Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Really worrying about strep A

92 replies

QueenBean9 · 05/12/2022 21:19

I am usually pragmatic with this sort of stuff but what the hell is going on?!

OP posts:
QueenBean9 · 06/12/2022 08:54

@LiveIngSun you don't vaccinate?

OP posts:
chickywick6 · 06/12/2022 08:54

It is worrying me too. Especially as currently at home with a sick child who gets every bug going.
To follow on what @LiveIngSun
has said (which I'm sorry to hear you went through) I've read a few times that around 20 children die each year from chicken pox but again we don't worry about that. In that case there is even a vaccine not available via NHS but it which can he paid privately but most people don't get it. It's very hard to know how to respond to the strep A news and know how much of this worry is due to the media vs reality.

LiveIngSun · 06/12/2022 08:45

Two of my children have had scarlet fever to reassure you. When you see it I personally found it distinctive, strawberry tongue surprises you and the cheeks flush. The body rash also is noticeable.
one of mine was milder and it cleared up alone, the other was quickly responsive to antibiotics.

whilst it’s in the media, remember any virus we see as ‘harmless’ may be severe. One of mine has a lifelong complication after nearly dying from chicken pox. No one is scared of it still, but I actually know of another child locally who was also similar. We don’t vaccinate or worry much though.

CrappyUsername · 06/12/2022 08:26

GabrielAgreste · 05/12/2022 23:02

@CrappyUsername yes they do use those alternatives.

Thanks

Monmouthy · 06/12/2022 08:17

Freddosforall · 05/12/2022 23:09

Maybe we shouldn't have shut down our kid's world for an illness that didn't kill them, as they're now expected to carry on as normal when there's an illness about that could. Maybe we should make all the old people stay inside too. Not because they're at risk but because if they go out they might kill Grandchild.

Keep it classy mate

Somethingsnappy · 06/12/2022 08:14

orchid220 · 05/12/2022 23:48

Children haven't been living in a germ free environment for a number of years and even if they had been, I wouldn't mean their immune systems stop working. Don't be ridiculous.

Why on earth is it ridiculous? It's one of the widely respected theories about all this. Do you know something nobody else does? Or are you just bring argumentative for the sake of it?

Prescottdanni123 · 06/12/2022 07:09

Cases of strep A are extremely high. This coupled with lockdowns and social distancing causing low immune systems in kids are what has caused a higher number of deaths sadly. The risk is still extremely low. As someone said on another thread, 8 children dead headlines sell more papers than 900,992 children live headlines.

ofwarren · 06/12/2022 06:48

CrappyUsername · 05/12/2022 22:53

Not read all the posts, but, asking for a friend, if your child is allergic to penicillin/amoxicillin does the alternative (usually erythromycin or clarithromycin) work?

Yes it usually does

Squirrelgate · 06/12/2022 06:41

SD1978 · 05/12/2022 23:19

Media needs a new pandemic since everyone is bored of covid. So now emergency is clogged with people concerned they have strep A even if it's not severe. Previously it was covid, before that swine flu........

This is it. The risk from strep A isn't any greater this year but media reporting of infectious disease has changed dramatically and the public's perception of risk has also changed.

GabrielAgreste · 06/12/2022 06:36

@QueenBean9 thanks, I was responding to your last sentence “surely the more germs you are exposed to, the stronger your immune system will be?”

QueenBean9 · 06/12/2022 06:28

@GabrielAgreste apparently it does

Really worrying about strep A
OP posts:
GabrielAgreste · 06/12/2022 06:06

@QueenBean9 no it doesn’t work like that.

The more different pathogens/bugs (viruses, bacteria or fungal infections) your immune system is exposed to (through vaccines or exposure to infection) the bigger its reference library is, so it can “look up” how to respond to an infection effectively.

Strep A, the pathogen is very common - I’ve seen figures that 1/4 kids would test positive for it if you swabbed the back of a random sample of throats - mostly it’s there asymptomatically and the immune system prevents it from getting out of control. We don’t treat asymptomatic infection as we need to keep antibiotics from becoming overused - we really don’t want to increase antibiotic resistance (which is where you get strains of bugs that are no longer killed by antibiotics that used to work).

However, if a person’s immune system is exposed to lots of threats at once then it begins to struggle. This is (sort of) our first normal winter cold & flu season since Covid-19 came into the scene. In normal mixing we may see colds, RSV, flu and now Covid strains being passed around.

All of this means that kids colonised with Strep A might end up with Strep A getting out of control because their body’s immune system is also dealing with various viral threats.

QueenBean9 · 06/12/2022 01:21

@orchid220 These are just suggestions, not facts, do you feel guilty because you decided to isolate your child or something?

surely the more germs you are exposed to, the stronger your immune system will be?

