Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Offered a job at a lower ranking, not sure whether to take it

62 replies

Rolaskatox · 06/12/2022 16:21

I went for an interview yesterday for a management position. I don't have any management experience yet but I'm completing a qualification at the minute which would give me a much greater chance to work in this field.

I was honest that I didn't have management experience yet but that I was working on the qualification and believed that I had what it takes,keen to progress etc.

I received feedback saying they would love to offer me a job, but an entry level one, not the management role I wanted, as I haven't got the experience.

They said if I perform well in this role then maybe with time they would promote me to management.

I really don't know what to do, I've got to give an answer asap. In a way it's frustrating because I'd like to get into management roles, but where are you meant to get the experience from if everyone wants experience?

Just not sure what to do

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Judgyjudgy · 07/12/2022 09:37

I wasn't based on something that might happen in the future unless it's your dream company or some other reason

Rolaskatox · 07/12/2022 09:30

Hey I decided not to do it as it's not worth 1h commute each way for £10 an hour. Thanks for all the help

OP posts:
SafariRushHour · 06/12/2022 19:25

If you’re interested in the type of work I’d be tempted to take the entry level job. The secret to moving through a company … show an interest in taking on tasks which give you an insight into a managerial role. Voice this in probation and supervision meetings so that your managers knows you’re keen and they can support your professional development. Offer to train up to do audits, checks, induct new staff.

LaughingCat · 06/12/2022 19:18

Rolaskatox · 06/12/2022 16:27

Sorry i meant 6k less than the management role

Also this is the 2nd time this has happened! Another company interviewed me for a management role then offered me an entry level job
But how do I get the management experience in order to be considered if nobody will take me without experience?

I have recruited a lot in both my current and my last role and there is definitely one type of interview that happens a lot.

“Thanks so much for interviewing with us today, and we’ll be in touch by the end of the week.”
waits for candidate picture to wink out and smile at other interviewers
“Well, that was a perfect interview for a <insert grade lower than vacant role>, wasn’t it?”

It becomes painfully obvious across the questions that you wouldn’t have the skills and experience to deal with the day to day challenges of the role yet. But you’re right, it’s really tough to make that step up.

This is what I did, and what I encourage my staff to do in our coaching sessions.

  1. Formal training - you’re already doing this so that’s great. Soft skills management training is great as well, so get as much in as you can from the resources in your field. Also LinkedIn is good for that. But I wouldn’t list those, it just means that you’ll have some of that learning at the back of your mind which then comes out in interview answers.
  2. Shadowing - I asked to regularly shadow my boss and see firsthand what the responsibilities are and how they approached the challenges (obviously not the direct line management ones though!). It also gave me a chance to ask questions in a safe space.
  3. Stretch assignment - sometimes you don’t have to actually be directly responsible for people to manage them. In my field, that meant asking to lead projects and campaigns, that brought in people from a lot of different departments and then ensuring their work on it was done to time, to budget and executed well. In many ways that mimicked a management role and gave me examples of leading multi-disciplinary teams for interviews.
  4. Mentorship - I took on training and coaching graduates/apprentices/interns etc from early on. Again, not responsible for their line management but was as close as you can get to management responsibilities. I set work for them, evaluated it, provided feedback and signed it off, under the eye of my manager. That gave me some great examples to use in interviews.

Soooo…go for it! Loads of options to build your skillset so that you become ready for a management role.

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 06/12/2022 19:04

Could you go back and negotiate? That you take the entry level position with some additional responsibilities that managers normally do to get experience, with a performance review in say 6 months at which time, if you are doing well, you get promoted? If they don't promote you then, you use that experience and the qualification to apply elsewhere?

Abitofalark · 06/12/2022 19:03

What you don't want is to take a job at the same level and pay as you are at now, based only on a vague mention that you might at some unspecified time in the future be made a manager if and but and whatever else might come to pass.

Instead you could look for employers with a defined career management structure which includes a trainee management scheme so that you would be recruited on to that pathway.

It's important to you so it's something you must probe and lay out your clear expectations and aspirations to management during any recruitment process and interviews that you do.

I don't know but once you get your qualification, you might find you are eligible to apply for a wider range of roles, even if you don't have hands-on experience of management. Use it to make a lot of your ambition and dedication and demonstrate a real sense of your seriousness and intent.

reallyhatewinter · 06/12/2022 18:59

I think it's very unlikely they will take you for a management role if you have neither the experience or the qualification. Just because you think you could do the job and want to go into management doesn't mean you can. Many places will offer a lower grade job to see how you get on.
Many people say they want to be management - it doesn't mean they're any good, hence either experience or qualification is needed.

Lolacat1234 · 06/12/2022 18:45

Rolaskatox · 06/12/2022 16:27

Sorry i meant 6k less than the management role

Also this is the 2nd time this has happened! Another company interviewed me for a management role then offered me an entry level job
But how do I get the management experience in order to be considered if nobody will take me without experience?

Typically you work for a company, they see potential in you for line management and as a result of various reshuffles within teams you might be given one or two direct reports, this is once you and your capabilities are more well known. This is how it works in my organisation anyway, it's on your PDP that you want to take on line management experience and tasks etc are given to you with gaining that experience in mind, for example you might get the opportunity to take the lead in a project which might involve delegation and people management.

