Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a bit weird about this?

31 replies

YourApplePie · 06/12/2022 12:44

NC, not a reverse or anything clever like that.

My DD14 has been invited to attend a STEM residential at a good university. It's entirely free and includes ongoing mentorship if she wishes to continue in the relevant subjects. She's a fairly high achiever across the board and expressed an interest in it when a teacher spoke to her about it. All good.

I received an email about it today and among the details was the fact that this programme is only open to pupils of Black heritage (which she is and I am). I explained this to my daughter, as she was wondering why her friends (white, like pretty much everyone at her rural secondary school) didn't know about it.

She was fine about it and still wants to go, but I feel a bit weird about it. Perhaps that there are kids in her school who'd benefit far more from it that aren't eligible.

AIBU to feel weird about my DD getting this opportunity because of her heritage?

OP posts:
W0tnow · 06/12/2022 13:04

I don’t think it’s vastly different to encouraging girls to take STEM subjects, in order to encourage more diversity. It’s an area that was historically hugely male dominated and strategies were implemented to address the imbalance. Perhaps, statistically, there’s fewer black students electing STEM. 🤷‍♀️

user143677433 · 06/12/2022 13:01

Most STEM fields are very, very white and would undoubtedly benefit from a much broader pool of qualified and talented people. I assume this is a way to help to create that pool.

As such, it is not actually about benefitting the pupils - it’s about benefitting the profession. So the fact that other pupils may have benefitted more is unfortunate for them, but not the purpose of the programme.

Stompythedinosaur · 06/12/2022 12:58

While your dd is clearly well supported by yourself, the fact is that she lives within a society that is still racist and therefore may face a subconscious bias in the future in accessing work and higher education. It seems perfectly reasonable to me to make an attempt to counterbalance this in a small way by offering this opportunity.

CarlsHat · 06/12/2022 12:55

Hmm, I think I would feel the same.

Is it based on the fact that statistically the uptake of black pupils in STEM is lower? So this is a good way to even the paying field?
Or do they think black pupils are more disadvantaged? (Are they?)

Is it based on low income as well or just heritage?

YourApplePie · 06/12/2022 12:53

luxxlisbon · 06/12/2022 12:47

Perhaps that there are kids in her school who'd benefit far more from it that aren't eligible.

Do you think your DD isn’t deserving of the place?

Yes and no.

She's a good student that'll definitely engage with the opportunity. But I doubt very much she's the strongest candidate in STEM subjects (not her favourites) and we're in a position to help her ourselves or provide tutoring. It's the fact that her heritage was one of the criteria that I can't seem to swallow.

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 06/12/2022 12:47

Perhaps that there are kids in her school who'd benefit far more from it that aren't eligible.

Do you think your DD isn’t deserving of the place?