Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to message the teacher re Christmas play cancellation

214 replies

Rascalsandradishes · 06/12/2022 18:52

DS(10) in y6 came home very upset today saying that class performance has been cancelled. It is tomorrow morning.

Teacher messaged in the class app approximately half an hour after school ended to say the play hasn't really been cancelled but wanted to use this as a stimulus for them to write a persuasive letter to get the head to change his mind. Teacher requested parents play along and help them form some arguments.

DS was really quite upset that his last show of primary school was 'cancelled'.

I couldn't play along, it just felt cruel and I don't lie to my DC. I had to tell him it wasn't real and that this was the base of a homework task.

AIBU to message the class teacher to say I've not played along and tell her how upset DS was? I can't imagine being the only parent feeling this way.

OP posts:
ShillyShallySherbet · 07/12/2022 19:27

savehannah · 07/12/2022 18:43

Particularly cruel to do this to children who have spent the past couple of years having all sorts of fun things cancelled for real left right and centre. Absolutely unacceptable and I would be fuming.

So this! It’s awful OP I’d have done the same as you, YANBU. That task could easily have been set as a hypothetical piece of work done in school time as well.

Blanketpolicy · 07/12/2022 19:23

I would tell ds, then pretend I hadn't seen the entire message and get him off writing the stupid letter.

GUARDIAN1 · 07/12/2022 19:18

YANBU Not at all! I would be furious if my kids' schools had pulled this sort of stunt. I would not just message the teacher but complain to the head and governors. I've never heard anything like it.

BagpussBagpussOldFatFurryCatpuss · 07/12/2022 19:12

Who the hell does this. Stupid idea.

Kgiggl3s · 07/12/2022 19:11

As a teacher, I usually roll my eyes at threads that begin like this.. however I actually completely agree with you. I've taught yr 6 quite a few times and So much effort goes into these productions that I can't even imagine doing this. What was she/he thinking?
On a side note, teachers are encouraged to create scenarios where children can 'write for a purpose' to make the work more engaging and relevant which I'd imagine is what she was trying to achieve but this is not the way to do it. Very very bizzare. Poor kids.

BogRollBOGOF · 07/12/2022 19:07

savehannah · 07/12/2022 18:43

Particularly cruel to do this to children who have spent the past couple of years having all sorts of fun things cancelled for real left right and centre. Absolutely unacceptable and I would be fuming.

Absolutely. These children were 7-8 when they were told that they were breaking up early for Easter, and many didn't get to set foot back in school for nearly 6 months.
After Christmas when they were 8-9, they either did a day back at school or were at bedtime (or in bed) preparing to go back to school the next morning and that was removed from them for another two months again with pretty much no notice.

Dishonesty of this nature, especially in recent times is an appalling misjudgment of the teaching team.

Even without that context, it would always be a risky strategy for upsetting some members of the class who struggle with distinguishing reality and fiction due to SNs, maturity or difficult past experiences.

Bekstar · 07/12/2022 19:03

That is so out of order for a school. All the work those kids have done and they get told it's not going ahead for what a bit of homework to write a begging letter. It's nothing shirt of absuive what if some of them kids are on the autistic spectrum. My son would probably be relieved because he hates preforming so I can imagine the idea of turning up and finding it is going ahead just too much for him.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/12/2022 18:59

Is this the second thread on this exact homework? I’m sure I saw one yesterday, with more responses from the OP on it. I’m just hoping I haven’t lost my last marble!

MustWeDoThis · 07/12/2022 18:57

Rascalsandradishes · 06/12/2022 18:52

DS(10) in y6 came home very upset today saying that class performance has been cancelled. It is tomorrow morning.

Teacher messaged in the class app approximately half an hour after school ended to say the play hasn't really been cancelled but wanted to use this as a stimulus for them to write a persuasive letter to get the head to change his mind. Teacher requested parents play along and help them form some arguments.

DS was really quite upset that his last show of primary school was 'cancelled'.

I couldn't play along, it just felt cruel and I don't lie to my DC. I had to tell him it wasn't real and that this was the base of a homework task.

AIBU to message the class teacher to say I've not played along and tell her how upset DS was? I can't imagine being the only parent feeling this way.

Coercive and emotional abuse. Report her.

KrystynaZ · 07/12/2022 18:57

I think it is a good exercise. Learning to argue one's case calmly and persuasively, rather than reacting to a situation with pure emotion, is a very valuable life skill.
Bravo to that teacher!

AmyDudley · 07/12/2022 18:54

My Ds is a teacher, he has told me that over the last couple of years they have had to deal with a huge amount of anxiety among the children, lockdown caused so much damage. He's done a lot of one to one work with pupils on how to cope with anxiety.
writing persuasive letters - fine. Lying to kids in a way that anyone with half a brain would know would upset them is imbecilic.

happydivorcee · 07/12/2022 18:51

As a teacher, I read your thread title and was ready to jump in and say “Please don’t message a stressed out teacher at this time of year!”. Then I read your post and I’m gobsmacked. Totally bonkers idea and I’d be surprised if SLT had agreed to this lesson plan..!

drivinghomeforchristmascraic · 07/12/2022 18:45

I think the ideas good. It's important for people to write persuasive letters to they're MPs and 'leaders'.

Perhaps ask the school to get the kids to find a real cause they are worried about (rubbished dumped in local stream, need more park benches etc) and write a real letter to their real MP.

savehannah · 07/12/2022 18:43

Particularly cruel to do this to children who have spent the past couple of years having all sorts of fun things cancelled for real left right and centre. Absolutely unacceptable and I would be fuming.

BatshitBanshee · 07/12/2022 18:37

blondie185 · 07/12/2022 18:15

Jesus. You sound horrible. Poor teacher! Anyone would think she told them Santa wasn't real.

Oh, I'm horrible? But the adult in a position of trust who lied to kids in their care for a homework assignment the night before their show they had put time and effort into is to be pitied? Ok so. How do you suppose the children in the class will completely trust this teacher again? Using small kids to do a mandatory homework assignment to plead with an authoritative figure like a head teacher to allow them to continue their Christmas show and ask parents to go along with the lie is very, very wrong @blondie185.

rosemarysalter · 07/12/2022 18:36

Perhaps your child can write a persuasive argument about why the teacher is BU?

Zhampagne · 07/12/2022 18:35

I’ll be interested to know the outcome of this if OP comes back. The teacher has fucked up and a complaint would be warranted.

However I am absolutely fascinated by the batshit posters on this thread who have (presumably) reached adulthood genuinely thinking they can compel a headteacher to drop everything to take an evening call, or ‘call for’ and achieve the sacking of a teacher with a single complaint.

BreatheAndFocus · 07/12/2022 18:31

Unnecessarily cruel - what a stupid, thoughtless thing to do. I wouldn’t let my DC take part and I’d be telling the teacher and Head my feelings. It’s completely unnecessary to pull a stunt like that in order to practise persuasive writing. It’s particularly cruel at this time of year and after the last few crap COVID years with everything cancelled and children stressed.

electricmoccasins · 07/12/2022 18:26

Poor judgement from the teacher. You have to be so careful what you say to children. They don’t have the experience to recognise something isn’t true and simply a device.

Examples of good and bad judgement at my daughter’s school…

Practising a whole-school lockdown in case an intruder enters the school:

Good judgement - Reception teacher: ‘Hey, children! The Head is playing hide-and-seek with us. We need to hide under the tables and hope she doesn’t find us…’

Bad judgement - Year 1 teacher: ‘Quick, children! There’s a wolf loose in the school and we need to hide under the tables. Be quiet else we’ll be eaten.’

My poor daughter was in the Year 1 class. Nightmares for weeks.

pollymere · 07/12/2022 18:22

The really stupid thing is that these kids write these sorts of letters every year without learning how to do it properly so you then spend Secondary teaching them how do it, but by then their all sick of writing the stupid things. This was an awful topic and I'm dismayed the teacher thought it was a good idea as it was guaranteed to cause upset or relief in students. I'm not sure which is worse, the relief that the School Play is happening or the horror that it was a joke and you still have to do it. They could easily have said future productions. OR how about the state of the school toilets, extending the school day, abolishing morning playtime, why we need school uniform, why Y6s need mobile phones (much more controversial 😂), why kids should walk to school, why Tesco's should remove the ban on Students (this actually happened) etc...

Knittingnanny2 · 07/12/2022 18:18

And I said this particular scenario would have been run past the head.

Laurie000 · 07/12/2022 18:16

I’d speak to the teacher in the morning about how upset your DC was. I wouldn’t bother the head with this (unless a series of similar things have happened). This time of year is incredibly busy in schools and with scarlet fever/strep A doing the rounds, I would imagine that the head would have more pressing matters to deal with. Teachers aren’t robots and do misjudge situations or make decisions, without thinking it through properly. The teacher was most likely thinking that they would get some great writing from it because of how strongly the children would feel about having the play cancelled.
It’s great that you don’t lie to your children. Out of curiosity, does that mean they’ve always known the truth about Santa and the tooth fairy?

blondie185 · 07/12/2022 18:15

BatshitBanshee · 06/12/2022 19:07

So after the kids have worked hard on their school play... Their teacher tells them it's cancelled the day before and to persuade the principal to uncancel it?

Yeah I wouldn't play along. I'd have the head on the phone this evening or the morning at the very latest to see if they also are going along with this and ask them the thought process.

The teacher would get an email with a polite version of what the fuck do you think you're doing and DS wouldn't be doing the homework. We don't do lies in my house.

Jesus. You sound horrible. Poor teacher! Anyone would think she told them Santa wasn't real.

LynetteScavo · 07/12/2022 16:42

So what what was the schools response @Rascalsandradishes?

mathanxiety · 07/12/2022 15:41

This is a completely unprofessional lapse of judgement, and downright cruel.

I wouldn't mince words to the teacher and I would cc the HT.