Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to message the teacher re Christmas play cancellation

214 replies

Rascalsandradishes · 06/12/2022 18:52

DS(10) in y6 came home very upset today saying that class performance has been cancelled. It is tomorrow morning.

Teacher messaged in the class app approximately half an hour after school ended to say the play hasn't really been cancelled but wanted to use this as a stimulus for them to write a persuasive letter to get the head to change his mind. Teacher requested parents play along and help them form some arguments.

DS was really quite upset that his last show of primary school was 'cancelled'.

I couldn't play along, it just felt cruel and I don't lie to my DC. I had to tell him it wasn't real and that this was the base of a homework task.

AIBU to message the class teacher to say I've not played along and tell her how upset DS was? I can't imagine being the only parent feeling this way.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
typopro · 30/03/2023 22:32

Zombie 🧟‍♀️

cruisebaba1 · 30/03/2023 18:19

BCxx · 06/12/2022 19:43

The teacher has most likely lost her marbles as a result of it being December and she’s having to deal with homework, behaviour, school play, planning, marking, observations, learning walks, tracking meetings and probably various parents complaining over trivial things daily. She’s misjudged this but why not just play along, the kids would talk about that for years! I was a teacher, worst job in the world. Send her a bottle of wine in and tell her to have a bubble bath when she gets home, she’s probably already a member of the same Facebook group as me and 110k others (exit the classroom and thrive) don’t push her over the edge.

If the teacher can’t cope she should find a job that suits her capabilities, she obviously hasn’t got the children’s interests at the core of this. She’s being ridiculous and should be reprimanded.

ArrrrrghStopLickingTheDog · 08/12/2022 12:33

I really can't think of any reason that the teacher would think it OK to do this

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 08/12/2022 12:21

It really wouldn't be difficult to think up a suitably festive scenario for this task - maybe the teacher could have said that Father Christmas was going to sack Rudolf, and ask the children to write letters to persuade him not to. Or the Prime Minister is going to make a law saying you have to eat sprouts at Christmas - write a letter saying why this is wrong. And that's just off the top of my head.

I can well imagine that the task the teacher set will have upset a number of the children, who have been working so hard on the Nativity play - and even if that upset only lasts until the next day, when the teacher tells them it was all made up, and of course the play is happening - that is still unnecessary upset.

I agree with previous posters, who have said that this sort of thing does not build resilience, and will make the children wary of trusting that teacher again.

I also find it hard to believe that some posters would not be cross if their child came out of school really upset because the teacher had told them the play was cancelled. Even if you can reassure them, and tell them that it is just a homework task, that doesn't negate the unhappiness caused initially. And if your child either isn't bothered by the play, or sees through the teacher's ruse, and isn't upset, wouldn't you be at all moved by the other children's unhappiness?

Frabbits · 08/12/2022 12:19

KrystynaZ · 08/12/2022 05:42

No Santa Claus in your house then?

I can't believe the hysteria on this thread. I really hope the worst thing that ever happens to these kids is that their Christmas play gets cancelled. They are going to grow up with zero resilience, thanks to their outraged parents.

This kind of shit doesn't build resilience, it was ill-advised and just plain mean.

GlomOfNit · 08/12/2022 11:17

Dear god. I'm sure the teacher thought this was creative and clever and is telling herself it'll be ok because tomorrow all will be revealed, but it's a shitty thing to do once expectations have been raised, rehearsals etc, and the heightened hysteria that is the last few weeks at school before Christmas... So badly judged! And as others have said, it's fine to be rational about this as an adult, but this teacher is showing very little understanding of how children think and feel. I would hope a teacher could show more empathy.

I've heard of this sort of stunt before, as a frame to build a creative writing exercise on - I think one year in my son's primary, the head teacher was 'kidnapped' and the entire school then worked, at their appropriate level, on various tasks around this crisis. Grin But I seem to remember it was a very implausible, fantasy scenario so presumably most kids didn't actually believe it. To tell your class that their beloved Christmas play was cancelled the night before is just cruelty. I'd be interested to know if the Head signed off on this.

