Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Strep A - are you worried?

211 replies

lucylollipop · 06/12/2022 09:42

Apologies if there are already threads on this. I haven't seen any yet.

News in today that a 9th child has sadly died from strep a. I have primary school age dc and a young baby so I'm worried about them getting sick and also bringing bugs home to the rest of us.

I'm not clued up enough to know if this is comparable to flu deaths in kids? I suppose I just wondered if others are worried? Given the state on the NHS at the moment it isn't a great time to get unwell.

OP posts:
Tirrrrred · 06/12/2022 12:30

Both dds have had a temperature, sore throat and a headache on and my off for weeks.

Is there definitely always a rash?

Scottishskifun · 06/12/2022 12:27

All the talk of antibiotic resistance is a misdinoma in this case. A single course of antibiotics is not going to result in antibiotic resistance. Dr's have been told rather then look for 4 markers for tonsillitis for example as they would prior to prescribing antibiotics to relax this because of high circulation of Strep A.

That doesn't mean they are going to keep being relaxed about it its for this particular issue because of the higher rates.

Also giving your kids a prebiotic alongside antibiotics and afterwards will help with getting the body back to normal quicker

nothingleftttt · 06/12/2022 12:27

I had huge issues getting my child seen recently. Only saw the nurse 1st visit told viral, 2nd visit we were given anti Biotics. At both appt never looked at throat and couldn't test o2 levels as couldn't find the paediatric monitor despite this being one of my concerns.
As with children things can go either way and my child bounced back quickly from being very lethargic and a big concern to us at the time.
The issue is child wasn't really checked sufficiently and yet we took up the surgery time. If he had not improved / worsened, would we have got further help in time.

A child the same age here has died but isn't yet counted in the reported numbers.

Buzzinwithbez · 06/12/2022 12:20

"The surfaces of the body – the skin, digestive system, and the lining of the nose – are covered by a community of microbes called the normal body flora. They help protect the host from becoming infected with more harmful micro-organisms by acting as a physical barrier. The normal body flora colonises these linings which reduces the area available for pathogens to attach to and become established. It also means that the harmful microbes have to compete with the normal body flora for nutrients. The average human gut contains around one kilo of these good bacteria which is equivalent to one bag of sugar."

microbiologysociety.org/why-microbiology-matters/what-is-microbiology/microbes-and-the-human-body/immune-system.html

But you know, let's kill off our kids' good flora with antibiotics just because some other kid in the class has a sore throat.

Scottishskifun · 06/12/2022 12:20

packedlunchlife · 06/12/2022 11:39

Okay so have I got this correct - Strep A is a bacteria that causes a few different infections like scarlet fever and impetigo ?
So you could have a standard infection that could then enter the blood stream and turn dangerous, is this correct ?

So what can make it become invasive ? And how exactly is it spread , is it airborne ?
Sorry just trying to be in the know

Strep A can cause those and strep throat yes and then further develop into invasive strep A or can skip the others and become invasive strep A if it gets into the blood stream.

The problem is symptoms are very similar to a wide variety of viruses as well hence its difficult for parents to know. Scarlet fever can be obvious but other symptoms such as vomiting fever etc csn be generic.

The bacteria is spread several ways its on people's skin anyway but also via coughs/sneezes contaminated surfaces.

The best thing to do is be aware of the symptoms and keep speaking to nursery/schools its a reportable illness which helps. Seek medical advice if your child comes down with the symptoms as the quicker antibiotics are given the better for it if it's strep A.

Good news is it can be swabbed for as well.

BeatrixPottery · 06/12/2022 12:18

I know @Cuppasoupmonster thats why we are where are!

Buzzinwithbez · 06/12/2022 12:08

This is complete nonsense. Bacteria develop antibiotic resistance, not people.

So the good bacteria in our bodies that we've just killed off does absolutely nothing for our immune system?

Buzzinwithbez · 06/12/2022 12:04

WishingWell5 · 06/12/2022 11:07

The doctors will give out the antibiotics based on their medical experience, knowledge and (thankfully) an understanding of the current situation (ie rates being unusually high and therefore much greater caution than they might have had a week ago when symptoms present).

If they have symptoms they should get antibiotics.
I don't think anyone is suggesting everyone with a cold should get them.

