Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN shouldn't be promoting old fashioned and cruel methods of pet ownership

139 replies

Newfluff · 05/12/2022 22:29

OK, my teens will say 'it's not that deep' but AIBU to be saddened that the best toy of 2022 is based on cruelty?

Guinea pigs are social creatures that need to live in pairs, but ideally groups. They need space to thrive not a tiny handbag cage.

I'm sure the majority will say I'm batshit and that it doesn't matter as they aren't real, but this perpetuates the idea of it being acceptable to house pigs alone in dark cages, and this shouldn't be promoted in 2022

To think MN shouldn't be promoting old fashioned and cruel methods of pet ownership
OP posts:
Tiredalwaystired · 06/12/2022 17:34

Newfluff · 05/12/2022 22:49

But toys recreate reality, I've seen toy kitchen, toy hoovers, toy houses all toy versions of acceptable reality. I don't think a tiny cage is acceptable reality.

I’ve also seen a toy school which you can only fit three children in. Bring in the barbies to make an authentic class size and you’ve got a fire risk on your hands.

It’s. A. Toy.

Janieread · 06/12/2022 12:07

This is a weird thread.

My dd had a toy horse that lived in a box. She also has a real horse that lives in the field, and understands the difference.

HowDoYouOwnDisorder · 06/12/2022 12:05

You have a point there OP,

We made the mistake of giving my DS a cuddly penguin that he had in his bed, alongside his stuffed owl and baby tiger.

When he grew up and replicated this with real live animals, all hell broke loose. The penguin overheated and just would not stay still, and the lion ate the owl

He blames us for bad parenting and giving unrealistic expectations of how animals should be kept.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 06/12/2022 11:58

Mamamia7962 · 06/12/2022 11:48

Any reputable pet shop will only sell guinea pigs in pairs or more.

According to the Blue Cross Pet Census, 60% of rabbit owners were sold their rabbits individually. The data for guinea pigs isn't held, unfortunately, but I suspect it isn't dramatically better sadly.

Strangely enough, @NosnowontheScottishhills, I found your responses condescending and unpleasant in tone. I don't think there was anything "aggressive" in any of my responses, but I responded in keeping with the tone of your posts. I'm allowed to disagree with you, to express that, and to point out where you are misrepresenting my statements (specifically, with reference to CP toys being a "true insight" into horse ownership).

IDontWantToBeAPie · 06/12/2022 11:57

People who will buy the toy and the ones who don't have space for a Guinea pig but their kid still wants one.

So they buy the toy instead.

NosnowontheScottishhills · 06/12/2022 11:50

Yup you’re right my math went a bit mad! So as it’s actually 0.3% of households who own horses my assumption is definitely not bizarre in fact it is totally realistic and sensible. But as others have said some on here can argue about anything which is something I’ve noticed is getting worse over the years. I’ve posted about horse ownership amongst other things and it’s many ups and downs repeatedly on here (under other user names) for over 15 years and have never before met with such an aggressive response but that seems to be the norm in MN these days which is why Im increasingly backing away.

Mamamia7962 · 06/12/2022 11:48

Any reputable pet shop will only sell guinea pigs in pairs or more.

MillyMollyManky · 06/12/2022 11:45

If you did this to a real bear, it would rip your head off. Something must be done!

To think MN shouldn't be promoting old fashioned and cruel methods of pet ownership
Seaweedandsalt · 06/12/2022 11:41

This soft, interactive Mama guinea pig comes with a deluxe, interactive hutch. Care for Mama and when her heart glows, a baby is on the way. Place her inside her interactive hutch and wait patiently. Discover a new-born guinea pig baby and a special care package. Care for Mama again and you will find new guinea pig babies to complete your adorable, guinea pig family. This magical experience is repeatable, so that you can go through the surprise and delight of caring for Mama and discovering her babies, again and again.

Just Like a Real Pet Mama Surprise teaches children to care for and nurture their pet. Just like a real pet, you can look after your Mama guinea pig by feeding, grooming and patting her.

Feed Her Mama loves to snack on her delicious celery stick. Simply place it inside her mouth and listen as she makes cute feeding sounds.

Brush Her Mama has long, beautiful and silky fur. Keep her fur clean and tidy with her brush. Mama will make happy sounds as you brush her.

Mama's Heart Glows When Mama receives enough love and attention, her heart will start glowing and she'll let out a melody to let you know that a baby is about to arrive.

When Will The Baby Arrive? When Mama's heart starts glowing, she's ready to be placed her inside the hutch. When Mama's heart stops glowing and the hutch light turns off, a cute baby has arrived.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 06/12/2022 11:37

Pascor · 06/12/2022 11:34

1 in 10 UK homes have horses? I find that extremely hard to believe. It can't possibly be that high.

I also found it hard to believe, hence the "if" at the start of the statement.

Pascor · 06/12/2022 11:36

Says here its 0.3% of UK homes, which sounds more like it.
petkeen.com/horse-statistics-uk/

Perhaps you are talking about toy horses, given the topic.

Pascor · 06/12/2022 11:34

1 in 10 UK homes have horses? I find that extremely hard to believe. It can't possibly be that high.

FelizNavicrab · 06/12/2022 11:34

I swear mn posters can argue about absolutely anything....

CaptainThe95thRifles · 06/12/2022 11:25

NosnowontheScottishhills · 06/12/2022 11:15

I’m not sure why you’re being so argumentative. Only 10% of UK homes own horses so it’s hardly a “bizzare assumption”. Anyway I stand by what I said Crafty Pony doesn’t give you any true insight into horse(s) ownership however accurate the rugs are and I don’t believe that the toy mentioned does either. Both are just toys that are hopefully fun for children. Maybe you they are aimed at children who will never have either a Guinea pig or a horse. Again I genuinely wish you a dry winter (as before I am extending virtual olive branch). 😀

I'd say, if 1 in 10 households in the UK own horses, there's pretty decent odds that someone posting online about a horse related topic probably does own them unless otherwise stated. It's pretty condescending to assume otherwise, and your original post in response to mine was condescending in tone. If you want people to respond to your posts differently, you should look to how your own posts read.

I don't recall suggesting that CP give a "true insight" into anything - I said they were a better toy than the one shown in the OP, and I stand by that. If you want to offer an olive branch, you'd be better to start by not creating straw man arguments out of people's posts. I don't actually need a dry winter - I have enough land and facilities to manage either way.

NosnowontheScottishhills · 06/12/2022 11:15

CaptainThe95thRifles · 06/12/2022 10:07

It's more your bizarre assumption that I don't have horses that I find objectionable. There are a lot of posters on here with horses, so when you see someone posting about them, it's fairly reasonable to assume they know as much, if not more, than you do, unless you're given evidence to the contrary.

All you're doing is demonstrating that you don't understand the nuance of the issue with this specific toy, and why, in my opinion, it is very different to something like CP which at least aims to be educational as well as fun. Some people do buy horses without any real idea of how to keep them - as a professional in the horse industry, I've met new owners who don't know the difference between hay and straw, or how to put on a rug - but due to the price of horse ownership and livery, they're the exception rather than the rule, and people tend to notice if an idiot owner moves onto their yard. With guinea pigs, there is often nobody to notice and report issues, and their purchase cost with an unsuitable hutch is so low that there is little incentive to do their own research.

I’m not sure why you’re being so argumentative. Only 10% of UK homes own horses so it’s hardly a “bizzare assumption”. Anyway I stand by what I said Crafty Pony doesn’t give you any true insight into horse(s) ownership however accurate the rugs are and I don’t believe that the toy mentioned does either. Both are just toys that are hopefully fun for children. Maybe you they are aimed at children who will never have either a Guinea pig or a horse. Again I genuinely wish you a dry winter (as before I am extending virtual olive branch). 😀

RoyFuckingKent · 06/12/2022 10:45

You’re kidding? Donkeys don’t actually contain sweets? Bugger.
cancels raid on donkey sanctuary

plinkplinkfizzer · 06/12/2022 10:38

Jesus christ it's a toy ! Now I think about I'm a bit worried at how my niece treats her dolls , just chucks them on the floor and goes out . She's gonna be a terrible Mother .😂

Kanaloa · 06/12/2022 10:21

kingtamponthefurred · 06/12/2022 10:14

What happens when one dies? Most people with pets eventually get to the stage where they decide not to replace them when they die.

I imagine that’s the type of law that’s very difficult to police - it will be policed mostly in pet stores when the animal is being sold. So the law will be in effect making it illegal to sell a single Guinea pig unless they can prove they’ve got more at home I suppose.

I will say though (op might explode) this toy also comes with accessories and hair ties to dress the baby Guinea pigs up in different styles. And mummy Guinea pig’s ‘heart glows’ to show she’s pregnant. So pretty obviously not trying to imitate real pet ownership.

kingtamponthefurred · 06/12/2022 10:14

JamSandwichWithNutella · 06/12/2022 08:48

In Switzerland it’s actually illegal to only own one Guinea pig.

What happens when one dies? Most people with pets eventually get to the stage where they decide not to replace them when they die.

Blocked · 06/12/2022 10:10

I feel guilty about that handbag with a dog in it I bought DD for Christmas now. Don't want her to grow up to be a Paris Hilton type of dog owner!

CaptainThe95thRifles · 06/12/2022 10:07

NosnowontheScottishhills · 06/12/2022 09:55

How am I to know you have horses? As Im sure you are aware plenty of people have absolutely no idea about the cost and time factor involved in horse ownership and I would hate someone to think that purchasing Crafty Pony sets gives them a good insight.
Anyway I genuinely hope you have a reasonable dry winter with your 6 😊.

It's more your bizarre assumption that I don't have horses that I find objectionable. There are a lot of posters on here with horses, so when you see someone posting about them, it's fairly reasonable to assume they know as much, if not more, than you do, unless you're given evidence to the contrary.

All you're doing is demonstrating that you don't understand the nuance of the issue with this specific toy, and why, in my opinion, it is very different to something like CP which at least aims to be educational as well as fun. Some people do buy horses without any real idea of how to keep them - as a professional in the horse industry, I've met new owners who don't know the difference between hay and straw, or how to put on a rug - but due to the price of horse ownership and livery, they're the exception rather than the rule, and people tend to notice if an idiot owner moves onto their yard. With guinea pigs, there is often nobody to notice and report issues, and their purchase cost with an unsuitable hutch is so low that there is little incentive to do their own research.

SD1978 · 06/12/2022 09:57

No, I'm not really seeing this. You could say exactly the same about any animal shaped toy as it wouldn't be in an appropriate pretend environment

NosnowontheScottishhills · 06/12/2022 09:55

CaptainThe95thRifles · 06/12/2022 09:36

I'm not sure why you're telling me how much it costs to own horses - I have 6 of them in my fields right now. I'm also not sure why you'd think I'd need your idiot's guide to horse ownership. None of mine wear shoes though, so that's something...

You're missing the point though. It's not about making toys inconvenient for parents, or taking the joy out of toys so that nobody can ever do anything with a toy that they couldn't do with the real thing. CP are a joyfully interpretation of horse ownership, where the idea of horse welfare and care are modelled and explained so that children can learn how horses are kept, or play catch with their toy horse / put it in a buggy wearing a nappy / dress it up as batman as they choose. This toy sets out to model how guinea pigs shouldn't be kept, and in my view, that's pretty shit.

How am I to know you have horses? As Im sure you are aware plenty of people have absolutely no idea about the cost and time factor involved in horse ownership and I would hate someone to think that purchasing Crafty Pony sets gives them a good insight.
Anyway I genuinely hope you have a reasonable dry winter with your 6 😊.

allthelittlelights · 06/12/2022 09:55

My eldest child had some of these when he was about 8 - I am glad to report that as an adult he has progressed to extremely responsible pet ownership.

Tiredalwaystired · 06/12/2022 09:48

YABU

Its a toy that doesn’t take up tons of space. No one would buy it if it was life size

Get them a real Guinea pig and get them the right kit.

Toy high chairs and toy prams are not life size either but kids seem to understand that their baby brother can’t by put in them.