Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to message the teacher re Christmas play cancellation

214 replies

Rascalsandradishes · 06/12/2022 18:52

DS(10) in y6 came home very upset today saying that class performance has been cancelled. It is tomorrow morning.

Teacher messaged in the class app approximately half an hour after school ended to say the play hasn't really been cancelled but wanted to use this as a stimulus for them to write a persuasive letter to get the head to change his mind. Teacher requested parents play along and help them form some arguments.

DS was really quite upset that his last show of primary school was 'cancelled'.

I couldn't play along, it just felt cruel and I don't lie to my DC. I had to tell him it wasn't real and that this was the base of a homework task.

AIBU to message the class teacher to say I've not played along and tell her how upset DS was? I can't imagine being the only parent feeling this way.

OP posts:
TeenDivided · 07/12/2022 15:01

Knittingnanny2 · 07/12/2022 14:11

So the year group teacher/teachers were following the unit of work for year 6 persuasive writing. They may have added their own embellishment eg the scenario, but in all schools I’ve worked at over almost 40years, something like this would have had to be run by the head first.

The scenario is the total issue!

I don't suppose anyone minds about y6 doing persuasive writing.

Knittingnanny2 · 07/12/2022 14:11

So the year group teacher/teachers were following the unit of work for year 6 persuasive writing. They may have added their own embellishment eg the scenario, but in all schools I’ve worked at over almost 40years, something like this would have had to be run by the head first.

Knittingnanny2 · 07/12/2022 14:08

The teachers are not allowed to teach whatever they want. They plan the lesson following “ the grand plan” set by those in higher office.

LlynTegid · 07/12/2022 13:52

Bad idea.

Something such as asking children a month ago to say why there should be a play would have been a worthwhile exercise, but not the day before.

forrestgreen · 07/12/2022 13:37

Knittingnanny2 · 07/12/2022 13:01

It won’t be the class teacher who set this task, no need for her to be sacked !

Who do you think plans the classes' work?

Knittingnanny2 · 07/12/2022 13:01

It won’t be the class teacher who set this task, no need for her to be sacked !

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 07/12/2022 09:49

daisychain01 · 07/12/2022 04:22

To my mind, this should be a sackable offence.

Its no different to a social experiment, that would need ethics committee scrutiny according to ethical guidelines (full informed consent, ie each person knowing in advance what they were being involved in, and the ability to withdraw at any time). It also involves the person in authority not lying through their teeth and stating something as fact, to mislead or engineer a certain response. Especially not when the unwitting subjects are minors who could experience disturbing emotional response to the lie, they would need their parents to,agree, not be forced to play along with the lie and harm their children.

OP I would report this as being unethical and have the perpetrator sacked for misconduct. It really is unacceptable, especially nowadays when academic institutions should abide by good practice according to ethical guidelines.

Just so we're clear, you feel that the best way to resolve this situation is to have the teacher (who OP is otherwise happy with) sacked for a one-off lapse of judgement, leaving Year 6 with a patchwork of supply cover for the spring term as they prepare for SATs and possibly only getting a new permanent teacher for the summer term if they are very lucky and the headteacher is able to advertise and recruit an excellent candidate in the last, and busiest, eight working days of the term? Right.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 07/12/2022 08:55

This is a normal Y6 piece of work, both of mine had to write persuasive letters to the head when they were in Y6, however I think the topic was misguided and I would feed that back. I think my two had to argue why afternoon break shouldn’t be cancelled and why they shouldn’t have to do extra maths. They had to write for and against arguments. Something they could have a strong opinion on but not be upset by is best.

user1477391263 · 07/12/2022 08:46

As for my own actions: I'd tell my kid the truth, and ask them to write the letter anyway.

I would mention at the next parents' evening that telling kids fibs may not be a great idea, as it puts doubt in their mind about the veracity of everything that's said to them.

user1477391263 · 07/12/2022 08:41

I think it's a bit immature/mean, but some of the responses here ("Get the teacher sacked for misconduct!!") are so ridiculously over the top. Most kids will be mildly annoyed if they think their end of year concert is cancelled, unless the adults around them are teaching them to have no resilience and to get excessively wound up about things - I really don't think the hysteria and catastrophizing here is helpful.

Then again, I also don't understand the MN hysteria about "leavers" needing all this special stuff to leave primary school - special hoodies and gifts, proms, a bunch of events, blah blah. We had very little of this when I was at school, and I'm buggered if I can remember most of the concerts we had.

PuppyMonkey · 07/12/2022 08:35

a couple said they were happy that it been cancelled because they didn't want to do it anyway (so that's backfired!)

it would be hilarious if the kids collectively decided to pretend they didn’t give a shit and came in this morning saying “whatever” to the teacher.Grin

Lampzade · 07/12/2022 06:13

Really stupid idea. Poor kids

Goatinthegarden · 07/12/2022 06:09

BotWaterHottle · 06/12/2022 20:27

How should you go about getting what you want when others don't agree?

Write a letter convincing them of your viewpoint, with well reasoned arguments.

What is OP being advised to do? Use her words to express her dissatisfaction, with the aim of the teacher making a different choice next time.

Maybe it's actually designed to test parents' literacy and critical thinking skills!

And people lie to their children all the time.

Nah. I’m a p7 teacher (Scottish equiv. of Y6) and I think this is an incredibly poorly judged decision from the teacher.

