Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think unless you've had a miscarriage or infertility - you have no idea!

30 replies

Vwswimmer1 · 06/12/2022 21:18

This is off the back of an earlier thread about telling people when they're TTC. Just that for me it highlighted how in general people have no real empathy for what it's like you've had a miscarriage or suffering infertility.

Obviously not everyone is the same but people should feel able to talk about these things if they want without worrying their SIL is thinking they're over sharing...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
0hs0s0rry · 06/12/2022 23:10

We’re an infertile couple due to my husband. I’ve found it difficult because I don’t know any women who can relate. I don’t even sometimes know whether I have the right to ‘grieve’ the infertility because it’s not ‘because of me’. Sometimes I don’t even have the right words to describe how it feels.

AnneLovesGilbert · 06/12/2022 22:56

I agree that this is the same for all of life’s tragedies. I still have my mum and dad and can’t begin to imagine what’s it’s like to lose a parent despite several friends having experienced it. I hope I’ve been supportive and not said anything stupid in my ignorance.

I also think it’s not always helpful to share experiences of pregnancy loss or fertility struggles unless you’ve gone through something very similar to the other person and they specifically ask. I’ve had 5 mcs and when I’d had one, two or even three I wouldn’t have wanted to hear from anyone who’d had 5 as the idea of going through it again would have made me feel way worse. Sadness and shit fucking luck aren’t contagious but people sometimes feel they are. Who wants to talk about dead babies or no babies at all when someone is desperate beyond belief to conceive. Anyone who wants to share what they’re going through should absolutely be able to. But its okay to not want to as well.

Lmgify · 06/12/2022 22:56

Oh totally, when I had three miscarriages in a row when I was 30, my older colleague asked me ‘oh no what did you do? I got pregnant twice in my 40s with no issue’. Oh do fuck off Amanda

Firen · 06/12/2022 22:52

I don’t really, I can empathise, but even going through the experience doesn’t make you the same. I’ve been guilty of it with miscarriages. I’ve had so many and very late ones. When I see posts about chemicals and very early miscarriages, it makes me see red for some reason. Now when I have a an early miscarriage, I shrug it off, but forget how I felt when I had the first one. It’s completely relative and you never know how others feel about things - even with the same experience.

redflowerbluethorns · 06/12/2022 22:44

Agree OP. I have subfertility, only had one pregnancy since trying for dc2 which ended in miscarriage. I have endo and pcos. The dumb crap people say to me with absolutely no regard for the insensitivity. Recently I've had:
"Wouldn't it be awful if I was pregnant, I'd have to give you my baby because you want one so much"
"You can have my eggs if you want them because I'm not bothered" (no conversation was being had about egg donation, nor would I want to do this)
"Maybe consider yourself lucky that you haven't been able to have more children, two is hard"
"When you're meant to have more children, you will"

LBFseBrom · 06/12/2022 22:43

I agree but would add there are people who have not experienced either but are experienced in knowing and working with those who have, who often empathise very well.

There definitely needs to be a safe place where those in the same boat can talk about it.

GrandTheftWalrus · 06/12/2022 22:32

I thought I was infertile with my exH as I hadn't even had a hint of a line for 6 years, and told I wasn't ovulating.

With now dh I fell pregnant almost immediately and sailed through it, so my 1st pregnancy was successful.

I fell pregnant again in 2020 and I said to him I will be extremely lucky if I carry to term. As it turned out I had a mmc at 7wks 3days and didn't find out till 11wks.

I then fell pregnant again in Sept 2020 and I was terrified of every single twinge.

But after my miscarriage I found out how many people I was working with that had had one as it seemed no one spoke about it. As it is I still haven't told my mum I had one.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 06/12/2022 22:15

Telling people you’re trying for a baby is basically telling them you’re having more sex. It’s not ‘news’

Absolutely nothing like telling them you’ve lost a baby or are struggling to have a baby.

And I’ve had miscarriages. I still don’t wanna know that people are having more sex than usual at certain times of the month.

takealettermsjones · 06/12/2022 22:12

I've actually had nastier comments from people who've been through it themselves. Mostly people saying things like "you think that's bad, I had to go through X". Some people fail to realise that it's not the misery Olympics; everyone is allowed to feel pain, even if someone else's pain is considered to be 'worse'.