Well, ministers are suggesting children without even colds get them

Strep A - are you worried?
BeatrixPottery · 06/12/2022 12:00

@prescribingmum when the government was willing it still took months, children are not of value in this country so there’s no way a response like that would be pulled together in time, the threat will be passed and over by then. I completely understand re antibiotic resistance. And understand it fully. But it is a huge picture huge problem. This is a relatively small, time critical problem in the here and now and sometimes you need to go off the bigger picture plan and deal with a clear and present danger that will be over by the spring. No one’s talking about to is as a long term strategy it’s to deal with hear and now.

All very nice to be pious but, try that with parents of dead children and see how you get on👍.

maryberryslayers · 06/12/2022 11:54

I'm worried about how hard you have to push to get your child seen. My son has symptoms and at first the receptionist did was ask me if I'd done a covid test and 'to think of the other patients in the surgery', I told her I wasn't going to traumatise my very poorly little boy again and I couldn't care less about covid given he's 4 and could potentially have strep A. They then text me an appointment with a clinical practitioner so I had to argue with them again 'oh don't worry, she's well qualified, nearly a doctor' err no thanks I'd like an actual doctor!
We did see a doctor we know in the end who was fantastic, tested for Strep A, prescribed the antibiotics immediately without hesitation and sent me some useful information.

berksandbeyond · 06/12/2022 11:47

Yes I am worried. Having real anxiety about it actually

prescribingmum · 06/12/2022 11:47

BeatrixPottery · 06/12/2022 11:29

@Survey99 yep that’s probably part of why we’re here with this, doctors failing to prescribe antibiotics ( or test for what is actually causing they symptoms), in cases where they are needed because of the messaging around resistance. Of course antibiotics shouldn’t be handed out Willy nilly as a run of course, we all know that. But, when we have extremely high levels of a highly treatable bug when antibiotics are given quickly, which can kill some children if they’re not, and an NHS service which isn’t set up for testing quickly in any setting - if at all in the community. Then giving antibiotics when all symptoms point to that it could be a bacterial or equally a viral infection is sensible until testing indicates otherwise, I.e that it’s viral and self limiting.

Complete lack of awareness towards the huge issue that is antibiotic resistance. Using this method will mean that the antibiotics will soon stop being effective for those with the bacterial infection. Then what’s your solution…?

The answer is setting up community testing via pharmacies etc. Covid showed us all these things are possible when the government is willing so that would be the next step

prescribingmum · 06/12/2022 11:43

Brunilde · 06/12/2022 10:24

I'm more concerned that parents will take up unnecessary NHS resources when it's not needed as they are all in a panic. Most need to get better at assessing their children themselves (to a point) rather than thinking they need a GP for everything. Most kids with strep will be fine with no intervention like they are the rest of the time and don't need taking to a GP everytime they get a bit of a sore throat or a sniffle. Then the ones who are truly unwell can be seen in a timely manner.

Agree, this is my concern too.
My oldest is currently mildly unwell with sore throat and some congestion so I’m keeping an eye on her but at this stage, there is nothing to indicate anything more than a viral infection. I know a few who have experienced it recently and one of her friends spent 2 nights in hospital so the prospect is scary but it’s even scarier that we may not get fast medical attention when needed because too few GPs and they plus A&E are clogged up with over anxious parents.

berksandbeyond · 06/12/2022 11:42

Mammamia23 · 06/12/2022 10:09

Last I read (this morning) think 3 more children have died this year, than did last year so for that reason I’m not worried.

Am I worried that parents of primary school aged children will demand antibiotics because their kid has a sore throat, meaning my baby who gets an ear infection gets nothing? Yep. Some parents are losing their mind and it’s pathetic.

You sound lovely

BeatrixPottery · 06/12/2022 11:42

@Guitarbar no they don’t, because we don’t have community testing (America is a good comparison where if you or a child presented with a sore throat you’d be tested so they’d no if what was viral or bacterial and treat accordingly) in past, say when I was a child (40 now) they’d prescribe penicillin jic.

This is absolutely not the right thing to do, but not because others will go without, no one did, because of resistance. However as we are where we are in terms of not being set up for managing it properly, we can’t have children paying for that with their lives whilst we have extremely and much higher than usual levels of this bug circulating.