Cheesuswithallama · 06/12/2022 18:42

Rolaskatox · 06/12/2022 17:11

I really don't know..
I do agree with the face fits thing sadly.
It's happened before where it had emerged one of our colleagues on the same level had been helping out management with admin work. This opportunity was never presented to us.
Indeed there's no guarantee they'd even promote me ever

I was this colleague in couple of jobs. It was never opportunity presented I went and asked if I can help with x so I can learn it.
That's how you get it in many places. Being active not passive. I ended up covering floor druing slt meetings etc and then moved to supervisor. If you never lead a team in any manner it's understandable they say no if they want experience. Where they are unreasonable is to actually interview you knowing you don't have what they want

anon666 · 06/12/2022 18:39

No. Wait till you've got the qualification then reapply for jobs

roarfeckingroarr · 06/12/2022 18:38

You have to be proactive. Speak with management about stepping up, taking on more responsibilities to gain experience.

Peedoffo · 06/12/2022 18:36

Rolaskatox · 06/12/2022 16:50

It's carer vs Senior carer/team leader !

Don't bother the wages are crap usually to get to senior management and the good pay you normally need to be a registered nurse. Are you interested in nursing ?

Relocatiorelocation · 06/12/2022 18:36

Are you working in a home or dom care?

Most homes will want to take you on as a result so you can demonstrate appropriate values and behaviours, and will make you a senior once they see you as a role model.

If the set up seems better go for it.

OutDamnedSpot · 06/12/2022 18:34

I’d look to develop your career where you are rather than move and have to ‘start again’ so to speak. What’s your current manager like? Can you explain to them that you’d like to progress your career and volunteer to take on more responsibility (for free, initially, but to put yourself in a better position to apply for management roles)?

CoffeeBoy · 06/12/2022 18:34

Rolaskatox · 06/12/2022 16:33

I probably do... They were the only company who replied to me which is likely due to not having completed the diploma yet.. The wage is virtually the same as now too. It seems like a very nice place to work but who knows

Honestly I’d do it but try to negotiate a couple k extra so you have a bit of a pay rise. They obviously like you and have seen potential. You must be prospects /opportunities at your current place arent good currently?

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 06/12/2022 18:33

I’ve been on the other side of this recently after having held multiple interviews for jobs roles. Dunno if having this perspective will be helpful or not??

I contacted 2 people saying we wouldn’t offer them the management position because they didn’t have anything in their CV or interview that showed they had the necessary experience and we had other applicant who had management experience. Also they didn’t meet the criteria we were looking for at interview. However they were suites to more junior roles, so we offered them those as a possibility. It wasn’t us trying to be cheeky and get someone to do the work for less, it’s just we had people better suited/more experienced applying for the management role.

Did they give specific feedback about what they didn’t see that they wanted at interview?

How many management roles have you interviewed for so far?

I would base whether you move or not on which organisation has the better opportunity for moving up (do they advertise management roles regularly etc). It is usually easier to move into management with your current employer because If they know you and value you they are more likely to take a chance giving you your first management role.

declutteringmymind · 06/12/2022 18:31

So it's a sideways move with better prospects? Take it. It doesn't mean you have to stay there to progress, if something comes along sooner then you can jump ship. At least you'll be able to learn from the managers that are there.

boomboombang · 06/12/2022 18:27

Unless I’ve misread it’s not. A pay cut it’s just less than the role you applied for?

boomboombang · 06/12/2022 18:26

But you don’t have management experience and no training or qualification will give you that

you applied for a reason, if you like the company I’d take it as if you join see what happens and if you find there is no progression look around again

if I like someone I interview but they don’t have all the skills I’d do this then support their development into the role they wanted

Astrabees · 06/12/2022 18:21

I retired as a care manager this summer, after 17 years I know the sector very well. If you want to be a manager you need to:
Get ahead with the training, get trained to level 4 or 5 asap, lots of care training is free.
Get to know CQC regulations inside out - especially safeguarding and medication.
Develop presentation skills, you will be asked to do one for most jobs.
Don’t wait for adverts, put the word about that you are looking, huge turn over at all levels in care.
Contact your local care providers association, they often know of jobs going and they and Skills for Care offer aspiring managers courses.
Take short courses in things like risk assessment, dementia etc at level 3 plus, not the on line ones.
If you get an interview dress and present yourself in a professional way. In my time I interviewed so many people who came for supervisory posts dressed in leggings and T shirts, with Crocs or similar.
Lastly as there is such a shortage of carers you will be offered a carers job if you aren’t successful with your application. I always did this and no one ever accepted. I can almost guarantee there will be no immediate prospects of promotion. I think you would be best advised to keep the applications going.

Dittosaw · 06/12/2022 17:50

A pay cut? An entry level position. People would be asking why you made that error in judgement. Women often tend to undervalue themselves. Know your worth

MuggleMe · 06/12/2022 17:49

Stay where you are if they like you there, and see if you can offer to step up where possible.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 06/12/2022 17:47

I would consider
What are my chances of promotion with my current employer? If negligible I would move for the same money.

hattie43 · 06/12/2022 17:45

No I wouldn't .
They are getting someone with potential on the cheap

Avrenim · 06/12/2022 17:42

As someone who had to take time out due to illness and will never now get back to the salary I had previously, don't take a pay cut! Could you not get some management experience from voluntary work or something??

New shiny graduates get taken on as managers all the time and some of the ones I've met can barely run a bath never mind a team or a departmen. I think the company is being beyond cheeky to offer you less than you're on in the current climate. They'll end up using your desire to manage as an excuse to get you to do all kinds of things outside your job description....