Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that a unit I rent is NOT the landlords family home?

56 replies

xania2022 · 06/12/2022 17:33

I live in a country where landlords cannot ban pets. They are protected under lease laws and landlords can only ban pets in a very few limited circumstances. None of these apply to me.

I got a cat and messaged the landlord informing them so they are aware in case they ever need to access my unit in emergencies. He got upset, stated he doesn't like animals "in his family home" and operates a no pet clause. Obviously there is nothing he can do under the law of the country I'm in and he should be aware of this.

AIBU to be annoyed by this? He chose to be a landlord in a country where pet exclusion clauses are illegal and tenants have a wide variety of rights and protection. He should be up to date with basic laws and procedures. It is his property and I will take care of it, return it in exactly the same condition and of course I would pay for any damages if they occurred, whether it be cats, children or anything that is my fault.

However, it has rubbed me the wrong way the way he has called it "his family home." I pay an extortionate amount of rent, I pay my rent on time and I'm a good tenant. I have all the necessary insurance, report issues promptly and make sure I do routine maintenance to keep the property and appliances in order. It is his property, but whilst I am renting, it is my home in a sentimental sense and legally mine to exclusively occupy. He does not live here (or anywhere near here, to be exact) and I resent him for not even being up to date on basic residential tenancy act laws.

He's also previously tried to access the unit on the basis of, "it's my home, so why can't I fix things without giving you notice?" (Again, a basic tenancy right.)

AIBU to think you shouldn't be a landlord if you're not going to obey basic residential tenancy laws? AIBU to think that whilst I'm lucky to live in a country where pet exclusion clauses are illegal and unenforceable, owning pets isn't a "luxury" reserved for those who own property, especially in light of my generation (mid 20s) being pretty much f*** in terms of owning property until either I inherit a house or can afford a massive downpayment?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FlairBand · 06/12/2022 22:39

YANBU for expecting the rules to apply. YABABU for having not quite been the tenant he thought he was getting!

IME children generally cause WAY more wear and tear than pets unless they’re poorly looked after.

When I was a landlord I never said no pets and I never said no children… to much grief from prospective tenants. I just never accepted offers from people with pets and never accepted offers from people with children. Divorcees and single / couple professionals all the way!

He’s cross because he thought he was getting round the rules by being selective and you’ve cornered him! HIBABU by calling it his family home though.

xania2022 · 06/12/2022 22:32

I do think in general that people don't realise that being a landlord isn't just letting someone else live in a property and them paying you until their contract ends.

If you choose to benefit from the housing needs of the general population/those who don't own property to fund your own lifestyle, then this becomes your business. You have to treat it like one and accept there will be losses, such as damage. But that doesn't give you the right to impede on tenant's lives to an extent that is unreasonable.

I have come across too many landlords who do the bare minimum upkeep, do no maintenance or think renting houses out is simply taking money and letting someone live there. For example, the city I live in is full of landlords who rent out their illegal basements with no fire escapes to afford the overpriced mortgage they should never have taken out. Or people dividing their home up into illegal apartments and not being able to replace the outdated electrical appliances and tenants being left with no oven or shower. I have grown up seeing newspaper stories of people (frequently poorer immigrants) drowning or burning to death as their unit wasn't safe.

If your tenant not paying rent for a couple of months will bankrupt you, then you do not have the financial resources required to maintain properties and are at risk of not being able to meet your professional duties as a landlord, morally or in terms of safety.

I am not against landlords. I appreciate not having to own a house when I frequently move due to my job. I appreciate that I pay rent and then the boiler needing to be replaced isn't my responsibility. I understand that it is not my property and I must take care of it. What I am against is hobby landlords and unethical landlords who don't realise the commitment and cost of legally and morally meeting the upkeep requirements of maintaining property, whilst making unrealistic demands of tenants that impede far too much into their lives when they are paying for the space to be theirs for the period of the tenancy contract.

OP posts:
Butchyrestingface · 06/12/2022 21:33

FurAndFeathers · 06/12/2022 19:37

It’s entitled to expect your landlord to act within the law?

Christ some folk have low standards!

It's just Keyansier, Mumsnet's resident weirdo contrarian.

silentpool · 06/12/2022 21:23

YANBU. A rental is a business venture and needs to be viewed dispassionately. Tenants are treated badly and should be able to settle in and make the place home. If there is damage, it can be dealt with at the end of the lease.

germancowboy · 06/12/2022 21:14

Keyansier · 06/12/2022 17:56

You sound very entitled. Yes, it's legal what you're doing as you (repeatedly) point out but it sounds like you are purposely trying to stir up trouble IMO.

Entitled??

HairyMcLarie · 06/12/2022 20:41

theydontspeakforus · 06/12/2022 18:40

A house which you choose not to live in is not your family home.

@HairyMcLarie you don't allow children??

Who even are these people. Take back your home and pay your own bloody mortgage if you don't like the (legal!!!) rights of tenants. Fuck me. Entitled and privileged second home owners really are the lowest of the low.

No I don't rent to people with children. The property isn't suitable for them, they are noisy and damage things. Granted mine is a short term rental but when I've allowed them previously I've had drawing on the walls, a broken shower from a child hauling themselves up from the floor using the hose, vomit in the carpet, chocolate mushed into the carpet, a broken washing machine due to it being on non stop for 4 days, mud tramped around from pram wheels and nappies left all over the house. So SO entitled so now I say no children.

Pet owners have left it looking pristine so they are more than welcome.

PinkFrogss · 06/12/2022 19:54

roarfeckingroarr · 06/12/2022 18:43

@CorporateBull you should return the property just as it was when you moved in though?

No she doesn’t, every property will have wear and tear. If a house you rent was freshly painted when you moved in, and you move out 10 years later you don’t have to repaint it etc

Butchyrestingface · 06/12/2022 19:53

I ban kids from our rental for the same reason.

Lol. Whit??

@xania2022 Are you sure this is the right rental for you? Regardless of the legalities, it must be surely be a chore to be the tenant of someone who thinks rules and for loserz and attempts to gain entrance to the property with no warning.

FurAndFeathers · 06/12/2022 19:37

Keyansier · 06/12/2022 17:56

You sound very entitled. Yes, it's legal what you're doing as you (repeatedly) point out but it sounds like you are purposely trying to stir up trouble IMO.

It’s entitled to expect your landlord to act within the law?

Christ some folk have low standards!

Blowthemandown · 06/12/2022 19:31

@xania2022 I’m allergic to cats, much as I love them. So I would want someone without pets. That said, I probably wouldn't take the risk letting a property if there were a chance someone would decide to have a pet.

CorporateBull · 06/12/2022 19:26

SarahAndQuack · 06/12/2022 19:24

But it often is a matter of law, isn't it? In the UK, it is.

And it’s inappropriate to share his feelings with his tenant because legally she is in the right.

The issue often is that the emotional attachment can easily lead to a landlord overriding the law and tenants not understanding their rights when that happens.

He can think it all he wants, but it’s irrelevant to the OP other than to make her feel uncomfortable in her home.

SarahAndQuack · 06/12/2022 19:25

Sorry, that should be: in England it is a matter of law; I believe elsewhere in the UK but might be wrong.

SarahAndQuack · 06/12/2022 19:24

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 06/12/2022 19:22

I did ask OP to clarify where she lived @Dragonskin

As regards to someone identifying a property as their home/family home, isn’t a matter of laws, contracts and legal rights etc….. is a statement of personal feeling/opinion.

That clearly and obviously doesn’t mean a landlord overrides the law, contract or legal responsibility’s towards their tenant, just because they identify a property they own as their former family home.

In this case going by what the OP has advised he’s expressed a feeling/opinion that they’d rather not have pets in their property they rent out which they identify as their family home.

Personally I don’t see an issue with either and the OP reaction is OTT.

But it often is a matter of law, isn't it? In the UK, it is.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 06/12/2022 19:22

I did ask OP to clarify where she lived @Dragonskin

As regards to someone identifying a property as their home/family home, isn’t a matter of laws, contracts and legal rights etc….. is a statement of personal feeling/opinion.

That clearly and obviously doesn’t mean a landlord overrides the law, contract or legal responsibility’s towards their tenant, just because they identify a property they own as their former family home.

In this case going by what the OP has advised he’s expressed a feeling/opinion that they’d rather not have pets in their property they rent out which they identify as their family home.

Personally I don’t see an issue with either and the OP reaction is OTT.

CorporateBull · 06/12/2022 19:19

SarahAndQuack · 06/12/2022 18:49

He sounds like a knob. Presumably you're in a country where, legally, it is not his family home if it's rented out? I have had a couple of LL (in England) who acted as if this came as news to them, and they are a pain. I would always avoid anyone who was letting out a house in which they'd previously lived/intended to live. It is just not worth the hassle. A few people manage to detach emotionally, but many still feel as if it's their home and it's just uncomfortable all round.

If you're not too afraid of eviction, personally, I would be awfully tempted to get passive aggressive and write him a (polite) letter drawing his attention to the law, and referring to the house as your family home.

This very much.

When you pay rent and have a tenancy agreement, it’s your home. Someone who sees that still as THEIR home is emotionally involved and as I have repeatedly experienced (including unfortunately my current landlord) it can lead to inappropriate and/or disproportionate requirements on tenants, and overreaction to minor day to day issues. It’s also really tricky when someone is telling you that your home is their home - it subtly affects your sense of security in the place you live. Tenants have every right to regard the place they live as their home.

It’s not great to rent out a house you haven’t emotionally detached from. It doesn’t lead to good decision-making.

Poor tenants are poor tenants, but poor landlords are poor landlords too.

antelopevalley · 06/12/2022 19:19

@Sleepingbabies2021 I think lots of landlords underestimate wear and tear from families. You can't expect things not to get broken.

antelopevalley · 06/12/2022 19:17

Property should not be returned as it was when you moved in. There is reasonable wear and tear. A newly painted house will not look the same five years later.

CorporateBull · 06/12/2022 19:13

roarfeckingroarr · 06/12/2022 18:43

@CorporateBull you should return the property just as it was when you moved in though?

Yep, with a reasonable amount of wear and tear, which is set out in guidelines that a leasehold tribunal will adhere to. Both my landlords wanted to use our deposit to make it nicer. One wanted to fund extensive garden landscaping (eg a tree removed) and one to paint a house that wasn’t freshly painted when we moved in. That’s called betterment and it’s not allowed. Unfortunately the country in which we lived had laxer tenancy laws so both got away with it to some extent.

Sleepingbabies2021 · 06/12/2022 19:10

I used to rent out two flats within my home (a triplex) in a very high cost of living city with an serious affordable housing shortage. Sadly after years of dealing with damages, entitled tenants, loud tenants, unauthorized pets and constant repairs due to tenants lack of care for the property we no longer rent. Our flats were affordable, well maintained and we were responsible landlords. Now one is empty and the other we've taken over for our own use.
And people wonder why there is such a shortage of affordable rental housing .... 🙄

Quveas · 06/12/2022 19:06

PonkyPonky · 06/12/2022 17:55

I actually think landlords should have the right to say no pets. Controversial opinion I know! But I for one can’t stand animals. They do damage things that aren’t always so easily fixed with money and they smell, obviously dogs more so than cats. But if I had the good fortune to have a property to rent out, I would not want pets in there under any circumstances. As the owner, they should get a say in this.

I have the same opinion about children.

PuttingDownRoots · 06/12/2022 18:59

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 06/12/2022 18:44

My parents home was my family home even tho I haven’t lived in it since I was a teen…

A property can still be a family home even if they don’t currently live it in.

Do your parents pay you to live in it? That's the difference... contracts, legal rights and money.

Dragonskin · 06/12/2022 18:59

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 06/12/2022 18:32

i believe in the UK the law changed in mid July this year and only applied to certain tenancies and was separate to model tenancy agreement which you would need to write to the landlord for permission. (If memory serves)

it’s not as simple in my country it’s X, as it varies depending on your tenancy agreement which is also a legal contract.

Maybe OP isn't in the UK?

butterfliedtwo · 06/12/2022 18:54

The law is on your side. But do you want to die on this hill and risk him not renewing the lease?

SarahAndQuack · 06/12/2022 18:50

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 06/12/2022 18:44

My parents home was my family home even tho I haven’t lived in it since I was a teen…

A property can still be a family home even if they don’t currently live it in.

There's a difference between how something feels/how you might refer to it colloquially, and the law, though.

In England (for example; I don't know where the OP is), a rented property is the home of the tenant, not the landlord, whether or not the LL has previously used it as a family home or intends to do so in the future.

toffeecrisps · 06/12/2022 18:49

Keyansier · 06/12/2022 17:56

You sound very entitled. Yes, it's legal what you're doing as you (repeatedly) point out but it sounds like you are purposely trying to stir up trouble IMO.

Entitled for having a cat? Or for not wanting someone to enter her home without notice?

Swipe left for the next trending thread