Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a traditional nativity play for once?

117 replies

Shutthegatepeter · 06/12/2022 10:02

This week my son has his nativity. He has already done a dress rehearsal that parents could attend so I’ve seen it, his ‘proper’ performance is on Friday evening. It’s very cute and the kids and teachers have done a great effort so I do appreciate it, it’s certainly better than no nativity at all like during covid. But I’ve noticed with all 3 of my children now that they never do a traditional nativity anymore. One year my eldest daughter didn’t do a nativity they did a ‘Christmas play’ instead with Santa and dancing teddy bears, no Mary and Joseph. Another year my middle child was a spaceman who travelled to a Christmas planet, there was a brief mention of the birth of Jesus but no Mary, Joseph, shepherds etc. This year my youngest is a Christmas tree, there is a Mary and Joseph and a basic nativity story, but there’s breakdancing kings and they sing Bruno Mars I think I want to marry you. There’s no silent night, no away in a manger. None of my 3 children know away in a manger because they’ve never sang it in their nativities, they’re always trying to spice it up and modernise it and make it different. I appreciate the thought and maybe as a one off one year it’d be nice to see something different, but it’s every year and now none of my 3 have ever done a normal nativity. I want to hear away in a manger, not Bruno mars! I’m not even religious 😂 Has anyone else had a traditional nativity or are they a thing of the past now?

OP posts:
GloomyDarkness · 06/12/2022 11:21

Aliens - children playing younger children - woodland creature/snowman - someone who needs the nativity story explaining to them it's a plot device.

Means the so the naivety becomes a play with a play - means more parts a wider story and Mary and Joseph aren't the main parts.

The nativity/Downfall mash-up does sound particularly inspired - and not one I came across.

The C of E school my children first went to didn't do whole school play but it was two year groups - it was two form entry and 30 + in each class so 120 kids to find parts for - so even with kings servants people around town there was a need for more parts. Also meant most years I had three plays to attend - till we moved and that school, was much smaller had big enough hall to fit all the parents in and did at most two plays.

Feelallright · 06/12/2022 11:20

WednesdayFridayAddams · 06/12/2022 11:07

DC was an alien one year.
WTH have aliens got to do with Christmas? Confused

Ooh, quite a lot… Extraterrestrial beings, otherworldly happenings, strange visitations, etc.

soundsystem · 06/12/2022 11:20

Ha you're so NBU. My Y1 is singing Reach for the Stars and Forever Young Confused (We're not sure if this is part of some sort of play... he claims not but who can say!)

Does your school have a choir? My Y3 is in the school choir and they're doing various "civic events" where they sing carols and Christmas songs...

No nativity though! Big disappointment for DS who was angling to be cast as Balthazar (me neither!)

Museya15 · 06/12/2022 11:17

Most people in the UK don’t go to church, don’t believe, so why would they have nativity in schools? We are practising catholics, we have nativity.

MsFannySqueers · 06/12/2022 11:14

Think yourself lucky OP. It could be worse.There was a thread on here the other day where Mary was going to go round slapping people. A bit of the nativity story that I must have missed!

JulieMarooley · 06/12/2022 11:13

I find this sad. You’d think they could easily keep the main nativity thread and add some characters - the people of Bethlehem talking about how busy the town is, the census takers going around asking questions at the houses, merchants selling the gold, frankincense, myrrh to the kings, locals making food and taking it round to the barn, the animals could have a conversation (camels, donkey, sheep), astronomers noticing the star… that’s about 20 extra parts just there.

I don’t think the modern plays even have a good even split of roles in my experience.

WednesdayFridayAddams · 06/12/2022 11:07

DC was an alien one year.
WTH have aliens got to do with Christmas? Confused

GloomyDarkness · 06/12/2022 11:05

Comedycook · 06/12/2022 10:22

My DC have both finished primary school so I've sat through a lot of Nativitys. Not one has been the traditional story. There is usually a mention of Jesus and a hint to the story but that's it. I agree with you op. I'd have loved to see a traditional one.

I'm the same - and I went to a lot.

I can see with parts why and some were very funny.

They also haven't sung many of the traditional hymns - not just the Christmas ones but more generally. In an effort to make the music more relevant they have often sung pop songs instead.

I did with many other parents raise an eye brow with Fairy-tale of New York with original lyrics including slut on junk and faggot sung by whole primary school one Chistamas concert finding it a particular low point. I did a few years later see an AIBU thread on same thing - and did wonder how wide spread this had become.

Notanotherone6 · 06/12/2022 11:05

I've just been to my daughter's nativity. No carols but basically was the traditional Christmas story with songs, adapted for young children. No mention of Santa.

They are a C of E school though, so have a carol service in church, and other events that cement the meaning of Christmas for the kids.

My older children went to a non-religious school and their nativities came in all shapes and sizes. There was always the Christmas story but a lot more modern. My middle daughter was a robot in her last year there. They still had an assembly with carols though.

CherryLongIsland · 06/12/2022 10:57

This will be my last primary Christmas play, and the first in person one after Lockdown. I'm a little bit gutted that it's the slightly dull, chilly, Church nativity where most of the children are just in the choir or narrators rather than the fun, random pantomime ones they do in the school hall (three local schools take it in turns to use the church so every third year it's a traditional one)

Mine already take part in one at our Church where they play most of the parts as barely anyone goes to Sunday school, which is lovely and cosy.

Firen · 06/12/2022 10:56

Sing carols at home or take them to church? Unless it’s a religious school it seems odd to do a religious play, so they do other plays from other religions at other points of the year?

Moonmelodies · 06/12/2022 10:55

I guess there could be something distasteful about a poor young woman (possibly in her early teens according to some scholars) being impregnated by an omnipotent cosmic deity who has already demonstrated his petulance elsewhere in the Old Testament when he doesn't get his way.