Survey99 · 06/12/2022 11:42

BeatrixPottery · 06/12/2022 11:29

@Survey99 yep that’s probably part of why we’re here with this, doctors failing to prescribe antibiotics ( or test for what is actually causing they symptoms), in cases where they are needed because of the messaging around resistance. Of course antibiotics shouldn’t be handed out Willy nilly as a run of course, we all know that. But, when we have extremely high levels of a highly treatable bug when antibiotics are given quickly, which can kill some children if they’re not, and an NHS service which isn’t set up for testing quickly in any setting - if at all in the community. Then giving antibiotics when all symptoms point to that it could be a bacterial or equally a viral infection is sensible until testing indicates otherwise, I.e that it’s viral and self limiting.

Then giving antibiotics when all symptoms point to that it could be a bacterial or equally a viral infection is sensible until testing indicates otherwise, I.e that it’s viral and self limiting.

You still are not getting it - "giving antibiotics......until testing indicates otherwise" is the issue.

Just because testing doesn't indicate Strep A or Scarlett fever does not mean the antibs are not working on other bacteria present in your body but not causing you any significant issues. If you stop the full course early the remaining bacteria can then become resistant to the antibs. This ignorance and not completing full courses of antibs is exactly why we have problems with bacterial resistance.

packedlunchlife · 06/12/2022 11:39

Okay so have I got this correct - Strep A is a bacteria that causes a few different infections like scarlet fever and impetigo ?
So you could have a standard infection that could then enter the blood stream and turn dangerous, is this correct ?

So what can make it become invasive ? And how exactly is it spread , is it airborne ?
Sorry just trying to be in the know

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 06/12/2022 11:39

The next infection comes along and they've got less personal resources to manage it.

This is complete nonsense. Bacteria develop antibiotic resistance, not people.

Antibiotic over-prescribing is a real issue but use of a widely used very old-school antibiotic that's effective against Strep A, even this latest strain, is relatively low risk, given the risks associated with not treating it.

Guitarbar · 06/12/2022 11:30

I think lots are being pretty purposefully obtuse. The issue is that if lots of over anxious parents push for antibiotics because the news told them so then others will go without (either as they cannot get an appointment or there are shortages in the medication). Doctors should be able to make sensible decisions though, I don't think anyone for a moment would wish to deny a child at risk goes without, but if many have them just in case that creates different issues. Let's hope it doesn't become like covid where other illnesses aren't seen as much of a problem.

Unicorn34 · 06/12/2022 11:30

Meant to say that the school in Ashford Middx where the first 6yr old sadly died.

BeatrixPottery · 06/12/2022 11:29

@Survey99 yep that’s probably part of why we’re here with this, doctors failing to prescribe antibiotics ( or test for what is actually causing they symptoms), in cases where they are needed because of the messaging around resistance. Of course antibiotics shouldn’t be handed out Willy nilly as a run of course, we all know that. But, when we have extremely high levels of a highly treatable bug when antibiotics are given quickly, which can kill some children if they’re not, and an NHS service which isn’t set up for testing quickly in any setting - if at all in the community. Then giving antibiotics when all symptoms point to that it could be a bacterial or equally a viral infection is sensible until testing indicates otherwise, I.e that it’s viral and self limiting.

Unicorn34 · 06/12/2022 11:28

My grandson was the 1st child in the school next door in Ashford, Middx that got Strep A in Year 1. He was very unwell to begin with and went straight to A&E after a GP had seen him the same day - sent home with antibiotics and is back at school now. I do believe that him being seen quickly was key. My granddaughter is 10 months old and showed some signs of it, was given antibiotics just in case and is OK, still a bit grumpy and sporadic hot/cold but seems to be doing just fine. I think that if the child is seen quickly then there shouldn't be complications, but that's just from my recent experience with my grandchildren.

If in doubt - get help. I think GPs and A&E would be happier to help as a precaution than for children to die.

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/12/2022 11:28

Mammamia23 · 06/12/2022 10:22

oh for heavens sake. Let me make it clearer. I don’t think children who go to the doctor with a cough this winter should get antibiotics. Parents are losing their mind because their children have coughs. Put it this way: when there is panic, and a&e is full of frantic parents with their children who have coughs, it might mean if your child has banged their head, or your elderly parent has fallen down the stairs, they can’t get seen as quickly as they should.

To be honest we’ve done enough prioritising of elderly people and it’s time we put children first.

WishingWell5 · 06/12/2022 11:26

SF that should say

WishingWell5 · 06/12/2022 11:26

I don't agree that 'children die every year from strep a, SV, sepsis etc' is the best argument.
Yes, they do.
But preventable deaths in children are just that... preventable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread