Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN shouldn't be promoting old fashioned and cruel methods of pet ownership

139 replies

Newfluff · 05/12/2022 22:29

OK, my teens will say 'it's not that deep' but AIBU to be saddened that the best toy of 2022 is based on cruelty?

Guinea pigs are social creatures that need to live in pairs, but ideally groups. They need space to thrive not a tiny handbag cage.

I'm sure the majority will say I'm batshit and that it doesn't matter as they aren't real, but this perpetuates the idea of it being acceptable to house pigs alone in dark cages, and this shouldn't be promoted in 2022

To think MN shouldn't be promoting old fashioned and cruel methods of pet ownership
OP posts:
CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 06/12/2022 06:57

Hrtft... So apologies for any repeat. What about pinatas where you bludgeon a donkey to death for a prize while your mates cheer you on. 🙃 I think the toy isn't promoting a real world scenario.

BeanieTeen · 06/12/2022 06:47

YANBU. But chances are the people who designed this toy don’t know either - there is a lot of ignorance around this. I work in a school and another teacher excitedly told me we were getting a guinea pig for the school, SLT had approved it and I was like ‘oh how many?’ She said ‘just one’. She, headteacher, and three other grown and apparently intelligent adults who support the running of the school we’re completely oblivious to the fact you can’t just keep them alone.
And then we didn’t get the school pet… I think I rained on everyone’s parade that that day with my revelation that guinea pigs, rabbits, rats etc should be in pairs at least - maybe no budget for more than one - sorry kids 😂

luxxlisbon · 06/12/2022 06:40

@TheLadyofShalott1 I do seriously think that anything like keeping toy pets, or babies (baby dolls) should come with a list of care notes, and should not be given to a child until they have a reasonable understanding of their parents vocabulary

So shall I tell my DD who’s favourite toy is her ‘baby’ that MN said she isn’t allowed to have a doll until she can follow a full list of care instructions? She’s 2, that’s a long way off. Do you actually think the way a toddler plays with a doll in indicative of their future parenting skills in like 25 years time?
It sounds like you were more damaged by your own mother’s extreme views than actual playing with a naked doll, which is something pretty much all children do by the way. They are fascinated by what’s underneath the baby clothes.

DD has her baby naked on a cold winter day, dangerously cosleeps with the tiny baby, doesn’t feed her every day, frequently drops her while running about and when she’s bored she shoves baby back in a cupboard. I have no worries that she will somehow think that is acceptable parenting as an adult to a real child.

@alasangne In the same way a torturing a puppy toy wouldn't be acceptable but this is slightly less extreme

Wait… a plastic toy pet is only slightly better than torturing a puppy????

Itsbeenashortyear · 06/12/2022 06:35

Unless the toy is there, specifically, to teach and prepare children for a pet, then I think yabu.

my niece throws her baby dolls all over and the cradle that came with some was far too small. In real life it would be cruel. My niece didn’t attempt to treat her baby sister the same.

My son had a plush curious George since he was one, that’s been bounced all over. It was never intended to teach him how to take care of an actual monkey.

If parents are the type to buy a pet and not look into how they should be cared for, they will not look into it regardless of toys. I don’t know any adult who looks at a toy and presumes that’s exactly what should happen in real life. Pet buying is down to adults.

As for toy kitchens, they don’t come with plumb in gas. It’s not an exact simulation and not designed to teach kids how to cook.

alasangne · 06/12/2022 06:22

I thought you were being ridiculous OP if I'm truly honest with you. But then I got to the end of your post and thought oh actually..maybe you have a point. In the same way a torturing a puppy toy wouldn't be acceptable but this is slightly less extreme

JuneOsborne · 06/12/2022 06:18

If they only sold toy hamsters/guinea pigs/whatever with the appropriate size cage and in the right multiples, nobody would buy them because of how huge they were and they'd probably think, you know what, we might as well get a real one if we're going to give this much space over and spend this much money on it. Which would be way worse in the long run for these pets, wouldn't it?

Bunnycat101 · 06/12/2022 06:00

You should see what my 3yo does to her dolls. I’m not sure that her neglect of a plastic dolL will pre-dispose her to a social services referral. I was debating getting the Guinea pig toy. I’m not a complete idiot though so if I were to get a real one, I’d do a bit of research first and not assume the toy aimed at 7yos would be a realistic interpretation of the care required for a real animal.

Myguessis · 06/12/2022 05:44

It's a just a toy.

It doesn't cement the idea of anything.

