Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Irish v English Primary Teachers/School... Wildly different experiences.

118 replies

bunnybabies · 06/12/2022 19:54

I am a Primary Teacher working in Ireland. I go to work at 910 and finish/leave at 250. If a parent wants to speak to me, they ring the secretary and make an appointment to do so, either by phone or in person.Always during school hours. If a parentt has a grievance, they first speak with me and then if not satisfied arrange another meeting with Principal Teacher and Class Teacher. I am a regular user of MN and am genuinely stunned at the access that parents have to Class Teacher and the school in England, generally.Parents at the school in which I work are not allowed into the building randomly.Again, a meeting is set up if needed. There is no such thing as emailing, social media contact or otherwise outside of working hours. From what I read on here, my experiences in the school I teach in, are wildly different.I am interested to know how things work at your children's school or indeed at your place of work, as a teaching staff member.Thanks.

OP posts:
bunnybabies · 06/12/2022 22:37

We dont have any childcare options at our school.I know some are dropped to a local club from 7am and can be collected up to 7pm and are dropped and collected to/from our school but not on site, no.I would have loved that for my own children.At the most expensive time of my childcare, I paid a lady to come to mine at seven and leave at fou fprpick ups/drop off r.I travel for work.It was e350 per week.

OP posts:
Margo34 · 06/12/2022 22:35

Primary teacher in England here! Never knew there was such a difference with teaching in Ireland!! I get in at 8am and am often last one in (frowned upon by some) and have to park a good 5m walk down the road because I'm 'late'. Doors open to children at 845am and hometime for children is 3:20pm (although after school club runs until 6pm). I tend to leave about 6pm, sometimes 630pm but take very minimal work home (maybe 30min, max a week) and never go in during holidays either - I just don't understand those that do?! Parents catch me on the door in the morning or on the playground after school, or email all day long, or call the office who transfer the call outside of the school hours, or they arrange to meet after school if it'll take longer than 10mins. I had 2 back to back parent meetings a couple of weeks ago that took over an hour and then required logging on the system after that too, it was the week before parent consults too 🥴 parents exhaust me more than the children!

bunnybabies · 06/12/2022 22:33

Foodie Too, we need serious admin support but have none whatsoever. You are lucky.

OP posts:
bunnybabies · 06/12/2022 22:31

Our class sizes are one of the highest in the OECD but so are the scores so we are doing ourselves a serious disservice.We go to work, we teach, we impart and we go home.In our school, our Principal has no time for paperwork, monthlys, plans.He wants high quality teaching and high quality empathy.That's the bottom line.When Inspectors come in, we are entirley responsible for our own notes.He wants a copy but doesnt even look at them.He knows he has quality, invigorated teachers.He doesnt subscribe to the paperwork bullshit and has no problem in saying so.

OP posts:
FoodieToo · 06/12/2022 22:30

Bunnybabies we have that number of SNAs because we have many kids with complex needs but in general they are very helpful and willing to assist the teacher.

FoodieToo · 06/12/2022 22:28

Teachers are involved in the after school club if they would like to earn sone extra money .

FoodieToo · 06/12/2022 22:26

Our average class size is about 24 . Some as low as 19 . We also have an after school club that runs to half 5 .

bunnybabies · 06/12/2022 22:26

I am envious FoodieToo...We have 1.5 and they dont meet the SN of the kids as there are not enough staff.Our SENT babysits for an hour a day to ensure one pupil doesnt violently assault kids but that's awhole other thread ... Previously our SNAS used to be photocopying and laminating as our secretary was too busy with admin for Principal and treasurer....Go figure.

OP posts:
Gruffling · 06/12/2022 22:25

What are class sizes like in Ireland?

That shorter day for pupils sounds so much better for young children. Must be difficult for working parents though?

Shinyandnew1 · 06/12/2022 22:23

bunnybabies · 06/12/2022 22:18

Do NOT have TAs that should have said.

Very few of the classes at my school have class TAs any more due to funding cuts -they only really come attached with funding for children with EHCPs.

Whee · 06/12/2022 22:23

One of the oddest things about England is that schools up and down the country have spent the last 2 years rewriting all foundation subject plans (ie topic lessons - history, art etc) and making progression documents to show how the objectives children follow progress from one year group to the next. Following the national curriculum objectives is not enough, and apparently what my school did was no good enough either (according to Ofsted) even though there's no guidance available. It's absolutely crazy that thousands of schools are duplicating the same pieces of work, which in a single school will be taking hundreds of hours. Pretty much sums up teaching in England.

bunnybabies · 06/12/2022 22:22

Thereare absolutley loads of jobs BUT our NQTs are paid shite and their pensions are worse. If you were to move to Dublin your rent may be e1500/2000 per month, whereas down the country where I live, it's still shitty at e1000 per month but doable if on first tier.

OP posts:
FoodieToo · 06/12/2022 22:21

We have about 12 Special Needs Assistants in our school and they are wonderful .

bunnybabies · 06/12/2022 22:18

Do NOT have TAs that should have said.