OP, I'd be writing a fairly strong letter here. Make sure it's a poor judgement she won't make again in her career.

nocciola · 08/12/2022 10:45

OP, I am a teacher and that is a really crappy thing to do!!

eastegg · 08/12/2022 09:40

BotWaterHottle · 06/12/2022 20:27

How should you go about getting what you want when others don't agree?

Write a letter convincing them of your viewpoint, with well reasoned arguments.

What is OP being advised to do? Use her words to express her dissatisfaction, with the aim of the teacher making a different choice next time.

Maybe it's actually designed to test parents' literacy and critical thinking skills!

And people lie to their children all the time.

What a load of nonsense. Why on earth would a school want or need to test parents’ critical thinking skills?

Stewball01 · 08/12/2022 08:58

Teachers can be very moronic.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/12/2022 07:42

KrystynaZ · 08/12/2022 05:42

No Santa Claus in your house then?

I can't believe the hysteria on this thread. I really hope the worst thing that ever happens to these kids is that their Christmas play gets cancelled. They are going to grow up with zero resilience, thanks to their outraged parents.

It's not resilience training to give a bunch of children what, for some, will be their first experience of gaslighting or coercive control.

Pretending to cancel something they've worked hard for and were looking forward to in order to see how they react and dismiss upset as character building is textbook psychological abuse. Some could have been told previously by abusive parents that it had been cancelled, only to find it wasn't, and then the adults they could actually trust did exactly the same. They would all learn that teachers are untrustworthy and cannot be relied upon.

This isn't a fantasy situation like dragons or naughty elves, it's absolutely feasible and shouldn't be used as a writing stimulus. Because it turns into a social experiment in how post pandemic children react to being told they're going to experience yet another loss instead of whether there is the correct number of adverbs and tone in their writing.

carefulcalculator · 08/12/2022 06:50

KrystynaZ · 08/12/2022 05:42

No Santa Claus in your house then?

I can't believe the hysteria on this thread. I really hope the worst thing that ever happens to these kids is that their Christmas play gets cancelled. They are going to grow up with zero resilience, thanks to their outraged parents.

You don't need to invent problems to teach children resilience, you just help them deal with life.

People still have problems - this country is facing widespread poverty, hunger, cold, lack of healthcare, lack of mental healthcare, problems in education.

We just lived through a pandemic where children's schools were closed - this affected all children whether rich or poor, healthy or unhealthy.

This bullshit about 'resilience' is also toxic. You don't make people resilient by pulling these kinds of stunts, this is not what resilience is about.

KrystynaZ · 08/12/2022 05:42

BlueMongoose · 07/12/2022 20:46

My parents never lied to us. We were not told that fairy stories of any kind were true. Just that they were stories.Do you think year 6 kids believe dragons exist if they read The Hobbit?

No Santa Claus in your house then?

I can't believe the hysteria on this thread. I really hope the worst thing that ever happens to these kids is that their Christmas play gets cancelled. They are going to grow up with zero resilience, thanks to their outraged parents.

daisychain01 · 08/12/2022 04:26

I think it was rather creative of the teacher

that's because you're an adult, with (presumably) logical thought processes that signal to you that there'll be another year, another Christmas play, and that nobody died.

in the eyes of a child it will be a huge disappointment, that is based on a deliberate lie. That's called cruel and callous not creative. Not only do you lack empathy, you clearly have zero concept of ethics in this situation.

Autumn61 · 08/12/2022 02:30

Rascalsandradishes · 06/12/2022 18:52

DS(10) in y6 came home very upset today saying that class performance has been cancelled. It is tomorrow morning.

Teacher messaged in the class app approximately half an hour after school ended to say the play hasn't really been cancelled but wanted to use this as a stimulus for them to write a persuasive letter to get the head to change his mind. Teacher requested parents play along and help them form some arguments.

DS was really quite upset that his last show of primary school was 'cancelled'.

I couldn't play along, it just felt cruel and I don't lie to my DC. I had to tell him it wasn't real and that this was the base of a homework task.

AIBU to message the class teacher to say I've not played along and tell her how upset DS was? I can't imagine being the only parent feeling this way.

I think it was rather creative of the teacher . Will get the children writing some emotional, heartfelt letters and have a nice surprise at the end . Did I miss something or did somebody die? Jaamoi, what did you tell your child about Santa? Just wondering about the ‘ not lying to my children ‘ bit.

BabyOnBoard90 · 07/12/2022 23:46

Personally don't see the big deal. I would just have motivated my child to write a strongly worded letter and leave it at that.

They'll get over it once they find out it's not cancelled.

Donewaiting · 07/12/2022 22:39

I work in a primary school and can never imagine this happening here.

I agree with others that it's a misguided idea. The children have every right to be upset.

Plus in my experience Chinese whispers start on parents WhatsApp groups and before you know it, word will be out that the play is actually cancelled, rather than it being part of some elaborate homework hoax, parents will have rearranged work and childcare to attend the play and if they've misunderstood, be quite rightly feel annoyed, leading to a number of calls to school. Plus they have an upset child to deal with as well.

Terrible idea.

Zhampagne · 07/12/2022 21:23

JustCakeInDrag · 06/12/2022 20:45

Yes, the teacher has badly misjudged this, but

I'd have the head on the phone this evening or the morning at the very latest

Who the fuck do you think you are, love?

Indeed. I work for a network of schools. I had a conversation with one of our headteachers today who has fifteen staff absent due to illness and is doing a daily Sudoku to work out if she can safely open to all classes, plus six confirmed cases of scarlet fever amongst the children and Public Health England on the phone every day. The idea that this headteacher should have to drop all this to make themselves immediately available to take an evening call for a parental complaint, however justified, is actual madness.

Laurie000 · 07/12/2022 20:56

I’d be very impressed at a 6 year old reading the hobbit. While I get your point, there is a slight difference. Parents who tell their children that Santa is real, usually follow it up with presents from Santa on xmas day. Whereas, a child who has read the hobbit aren’t going to find a dragons egg in their kitchen cupboard so to speak.
My question was just that… a curious question.

BlueMongoose · 07/12/2022 20:46

Laurie000 · 07/12/2022 18:16

I’d speak to the teacher in the morning about how upset your DC was. I wouldn’t bother the head with this (unless a series of similar things have happened). This time of year is incredibly busy in schools and with scarlet fever/strep A doing the rounds, I would imagine that the head would have more pressing matters to deal with. Teachers aren’t robots and do misjudge situations or make decisions, without thinking it through properly. The teacher was most likely thinking that they would get some great writing from it because of how strongly the children would feel about having the play cancelled.
It’s great that you don’t lie to your children. Out of curiosity, does that mean they’ve always known the truth about Santa and the tooth fairy?

My parents never lied to us. We were not told that fairy stories of any kind were true. Just that they were stories.Do you think year 6 kids believe dragons exist if they read The Hobbit?

CelestiaNoctis · 07/12/2022 20:45

I see this was yesterday so how did it turn out in the end?

CelestiaNoctis · 07/12/2022 20:44

I'm confused. How can they complete homework for tomorrow when the play is in the morning? What if parents haven't seen the message because they're at work and don't get a chance to tell their child before the following day because they've gone to bed? Or what if they didn't bother reading the message and just took what their child said and don't show up tomorrow for the play now. This is clearly something they've all worked weeks on and put in effort so its definitely really mean. What a really strange and not well thought out idea!! I can imagine this will cause chaos.

BlueMongoose · 07/12/2022 20:41

JustCakeInDrag · 06/12/2022 21:00

Are you a sock puppet or are you claiming credit for other people’s posts?

What?

Whatwouldyado · 07/12/2022 19:41

Catatemysandwich · 06/12/2022 18:58

Reminds me of the year in infants my DD's class decorated the classroom then a 'grinch' came and tore it all down - it was meant to be a detective task to work out who did it, alongside English text of The Grinch. Most of the children were in tears/devastated! I don't think they did it the next year... I agree, tell your son and mention to teacher

jesus!

purplebunny2012 · 07/12/2022 19:37

YANBU, what a totally stupid idea!

Brokendaughter · 07/12/2022 19:28

I wonder if there was a child in that class who was building up to trusting the teacher enough to disclose abuse?

They wouldn't trust the teacher after this.

If a parent intentionally emotionally distressed a child 'so they knew how it felt' I suspect they'd be accused of abuse.
The school is just as capable of causing significant emotional harm as anyone else & for some children, that breaking of trust would be enough to do it.