Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that a unit I rent is NOT the landlords family home?

56 replies

xania2022 · 06/12/2022 17:33

I live in a country where landlords cannot ban pets. They are protected under lease laws and landlords can only ban pets in a very few limited circumstances. None of these apply to me.

I got a cat and messaged the landlord informing them so they are aware in case they ever need to access my unit in emergencies. He got upset, stated he doesn't like animals "in his family home" and operates a no pet clause. Obviously there is nothing he can do under the law of the country I'm in and he should be aware of this.

AIBU to be annoyed by this? He chose to be a landlord in a country where pet exclusion clauses are illegal and tenants have a wide variety of rights and protection. He should be up to date with basic laws and procedures. It is his property and I will take care of it, return it in exactly the same condition and of course I would pay for any damages if they occurred, whether it be cats, children or anything that is my fault.

However, it has rubbed me the wrong way the way he has called it "his family home." I pay an extortionate amount of rent, I pay my rent on time and I'm a good tenant. I have all the necessary insurance, report issues promptly and make sure I do routine maintenance to keep the property and appliances in order. It is his property, but whilst I am renting, it is my home in a sentimental sense and legally mine to exclusively occupy. He does not live here (or anywhere near here, to be exact) and I resent him for not even being up to date on basic residential tenancy act laws.

He's also previously tried to access the unit on the basis of, "it's my home, so why can't I fix things without giving you notice?" (Again, a basic tenancy right.)

AIBU to think you shouldn't be a landlord if you're not going to obey basic residential tenancy laws? AIBU to think that whilst I'm lucky to live in a country where pet exclusion clauses are illegal and unenforceable, owning pets isn't a "luxury" reserved for those who own property, especially in light of my generation (mid 20s) being pretty much f*** in terms of owning property until either I inherit a house or can afford a massive downpayment?

OP posts:
Fladdermus · 06/12/2022 17:58

In my country we report landlords like this to the Renters Union then sit back and enjoy watching them get their arses handed back to them. Sadly whatever the rules there will always be landlords who think they don't apply to them or who are ignorant of the fact they even exist.

camdenn · 06/12/2022 17:58

It’s a hard one cause although you’ve done nothing wrong, there’s hundreds of irresponsible pet owners out there that would allow the property to be damaged by the cat eg indoor urination, scratching walls and furniture. So the landlord may retaliate and evict you by claiming he wants to move back in, especially as he’s referring to it as his “family home”

Keyansier · 06/12/2022 17:56

You sound very entitled. Yes, it's legal what you're doing as you (repeatedly) point out but it sounds like you are purposely trying to stir up trouble IMO.

PonkyPonky · 06/12/2022 17:55

I actually think landlords should have the right to say no pets. Controversial opinion I know! But I for one can’t stand animals. They do damage things that aren’t always so easily fixed with money and they smell, obviously dogs more so than cats. But if I had the good fortune to have a property to rent out, I would not want pets in there under any circumstances. As the owner, they should get a say in this.

Sparklfairy · 06/12/2022 17:37

Do you have no fault evictions in your country? If not, crack on I would love a cat in my flat

Ponoka7 · 06/12/2022 17:36

You just need to keep pointing out that it isn't his family home, it's a rented out property covered by legalisation.