Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just buy DD boys clothes?

111 replies

Shannny · 06/12/2022 15:33

DD is 2.5
Whenever I take her shopping I ask her what clothes she wants and she always chooses boys clothes, boys pyjamas, boys hoodies and jumpers etc - I’ve been trying to encourage her with the girls stuff (not sure why, just naturally wanted to buy her girls clothes) but it’s becoming an “argument” so to speak everytime. At weekend I bought her a load of boys clothes she chose and we had so many comments from friends and family saying how lovely she looked and how much they suited her! So now I’m thinking I might as well just buy her boys clothes as default.

I know it’s not unreasonable as such but it still feels a bit odd to me

Has anyone else been through this?

lighthearted btw! I know there are bigger things to worry about etc etc

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BCBird · 29/01/2023 19:53

I would not be asking a child that young her opinion.

FancyFran · 28/12/2022 19:19

@Rainbowshit you have got me there. I have to buy female jeans (tesco greenlife) as the mens don't fit the DD. Beaonce booty! Shoes are interesting. In docs she is a 9, ugg female 8. I like men's t shirts because I am 5'10''. Belly flashers otherwise. I have seen a few new brands overseas, gender neutral. I know my marketing friends are now not targeting women.

Snaketime · 28/12/2022 17:40

My DD is 8 and always goes straight to the boys section, she likes dinosaurs, xbox and Minecraft and the boys clothes are much better for that kind of thing. My DS on the other hand tends to like tops from the boys section (same interests as my DD) and trousers from the girls (he really likes skinny jeans).
Just let your DD be who she is and develop her personality.

Purplemagnolias · 28/12/2022 17:33

When your daughter is a teenager there won't be any gender brands.

But surely women's and men's bodies are shaped differently?

TheVolturi · 28/12/2022 17:32

I myself prefer men's tshirts these days! I tend to wear fitted jeans so womens t shirts are often too figure hugging, I don't always want all of my curves on show!
They're definitely harder wearing as well.

Rainbowshit · 28/12/2022 17:27

FancyFran · 28/12/2022 15:38

My DD (19) wears a mixture now. I think the world is changing. When your daughter is a teenager there won't be any gender brands. The young girls are demanding equality and it is improving things. My daughter loves marvel, she loved Disney too. Tis just clothes. My 6'5'' beared son had a full dolls house. Early learning. I kept it for his children.
Via la difference.

Except male and female bodies are fundamentally different shapes. Jeans cut for males just don't fit me well. Same with shirts.

I made the mistake of buying male trainers once, the length was fine but my feet just rattled about in them.

Twizbe · 28/12/2022 16:55

Whatdoyouthinkno · 28/12/2022 15:50

Kind of surprised you give her so much choice at 2.5. I have a DS this age and he couldn’t give less of a fuck what he wears, he definitely has no interest in choosing his clothes.

My DS doesn't care what he wears and will happily wear what is put out.

My DD has to pick her own clothes. If she doesn't want to wear it, she won't.

Different kids react in different ways to clothes.

Whatdoyouthinkno · 28/12/2022 15:50

Kind of surprised you give her so much choice at 2.5. I have a DS this age and he couldn’t give less of a fuck what he wears, he definitely has no interest in choosing his clothes.

FancyFran · 28/12/2022 15:38

My DD (19) wears a mixture now. I think the world is changing. When your daughter is a teenager there won't be any gender brands. The young girls are demanding equality and it is improving things. My daughter loves marvel, she loved Disney too. Tis just clothes. My 6'5'' beared son had a full dolls house. Early learning. I kept it for his children.
Via la difference.

Millana · 06/12/2022 22:18

musingsinmidlife · 06/12/2022 19:55

Most of these kids clothes are made in the same factories in foreign lands for very cheap - the boys and girls clothes are the same quality. If they were making boys clothes from better materials and higher quality workmanship, they would also cost considerably more. Different fits and patterns but the blue sweatpants with the dinosaur and the pink sweatpants with the princess are the same quality.

I get what you are saying but irl there is a huge difference.

Just go and actually compare the same size boys and girls school trousers in Tescos or compare girls tracksuit bottoms and boys tracksuit bottoms in Primark. Look at the amount of material used(even when the fit is meant to be the same) and the thickness of it. Look at the length of the standard girls t-shirts compared with the boys. You try finding "girls" trousers with reinforced knees. Try counting the number of pockets between the genders!

So yeah, they are all made with very little ethics or care but they are very different.

BiddyPop · 06/12/2022 22:05

We used to buy a lot of boys clothes for Dd at that age. The colours suited her better and they were much harder wearing (I e made for mucking around in). And boys trousers tended to have adjustable waists while girls were just elasticated (not great for a very skinny, very active girl...)

TerraNostra · 06/12/2022 22:05

I grew up in the seventies. There wasn't so much difference between boys' and girls' kids clothes then. We definitely didn't wear dresses and skirts except for school and parties. Most clothes were brown! I find it weird to see little girls at the park in skirts and dresses, I worry they'd get caught in stuff when swinging and climbing etc.