RobinRobinMouse · 06/12/2022 05:12

How ridiculous. You would really dislike dd's elephant toy who lives in a baby cot and regularly has nappies, baths in her kitchen sink and then sits in a little high chair to have his breakfast.
I think the guinea pig toy looks amazing personally, I'd have loved that when I was a child. Far better to encourage this than real pet ownership if someone doesn't have the time or room.

onlythreenow · 06/12/2022 05:02

For goodness sake OP, most children understand the difference between a toy and something real. I gouged a hole in my doll's forehead when I was a child, to match the scar on my own head - pretty sure I never felt the urge to do it to a baby in later life. Do you take everything in life this seriously?

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2022 04:59

@RefuseTheLies 😆😂🤣

RefuseTheLies · 06/12/2022 04:54

you mean flamingos don’t use the toilet when they need a poo?

To think MN shouldn't be promoting old fashioned and cruel methods of pet ownership
MrsTerryPratchett · 06/12/2022 03:43

Toy dogs, usually children do not walk them twice a day (or more) and attend training classes to simulate true responsible dog ownership.

DD used to grab every animal around the neck and squeeze, hard. She used to drag her poor dogs around with a lead bouncing their poor heads off the furniture. Swinging them sometimes.

Now I have to buy humanely produced food for her cosseted, spoiled animals, who live a life of sheer luxury. I regularly get told off for wanting to half-arse their care. Anyone bathed a reptile recently? Because it didn't completely shed. I have.

Her snake stuffed animals were used as door stops. And sometimes weapons. Now the reptiles are bloody fed better than me.

It doesn't create behaviour.

kingtamponthefurred · 06/12/2022 03:29

I know a My Little Pony which lives under the bed with a dinosaur.

notangelinajolie · 06/12/2022 02:55

They aren’t real. Kids aren’t stupid, they know this.

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2022 02:45

Kanaloa · 05/12/2022 22:53

But the orcas are sold separately - they should live in matriarchal pods, usually staying with their own families for all their lives. These come alone. Surely that is then equally wrong? Of course we could buy several, but then anyone could buy several of these toys.

Then there’s the Noah’s Ark toys - very wrong to depict all those animals crammed into a small boat.

Toy dogs, usually children do not walk them twice a day (or more) and attend training classes to simulate true responsible dog ownership.

Baby dolls often come with toy bottles which don’t offer a good representation of the choice between breast and bottle, many of them do not come with safe sleeping required cots but just little plastic cribs.

Roleplay toys are a joke. My kids’ toy kitchen does NOT meet health and safety requirements, and my dd frequently drives a toy car with no licence, plus I’m pretty sure she has been performing illegal surgery with her doctor’s kit. She doesn’t even have a medical degree.

They are toys. If you want reforms in small pet ownership that needs to be campaigned for with pet stores, campaigns to stop people selling pets on Facebook/gumtree. Not getting frazzled over a toy Guinea pig that is specifically made to be portable.

@Kanaloa 👏 Well said.

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2022 02:40

I used to love that game called Operation. But I never felt inspired to cut open my sister and perform surgery on her.

I also grew up in a time with toy guns. It never trivialised the reality of gun violence. We played cops and robbers and none of us grew up to become criminals or to arrest people on absolutely no charges and throw them in jail just for the fun of it.

I bought dd a toy puppy that you feed it little plastic pellets and when you make it sit it poops it out. Then you feed it the pooped out pellets again and again. I really don’t think that if I got her a real puppy that she would feed it with it’s own poo.

Toy spiders and snakes could be viewed as encouraging handling venomous creatures.

The list goes on.

I think the toy Guinea pig enclosure is made compact for practical reasons.

Any parent who bought a Guinea pig and housed it in something that small on it’s own with no other Guinea pigs for social interactions would be the only one responsible for teaching animal cruelty.

RafaistheKingofClay · 06/12/2022 02:16

XenoBitch · 05/12/2022 22:52

Do you feel the same outrage at small children playing with baby dolls/prams etc?
I mean, small children make pretty shitty parents when you think about it.

Are you suggesting that babies shouldn’t be picked up and carried about by the ankle? I think I’ve been doing things wrong with my nieces.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 06/12/2022 00:40

SeenAndNot · 05/12/2022 22:40

They fall out from the roof. Childbirth made easy.

I think this more misleading and cruel than the suggestion that Guinea Pigs can live alone is small cages. A child who plays with this thin which looks terrifying will be traumatised if they end up at antenatal as an adult! Grin

TheLadyofShalott1 · 06/12/2022 00:26

I voted that you are not being unreasonable
@Newfluff but maybe I shouldn't have voted at all, as I believe that it is a rather grey area. Some of your issues I absolutely agree with, while others don't seem to be so much of a problem.

Take the cage worry for a start, a small child's pet guinea pig toy should only arrive at the child's home in it's transporting cage, and then be taken out and be treated gently by the lucky child. This (illustrated) guinea pig is obviously going to be a 'house' guinea pig, and have the freedom of the house - or part thereof, but until the pig can be trained to poo in it's litter tray (I suggest an old backing tray and shredded paper from the office - home or at work, and must have been printed on with non-toxic ink), it's little adopter will need to learn to be aware and to clean up any wees or poos that it does in the meantime! But that is definitely only a trasnsporting cage OP for when the little piggy goes to the vet etc.

I do seriously think that anything like keeping toy pets, or babies (baby dolls) should come with a list of care notes, and should not be given to a child until they have a reasonable understanding of their parents vocabulary - with the exception of from birth suitable furry animals. My own wish is that all babies should have at least one of their own well made furry animal toys, and I mean all, I think it is extremely sad that globally there will be so many babies who do not get that opportunity - sorry for the aside.

Obviously most enlightened mums parents will tell their little ones if they start to treat their toys "cruelly" (what would be considered cruel if it was a real animal or baby), eg holding baby upside down, and dunking it's head into a bucket of water/the toilet! My own Dear Mum, sadly now long passed away, once remarked to me when I was little, that she was worried that when I had my own baby I would never dress it, as I kept my own life size baby doll undressed most of the time - I never forgot her saying that, even though I am pretty sure that at the time she said it with an exclamation mark! When my first born was about 13 months old I did say to her "see I have kept him/her dressed - when appropriate!"

Like a PP said, if your little one's baby doll came with it's own milk bottle, and a miniture bottle of - hopefully pretend - whiskey (I'm half Irish, long survive Bush Mills 😍), for the purpose of (pretend) adding some to the baby's milk bottle to help it sleep, then hopefully every single mumsnetter would find that outrageous! My very Dear Departed Uncle gave my first born a teaspoon of whiskey after my child's Christening, when I found out I was naturally furious. My Uncle was born in the 1920's, he was highly intelligent and educated (he could not only speak fluent Latin, but fluent Greek too, he was brilliant at maths, and very educated in, and enjoyed many of the arts - it is such a pity that none of that rubbed off on me 🙈).

The point that I appear to be struggling to make is that depending on a multitude of different reasons, anyone can make important mistakes in regards to child rearing, no matter what their level of commonsense, education, or a myriad of other positive or negative qualities, so I am very much on OP's side for starting this thread, and I also believe that any 'toy' that needs taking care of because it represents a living creature in real life, should absolutely come with care instructions.

Hopefully those enlightened people that I mentioned earlier, would be able to explain the difference between toys and real animals (including humans) to their child, and the importance of still looking after their toy even though it is 'only' a toy. But then I am also someone who is horrified by family and neighbours who think it is ok to pour boiling water on an ant hill, or to cut slugs in half, etc, which is probably why I do find that quite a few aquaintences seem to find me very strange, or far too serious...

donquixotedelamancha · 05/12/2022 23:29

I'm sure the majority will say I'm batshit

It sounds like you hear that a lot, OP?

I would love to know what other things you think should be banned. I imagine it's a fascinating list.

RoyFuckingKent · 05/12/2022 23:24

Newfluff · 05/12/2022 22:49

But toys recreate reality, I've seen toy kitchen, toy hoovers, toy houses all toy versions of acceptable reality. I don't think a tiny cage is acceptable reality.

Some Toys recreate reality.
I’ve spent half my life waiting to really fly the Millenium falcon with R2.

dancingqueen123 · 05/12/2022 22:59

luxxlisbon · 05/12/2022 22:32

It’s a toy. My DD’s toy bear lives in a cardboard box, is that animal cruelty too?

😆

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 05/12/2022 22:59

If I had my way , no one would keep rabbits, Guinea pigs or any rodent in a cage.
They should be banned.
In particular, no one should keep a bird in a cage , either.

Kanaloa · 05/12/2022 22:58

It's not the idea of a toy guinea pig that's the issue. It's a toy guinea pig, kept alone (other than the expectation of babies from on high), in a small hutch, purely to breed from it.

You’re right, better remove the kids’ V-Tech laptop before they try selling the babies in gumtree…