Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN shouldn't be promoting old fashioned and cruel methods of pet ownership

139 replies

Newfluff · 05/12/2022 22:29

OK, my teens will say 'it's not that deep' but AIBU to be saddened that the best toy of 2022 is based on cruelty?

Guinea pigs are social creatures that need to live in pairs, but ideally groups. They need space to thrive not a tiny handbag cage.

I'm sure the majority will say I'm batshit and that it doesn't matter as they aren't real, but this perpetuates the idea of it being acceptable to house pigs alone in dark cages, and this shouldn't be promoted in 2022

To think MN shouldn't be promoting old fashioned and cruel methods of pet ownership
OP posts:
vera99 · 06/12/2022 09:42

I can't bear to see creatures in less than ideal conditions and it's obvious to anybody who has any empathy for living things when it's not.

RobinRobinMouse · 06/12/2022 09:41

@Newfluff A toy guinea-pig does not perpetuate the idea that small cages are acceptable. What nonsense. I used to work for an animal charity, but this is just so ridiculous I can hardly believe someone would think it. Toys are not reality, that is the whole point.

socialmedia23 · 06/12/2022 09:36

I agree OP. I have well loved gerbils who live in a 150 cm by 60 cm cage in a spare room. The number of people who say that this is such a large cage for small animals. Actually its only 50% larger than the minimum! And bigger is better. Anything that emphasizes the fact that a cage should be many times the size of the animal would be a good thing. it doesn't need to be to scale obviously.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 06/12/2022 09:36

NosnowontheScottishhills · 06/12/2022 09:25

I’ve spent most of my life owning horses trust me it doesn’t matter what accessories Crafty Pony provide unless they are actually relieving you of at least £50 (usually live pony/horse costs considerably more) every week and the £80+ for shoes every 8 weeks or more frequently in lots of cases, somehow managing to fill you every spare waking moment with horse stuff/activities preferably in the pissing rain and up to your knees in mud) and letting you experience endless highs and crushing disappointment, (usually more of the latter) and finally having you vet on speed dial whilst he systematically relieves you of all your spare money then Crafty Pony are not giving you any insight into the joys and disappointments of owning these complicated but addictive animals.

I'm not sure why you're telling me how much it costs to own horses - I have 6 of them in my fields right now. I'm also not sure why you'd think I'd need your idiot's guide to horse ownership. None of mine wear shoes though, so that's something...

You're missing the point though. It's not about making toys inconvenient for parents, or taking the joy out of toys so that nobody can ever do anything with a toy that they couldn't do with the real thing. CP are a joyfully interpretation of horse ownership, where the idea of horse welfare and care are modelled and explained so that children can learn how horses are kept, or play catch with their toy horse / put it in a buggy wearing a nappy / dress it up as batman as they choose. This toy sets out to model how guinea pigs shouldn't be kept, and in my view, that's pretty shit.

midgetastic · 06/12/2022 09:34

Mn don't control the adverts directly

Should they also ban all beauty adverts as promoting unrealistic looks ?

And play kitchens because they are too small and plastic pans would melt on a real hob?

W0tnow · 06/12/2022 09:32

That is a hugely expensive piece of plastic tat that would entertain for a day, tops. On that basis it should be illegal.

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2022 09:30

How many people who buy a single Guinea pig or a single rabbit are doing it because of a toy/play scenario they had as a child?

Probably none. The real outrage and issue is with the pet industry. That is where our efforts need to go. Focus on changing the pet industry and how we sell animals as pets.

Some pets require a license to keep them that requires you to learn about how to keep them.

Perhaps that is what we need to do for all animals kept as pets.

That is where it starts, not the toy industry. Not imaginative play, which can loosely reflect reality but also reflect any number of things that have no correlation with reality because it is imaginary, creative, fantasy.

@Newfluff I get your concern, I just think it is misdirected. Focus on changing the pet industry. That is what will make a real difference.

I get that you understand the difference between toys and reality. But I don’t think you realise that children’s play isn’t solely about learning about real life.

It is about many things. One of them is exploring and developing your imagination. The rules that are applied to real life are suspended in an imaginary scenario. Magic exists!

We can’t take that away from children. We can’t turn every play scenario, every toy, every story, every movie into a moral lesson. It takes away the freedom of imagination and the simplicity of fun.

unsureatthispoint · 06/12/2022 09:26

It's a toy 🙄

NosnowontheScottishhills · 06/12/2022 09:25

CaptainThe95thRifles · 05/12/2022 22:36

I agree, OP, I think that's appalling. I don't think sea life figures are comparable to a lone toy guinea pig that comes with a tiny hutch. It's the accessories / "care" aspect of the toy that is deeply concerning, and it's appalling that the other options (e.g. the lizard mentioned above) aren't any better. Compared to something like Crafty Ponies (to whom I'm not affiliated!) who make toy ponies with rugs, accurate miniature tack, farriery sets and all sorts of educational kits, for a similar (large set) price as this, I can't possibly imagine why this would be the best of the best.

I’ve spent most of my life owning horses trust me it doesn’t matter what accessories Crafty Pony provide unless they are actually relieving you of at least £50 (usually live pony/horse costs considerably more) every week and the £80+ for shoes every 8 weeks or more frequently in lots of cases, somehow managing to fill you every spare waking moment with horse stuff/activities preferably in the pissing rain and up to your knees in mud) and letting you experience endless highs and crushing disappointment, (usually more of the latter) and finally having you vet on speed dial whilst he systematically relieves you of all your spare money then Crafty Pony are not giving you any insight into the joys and disappointments of owning these complicated but addictive animals.

GoingOnce · 06/12/2022 09:23

It’s out of stock everywhere. Thanks OP.

Notanotherone6 · 06/12/2022 09:22

It's not real ffs. Can you imagine how pissed off parents would be if they had to buy a full sized guinea pig cage to accommodate a toy?

ILoveeCakes · 06/12/2022 09:17

Its cruel to keep teddy bears in the house. Unless you own a forest, you shouldn't get one!

SirSniffsAlot · 06/12/2022 09:15

I kind of get where you're coming from, OP.

My own bugbear is how often goldfish are protrayed in bowls or small tanks. I spot it on TV all the time and it drives me mad. It just creates a general impression that it is OK to keep them that way when it is far from it.

Lots of people don't go proper research before getting a pet, especially those seen as more simple pets like fish (and probably like Guinea Pigs).

That said, this is just a toy and they very often mimic a version of life that is far from reality.

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2022 09:09

JamSandwichWithNutella · 06/12/2022 08:48

In Switzerland it’s actually illegal to only own one Guinea pig.

@Newfluff That’s what you should be aiming at rather then the toy industry.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 06/12/2022 09:08

I think it's obvious from the replies on here that a lot of posters don't actually understand the issue. It's not that the cage should be full size, but that giving it a cage - rather than a travelling crate or similar if you need to add in some plastic crap - perpetuates a long standing myth about how small animals should be kept - alone, in a small cage.

For all those saying that people are responsible and will do their own research before buying a live animal, how do you explain all the guinea pigs and rabbits who do live alone, in small hutches that are unsuitable for their needs? Well kept small furries are still the exception rather than the norm in the UK.

The toy is not "the" problem, but it is part of a bigger problem about how we see small animals in the UK and how many people don't even realise there's anything to research before buying them.

luxxlisbon · 06/12/2022 09:02

@Newfluff because it perpetuates an idea that tiny cages are acceptable.

But people buy toy dogs, toy gerbils etc precisely because they don’t want to have to look a pet!
Its a small stuffed toy, are you seriously saying you need to have a huge pen for a toy and you can’t buy one must buy two because in real life they need to be in pairs?

LT2 · 06/12/2022 09:02

YABU

and this is coming from someone who has had many guinea pigs that lived in huge (cube and coroplast) cages. It is a toy. They couldn't exactly give the toy a massive cage.

Newfluff · 06/12/2022 08:58

BeanieTeen · 06/12/2022 06:47

YANBU. But chances are the people who designed this toy don’t know either - there is a lot of ignorance around this. I work in a school and another teacher excitedly told me we were getting a guinea pig for the school, SLT had approved it and I was like ‘oh how many?’ She said ‘just one’. She, headteacher, and three other grown and apparently intelligent adults who support the running of the school we’re completely oblivious to the fact you can’t just keep them alone.
And then we didn’t get the school pet… I think I rained on everyone’s parade that that day with my revelation that guinea pigs, rabbits, rats etc should be in pairs at least - maybe no budget for more than one - sorry kids 😂

This illustrates exactly why I have a problem with it.

It isn't that I struggle to separate toys from real life animals but because it perpetuates an idea that tiny cages are acceptable. And adults clearly don't realise what goes into looking after a small animal as show by the quoted post.

I do donate and campaign against pets shops selling small cages, but the public also need to move away from the idea that a hutch is an acceptable means of keeping animals.

In fairness I'm heartened that 25% of the vote at the moment understands why I dislike it. To the pp that asked if I'm often seen to be batshit, the answer is yes. Sadly cruelty to animals is accepted by so many, often it is through ignorance rather than malice, so people do think I'm batty when I talk about them.

OP posts:
MissGroves · 06/12/2022 08:52

Ooh, dd3 has been pestering for guinea pigs to which I've said no. But this toy is a good compromise. Going to go and look - hadn't even bothered looking at that article/list but will now. Thanks.

It is a toy OP. It encourages children to care and have empathy as do baby dolls etc.

JamSandwichWithNutella · 06/12/2022 08:48

In Switzerland it’s actually illegal to only own one Guinea pig.

BiscuitLover3678 · 06/12/2022 08:46

You mean because it’s only one Guinea pig? Or because the cage is small? I’d assume anyone who actually bought one would know that’s not what you do! I also bought a toy dog wearing pjs and a dummy but we all know they don’t really have that.

Anothernamechange1010 · 06/12/2022 08:43

This thread is hilarious, it's brightened up an otherwise dull Tuesday morning 😅

HereComeTheGrannies · 06/12/2022 08:35

I get what you’re saying, and the way we treat small animals is gross. But I think there are actual bigger issues to be tackled. Shoebox sized runs at pet at home etc shouldn’t be allowed for a starters.

ImprobablePuffin · 06/12/2022 08:29

Of all the things to get worked up about, this isn't it. Playing with toys doesn't "cement" anything. Who's going to buy a toy Guinea pig if they have to buy a life size hutch and all the gubbins to go with it. Madness.

CarPoor · 06/12/2022 07:20

I think you are being ridiculous

It's a toy. Toys are supposed to be fantasy and they are not supposed to be recreations of the real world. Play uses objects thay aren't real life to act as other objects

I used to tuck all my toys up in a shoebox. I don't think its appropriate to tuck 25 children in a shoebox. But obviously I couldn't buy a 4 bed house and life-size beds for my teddies.

This isn't the same as torturing a puppy. It's more like tying a string round a dogs neck to act as a lead. Completely inappropriate in real life but find in imaginary play