WeightoftheWorld · 06/12/2022 21:54

My DD is 4 and has always worn a mix of stuff from the girls and boys sections her whole life so far. She likes stuff in both sections. She occasionally has adults or children missex her or ask her sex, as she also has very short hair. But the hair is her choice too. She likes what she likes, be that a dress with a Spiderman sweatshirt on top or whatever.

Tigresswoods · 06/12/2022 21:50

My mum bought me what I wanted & they were boys' clothes. I grew out of it but still don't dress overly girly day to day. Go with it.

Calphurnia88 · 06/12/2022 21:46

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 06/12/2022 15:52

Ive been wearing mens’ jumpers since I was a girl, much thicker and better quality though rather long in the arms.

im seventy and still definitely a woman

May I ask which brands you buy from?

I've often considered buying mens jumpers but never sure where to go as I'm on the petite side!

LaughingCat · 06/12/2022 21:20

Yeah, clothes are clothes like other posters have said. My mum and I used to argue all the time over clothes as I always preferred boys clothes, ever since I was old enough to point to what I wanted. She’s happy, people think she looks great and you get all the benefit 😊. Plus, having agency in her own choices from such an early age will be fantastic for her self-esteem and confidence as she grows up. It’s a small thing but crucial.

AegonT · 06/12/2022 21:08

I buy both for my daughters. I like plainer denim and some longer shorts which are easier to get in the boys section. I also like some boys styles. My 7 year old has only recently started caring what she wears. When I was a kid I refused any "girly" clothes till I was a teenager and have a lot of blue hoodies now and hardly ever wear a skirt (but do like them now).

Workawayxx · 06/12/2022 21:05

Yanbu. My dd is nearly 2 and many of her clothes are “boys”. She especially loves a farm theme hoody from next and sings old Mac Donald every time she wears it. I remember my ds climbing on sone rocks at a farm park in shorts, t shirt and sturdy sandals and a girl trying to climb to wearing ballet shoes and a dress and her mum calling her off. I vowed then if I ever had a daughter to put her in practical clothes as much as possible! M&S have some good neutrals - patterned animals tracksuits etc they are lovely and usually 3 for 2. My 5yo niece wears clothes that are definitely in the girls side but practical like denim short dungarees and tights and trainers.

autumndays2 · 06/12/2022 20:47

My DD is now 8. From about 3/4 she stopped wanting to wear skirts and dresses. She now naturally chooses 90% clothes from the boys section. We look at all clothes but she definitely has her own style which tends to be in the boys. Eventually family and friends catch on not to buy clothes as gifts of a certain style. Never been an issue, schools are now very good at allowing girls to wear trousers and shorts.

Hesleepswiththefishes · 06/12/2022 20:46

Eh?
your asking a 2 yr old?

im all for self autonomy but surely you want clothes that have hard wearing bums and knees I have three teens and I don’t ever remember this being a thing, must be forgetful already

it was oshkosh dungarees and random stuff, they only expressed an interest in their clothes around 12/13

healthadvice123 · 06/12/2022 20:44

@BlibBlabBlob yes they are but we both tend to buy next jeans certain styles , if mine are a tiny bit smaller at most, but then he is 6ft im 5 ft so length of jeans is a little different .
I have big boobs and I dress to show them at times as personally I like them and my best asset, i give zero shits if men look ( not on full show) its just boobs
But we are designed to be attracted to bodies as well thats just a simple biological fact really

BlibBlabBlob · 06/12/2022 20:40

healthadvice123 · 06/12/2022 20:14

@BlibBlabBlob but some women do want to dress like that as thats how they feel comfortable, that is not wrong either
Mens jeans would be awful on me and not fit at all and have to buy certain womens jeans
But my jeans have same pockets as my dh mens jeans?
People should wear what they like and what they are comfortable in but also not judge others

That's a fair point, I guess I just get a bit sad and worried when I see teenage girls in really revealing clothing. I wonder who they're really doing that for, given it's rarely comfortable clothing. Our 14 year old neighbour puts on thick makeup and false eyelashes and fake tan and then pouts on TikTok while vaping, this is an extreme case of course but it makes me sad that this way of presenting yourself is seen as desirable by not just young adults but also children.

Are your jeans pockets REALLY the same as your DH's though? There will be the same number and positioning, but the main hip pockets are usually much smaller (shallower) on women's jeans. You can't fit even a small phone in them safely. Whereas on men's jeans you can fit your whole wallet in one pocket and a large smartphone in the other.

VillanellesCoat · 06/12/2022 20:40

Heartening to see all the “clothes are clothes” comments. Everyone at any age should wear whatever they want, and hopefully one day we’ll all be able to do that without judgement 😊

glamourousindierockandroll · 06/12/2022 20:37

No problem with this. I dislike the overly gendered clothes though. My son is in aged 7-8 now and I'm disappointed to see so much stuff emblazoned with gaming characters and logos. You won't be so keen on it then!

True that boys sections are better for lovely warm fleecy jogging bottoms, but girls sections have warmer pyjamas and slipper socks.

Crunchymum · 06/12/2022 20:37

Why wouldn't I let a toddler pick their own new clothes?

Because a toddler isn't always capable of picking durable, practical and comfortable clothes.

Because taking a toddler clothes shopping would have made my life so much harder and ditto letting them look online.

Because my kids when toddlers battled me on enough, so feck was I going to add clothes to the list of battles.