I think it's important for people to listen to the perspectives of adults who were home educated as children. Parents who choose to home educate believe that they're doing the right thing for their children, and when they post on MN, they're generally seeking validation and support for their choice. That's fair enough.
But if you speak to a sample of adults who have themselves been home educated (rather than the adults doing the home educating), I suspect you would get a far more mixed picture.
I usually avoid posting on home ed threads on MN, partly because, well, reading about home ed can be a bit triggering for me, and partly because it's not very productive to pop onto a thread of home educating parents and point out to them how dreadful home education was for me in various ways. For all I know, most of the children being home educated by MNers are having a far better time of it than I did.
But I responded to this thread because it's so goady of the OP to say that if you don't support home ed, it must be because you don't understand it.
Trust me, I'm not the only adult out there who has struggled to cope in the world after a childhood of being educated at home.
One of the problems about home education is that because there is no oversight, the spectrum of how different families go about doing it is extremely wide. The dark end of the spectrum (which involves social isolation and child abuse) is dark indeed.
If I can't unequivocally support home education, it's not because I don't understand, it's because I have firsthand experience of the dysfunctional end of the home education spectrum.