OP posts:
mummymeister · 05/12/2022 23:59

I wish people wouldnt just glibly say "a dose of penicillin and you will be fine" i am allergic to penicillin (anaphylaxis ) and have allergies to many many other antibiotics. so do my family. so for us and many like us and there are lots of people with penicillin allergy its not that straightforward. I worry a lot about getting any sort of illness and have now had shingles 4 times in 18 months. after 60+ years of suffering multiple allergies and odd infections I have at last been referred to a specialist.

orchid220 · 05/12/2022 23:48

fairywhale · 05/12/2022 23:08

Before people were placed in an artificial nearly germ free environment for a number of years. No need to be so aggressive.

Children haven't been living in a germ free environment for a number of years and even if they had been, I wouldn't mean their immune systems stop working. Don't be ridiculous.

Bluekerfuffle · 05/12/2022 23:39

luxxlisbon · 05/12/2022 22:30

Have you ever heard anyone say ‘you can’t say anything these days without being called a racist!’ who wasn’t actually racist?

Wrong thread?

SD1978 · 05/12/2022 23:19

Media needs a new pandemic since everyone is bored of covid. So now emergency is clogged with people concerned they have strep A even if it's not severe. Previously it was covid, before that swine flu........

Freddosforall · 05/12/2022 23:17

Siameasy · 05/12/2022 22:41

I was dubious about over use of hand gel during Covid and am now even more anti. It kills good bacteria as well as bad. During Covid my DD came back from school with red raw hands - I told her to refuse the 45 minutely hand sanitizing.

Happened to my son too. Never had excema before. His hands were literally bleeding and they were still putting it on him. This horrible cheap industrial stuff. I was never asked to give my consent and they kept doing it after i told them not to (was happy for him to wash his hands, although this was literally as he arrived at school and had just washed hands at home). I'm so angry about stuff like that. I still don't believe all the hand sanitiser made much difference to an airborne virus.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 05/12/2022 23:14

Our Emergency dept is seeing more dc with sore throats and 7 of them were strep A (but we don’t usually swab). You can actually get swabs at the pharmacy but our ED team is happy to see dc of worried parents. We’re really busy but they understand why parents are concerned.

Freddosforall · 05/12/2022 23:09

Maybe we shouldn't have shut down our kid's world for an illness that didn't kill them, as they're now expected to carry on as normal when there's an illness about that could. Maybe we should make all the old people stay inside too. Not because they're at risk but because if they go out they might kill Grandchild.

fairywhale · 05/12/2022 23:08

luxxlisbon · 05/12/2022 22:21

Based on what?

When were immune systems better? When people lived to their 40s? When infant mortality was high?

Really not understanding your argument.

Before people were placed in an artificial nearly germ free environment for a number of years. No need to be so aggressive.

Tonsiltrouble · 05/12/2022 23:06

I’ve just done a couple of days in a big children’s teaching hospital and trauma centre with my child (tonsillectomy issues as per username).

what I have seen is:

  • loads and loads of kids, especially really small ones with breathing trouble, especially RSV - many small babies; approx 70% of the other kids in ED and PMU were breathing issues/viral
  • an overall lack of capacity to deal with need, and mostly at the doctor level than the nurses (the nurses are working flat out but they are also waiting on doctors to do doctory things)
  • general inefficiency between systems (the ED and the ward and the ENT speciality all seem to use different computer/notes systems that don’t talk to each other)

I think that there is a huge (ongoing) issue with accessing primary care at the moment which is part of the issue - people are going to ED because they’ve not been able to use a more sensible route. Or have not managed to get a GP to see them and so have deteriorated.

The staff in ED in particular seemed to think that the media coverage had caused a massive surge in worried parents rushing kids in who maybe didn’t need to be there (but that’s a difficult message to get right because clearly some kids are very unwell).

seems the kids are suffering consequences of not being able to mix these past years.

but if I were feeling really cynical I’d question whether the blanket media coverage was in any way related to the nursing strike due next week. The deaths are alarming but the reporting of them is sensationalist.

GabrielAgreste · 05/12/2022 23:02

@CrappyUsername yes they do use those alternatives.

fairywhale · 05/12/2022 23:02

Such an aggressive and ignorant response. She probably means prior to the 2.5 years of nearly sterile environment.

Wigeon · 05/12/2022 22:59

From a quick google, approx five children A DAY are killed or seriously injured on the roads in England (source: here. I’d get anxious about that instead.

On the reason for the higher absolute number of severe strep A, from reading the quotes from the experts in the media, they are saying that overall cases of strep A are higher, and therefore if xx% of strep A cases generally end up as severe cases, then xx% of a bigger overall number is going to be a higher number of severe cases too. Nothing to do with weakened immune systems, and people not seeking help quickly or not being able to access help isn’t being given as a reason.