OP posts:
JodiePants · 06/12/2022 22:17

I'm a teacher and have many Irish colleagues who are desperate to get back to Ireland and teach but there seems to be a lack of jobs in education, at least in the regions they are looking for. I get to work at 7:30 and work until the children arrive at 8:30. I leave work at 3:30 to beat the traffic but will do all my planning and marking at home. On an average week, I work 60hrs. Parents can message me whenever they want on Class Dojo and I sometimes get ranty messages late at night or on weekends, but I only look at them during school hours. If a parent wants to meet with me, it's in my own time. It sounds like our experiences are extremely different and although I wish mine were more like yours, I do love the job and can't imagine doing anything else.

bunnybabies · 06/12/2022 22:17

We are at a great loss that we do have TAs.Our infant teachers spend an inordinate amount of time doing basic activities of daily living befitting of a 4/5 year old, thereby reducing quality teaching time.In fact, we are presently drawing up a list of what each child needs to be able to do before entering school eg opening/closing a lunch box, zipping up a coat, using the toiliets and washing hands,peeling a banana etc.A million miles away from where we were when I started teaching.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 06/12/2022 22:12

why would I NOT walk out the door at 250, for the sake of an extra e30 per week, when I can pass queue of angry and frustrated Parents losing their mind over a drop in scores or a drop in the school football team when they are simply not performing

If that’s the extra money SLT get paid, I’m surprised anyone does it!

bunnybabies · 06/12/2022 22:06

Yes I too am flabbergasted by the disparity in countries.I adore my job and of course I see that the success of a pupil's education in Pimary schoolis based on the Parent's being the primary educator however, our Principal will not entertain any nonsense from Parents.Everything we do is in the best interest of the child and while we are human and make mistakes at times, he refuses to entertain any horseshit which is wonderfully refreshing.Our previous Principal, because of the priviledged children who attend our school and his own self esteem issues , was almost fawning at times in his quest to appease some pretty ludicrous requests from Parents and of course, it was always the supremely wealthy, famous pupils who 'won' the competitions/awards. I agree though, our Principals and DPs are hugely overworked and underpaid..many teaching Principals.As a friend, who is a superb teacher and classroom manager once said to me...'why would I NOT walk out the door at 250, for the sake of an extra e30 per week, when I can pass queue of angry and frustrated Parents losing their mind over a drop in scores or a drop in the school football team when they are simply not performing.

OP posts:
Ballygoforwards · 06/12/2022 22:01

Also, my Irish friends gasp in amazement that 4 year olds in the UK are in school at 8.30/8.45 and finish at 3.15-3.30. And there is usually a before and after school wrap around care. Plus the fact that all English kids get a hot free school lunch daily until Year 2. And that we don’t pay a penny for school supplies at point of use. Or that most classes in the schools my DC have attended have a class teacher and a TA (not just for SEN).
All of that said, you wouldn’t convince me that education in English primary schools is any better than that in Irish ones.

FoodieToo · 06/12/2022 21:48

And 5 'illness in family' over 2 years for taking care of sick children. Time off to bring older relatives to hospital appointments etc.
Every day I am SO grateful for my job.

Cristmasshmismas · 06/12/2022 21:25

Irish teachers also have 5 personal (EPV) days to take off a year for whatever reason they wish (wedding, christening etc!) (they must do courses over the summer etc to be entitled to these though) they also get 7 consecutive calendar days off if the choose to get married in term time. Not like U.K. at all

FoodieToo · 06/12/2022 21:25

Bunnybabies I am also an AP2 . An AP1 was on offer recently but I didn't even apply .
Principals/ deputy are overworked/underpaid here in fairness.

CliffsofMohair · 06/12/2022 21:25

Shinyandnew1 · 06/12/2022 21:21

there is a two tiered system here re pay for the NQT's so Teachers are leaving in their droves.

What’s the 2-tier system? Are NQTs paid much less and are not staying?

Our Minister has tonight, suggested a ban on career leave due to a shortage.

Is career leave like a sabbatical?

During the financial crash law was passed to allow new entrants to the profession to be paid on a much lower scale. That has not been rectified. Hence ‘two tier’ system of pay.

career leave is unpaid time away usually to care for family or travel.

Id be remiss in not pointing out difficulties in the system - next to impossible to get accommodation in the cities right now. Teachers leaving in droves as they can’t afford to rent. No ‘Dublin weighting’ or equivalent.

SWS17 · 06/12/2022 21:21

I am not a teacher but have had a child at primary in the UK and in Ireland.

My observations align with OPs except that some teachers are involved in extra curricular after school activities (depending on school) and that teachers at some private schools might have longer contracted hours.

My experience in Ireland is largely positive and I think that the fact that teachers are well regarded and not overworked ultimately benefits the children. In the UK, it seems to be that endless bureaucracy and admin has obscured what school is all about - learning.

To echo PPs, in Ireland teaching is seen as a very well respected profession with family friendly hours and good holidays (2 months in summer for primary, 3 months in summer for secondary).

Shinyandnew1 · 06/12/2022 21:21

there is a two tiered system here re pay for the NQT's so Teachers are leaving in their droves.

What’s the 2-tier system? Are NQTs paid much less and are not staying?

Our Minister has tonight, suggested a ban on career leave due to a shortage.

Is career leave like a sabbatical?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.