MarigoldPetals · 06/12/2022 21:45

I agree OP but I also think you can still never really know how someone else is feeling even if you have experienced these things.
I have had infertility plus 3 miscarriages.
For me the years if infertility were the worst. The first miscarriage (after our first round of ICSI) was the next worst thing as I knew exactly what I would have to go through to have even a remote chance of getting pregnant again. I was jealous of people who had miscarriages following getting pregnant without assistance - all they had to do to get pregnant again was have sex, whereas I would have to have another round of treatment.
My next 2 miscarriages didn’t bother me - I already had a child and I knew 1:5 pregnancies end in miscarriages so I was prepared for the worst when I went for the viability scan at 12 weeks. When a friend found she had a miscarriage at her viability scan I couldn’t understand why she was so upset- she had got pregnant easily and knew about the miscarriage stats. She had never been through the agony of infertility and then the horrors of fertility treatments. But her distress was real, probably because it had all come so easy to her.
What I am trying to say is there are different levels of distress for the same issue depending on people’s situation.
Everyone feels upset and one type of distress does not outweigh another - they are all very real and difficult to that individual.

Blocked · 06/12/2022 21:44

No they don't know. How could they really? There's lots of situations I could never grasp what it's really like. It's not a problem really, that's just life. You learn as you go...sometimes you need people to tell you to help you learn.

Quitelikeit · 06/12/2022 21:43

I’ve had one and I felt that it was natures decision amd out of my hands

I didn’t tell a soul

Youngatheart00 · 06/12/2022 21:43

I agree. The pain of infertility and permanent childlessness cannot be grasped by someone who hasn’t experienced it

Vwswimmer1 · 06/12/2022 21:42

Peashoots · 06/12/2022 21:22

I think this is the case for most situations, though. You can have sympathy for someone, but can’t truly understand until you’ve been through something yourself.

Yeah I think that's very true actually and maybe I hadn't considered it enough in my original post.

I know before I had my losses I was guilty of asking the wrong things or not understanding fully so I probably just need to bear this in mind when reading things.

OP posts:
Whatafielddayfortheheat · 06/12/2022 21:41

It's like this for everything isn't it. I was angry with my sister (who fell pregnant very easily with both her kids) because she said things to me during my 2.5 year infertility plus ectopic pregnancy- like 'oh yes I know exactly how you feel, I was trying for 2 months' - which showed she didn't understand.

But since having my 2 kids (I'm very lucky it worked out in the end), I can appreciate that I was not empathetic with her post-partum struggles including terrible (worse than normal newborn) lack of sleep, and PND. I cringe when i remember telling her how tired and stressed I was after a busy week, when she had a poorly newborn and I was child free. We live and learn!

notinthestarsigns · 06/12/2022 21:38

My first baby died when I was 20 weeks pregnant and I found, and still do, that most people don’t understand what going through that, and living with it, means, physically or emotionally. However I wouldn’t have had any idea myself had I not been through it so I try not to blame anyone who doesn’t understand or says the “wrong” thing.

Luckyducker · 06/12/2022 21:36

I think a large proportion of women have had a miscarriage or infertility. A lot of women have experienced it and therefore have a very good idea of what it is like.

Ifeellikeateenageragain · 06/12/2022 21:36

I've had one naturally conceived miscarriage, a failed IVF cycle, then a miscarriage from the next IVF cycle... And yes, I started not talking/telling friends about it as none of my friends have had anything like this (not assuming this, they all told me they'd never experienced these things).

Mummieslncorporated · 06/12/2022 21:36

I only say this because it's worth not assuming that women with children haven't experienced miscarriage.

While this is absolutely true, there's a huge difference between the miscarriage I had (very early, could have been mistaken for a late period) and a miscarriage much further down the line.

I don't know what it's like for many women experiencing miscarriage, despite having one myself.

racquel86 · 06/12/2022 21:34

I agree, although applicable to a lot of things xxx

bagthoughts · 06/12/2022 21:33

Agree OP I've had four losses now and some of the dumb shit people say is beyond ridiculous - even DH doesn't get it

FiveShelties · 06/12/2022 21:33

I don't think people do understand, but to be honest I would not want people to experience infertility just so that they knew how I felt.

MissTrip82 · 06/12/2022 21:32

I have never found it true that people who experience something have more empathy - my experience has been that people who aren’t very empathic remain so no matter what their experience.

I also think that what I experience doesn’t really tell me what you experience of similar circumstances and it would be arrogant of me to think otherwise.

I much prefer the support of people who are kind and empathic than the support of people who’ve simply had a similar experience.

Comtesse · 06/12/2022 21:32

Miscarriages are very common. No one has ever had your exact experience of course, but many of us have been through the same thing. All the more reason to talk about it to avoid a sense of isolation. You are not the only one suffering sadly….

Windbeneathmybingowings · 06/12/2022 21:30

I was thinking about this in general earlier today. There’s a whole host of things people won’t ever understand

bejng poor if you’ve always been rich
being fat if you’ve always been slim
losing a parent (and as a child vs as an adult, the experiences are different)
being pretty if you are plain
being a different ethnicity
being a different sexual orientation

so many others that can be added. So YANBU but it’s not just infertility related and that’s why we should listen to each other to try our best.