We teach persuasive writing by getting children to critically engage with both sides of the argument and to discuss and consider all viewpoints. It’s important to choose a subject they can get passionate about…however getting them all worked up and flustered, then sending them to bed distressed when they have worked hard on something is just cruel.

You get the best out of children when they trust that you have their best interests at heart; that you make decisions and put in boundaries that benefit them. I wouldn’t be surprised if she started having difficulties in class with attitude and behaviour after this.

Ericaequites · 07/12/2022 04:59

Tweens are wound tightly enough already this time of year. Pulling this cruel and manipulative nonsense is not fair, and provides a terrible example. My mother was not one to interfere in school. Trouble at school meant trouble at home. She would have called the head to complain about this.

daisychain01 · 07/12/2022 04:26

If you let them off the hook, they will feel they have license to pull the stunt again at a future time. It isn't about going in all guns ablazing, it's about highlighting your concerns for the collective good of the children,

daisychain01 · 07/12/2022 04:22

To my mind, this should be a sackable offence.

Its no different to a social experiment, that would need ethics committee scrutiny according to ethical guidelines (full informed consent, ie each person knowing in advance what they were being involved in, and the ability to withdraw at any time). It also involves the person in authority not lying through their teeth and stating something as fact, to mislead or engineer a certain response. Especially not when the unwitting subjects are minors who could experience disturbing emotional response to the lie, they would need their parents to,agree, not be forced to play along with the lie and harm their children.

OP I would report this as being unethical and have the perpetrator sacked for misconduct. It really is unacceptable, especially nowadays when academic institutions should abide by good practice according to ethical guidelines.

NumberTheory · 07/12/2022 01:15

RoachPussy · 06/12/2022 21:15

How did those conversations go? Genuinely curious.

I can’t really recall exactly, my kids are teens now and it wasn’t ever a big deal. I think we just talked about it in the way we talked about any pretend play, whereby we pretended but if they said something along the lines of “Does he really?” we would say “No, of course not, but it’s a fun story, isn’t it?” and then go back to pretending.

PollyPut · 06/12/2022 23:45

Reminds me of the time that the school decided that the Junior School Play was going to be the Year 6 play. The year 5s were distraught when they found this out. Parents wrote to the head as some children were crying when they realised they would miss this. Sadly it was true and not changed.

My point being - write to the head. It's not acceptable. Of course the children are upset. Maybe some costume pieces will get left at home too?

Boobahs · 06/12/2022 23:11

surreygirl1987 · 06/12/2022 20:32

*Way back in 1990, when I was 13, the English department at my school decided to gather us all in the classroom and spin a lengthy horrifying story that the tap water in school had been contaminated and we were going to have to quarantine for weeks at school.

It was so believable and many of us were crying, as we'd been told that our parents would only be able to see us through the fence and would have to bring us our belongings from home. The details had all been thought out and I remember being petrified. I have no idea who thought this up, and why nobody else told them that it was a FUCKING TERRIBLE IDEA.

Oh, and the whole point was so we could write a diary about how we would feel in this situation.*

Oh my god. I'm absolutely horrified. I'm an English teacher and I can't imagine doing this!

I still think about how terrible it was. We thought we'd be sleeping in sleeping bags in the classrooms and would have to have food shipped in. Not to mention the fact that we all thought we were really poorly too.

EternalCountrygirl · 06/12/2022 22:20

Talk to the head teacher as this seems to me (a primary school professional for twenty years) to be very inappropriate, unprofessional and completely stupid idea! Is this person actually a teacher?!

TenoringBehind · 06/12/2022 22:16

I’d be writing a letter to the head and the governors, and would question if this was someone I wanted to be teaching my child.

Upwiththelark76 · 06/12/2022 22:07

forrestgreen · 06/12/2022 18:57

I get him to write a letter to the teacher persuading her to not use that homework again as it's cruel

This ⬆️

Irealisenow · 06/12/2022 22:00

I hate things like this. When I was in year 5 (so a long time ago 92/93) all 3 class teachers had a huge argument in assembly, shouting and screaming at each other and 2 stormed out. We all sat there shocked and some upset. They waited about 15 minutes and one came back to ask who we thought was in the right etc then after a long discussion the third teacher cane back and said it was part of a lesson . It was just horrible

I think you were right OP. If parents did this kind of thing it would be labelled emotional abuse

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 06/12/2022 21:59

WTF.

Id tell my child. Something like that would really upset my kids

Rascalsandradishes · 06/12/2022 21:57

Thank you everyone. I wasn't if I'm being precious.

DS knows it is not true, we had a chat about it and we came up with some arguments together. He added on the end that it's not nice to tell children lies.

He said one child was very upset in the class, a couple said they were happy that it been cancelled because they didn't want to do it anyway (so that's backfired!)

I think I understand where the teacher is coming from in setting this as a task, however I really think it could have been thought through a little more. As it has been mentioned above they have had so much cancelled over the past couple of years that it seems a bit more cruel.

I definitely won't go in all guns blazing but I will send a quick message to say I have told DS the truth and the reason why, but he has come up with some arguments anyway.
I really don't believe it's in his best interest for me to 'go along with it' as requested.

The teacher isn't young or inexperienced, and I've never had reason to complain before. I'm usually very happy with the school.

OP posts: