Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a traditional nativity play for once?

117 replies

Shutthegatepeter · 06/12/2022 10:02

This week my son has his nativity. He has already done a dress rehearsal that parents could attend so I’ve seen it, his ‘proper’ performance is on Friday evening. It’s very cute and the kids and teachers have done a great effort so I do appreciate it, it’s certainly better than no nativity at all like during covid. But I’ve noticed with all 3 of my children now that they never do a traditional nativity anymore. One year my eldest daughter didn’t do a nativity they did a ‘Christmas play’ instead with Santa and dancing teddy bears, no Mary and Joseph. Another year my middle child was a spaceman who travelled to a Christmas planet, there was a brief mention of the birth of Jesus but no Mary, Joseph, shepherds etc. This year my youngest is a Christmas tree, there is a Mary and Joseph and a basic nativity story, but there’s breakdancing kings and they sing Bruno Mars I think I want to marry you. There’s no silent night, no away in a manger. None of my 3 children know away in a manger because they’ve never sang it in their nativities, they’re always trying to spice it up and modernise it and make it different. I appreciate the thought and maybe as a one off one year it’d be nice to see something different, but it’s every year and now none of my 3 have ever done a normal nativity. I want to hear away in a manger, not Bruno mars! I’m not even religious 😂 Has anyone else had a traditional nativity or are they a thing of the past now?

OP posts:
Sidge · 06/12/2022 13:07

My girls are older but did a mixture of traditional and novelty Nativity plays. I loved them all. The youngest was Mary one year (when she was in Y2 I think) and was thrilled, it was such an honour to be picked as Mary - she was the envy of all the other girls!

She then started rehearsals and came home outraged as being Mary was totally boring. “All you do is sit next to Joseph holding the plastic baby. You don’t even say anything!” She much preferred being an angel as she got to wear tinsel on her head….

Off topic slightly but why on Earth are they singing Bruno Mars’ Marry You in a Christmas play?!? Have they even listened to the lyrics? It’s about getting wasted in Vegas and getting married for a laugh!

Forever42 · 06/12/2022 13:05

Find out when your local church's crib service is (often Christmas Eve). These are family services with the traditional songs.

XelaM · 06/12/2022 13:02

steppemum · 06/12/2022 12:46

or not, because it is such an awful song to s boring tune.
We tend to sing better songs in our Sunday school!

I love Away in a Manger. It's a beautiful song

XelaM · 06/12/2022 13:01

My daughter did a traditional nativity play in nursery and never since (she's now 12). It was so lovely. I absolutely detest "putting a modern twist" on everything - including hip hop music in a film about Elvis Presley!

Kanaloa · 06/12/2022 12:51

steppemum · 06/12/2022 12:46

or not, because it is such an awful song to s boring tune.
We tend to sing better songs in our Sunday school!

Yes perhaps not - most Sunday schools I’ve been in would sing Away in a Manger at Christmas! Either way, if you’re extremely dedicated to a ‘traditional nativity’ and religious carols for your kids, Sunday school would be the place!

steppemum · 06/12/2022 12:46

Kanaloa · 06/12/2022 11:52

What church do you attend? Maybe you could start researching churches that provide a kids’ club or a good Sunday school. They will almost certainly learn Away in a Manger there.

or not, because it is such an awful song to s boring tune.
We tend to sing better songs in our Sunday school!

BigusBumus1 · 06/12/2022 12:45

At our little village primary, the Reception and Year 1 children did the traditional nativity as they are so cute in their tea-towel head dresses etc and it can be a short play. But the rest of the school did Christmassy plays so, Years 2, 3 and 4 did a joint one and so did Years 5 and 6. It worked well.

steppemum · 06/12/2022 12:44

I am a christian, and I don't mind a different take on the nativity, but I do think that schools sometimes forget that they need to know the actual story first, and then do a variation (I've seen ones from the shepherd's point of view and the littlest angel etc)
So in my mind, reception/year 1 stick to the story, any other year, have dancing snowmen if you like.

But you are definitely BU about away in a manger. It is possibly the worst song ever written and is a horrible dirge. There are loads of good carols and christmas songs. Away in the manger is not part of the original story, let's ditch it and use a nice song instead.

TofuonToast · 06/12/2022 12:40

@spiderlight
‘Hitlers 2nd Lieutenant’ 😂😂😂

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 06/12/2022 12:35

Why don't you volunteer to direct the play next year? If you have an artistic vision - why not make it real? I'm sure the school would be grateful to have enthusiastic people taking the work off their plates!

Sartre · 06/12/2022 12:31

I suspect it’s to include children from all faiths and backgrounds and if it’s a secular school then that makes total sense. My DC went to a CofE primary and the nativity in KS1 was always very traditional but then the local vicar was always in attendance so I don’t think anything else would suffice.

KS2 they were more relaxed and did some quite fun plays actually including one about Christmas traditions throughout different eras. Had children in 80s gear dancing to wham, I thoroughly enjoyed it.

AllTheAll · 06/12/2022 12:26

I can't imagine one without a First Lobster. Eight is a lot of legs David.

TugboatAnnie · 06/12/2022 12:16

Love that schools are getting the blame for the perceived threat of a secular society! Nothing wrong with a secular society either, religion is personal, go to church if it's that important! Eg, USA, France etc
Because we are in the minority of countries with a state religion I think parents hope that it rubs off on their children at school somehow without them having to do anything about it themselves.

housemaus · 06/12/2022 12:11

tulips27 · 06/12/2022 10:50

More seriously, I'm not religious but this is a good example of how we're becoming an almost totally secular society without considering any of the negatives to that.

Genuinely, what negatives are there of being a secular society? I guess the only thing I can think of off the top of my head is that you could suggest people might be more likely to commit crime if you don't think there's a higher power to answer to, but I think America puts paid to that idea...

But I may well be missing something obvious!

housemaus · 06/12/2022 12:08

I took part in my last nativity over 20 years ago and that wasn't remotely traditional - I played a snow sergeant 🤣

So YABU in assuming this is a recent change, I guess? I don't know anyone who sang traditional songs - ours were all jazzed up poppy numbers like "Get Jesus To That Inn (Oh Yeah!)" haha.

DNBU · 06/12/2022 12:08

It’s just not the big deal you’re trying to make it into..

DNBU · 06/12/2022 12:07

Literally watched a traditional nativity at the school yesterday.
Even when I was a kid in the 90s, at a catholic school, we had non traditional Christmas plays rather than a nativity some years.

Blueskies3 · 06/12/2022 11:58

But I still don't get how Christian schools can leave out the nativity play. I totally get how the public schools can go with a modern type message, after all they are catering for a wide range of faiths and backgrounds.

ClaribelLowLieth · 06/12/2022 11:55

tulips27 · 06/12/2022 10:50

More seriously, I'm not religious but this is a good example of how we're becoming an almost totally secular society without considering any of the negatives to that.

Agree!

I'm not religious but come on!

Kanaloa · 06/12/2022 11:52

What church do you attend? Maybe you could start researching churches that provide a kids’ club or a good Sunday school. They will almost certainly learn Away in a Manger there.

CulturePigeon · 06/12/2022 11:50

Notjusta · Today 10:41
YANBU - this in one of my pet hates. I think I've seen the traveling to another planet one - completely incomprehensible nonsense.
No one has a clue what is going on because the 'plays' are written to allow as many kids as possible to have a part (why??? Some kids are shit at performances and that's totally fine!).
I say this as a staunch atheist! But if you are going to do a nativity just do it properly. In fact I felt the Christmas with the aliens/another planet one one was actually some atheist trolling - combing two improbable stories in one!!

Ha ha! I get this, Nojusta.

I'm an agnostic but very culturally Christian (love Easter, Christmas etc). I've worked in primary and secondary schools, mainly state, but recently a big boys' independent school.

The primary was a church school and their nativities were pretty traditional and went down well. The intake was almost entirely white British and either churchgoers or those sympathetic to Christianity.

Not a nativity play, but a similar issue, I think:
The boys' independent school had an intake of well over half non-white British - a good mix of Jewish boys and many with Indian or south Asian heritage, but the school was nominally Christian. The parents were keen for their sons to go there and were fine with this - in fact, talking to the boys, most of those from non-Christian backgrounds celebrated Christmas in a secular way at home. We then got a very trendy chaplain, and he changed the annual service of 9 lessons and carols( which the parents loved) to a weird, vague, political, almost non-religious assemblage of videos and strange non-Christmassy readings. Only the carols remained, and he re-wrote the words of some of those!

I used to think - if I were attending a religious event from another faith, I would want to learn about it and therefore would prefer to see a traditional rendition. What some of the non-Christian families made of it all, I don't know. They must have gone away thinking 'This Christmas....what the hell is it about?'

TugboatAnnie · 06/12/2022 11:28

Plenty of places to learn and sing carols, home, church, Sunday school, carol concerts etc.
Non-faith schools are so many other things and the Christmas plays are a hoot! I've been in KS1 for 20 years and never been involved in a nativity, that's for nursery children ime.
The best Christmas play is The School Inspectors, basically Ofsted turning up in the middle of rehearsals with stressed-out teachers. 7 year olds playing teachers in the staff room is something I will never forget! Long live the Christmas play!

PuttingDownRoots · 06/12/2022 11:27

My children have been...
A camel (reception)
A sheep (yr1)
Background dancer (yr2)
Choir (yr3)

Page to the kings (nursery)
Mary (reception)
Angel (yr1)
Midwife (yr2)

Not one of these plays has had Away in a Manger. They have had some brilliant songs though....

I'm pretty happy to have had 8 completely different plays...

AnxietyIsMyShadow · 06/12/2022 11:23

Yep ours was very random, kids dressed up as wise men, shepherds and stars etc but no actual mention of what they were doing there, the whole plot centred on some elves singing songs about presents 😂

Blueskies3 · 06/12/2022 11:21

I want to see a traditional one too, my son had to dress up as a rock musician, how that fitted into Christmas I am still unsure....and our children go to a Catholic school.