ISeeTheLight · 06/12/2022 10:54

DD's (religious but very inclusive) primary school very much does a "proper" nativity each year; various ones actually for different age ranges. Baby Jesus, Mary, Joseph, 3 wise men, shepherds, angels, a donkey, an ox etc - the lot. They also sing religious (child-friendly) songs. In KS2 it's even in a church.
They also have weekly worship on a Friday morning with a vicar.

DappledThings · 06/12/2022 10:52

This is my first year with both DC in the same one as they are doing one for all KS1 together. It sounds like it's going to be part very traditional and part new with some Strictly element. DD is an angel and DS is a dancing shepherd.

3 years ago, last time we got to see one live, DS was in pre-school and did a lovely one that started in the present day with an extension to the Bethlehem Holiday Inn unearthing an ancient stable and a crown, the Bethlehem Archaeology Society shutting down the building works and then a segue into telling the traditional story. That was perfect.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 06/12/2022 10:52

spiderlight · 06/12/2022 10:23

I would have loved just one proper nativity, but our primary never did one. They tied in their Christmas plays to whatever they were learning about that term. The most memorable was when they were doing WWII and evacuees in about Y5, and DS came home and announced that he was Hitler's 2nd lieutenant - festive!! 🤔It was a great little performance in the end, though, about an evacuee child worrying in case Santa couldn't find him, while Hitler (complete with a permanent marker moustache that took about a fortnight to come off) plotted to shoot down Santa's sleigh and failed. The kids all loved it, which was the main thing, but just one traditional nativity would have been lovely.

I've got to say that I would pay good money to see a primary nativity/Downfall mash-up.

tulips27 · 06/12/2022 10:50

More seriously, I'm not religious but this is a good example of how we're becoming an almost totally secular society without considering any of the negatives to that.

inappropriateraspberry · 06/12/2022 10:49

I remember being a farmer one year - based on nativity but different people visited Jesus! Nurses, farmers, firemen etc.

CMOTDibbler · 06/12/2022 10:49

My mum organised the christmas play at her school for many years, and I always remember her saying that a traditional nativity was a nightmare as there were only 8 real roles in it and then you end up with loads of sheep/ stars / angels/ shepherds who just waft about for a few minutes and 97 narrators who sit terrified for most of it and then say 10 words. Not to mention that with 120 3-7 year olds some of whom are scared of masks, some will need escorting by an adult, some will wet themselves, and at least one will be rolling round on the floor it is very hard to find the right thing to make them and give them more than 30s on stage. Oh, and not to mention the parental fighting about who got to be Mary.
Wheras 'Goldilocks and the three bears go through the woods to find father christmas, meeting the care bears and other assorted characters along the way' (this is not entirely made up as an example) gave a much bigger range of equal speaking parts, the nursery children could be flowers sitting at the front of the stage to sing and so forth

inappropriateraspberry · 06/12/2022 10:48

No child wants to do the same nativity play several years in a row, and I'm sure the teacher's don't want to either! They usually mix it up to give everyone a part, and keep it fresh.
This year my son is Joseph, but I think it's a non-speaking part! It is more traditional this time round, with lots of snowflakes and angels, but it's hard to try and rework the basic story each year. I think they also try and play tot he children's strengths, so if there are some keen on breakdancing, why not let them do it?

tulips27 · 06/12/2022 10:48

a spaceman who travelled to a Christmas planet

Sorry but this cracked me up! 😆

Babdoc · 06/12/2022 10:45

OP, why aren’t your children taking part in your local church Sunday School nativity?
That will very definitely have some beautiful carols - I always cry at “Little donkey” and “Away in a Manger” - and the proper gospel story of the birth of Jesus will be told.
At my village church we often have a real baby in the manger, if a local mum
has given birth recently enough.
Thing’s occasionally get hilariously out of hand. Long ago, when my DDs were young, and cast as angels, a massive brawl broke out among the cast, during the performance at our church service. The minister had to wade in and separate the kids. All you could hear above the melee was my 5 year old shouting furiously “The shepherds started it!”. (She was cast as Herod the following year…!)

kingtamponthefurred · 06/12/2022 10:43

You can play carols at home and get the kids to sing along-what's nicer than three young voices all singing 'Hark the herald angels sing' slightly off-key for the 147th time?

PowerhouseOfTheCell · 06/12/2022 10:41

We had inn keeper Micheal Jackson one year! He answered the door to Mary and Joseph singing thriller. I think schools need to bulk out their cast so everyone who wants a part can have one, it would look a bit silly having 15 Shepard’s visiting baby Jesus

anerki101 · 06/12/2022 10:41

Chattycathydoll · 06/12/2022 10:31

Ours does a traditional nativity & carol concert, including all the classics and the equally traditional misunderstood lines, with DD confidently singing ‘the kettles hello-ing’ last year!

However they also do short festive ‘skits’ around the nativity, with each class doing a different one and the year 6s making up their own. It is a smallish village school though, max 30 kids per year, so no real stress about who gets what part.

Ours is the same. A traditional Nativity and carols. Years 4 - 6 are doing a Carol concert and the younger years are doing a Nativity the day before. My son is in reception and his class are singing Away in a Manger at the Nativity whilst dressed as barn animals.

Notjusta · 06/12/2022 10:41

YANBU - this in one of my pet hates. I think I've seen the traveling to another planet one - completely incomprehensible nonsense.

No one has a clue what is going on because the 'plays' are written to allow as many kids as possible to have a part (why??? Some kids are shit at performances and that's totally fine!).

I say this as a staunch atheist! But if you are going to do a nativity just do it properly. In fact I felt the Christmas with the aliens/another planet one one was actually some atheist trolling - combing two improbable stories in one!!