who are doing well at school.
My biggest worry for my kids isn’t screen time or abuse (which I don’t believe is more common than it used to be - I think we just hear more about it), but climate change and what kind of world they’ll grow up in, wars, famines, hardship. I love them immeasurably and can’t imagine life without them, but sometimes l do feel guilty about bringing them into the world.

BabyFour2023 · 07/12/2022 11:01

Oysterbabe · 07/12/2022 07:02

My kids watch a reasonable amount of screens and are happy and healthy with lots of active hobbies and great friendships. You can keep them away from screens but you are making this a bigger issue than it is.

This

Stompythedinosaur · 07/12/2022 10:59

I think you are being a bit dramatic tbh.

You are also thinking about DC as if they are items belonging to their parents - they aren't, they are their own separate people. They will, beyond a certain age, be able to make choices and show restraint (if they choose to). Parents are there to teach and encourage, not to control.

Also, screens are not the route of all evil.

But if you don't fancy having dc, that is fine and you don't need any excuse for it!

onmywayamarillo · 07/12/2022 10:59

You are on a screen, typing on a screen, on an internet forum! 🤣
My children hardly watch mainstream tv and the parental controls are far superior to 10 years ago. Imagine what it will like in another 10 years

xogossipgirlxo · 07/12/2022 10:52

If you don't have hope you can raise your child well, better off not having kids.

Kerrylass · 07/12/2022 10:49

Your overthinking it. There are a million reasons why having children will be difficult, but as a parent you do the best to prepare them for the future and weather you like it or not tech is part of living in a modern society. you teach them good values and respect and hope its enough to keep them on the right path. If you decide to have children you will need to chill, relax and go with the flow a bit more. Being a parent means you will need to let go off the need to control everything including the outside world. I dont think your currently in that mindset.

MilkyYay · 07/12/2022 10:33

This a particularly pessimistic outlook.

Its quite easy to keep under 12s away from screens, particularly unsupervised screen use. You do need to allow a small amount of computer access as computer skills are part of the school curriculum and its important you educate your children to help them stay safe online.

I live in a "naice" area and lots of children have only limited screentime. CBBC for 20 mins 3 or 4 times a week, occasional access, supervised, to educational apps on a tablet.

Its also easy to encourage othee hobbies and activities. My kids play sport & love board games, lego, books, art/crafts etc and do plenty of playing outdoors with friends.

I do think its a myth that children can self regulate. My personal opinion is that age appropriate limits need to be imposed by adults for a long time to ensure children build good habits and get used to enjoying other activities. Screens are definitely addictive.

Butchyrestingface · 07/12/2022 10:27

I agree with PP that you seem very anxious. I'd get a dog instead. Don't have to worry about screen time and climate change is a non-issue cos they won't be around to experience it.

Tigofigo · 07/12/2022 10:24

I do think YouTube / tiktok fast-cut content and fast paced frenetic TV shows are potentially really bad for developing brains so I get your point. I also think the UK is particularly bad.

But there are other routes.

Lots of people choose alternative education where screens are not really A Thing.

Having said that, my niece who is 14 barely looks at her phone.

My other niece who is 16 is glued to hers.

Both are lovely, well-rounded teens.

MermaidEyes · 07/12/2022 10:21

You sound like an extremely anxious person and that doesn't make a good parent. There are a million and one things you could be anxious about if you let yourself, and that anxiety feeds into your children, making them unhappy and anxious too. Sometimes as a parent you just have to 'not think' too much otherwise you'll spend the next 18 years or more lying awake at night worrying.

KimberleyClark · 07/12/2022 10:16

mynameiscalypso · 07/12/2022 07:06

I'm nearly 40 and watched a lot of TV as a kid. It doesn't seem to have done me much harm! My 3 year old is currently watching a documentary about the solar system on TV. I don't think that's the end of the world.

I can’t help thinking watching TV 40 years ago was different though. There wasn’t the constantly available stream of stuff like now. Four channels and a video player, that was it really.

MillyMollyManky · 07/12/2022 10:11

DebatingMumhood · 07/12/2022 08:27

Interesting for you to say that about education. I was thinking kids without smartphones would do much better in school as they would have a better capacity for reading and longform thinking.

I agree that unconstrained use of screens might affect reading, concentration etc. But it doesn't have to be unconstrained- one of your jobs as a parent is to help your child move from a position where you make the rules absolutely (eg a small child not allowed any screens) to where those rules are relaxed (a young teen allowed a phone for X amount of time a day to do a certain array of things) to a position where they make their own rules (an 18yo who has access to a phone whenever they want but knows that it's a bad idea to waste hours scrolling Insta when there are more rewarding things to be done).

That's why it's not necessarily the best idea simply to ban smartphones- the aim is to produce an adult who can function well in a world in which smartphones exist.

Hoowhoowho · 07/12/2022 10:04

I think one of the realisations you eventually have to make about having children is that what you do (outside the realms of abuse and neglect) doesn’t make a lot of difference.

Whether you’re the type of parent who hands their one year old an iPad or the type who bans tech until 18. Whether you buy pink and barbies for your daughter or shop for her only in the boys section, whether you encourage them into sports or push hobbies that don’t involve you standing around a rainy field on a Saturday morning. Ultimately none of it matters.

Kids are people not projects. They are born with their own personalities, they will be influenced by people and events that you not only have no control over but also quite possibly can’t even imagine now. They have disabilities, talents, looks that interact with the world in unique ways that change how it impacts them. As someone once wrote, you birth them, hurl them into the universe and pray.

If you can live with uncertainty and guilt and the reality of lack of control then have a kid and enjoy them. If you can’t, stick to imaginary children who are much more manageable.

RudsyFarmer · 07/12/2022 09:30

If you’re going to go into it with such a negative mindset I wouldn’t bother either.

DebatingMumhood · 07/12/2022 09:28

SuperCamp · 07/12/2022 09:02

I worry about climate change for my (future, theoretical) grandchildren.

OP, go camping, to a back to basics campsite, and you will see children spending hours enjoying rope swings, whittling twigs to toast marshmallows on campfires. Go to the Lake District in the summer and see kids out in the fells, splashing in streams, and messing about on or by lakes. Brownie, Guide and Scouts are packed.

You just do stuff with your kids and keep doing it.

Hobbies v screen time does not need to be an issue.

Sexual abuse has always been a problem. At least now we recognise it as such and can teach our children awareness.

That sounds lovely (the middle part of your post). Thanks for sharing.

OP posts: